Abstract
Evolution of complex communities of coexisting microbes remains poorly understood. The long-term evolution experiment on Escherichia coli (LTEE) revealed the spontaneous emergence of stable coexistence of multiple ecotypes, which persisted for more than 14,000 generations of continuous evolution. Here, using a combination of experiments and computer simulations, we show that the emergence and persistence of this phenomenon can be explained by the combination of two interacting trade-offs, rooted in biochemical constraints: First, faster growth is enabled by higher fermentation and obligate acetate excretion. Second, faster growth results in longer lag times when utilizing acetate after glucose is depleted. This combination creates an ecological niche for a slower-growing ecotype, specialized in switching to acetate. These findings demonstrate that trade-offs can give rise to surprisingly complex communities with evolutionarily stable coexistence of multiple variants in even the simplest environments.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
The E. coli long-term evolution experiment (LTEE) started in 1988 is one of the longest running biological experiments1,2. Every morning, about 1% of the population is transferred to a fresh culture medium containing a small amount of glucose, allowing a few generations of growth. The LTEE and similar laboratory evolution experiments appear to select for shorter lag phases when exiting stationary phase, followed by faster growth rates3. Yet despite the simplicity of the experimental protocol, the LTEE has resulted in a rich set of surprising phenomena4. Among the most unexpected was the spontaneous emergence of coexisting populations of strains, termed ecotypes5,6,7. This effect was originally discovered based on the different colony sizes formed by these strains and they were therefore denoted the L-strain (large colonies) and S-strain (small colonies). Even more surprising than the emergence of this coexistence was its persistence during continued evolution. Although both ecotypes continued to evolve, the coexistence phenotype has been maintained for >14,000-generations, notably without the emergence of a single, tertiary strain that could have invaded and replaced the two coexisting populations5,6. Several studies have followed up on these original observations. For example, one study has extensively profiled the ecological and evolutionary dynamics of the L- and S-strain by using reciprocal invasion experiments with L and S clones from the same or different generation of the LTEE8.
Theoretical work has also resulted in a better understanding of coexistence phenomena. Evolutionary game theory has shown that coexistence of strains can emerge even in simple environments from negative frequency-dependent selection9 and analytical solutions for coexistence ratios have been calculated10. It has been argued that ‘cheating’ fermenting and ‘cooperating’ non-fermenting strains can coexist due to the toxicity of accumulating fermentation products11. However, substrate concentration in the LTEE is much too low for this mechanism to play a role and it cannot explain the competitive advantage of the S-strain after glucose is depleted6. Neither is there any evidence of specialization of the L-strain and the S-strain for different concentrations of glucose, which has been proposed as a mechanism that can result in coexistence12. In this work, we wanted to better understand mechanistically, which physiological constraints result in negative frequency-dependent selection and coexistence on the LTEE.
Rozen and Lenski already performed a phenotypic characterization of the coexisting strains6 and found that the maximum growth rate in fresh medium of the L-strain was ~20% faster than that of the S-strain in glucose medium. They also showed that the S-strain has a fitness advantage in glucose-depleted medium. By using medium conditioned by the L-strain, they showed that this fitness advantage is based on nutrients left behind by the L-strain. However, it remains unclear to this day why coexistence emerged in the first place and why it proved remarkably persistent under continued evolution. This lack of understanding is partly due to the difficulty of studying constraints of long-term evolutionary processes experimentally.
In this work, to overcome this challenge, we employ a combination of experiments and computer simulations. We hypothesized that coexistence results from a combination of two recently uncovered trade-offs. The first is a trade-off between growth rate and fermentation13,14 (see Fig. 1a). It was recently demonstrated that fermentation results in acetate excretion and enables faster growth because it requires a smaller amount of protein investment per flux of ATP produced13,14. Thereby, the ‘leaner’ fermentation pathway frees up proteomic resources that enable faster replication, including a higher ribosomal proteome fraction. Indeed, forcing cells to ferment directly results in faster growth rates14. Mathematically, this trade-off between the growth rate \(\lambda\) and the acetate excretion rate \({j}_{{ace}}\) is determined by a Pareto front, described by the following expression13:
where \(\theta\) is the heaviside function, and the proportionality constant \(\alpha\) and the threshold growth rate \({\lambda }_{0}\) have been previously empirically determined from the strain NCM372213.
The second independent trade-off required for coexistence is a trade-off between growth rate and ability to quickly switch to growth on acetate (see Fig. 1b). Faster growth results in longer lag phases when shifting from glycolytic to gluconeogenic substrates such as acetate15,16. These lag times are remarkably long because of the difficulty of reversing the direction of glycolytic flux due to key irreversible reactions in glycolysis15,16. This second trade-off is also characterized by a Pareto front, which relates the lag time \({T}_{{lag}}\) with the growth rate \(\lambda\):
where the coefficient \(\beta\) and the critical growth rate \({\lambda }_{C}\) have also been also determined empirically from the strain NCM372215. The critical growth rate \({\lambda }_{C}\) is the growth rate at which lag times diverge and switching becomes impossible. We note that the lag time trade-off given by Eq. [2] is independent and mechanistically distinct from the acetate excretion trade-off given by Eq. [1]. The acetate excretion trade-off results from different protein cost of metabolic pathways for ATP production13. The lag time trade-off results from the difficulty of reversing flux in glycolysis while preventing futile cycling due to effectively irreversible metabolic reaction in glycolysis15. The phenotypic combinations allowed by the trade-offs given by Eqs. [1–2] can be visualized in a 3D plot of growth rate, acetate excretion rate and lag time (see Fig. S1). The intersection of the two Pareto surfaces is a line, plotted in Fig. S1.
We hypothesized that the combination of these two independent trade-offs can result in negative frequency-dependent selection leading to stable coexistence of two strains. The faster growing strain produces more acetate according to Eq. [1]. Therefore, an excess of the faster growing strain results in more acetate in the medium after growth on glucose, which favors growth of the slower growing strain that is more quickly able to utilize acetate, according to Eq. [2]. Conversely, if the abundance of the fast-growing strain is low, according to Eq. [1], there is less acetate in the medium for the slow-growing strain to utilize after glucose is depleted, reducing the benefit of the slow growing strain from quickly switching to acetate. But growth on glucose favors the faster growing strain. Hence, this situation results in stable coexistence of the two strains.
Results
Simulation of coexistence
To test if this hypothesis was theoretically correct, we implemented a simple computer simulation of the LTEE (see Supplementary Note 1 for mathematical details). Just as in the LTEE, every 24 h, a 100-fold dilution in glucose medium was introduced in the simulation. In the simulation, the two strains grow at their respective growth rates (Fig. 1c) and consume glucose according to their respective biomass yield (Eq. S5), which is determined by their respective acetate excretion rates. Acetate accumulates in the medium as glucose is consumed (Fig. 1d). When glucose is depleted, cells undergo a lag phase without growth, whose duration is restricted by Eq. [2], before they resume growth on acetate (Fig. 1c).
When we simulated these dynamics, we indeed found coexistence for certain parameter combinations (Fig. 1e). If the phenotypes of both strains (i.e., growth rates, acetate excretion rates and lag times) are directly on the two Pareto fronts to maximize their fitness, these phenotypes are fully characterized by their respective growth rates on glucose. We wanted to determine for which combinations of growth rates there exists stable coexistence. Therefore, we performed a parameter scan and simulated the serial dilution experiment with different combinations of strains with various growth rates. We let the simulation run until the populations reached stable steady-state levels. We plotted the resulting coexistence frequency (colour code) as a function of the growth rates of the two strains (two axes) (Fig. 1f). The resulting plot is symmetric because the two strains are interchangeable, as each strain is uniquely determined by its growth rate. A frequency of either 0 or 1 indicates no coexistence, as the population consists only of one strain. When both strains grow at slow growth rates below the acetate excretion threshold given by \({\lambda }_{0}\), there is no acetate excretion according to Eq. [1]. In this regime there is no coexistence (as indicated by frequencies of either 0 or 1). However, for faster growth rates, we indeed found that there is a large parameter regime where coexistence generally emerges. Interestingly, because evolution in the LTEE prior to the emergence of coexisting ecotypes favors faster growth rates, we expect the LTEE to generally move into the fast growth rate parameter regime that leads to coexistence of two strains. Hence, rather than constituting a special situation, coexistence of two strains could be the general outcome of the LTEE, based on the trade-offs given by Eqs. [1–2].
In silico evolutionary dynamics
Next, we wanted to test in silico evolutionary dynamics resulting from this theoretical model. We therefore introduced a third strain in the system. While two strains coexisted for many parameter combinations, the introduction of a distinct third strain always resulted in elimination of one of the strains. To implement evolution, whenever the abundance of one of the strains dropped below a low threshold, indicating elimination from the population, a new strain whose growth rate \(\lambda\) was randomly chosen from the interval \(\left[0,{\lambda }_{C}\right]\) was introduced. To speed up the simulation, we again assumed that phenotypes were directly on the two Pareto fronts because phenotypes away from the Pareto fronts are sub-optimal. Running this evolutionary simulation resulted in subsequent rounds of invading strains (Fig. 2a) and evolving strain phenotypes. The simulation converged to the same specific combination of strains (Fig. 2b, Fig. S2). When we initiated the simulation with this ‘stable’ combination of strain growth rates and simulated additional 50,000 days of evolution, where randomly sampled strains could invade the population, substantially different strains were unable to replace either original strain in the population, and the dynamics were soon dominated by strains that were only incrementally different from the stable strains. This indicates that this combination of growth rates is an evolutionarily stable configuration (Fig. 2c). We next ran the evolutionary simulation 10,000 times for 50,000 simulated days, each time initialized with a random combination of three strains growing at different growth rates. These randomly chosen initial growth rates cover the space of possible initial configurations (Fig. 2d). Independent of the initial conditions, the evolutionary simulation converged to the same combination of two growth rates, as seen in the clusters of the final growth rates of the simulation in Fig. 2e and also in the 2D projections of this plot shown in Fig. S2b–d. These data suggest that this combination of strains is the only stable-fixed point of the evolutionary dynamics that we simulated.
Phenotypic characterization
Next, we wanted to know to what extent the model predictions were reflected in the real phenotypes of the L- and S-ecotypes that emerged from the LTEE. We therefore phenotypically characterized a set of L- and S-ecotypes isolated at a specific timepoint in the LTEE. First, we measured acetate excretion rates of the L- and S-strains by taking supernatant samples along the growth curves of the L- and S-strain. Indeed, we found that different growth rates of the L- and S-strains on glucose also resulted in different acetate excretion rates (Fig. 3a), consistent with the trade-off between growth rate and acetate excretion rate (Fig. 1a).
To confirm the role of the second trade-off, we next wanted to measure lag phases of the L- and S-strains. The amount of acetate excreted with the glucose concentrations used in the LTEE is very low, making it difficult to quantify lag phases. Therefore, we grew the two strains separately in the presence of the normal LTEE concentration of glucose but with a much greater concentration of acetate present in the medium to measure their respective lag times in the resulting diauxic shift. To get a more precise readout of growth at the low optical densities, where glucose is depleted, we also transfected the L- and S-strains with fluorescent proteins. Indeed, precisely as expected from the model, the faster growth rate of the L-strain on glucose resulted in a longer lag time in the diauxic shift, as compared to the S-strain (Fig. 3b). This explains how the S-strain derives its fitness advantage after glucose depletion in the LTEE, whereas the L-strain benefits from faster growth enabled by higher acetate excretion during the glucose growth phase. This interplay is summarized in Fig. 3c.
Coexistence and break-down of coexistence in daily dilution experiment
Finally, we utilized the L- and S-strains with two different fluorescent proteins to perform the daily dilution experiment (see Fig. S3 for detailed protocol). We initiated the experiment with different ratios of the L- and S-strain and every 24 h, performed a 100-fold dilution in minimal medium with the same glucose concentration as the LTEE. As expected, the different cultures reached stable coexistence after several days (Fig. 4a). We next wanted to directly test the causal requirement of the two trade-offs for coexistence. Therefore, we split coexisting cultures and continued daily dilution in different modified media. In one case, a large amount of acetate (5 mM) was provided in addition to the normal glucose amount (139μM) with every dilution. According to the simulation, for a high enough amount of acetate provided in the medium, coexistence should disappear, and the L-strain should be eliminated. This is because when acetate is provided in the medium, the S-strain does not need to rely on the presence of the L-strain with its higher acetate excretion rate (Fig. S4). Indeed, experimentally, serial dilution in medium with high concentrations of acetate resulted in elimination of the L-strain (Fig. 4b, c squares). Conversely, at slower growth rates without acetate excretion, the simulation predicted absence of coexistence (see Fig. 1f). Indeed, performing the daily dilution experiment in glycerol minimal medium, where no acetate is excreted13, coexistence disappeared, and the slower-growing L-strain was eliminated (Fig. 4b, c triangles and Fig. S5).
Discussion
Our findings show that the emergence and persistence of coexistence in the LTEE can be explained by the interplay of two independent trade-offs given by Eqs. [1–2]. Despite thousands of generations of evolution, we show that the phenotypes of the L- and S-strain remain constrained by the two trade-offs (see Fig. 3a–c): The L-strain is a fermentation specialist that grows more quickly on glucose by excreting more acetate. Conversely, the S-strain is specialized in switching to acetate at the cost of a slower growth rate on glucose.
The long-term persistence of coexistence in the LTEE under continued evolution is remarkable because a hypothetical fast-growing strain that does not excrete acetate, having overcome the acetate excretion trade-off by evolution, would take over the population and abolish coexistence. Similarly, a hypothetical fast-growing strain without a lag when switching to acetate, having overcome the lag time trade-off by evolution, would immediately be able to utilize excreted acetate as efficiently as the slower growing strain. Therefore, this hypothetical strain would also outcompete both the L- and S-strain and abolish coexistence. Both trade-off are required for coexistence to be maintained. However, neither of these hypothetical scenarios have occurred in the LTEE. This demonstrates that the two trade-offs are indeed evolutionary constraints that are not easily overcome even after thousands of generations of evolution.
Methods
Bacterial strains
Strains used in this paper are the original E. coli strains isolated by Rozen and Lenski6. Original S-strain used in this study is REL7409 (which is a S morph clone from REL7324). Original L-strain used in this study is REL 7410 (which is a L morph clone from REL7324). Strains were received as a kind gift from Dr. Richard Lenski.
Preparation of L strain expressing cytoplasmic CFP (Cyan fluorescence protein) and S-strain expressing cytoplasmic YFP (Yellow fluorescence protein)
RNA1 promoter driving CFP:: Kanamycinr was transferred to L-strain via P1 transduction. RNA1 promoter driving mVenus:: Kanamycinr was transferred to S-strain via the same protocol and L-strain expressing cytoplasmic YFP was also prepared by same protocol. P1 transduction protocol was adapted from Thomason et al.17.
Growth media
N+C+ minimal medium with 20 mM NH4Cl and different concentrations of carbon sources was used. Composition of N+C+ minimal medium is detailed in table below. Each medium was prepared using a 4X N-C- salt solution stock, which was diluted to 1X concentration in final media formulation and supplemented with 20 mM NH4Cl (final concentration) and the carbon source. After preparation, each medium was filtered using disposable vacuum filtration system (Corning, PES filter with 0.22 pore size).
1 L of 4x N-C- stock salt solution was prepared in the following way:
Species | Grams (g) | Formula weight (Da) | Molarity (mM) |
---|---|---|---|
K2SO4 | 4 | 174.26 | 23.0 |
K2HPO4 | 54 | 174.18 | 310.0 |
KH2PO4 | 18.8 | 136.09 | 138.1 |
MgSO4 | 0.192 | 120.37 | 1.6 |
NaCl | 10 | 58.44 | 171.1 |
K2SO4 (VWR BDH Chemicals, Catalog #: BDH4618-500G), K2HPO4 (VWR BDH Chemicals, Catalog #: BDH9266-2.5KG), KH2PO4 (VWR BDH Chemicals, BDH9268-2.5KG), MgSO4 (Sigma Aldrich, M7506-1KG), NaCl (Sigma Aldrich, S7653-1KG)
Carbon sources: D(+) Mannose (Sigma Aldrich, M6020-25G, Lot #BCBV4824), Glucose (Sigma, G5146), Sodium Acetate (Sigma S2889), Glycerol (VWR BDHH1172-1LP)
Measurement of Acetate excretion rate
For acetate excretion rate measurement, the original S-strain (REL7409) and original L-strain (REL 7410) were used and excretion rate was measured following the protocol previously described by Basan et al.13. Briefly, L- and S-strain were inoculated in LB medium from single colonies and then diluted in N+C+ minimal medium with 44.4 mM glucose and 20 mM NH4Cl for overnight culture. The next morning, tubes with fresh N+C+ minimal medium with 44.4 mM glucose and 20 mM NH4Cl were inoculated from saturated overnight culture. Freshly inoculated tubes were placed in shaking water bath incubator at 37 °C, with 200 RPM orbital shaking. Optical densities (OD600) of the freshly inoculated cultures were measured using a spectrophotometer (Genesys 30 visible spectrophotometer, Thermo Scientific). After the freshly inoculated cultures reached exponential growth phase, 1 ml culture samples were pipetted out from the inoculated tubes in 1.5 ml microcentrifuge tubes. Multiple samples were taken from each tube along exponential growth phase and optical density at the time of sample collection was noted. After sample collection, bacterial cells were precipitated out of the aspirated samples by centrifuging the 1.5 ml tubes in a microcentrifuge at 16000Xg for 3 min. Media supernatants from the tubes were carefully transferred to fresh 1.5 ml tubes, without disturbing the pellet. Acetate concentrations in the collected media samples were measured using an acetate colorimetric assay kit (Sigma-Aldrich, MAK086) following the manufacturer’s protocol. Absorbance at 450 nm was read in a BioTek, Synergy H1 microplate reader. Measured acetate concentrations were plotted as a function of optical density of the samples at the time of sample collection. Acetate excretion rate was calculated from the slope of the linear regression through the origin, multiplied by the growth rate as described before by Basan et al.13.
Diauxic shift measurement
L-strain expressing cytoplasmic YFP and S-strain expressing cytoplasmic YFP were grown in LB culture from single isolated colonies. For overnight culture, N + C+ minimal media with 20 mM NH4Cl and 139 μM D(+) glucose (concentration used by Lenski in the LTEE) was used. Strains were separately inoculated from LB culture in 5 ml media and inoculated tubes were placed in a shaking air incubator (Infors HT) maintained at 37 °C, with 200 RPM orbital shaking. The next day, 1% of the saturated overnight cultures were freshly inoculated separately in 1 ml fresh N + C+ minimal media with 20 mM NH4Cl, 139 μM D(+) glucose and 10 mM sodium acetate and mixed well by vortex mixing. From the freshly inoculated tubes, 200 μl samples were transferred to a clear bottom 96 well plate with dark wall (Greiner bio-one, 655090). Two separate wells of the 96 well plate was used for each strain. Fluorescence intensity of YFP from each well was measured in 30 min intervals for 24 h in a BioTek Synergy H1 microplate reader, maintained at 37 °C with continuous shaking. Fluorescence intensity from duplicate wells was calculated and normalized to the point when the exponential growth slowed down for each strain, indicating the depletion of glucose and initiation of diauxic shift. Time of normalization for each strain was denoted as time 0 and normalized average fluorescence intensity calculated from duplicate wells as a function of time was plotted in semi-log scale.
Coexistence experiment
For coexistence experiment, we used L-strain with cytoplasmic CFP (henceforth mentioned as LC) and S-strain with cytoplasmic YFP (henceforth referred to as SY). LC and SY strains were grown in LB for 3 h, then diluted in 5 ml N + C+ minimal medium with 20 mM NH4Cl and 139μM D(+) glucose (henceforth referred to as daily dilution medium) from isolated single colonies, and grown overnight in a shaker air incubator (Infors HT, maintained at 37 °C, with 200 RPM orbital shaking). For two replicate experiments, two separate colonies of LC and SY strain were inoculated in LB and subsequently transferred to overnight culture in minimal medium. On the next day, we inoculated 5 ml tubes with fresh daily dilution medium with the different overnight cultures. We mixed LC and SY strains at different initial ratios and ensured that the total inoculum volume was 1% of the medium (i.e. 50 μL in 5 ml medium). We started the experiment with three initial ratios of LC and SY strains (LC:SY = 10:1, 45.5 μL LC and 4.5 μL SY; LC:SY = 1:1, 25 μL LC and 25 μL SY; LC:SY = 1:10, 4.5 μL LC and 45.5 μL SY). After inoculation, tubes were transferred to an air incubator (Infors HT, maintained at 37 °C, with 200 RPM orbital shaking). Every 24 h, we transferred 1% from the saturated overnight culture to new tubes containing daily dilution medium for daily dilution. Samples for colony counting were taken from the overnight saturated co-culture tubes and diluted 10,000-fold in N + C+ minimal medium. 100μL of diluted culture was plated on LB-Agar plates (in triplicate) for colony counting purpose. After plating, LB-Agar plates were incubated overnight in a 37 °C incubator. The next day each plate was imaged using a custom-built fluorescence colony imager set up. Each plate was imaged in three channels (brightfield, CFP-fluorescence channel and YFP- fluorescence channel). The number of LC (CFP colonies, representing L-strain) and SY (YFP colonies, representing S-strain) colonies from each plate was determined using Stardist plugin in Fiji (imageJ) using a custom macro. After automatic count, we also manually inspected each image for obvious errors, such as false positive or false negative colony detection. If required, total counts were rectified. Frequency of LC and SY colonies were plotted as a function of time.
As mentioned, plating was done in triplicate from each tube for each biological replicate experiment. For each ratio conditions of individual biological replicate, frequencies of L- and S-strain were calculated from each plate of the triplicate plating and then averaged. After this we averaged the frequencies from two biological replicate experiments. Finally, we plotted the mean frequency for each ratio from two biological replicates.
Coexistence breaking experiment
After the LC:SY = 1:10 batch culture from first replicate of the initial coexistence experiment was plated for consecutive 9 days and showed stable coexistence, we split this culture into different media conditions. We continued diluting the original batch culture in daily dilution medium each day, while transferring 1% inoculum from the coexisting stable batch culture to the following media in duplicate tubes:
-
1.
N + C+minimal media with 20 mM NH4Cl and 139μM D(+) Glucose and 5 mM Sodium Acetate (henceforth referred to as Acetate-media),
-
2.
N + C+minimal media with 20 mM NH4Cl and 277.52 μM Glycerol (we kept the number of carbon atom the same as in daily dilution medium. Glycerol being a 3 C compound was added in double molar amount to that of glucose).
Each day 1% inoculum was transferred to the respective type of fresh medium. Colony counts of L- and S-strains on each day in these new media conditions were determined by plating from each tube in triplicate plates. First, for each tube with new media condition, we calculated the frequency of L- and S-strain from each plate of the triplicate plates and averaged. Then frequency calculated for each of the duplicate tubes were averaged. We observed that the optical density of the culture reached a six-fold higher level in acetate as compared to the daily dilution medium. Thus, for colony counting, we first diluted the overnight acetate culture 6-fold, and then performed a 10,000-fold dilution and plated 100 μL sample (in triplicate) for colony count. (Another replicate of the coexistence breaking experiment was performed when the LC:SY = 10:1 from the second biological replicate reached steady-state coexistence. That culture was also split following the same protocol described above).
Statistical methods
Statistical tests were performed using GraphPad Prism. For Fig. 3a and Fig. S5, unpaired t-tests were performed and obtained p-values are reported in the respective figure legends.
P-value < 0.0001 represented as: ****, P-value ranging from 0.0001 to 0.001 denoted as: ***, P-value ranging from 0.001 to 0.01 denoted as: **, P-value ranging from 0.01 to 0.05 denoted as: *, and P-value ≥ 0.05 denoted as not-significant or ns wherever necessary.
Schematic graphics
Schematic graphics used in some figures (Fig. 3 and Fig. S3) is prepared with biorender.com.
Reporting summary
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this article.
Data availability
Source data are provided as a Source Data.ZIP file. Source data are provided with this paper.
Code availability
The simulation code will be shared upon request.
Change history
05 December 2023
A Correction to this paper has been published: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-43839-2
References
Pennisi, E. The man who bottled evolution. Science 342, 790–793 (2013).
Lenski, R. E., Rose, M. R., Simpson, S. C. & Tadler, S. C. Long-term experimental evolution in escherichia coli. I. Adaptation and divergence during 2,000 generations. Am. Nat. 138, 1315–1341 (1991).
Oxman, E., Alon, U. & Dekel, E. Defined order of evolutionary adaptations: experimental evidence. Evolution (N. Y) 62, 1547–1554 (2008).
Fitch, W. M., Ayala, F. J., Lenski, R. E. & Travisano, M. Dynamics of adaptation and diversification: a 10,000-generation experiment with bacterial populations. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 91, 6808–6814 (1994).
Rozen, D. E., Schneider, D. & Lenski, R. E. Long-term experimental evolution in Escherichia coli. XIII. Phylogenetic history of a balanced polymorphism. J. Mol. Evol. 61, 171–180 (2005).
Rozen, D. E. & Lenski, R. E. Long-term experimental evolution in Escherichia coli. VIII. Dynamics of a balanced polymorphism. Am. Nat. 155, 24–35 (2000).
Good, B. H., McDonald, M. J., Barrick, J. E., Lenski, R. E. & Desai, M. M. The dynamics of molecular evolution over 60,000 generations. Nature 551, 45–50 (2017).
Le Gac, M., Plucain, J., Hindré, T., Lenski, R. E. & Schneider, D. Ecological and evolutionary dynamics of coexisting lineages during a long-term experiment with Escherichia coli. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109, 9487–9492 (2012).
Lenski, R. E. & Velicer, G. J. Games Microbes Play. https://lenski.mmg.msu.edu/lenski/pdf/2000,%20Selection,%20Lenski%20&%20Velicer.pdf (2000).
Adami, C., Schossau, J. & Hintze, A. Evolution and stability of altruist strategies in microbial games. Phys. Rev. E 85, 11914 (2012).
MacLean, R. C. & Gudelj, I. Resource competition and social conflict in experimental populations of yeast. Nature 441, 498–501 (2006).
Wortel, M. T. Evolutionary coexistence in a fluctuating environment by specialization on resource level. J. Evol. Biol. 36, 622–631 (2023).
Basan, M. et al. Overflow metabolism in Escherichia coli results from efficient proteome allocation. Nature 528, 99–104 (2015).
Basan, M., Hui, S. & Williamson, J. R. ArcA overexpression induces fermentation and results in enhanced growth rates of E. coli. Sci. Rep. 7, 11866 (2017).
Basan, M. et al. A universal trade-off between growth and lag in fluctuating environments. Nature 584, 470–474 (2020).
Schink, S. J. et al. Glycolysis/gluconeogenesis specialization in microbes is driven by biochemical constraints of flux sensing. Mol. Syst. Biol. 18, e10704 (2022).
Thomason, L. C., Costantino, N. & Court, D. L. E. coli genome manipulation by P1 transduction. Curr. Protoc. Mol. Biol. 79, 1.17.1–1.17.8 (2007).
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Dr. Richard Lenski for kindly sharing the LTEE ecotypes with us and Dr. Oskar Hallatschek helpful discussions and for bringing the coexistence phenomenon in the LTEE to our attention. We would also like to thank Daniel Eaton and Johan Paulsson lab for providing fluorescent protein expressing strains used as donor strain for P1 transduction. This project was supported by MIRA grant (5R35GM137895), the Systems, Synthetic and Quantitative Biology PhD training award (T32GM135014), and an HMS Junior Faculty Armenise grant to M.B.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
A.M., M.B. conceptualized the project and designed the experiments. A.M., M.B. performed the modelling and simulation. J.E., A.M., Y.H., performed the coexistence experiment and analyzed data. A.M., Y.H. performed lag phase measurement and other experiments and analyzed the data. Y.H. prepared the Image processing pipeline. N.C.B. and M.P. contributed to dilution experiments and analyzed the data. M.B., A.M., J.E., N.C.B., Y.H., M.P. contributed to preparing the manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interest.
Peer review
Peer review information
Nature Communications thanks Christoph Adami and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. A peer review file is available.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Source data
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Mukherjee, A., Ealy, J., Huang, Y. et al. Coexisting ecotypes in long-term evolution emerged from interacting trade-offs. Nat Commun 14, 3805 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-39471-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-39471-9
- Springer Nature Limited
This article is cited by
-
Emergence and maintenance of stable coexistence during a long-term multicellular evolution experiment
Nature Ecology & Evolution (2024)
-
Environmental memory alters the fitness effects of adaptive mutations in fluctuating environments
Nature Ecology & Evolution (2024)
-
Shaping of microbial phenotypes by trade-offs
Nature Communications (2024)