Abstract
During the debates about the legalization of Voluntary Assisted Dying (VAD) in Victoria, Australia, the presence of anti-VAD health professionals in the medical community and reported high rates of conscientious objection (CO) to VAD suggested access may be limited. Most empirical research on CO has been conducted in the sexual and reproductive health context. However, given the fundamental differences in the nature of such procedures and the legislation governing it, these findings may not be directly transferable to VAD. Accordingly, we sought to understand how CO operates in the context of VAD. Prior to the implementation of the VAD legislation in June 2019, we conducted semi-structured interviews with seventeen health professionals with a self-declared CO to VAD, to explore what motivated their CO. Participants identified multiple motivations, which can be broadly categorized as: concerns for oneself; concerns for patients; concerns about the current Victorian legislation; and concerns for the medical profession. Participants’ moral commitments included personal, professional, and political commitments. In some cases, one’s CO was specific to Victoria’s current legislation rather than VAD more broadly. Our findings suggest CO motivations extend beyond those traditionally cited and suggest a need to better understand and manage CO in the healthcare context.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Althagafi, A., C. Ekong, B.W. Wheelock, et al. 2019. Canadian neurosurgeons’ views on medical assistance in dying (MAID): A cross-sectional survey of Canadian Neurosurgical Society (CNSS) members. Journal of Medical Ethics 45(5): 309-313.
Blaschke, S.M., P. Schofield, K. Taylor, and A. Ugalde. 2019. Common dedication to facilitating good dying experiences: qualitative study of end-of-life care professionals' attitudes towards voluntary assisted dying. Palliative Medicine 33(6): 562-569.
Brock, D.W. 2008. Conscientious refusal by physicians and pharmacists: Who is obligated to do what, and why? Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics: Philosophy of Medical Research and Practice 29(3): 187-200.
Card, R.F. 2017. The inevitability of assessing reasons in debates about conscientious objection in medicine. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 26(1): 82-96.
Chavkin, W., L. Leitman, and K. Polin. 2013. Conscientious objection and refusal to provide reproductive healthcare: A white paper examining prevalence, health consequences, and policy responses. International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics 123(S3): S41-S56.
Christie, T., J. Sloan, D.Dahlgren, and F. Koning. 2016. Medical assistance in dying in Canada: an ethical analysis of conscientious and religious objections. BioéthiqueOnline 5(14): https://doi.org/10.7202/1044272ar.
Clark, D., G. Dickinson, C.J. Lancaster, et al. 2001. UK geriatricians’ attitudes to active voluntary euthanasia and physician-assisted death. Age and Aging 30(5): 395-398.
Dresser, R. 2005. Professionals, conformity, and conscience. The Hastings Center Report 35(6): 9-10.
Ganzini, L., H.D. Nelson, M.A. Lee, D.F. Kraemer, et al. 2001. Oregon physicians’ attitudes about and experiences with end-of-life care since passage of the Oregon Death with Dignity Act. Journal of the American Medical Association 285(18): 2363-2369.
Huxtable, R., and A. Mullock. 2015. Voices of discontent: Conscience, compromise, and assisted dying. Medical Law Review 23(2): 242–262.
Karapetis, C.S., B. Stein, B. Koczwara, R. Harrup, et al. 2018. Medical Oncology Group of Australia position statement and membership survey on voluntary assisted dying. Internal Medicine Journal 48(7): 774-779.
Keogh, L.A., L. Gillam, M. Bismark, et al. 2019. Conscientious objection to abortion, the law and its implementation in Victoria, Australia: Perspectives of abortion service providers. BMC Medical Ethics 20(1): 1-10.
Lachman, V.D. 2014. Conscientious objection in nursing: Definition and criteria for acceptance. MEDSURG Nursing Journal 23(3): 196–198.
Liamputtong, P. 2013. Qualitative research methods, 4th ed. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
Maguire, M., and B. Delahunt. 2017. Doing a thematic analysis: A practical, step-by-step guide for learning and teaching scholars. The All Ireland Journal of Teaching & Learning in Higher Education 9(3): 3351-33514.
Medical Board of Australia and Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency. 2014. Good medical practice: A code of conduct for doctors in Australia. Australia: Medical Board of Australia. https://www.medicalboard.gov.au/ Codes-Guidelines-Policies/Code-of-conduct.aspx. Accessed February 12, 2021.
Meyers, C., and R. Woods. 2007. Conscientious objection? Yes, but make sure it is genuine. American Journal of Bioethics 7(6): 19-20.
O’Connor, M.M., R.W. Hunt, J. Gardner, et al. 2018. Documenting the process of developing the Victorian voluntary assisted dying legislation. Australian Health Review 42(6): 621-626.
Otte, I.C., C. Jung, B. Elger, and K. Bally. 2017. “We need to talk!” Barriers to GPs’ communication about the option of physician-assisted suicide and their ethical implications: Results from a qualitative study. Medicine, Health Care, and Philosophy 20(2): 249-256.
Savulescu, J., and U. Schüklenk. 2017. Doctors have no right to refuse medical assistance in dying, abortion or contraception. Bioethics 31(3): 162-170.
Schüklenk, U. 2018. Conscientious objection in medicine: Accommodation versus professionalism and the public good. British Medical Bulletin 126(1): 47-56.
Shanawani, H. 2016. The challenges of conscientious objection in health care. Journal of Religion and Health 55(2): 384-393.
Sulmasy, D. P. 2008. What is conscience and why is respect for it so important? Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 29(3): 135-149.
Swartz, M.S. 2006. Conscience clauses or unconscionable clauses: Personal beliefs versus professional responsibilities. Yale Journal of Health Policy, Law and Ethics 6(2): 269-350.
Turla, A., E. Ozkara, C. Ozkanli, and N. Alkan. 2007. Health professionals’ attitude toward euthanasia: A cross-sectional study from Turkey. Omega—The Journal Of Death And Dying 54(2): 135-145.
Wicclair, M.R. 2000. Conscientious objection in medicine. Bioethics 14(3): 205-227.
Wicclair, M. 2017. Conscientious objection in healthcare and moral integrity. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 26(1): 97–108.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Haining, C.M., Keogh, L.A. & Gillam, L.H. Understanding the Reasons Behind Healthcare Providers’ Conscientious Objection to Voluntary Assisted Dying in Victoria, Australia. Bioethical Inquiry 18, 277–289 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-021-10096-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-021-10096-1