Abstract
Sustainability transitions aim to comprehensively address key challenges of today’s societies through harmonizing ecological integrity and social viability. During the last decades, increasing attention has focused on the conceptual development and identification of trajectories that navigate societies toward sustainability. While a broad agreement exists with regard to the need for mainstreaming sustainability into the core of decision-making and everyday practices, different transition pathway narratives are advocated to foster urgently needed structural and societal changes. In this article, we describe four archetypes of present transition narratives, examining the system properties (from underpinning intent to mechanistic parameters) that each narrative seeks to transform. We review the articulated critiques of, and provide exemplary case studies for, each narrative. The four transition narratives are (1) the green economy, (2) low-carbon transformation, (3) ecotopian solutions and (4) transition movements. Based on our analysis, we argue that despite the assumption that these narratives represent competing pathways, there is considerable complementarity between them regarding where in a given system they seek to intervene. An integrative approach could potentially help bridge these intervention types and connect fragmented actors at multiple levels and across multiple phases of transition processes. Effectively mainstreaming sustainability will ultimately require sustainability scientists to navigate between, and learn from, multiple transition narratives.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aall C, Juhola S, Hovelsrud GK (2015) Local climate change adaptation: moving from adjustments to transformation? Local Environ 20:401–407. doi:10.1080/13549839.2014.908594
Abson DJ, Fischer J, Leventon J et al (2016) Leverage points for sustainability transformation. Ambio. doi:10.1007/s13280-016-0800-y
Aiken G (2012) Community transitions to low carbon futures in the transition towns network (TTN). Geogr Compass 6:89–99. doi:10.1111/j.1749-8198.2011.00475.x
Anderson J (2007) Elusive escapes? everyday life and ecotopia. Ecopolitics Online J. doi:10.1108/S2041-806X(2007)0000001006
Audet R (2014) The double hermeneutic of sustainability transitions. Environ Innov Soc Transit 11:46–49. doi:10.1016/j.eist.2014.02.001
Avelino F, Wittmayer JM (2015) Shifting power relations in sustainability transitions: a multi-actor perspective. J Environ Policy Plan 18:628–649. doi:10.1080/1523908X.2015.1112259
Aylett A (2013) Networked urban climate governance: neighborhood-scale residential solar energy systems and the example of Solarize Portland. Environ Plan C Gov Policy 31:858–875. doi:10.1068/c11304
Azevedo I, Delarue E, Meeus L (2013) Mobilizing cities towards a low-carbon future: tambourines, carrots and sticks. Energy Policy 61:894–900. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2013.06.065
Bailey I, Wilson GA (2009) Theorising transitional pathways in response to climate change: technocentrism, ecocentrism, and the carbon economy. Environ Plan A 41:2324–2341. doi:10.1068/a40342
Barbier E (2011) The policy challenges for green economy and sustainable economic development. Nat Resour Forum 35:233–245. doi:10.1111/j.1477-8947.2011.01397.x
Beatley T (2012) Sustainability in planning: the arc and trajectory of a movement, and new directions for the twenty-first-century city. In: Sanyal B, Vale LJ, Rosan CD (eds) Planning ideas that matter: livability, territoriality, governance, and reflective practice. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 91–124
Beland Lindahl K, Baker S, Rist L, Zachrisson A (2015) Theorising pathways to sustainability. Int J Sustain Dev World Ecol 23:399–411. doi:10.1080/13504509.2015.1128492
Bina O (2013) The green economy and sustainable development: an uneasy balance? Environ Plan C Gov Policy 31:1023–1047. doi:10.1068/c1310j
Blanchet T (2014) Struggle over energy transition in Berlin: how do grassroots initiatives affect local energy policy-making? Energy Policy 78:246–254. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2014.11.001
Borel-Saladin JM, Turok IN (2013) The green economy: incremental change or transformation? Environ Policy Gov 23:209–220. doi:10.1002/eet.1614
Bouvrie ND, Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen S, Jollands N (2015) Responsibility for radical change in addressing climate change. Carbon Manag 1–12. doi:10.1080/17583004.2015.1012394
Bowen A, Hepburn C (2015) Green growth: an assessment. Oxford Rev Econ Policy 30:407–422. doi:10.1093/oxrep/gru029
Brand U (2012) Green economy—the next oxymoron? GAIA Ecol Perspect Sci Soc 21:28–32
Brown RR, Farrelly MA, Loorbach DA (2013) Actors working the institutions in sustainability transitions: the case of Melbourne’s stormwater management. Glob Environ Chang 23:701–718. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.02.013
Bulkeley H (2010) Cities and the governing of climate change. Annu Rev Environ Resour 35:229–253. doi:10.1146/annurev-environ-072809-101747
Bulkeley H, Betsill M (2005) Rethinking sustainable cities: multilevel governance and the “urban” politics of climate change. Env Polit 14:42–63. doi:10.1080/0964401042000310178
Bulkeley H, Kern K (2006) Local government and the governing of climate change in Germany and the UK. Urban Stud 43:2237–2259. doi:10.1080/00420980600936491
Bulkeley H, Broto VC, Edwards G (2012) Bringing climate change to the city: towards low carbon urbanism? Local Environ 17:545–551. doi:10.1080/13549839.2012.681464
Bulkeley H, Castan Broto V, Maassen A (2014) Low-carbon transitions and the reconfiguration of urban infrastructure. Urban Stud 51:1471–1486. doi:10.1177/0042098013500089
Burch S (2010) In pursuit of resilient, low carbon communities: an examination of barriers to action in three Canadian cities. Energy Policy 38:7575–7585. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2009.06.070
Burch S, Shaw A, Dale A, Robinson J (2014) Triggering transformative change: a development path approach to climate change response in communities. Clim Policy 14:467–487. doi:10.1080/14693062.2014.876342
Chance T (2009) Towards sustainable residential communities; the beddington zero energy development (BedZED) and beyond. Environ Urban 21:527–544. doi:10.1177/0956247809339007
Coates GJ (2013a) Sustainable urbanism: creating resilient communities in the age of peak oil and climate destabilization. In: Wallimann I (ed) Environmental policy is social policy—social policy is environmental policy: toward sustainability policy. Springer, New York, pp 81–101
Coates GJ (2013b) The sustainable urban district of vauban in Freiburg, Germany. Int J Des Nat Ecodyn 8:265–286. doi:10.2495/DNE-V8-N4-265-286
Connelly S (2007) Mapping sustainable development as a contested concept. Local Environ 12:259–278. doi:10.1080/13549830601183289
Connors P, McDonald P (2010) Transitioning communities: community, participation and the transition town movement. Community Dev J 46:558–572. doi:10.1093/cdj/bsq014
Cook S, Smith K (2012) Introduction: green economy and sustainable development: bringing back the “social”. Development 55:5–9. doi:10.1057/dev.2011.120
De Geus M (2002) Ecotopia, sustainability, and vision. Organ Environ 15:187–201. doi:10.1177/10826602015002006
De Haan (Hans) J, Rotmans J (2011) Patterns in transitions: understanding complex chains of change. Technol Forecast Soc Chang 78:90–102. doi:10.1016/j.techfore.2010.10.008
Deakin M, Allwinkle S (2007) Urban regeneration and sustainable communities: the role of networks, innovation, and creativity in building successful partnerships. J Urban Technol 14:77–91. doi:10.1080/10630730701260118
Dietz S, Neumayer E (2007) Weak and strong sustainability in the SEEA: concepts and measurement. Ecol Econ 61:617–626. doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2006.09.007
Dow K, Berkhout F, Preston BL et al (2013) Limits to adaptation. Nat Clim Chang 3:305–307. doi:10.1038/nclimate1847
Ecotopia Österlen (2012) Ecotopia Österlen. www.ecotopia.se/en. Accessed 27 Apr 2015
Emelianoff C (2013) Local energy transition and multilevel climate governance: the contrasted experiences of two pioneer cities (Hanover, Germany, and Vaxjo, Sweden). Urban Stud 51:1378–1393. doi:10.1177/0042098013500087
Eriksson L (2008) Pro-environmental travel behavior: the importance of attitudinal factors, habits, and transport policy measures. Print & Media, Umeå University, Umeå
Farla J, Markard J, Raven R, Coenen L (2012) Sustainability transitions in the making: a closer look at actors, strategies and resources. Technol Forecast Soc Chang 79:991–998. doi:10.1016/j.techfore.2012.02.001
Field S (2011) Case study: vauban. Freiburg, Germany. In: Foletta N, Field S (eds) Europe’s vibrant new low car(bon) communities. Institute for Transportation & Development Policy, New York
Fraker H (2013) The hidden potential of sustainable neighborhoods. Island Press, Washington
Frantzeskaki N, Jhagroe S, Howlett M (2016) Greening the state? the framing of sustainability in dutch infrastructure governance. Environ Sci Policy 58:123–130. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2016.01.011
Fünfgeld H (2015) Facilitating local climate change adaptation through transnational municipal networks. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 12:67–73. doi:10.1016/j.cosust.2014.10.011
Gallie WB (1955) Essentially contested concepts. Aristot Soc 56:167–198
Geels FW (2002) Technological transitions as evolutionary reconfiguration processes: a multi-level perspective and a case-study. Res Policy 31:1257–1274. doi:10.1016/S0048-7333(02)00062-8
Geels FW (2005) Processes and patterns in transitions and system innovations: refining the co-evolutionary multi-level perspective. Technol Forecast Soc Chang 72:681–696. doi:10.1016/j.techfore.2004.08.014
Geels FW, McMeekin A, Mylan J, Southerton D (2015) A critical appraisal of sustainable consumption and production research: the reformist, revolutionary and reconfiguration positions. Glob Environ Chang 34:1–12. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2015.04.013
Gibbons JW, Winne CT, Scott DE et al (2006) Remarkable amphibian biomass and abundance in an isolated wetland: implications for wetland conservation. Conserv Biol 20:1457–1465
Gibson RB, Hassan S, Holtz S et al (2005) Sustainability assessment: criteria and processes. Earthscan, London
Glover P Creating community economics with local currency. In: Ithaca HOURS. Community curr. since 1991. http://www.paulglover.org/hourintro.html. Accessed 23 Jan 2016
Hallegatte S, Heal G, Fay M, Treguer D (2012) From growth to green growth. The World Bank, Policy Research Working Paper, Cambridge
Hamdouch A, Depret M-H (2010) Policy integration strategy and the development of the “green economy”: foundations and implementation patterns. J Environ Plan Manag 53:473–490. doi:10.1080/09640561003703889
Hansen T, Coenen L (2015) The geography of sustainability transitions: review, synthesis and reflections on an emergent research field. Environ Innov Soc Transit 17:92–109. doi:10.1016/j.eist.2014.11.001
Hegger DLT, Van Vliet J, Van Vliet BJM (2007) Niche management and its contribution to regime change: the case of innovation in sanitation. Technol Anal Strateg Manag 19:729–746. doi:10.1080/09537320701711215
Hermwille L (2016) The role of narratives in socio-technical transitions—Fukushima and the energy regimes of Japan, Germany, and the United Kingdom. Energy Res Soc Sci 11:237–246. doi:10.1016/j.erss.2015.11.001
Hodson M, Marvin S (2012) Mediating low-carbon urban transitions? forms of organization, knowledge and action. Eur Plan Stud 20:421–439. doi:10.1080/09654313.2012.651804
Hopkins R (2012) Peak oil and transition towns. Archit Des 82:72–77. doi:10.1002/ad.1432
Hoppe T, Graf A, Warbroek B et al (2015) Local governments supporting local energy initiatives: lessons from the best practices of Saerbeck (Germany) and Lochem (The Netherlands). Sustainability 7:1900–1931. doi:10.3390/su7021900
Ison R, Schlindwein SL (2015) Navigating through an “ecological desert and a sociological hell”. Kybernetes 44:891–902. doi:10.1108/K-01-2015-0007
Jackson T (2009) Prosperity without growth: economics for a finite planet. Earthscan, London
Jacob J, Brinkerhoff M, Jovic E, Wheatley G (2004) The social and cultural capital of community currency. An ithaca HOURS Case Study Survey. Int J Community Curr Res 8:42–56. doi:10.15133/j.ijccr.2004.002
Jacobsson S, Lauber V (2006) The politics and policy of energy system transformation—explaining the German diffusion of renewable energy technology. Energy Policy 34:256–276. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2004.08.029
Jänicke M (2012) “Green growth”: from a growing eco-industry to economic sustainability. Energy Policy 48:13–21. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2012.04.045
Johanson H (2010) Fossil fuel free Växjö: moving towards the vision of zero emissions (Växjö, Sweden). In: van Staden M, Musco F (eds) Local governments and climate change. Springer Netherlands, Dordrecht
Jones MD, Mcbeth MK, Shanahan A (2014) Introducing the narrative policy framework. In: Jones MD, Shanahan EA, McBeth MK (eds) The science of stories: applications of the narrative policy framework in public policy analysis. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, pp 1–26
Joss S (2011) Eco-city governance: a case study of treasure Island and Sonoma Mountain Village. J Environ Policy Plan 13:331–348. doi:10.1080/1523908X.2011.611288
Kates RW, Parris TM (2003) Long-term trends and a sustainability transition. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100:8062–8067. doi:10.1073/pnas.1231331100
Kates RW, Travis WR, Wilbanks TJ (2012) Transformational adaptation when incremental adaptations to climate change are insufficient. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 109:7156–7161. doi:10.1073/pnas.1115521109
Khan J (2013) What role for network governance in urban low carbon transitions? J Clean Prod 50:133–139. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.11.045
Khromov D (2011) Ithaca hours revival would require community support. In: Ithaca.com. http://www.ithaca.com/news/article_175100c4-65d6-11e0-bd73-001cc4c002e0.html. Accessed 23 Jan 2016
Kofler B, Netzer N, Beuermann C et al (2014) Towards a global energy transformation. Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, Berlin
Kurland NB, McCaffrey SJ, Hill DH (2012) The localism movement: shared and emergent values. J Environ Sustain 2:1–14. doi:10.14448/jes.02.0006
Leach M, Scoones I, Stirling A (2010) Dynamic sustainabilities: technology, environment, social justice. Earthscan, London
Lo K (2014) Urban carbon governance and the transition toward low-carbon urbanism: review of a global phenomenon. Carbon Manag 5:269–283. doi:10.1080/17583004.2014.981384
Loorbach D, Rotmans J (2010) The practice of transition management: examples and lessons from four distinct cases. Futures 42:237–246. doi:10.1016/j.futures.2009.11.009
Loorbach D, Van Der Brugge R, Taanman M (2008) Governance in the energy transition: practice of transition management in the Netherlands. Int J Environ Technol Manag 9:294. doi:10.1504/IJETM.2008.019039
Loorbach D, Frantzeskaki N, Thissen W (2011) A transition research perspective on governance for sustainability. In: Jaeger CC, Tàbara JD, Jaeger J (eds) European research on sustainable development. Berlin, Heidelberg, pp 73–89
Luederitz C, Schäpke N, Wiek A et al (2016) Learning through evaluation—a tentative evaluative scheme for sustainability transition experiments. J Clean Prod. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.09.005
Markard J, Raven R, Truffer B (2012) Sustainability transitions: an emerging field of research and its prospects. Res Policy 41:955–967. doi:10.1016/j.respol.2012.02.013
Mascornick J (2007) Local currency loans and grants: comparative case studies of Ithaca HOURS and Calgary Dollars. Int J Community Curr Res 11:1–22. doi:10.15133/j.ijccr.2007.002
McAlpine CA, Seabrook LM, Ryan JG, et al (2015) Transformational change: creating a safe operating space for humanity. Ecol Soc 20:art56. doi:10.5751/ES-07181-200156
Meadows D (1999) Leverage points: places to intervene in a system. The Sustainability Institute, Hartland
Meadows D (2008) Thinking in systems. A primer. Earthscan, London
Meckley F (2015) New local currency offers Ithaca another alternative. In: The Ithacan. http://theithacan.org/news/new-local-currency-offers-ithaca-another-alternative-currency/. Accessed 6 Feb 2016
Michel A, Hudon M (2015) Community currencies and sustainable development: a systematic review. Ecol Econ 116:160–171. doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2015.04.023
Milbourne P (2012) Everyday (in) justices and ordinary environmentalisms: community gardening in disadvantaged urban neighbourhoods. Local Environ 17:943–957. doi:10.1080/13549839.2011.607158
Millard-Ball A (2012) Do city climate plans reduce emissions? J Urban Econ 71:289–311. doi:10.1016/j.jue.2011.12.004
Miller TR, Wiek A, Sarewitz D et al (2014) The future of sustainability science: a solutions-oriented research agenda. Sustain Sci 9:239–246. doi:10.1007/s11625-013-0224-6
Moloney S, Horne R (2015) Low carbon urban transitioning: from local experimentation to urban transformation? Sustainability 7:2437–2453. doi:10.3390/su7032437
Murray B, Rivers N (2015) British Columbia’s revenue-neutral carbon tax: a review of the latest “grand experiment” in environmental policy. Energy Policy 86:674–683. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2015.08.011
Naess A (1973) The shallow and the deep, long-range ecology movement. A summary. Inquiry 16:95–100. doi:10.1080/00201747308601682
Nevens F, Frantzeskaki N, Gorissen L, Loorbach D (2013) Urban transition labs: co-creating transformative action for sustainable cities. J Clean Prod 50:111–122. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.12.001
North P (2010) Eco-localisation as a progressive response to peak oil and climate change—a sympathetic critique. Geoforum 41:585–594. doi:10.1016/j.geoforum.2009.04.013
Olsson P, Galaz V (2012) Social-ecological innovation and transformation. In: Nicholls A, Murdoch A (eds) Social innovation: blurring sector boundaries and challenging institutional arrangements. Palgrave MacMillan, London
Parhankangas A, McWilliams A, Shrader RC (2015) Doing well by doing better: entrepreneurs and sustainability. J Small Bus Strateg 24:1–20
Pelenc J, Ballet J (2015) Strong sustainability, critical natural capital and the capability approach. Ecol Econ 112:36–44. doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2015.02.006
Pepper D (2007) Tensions and dilemmas of ecotopianism. Environ Values 16:289–312. doi:10.3197/096327107X228364
Picciotto R (2002) The logic of mainstreaming: a development evaluation perspective. Evaluation 8:322–339. doi:10.1177/135638902401462420
Pool R (2010) Urban eco-warriors. Eng Technol 5:42–45. doi:10.1049/et.2010.0409
Raven R, Schot J, Berkhout F (2012) Space and scale in socio-technical transitions. Environ Innov Soc Transitions 4:63–78. doi:10.1016/j.eist.2012.08.001
Rice JL (2013) Public targets, private choices: urban climate governance in the pacific Northwest. Prof Geogr 66:333–344. doi:10.1080/00330124.2013.787011
Roberts D (2008) Thinking globally, acting locally—institutionalizing climate change at the local government level in Durban, South Africa. Environ Urban 20:521–537. doi:10.1177/0956247808096126
Roe E (1994) Narrative policy analysis theory and practice. Duke University Press, Durham
Rosenzweig C, Solecki W, Hammer SA, Mehrotra S (2010) Cities lead the way in climate-change action. Nature 467:909–911. doi:10.1038/467909a
Rotmans J, Kemp R, van Asselt M (2001) More evolution than revolution: transition management in public policy. Foresight 3:15–31. doi:10.1108/14636680110803003
Schneidewind U (2013) Transformative literacy. Framework for a knowledge-based approach to coping with the “Great Transformation“. GAIA 22:82–86
Schroepfer T, Hee L, Werthmann C (2007) Transurban: vauban. WIT Trans Ecol Environ 102:145–153. doi:10.2495/SDP070141
Scoones I, Leach M, Newell P (2015) The politics of green transformations. Routledge, New York
Seyfang G (2009) The new economics of sustainable consumption: seeds of change. Palgrave MacMillan, Basingstoke
Shawki N (2013) Understanding the transnational diffusion of social movements: an analysis of the US. Solidarity economy nework and transition US. Humanity Soc 37:131–158. doi:10.1177/0160597613481799
Short SW, Bocken NMP, Barlow CY, Chertow MR (2014) From refining sugar to growing tomatoes. J Ind Ecol 18:603–618. doi:10.1111/jiec.12171
Smith A (2007) Translating sustainabilities between green niches and socio-technical regimes. Technol Anal Strateg Manag 19:427–450. doi:10.1080/09537320701403334
SusCom (2004) Case study: mainstreaming energy in sustainable development in Växjö, Sweden
Swilling M, Musango J, Wakeford J (2015) Developmental states and sustainability transitions: prospects of a just transition in South Africa. J Environ Policy Plan 7200:1–23. doi:10.1080/1523908X.2015.1107716
Switch Alliance (2013) L’économie que nous voulons. Positionner le Québec dans un monde en transition [The economy we want. Positioning Quebec in a transitioning world]
Taylor PJ (2012) Transition towns and world cities: towards green networks of cities. Local Environ 17:495–508. doi:10.1080/13549839.2012.678310
Van Der Wiel A, Bossink B, Masurel E (2012) Reverse logistics for waste reduction in cradle-to-cradle-oriented firms: waste management strategies in the Dutch metal industry. Int J Technol Manag 60:96. doi:10.1504/IJTM.2012.049108
Vandevyvere H, Nevens F (2015) Lost in transition or geared for the S-curve? an analysis of flemish transition trajectories with a focus on energy use and buildings. Sustainability 7:2415–2436. doi:10.3390/su7032415
Växjö Kommun (2014) Environmental programme for the city of Växjö. Växjö
Vazquez-Brust DA, Sarkis J (2012a) Green growth: managing the transition to a sustainable economy. Springer, Dordrecht
Vazquez-Brust DA, Sarkis J (2012b) Green growth: managing the transition to sustainable economies. In: Vazquez-Brust DA, Sarkis J (eds) Green growth: managing the transition to a sustainable economy. Springer, Dordrecht
Walker G (2008) What are the barriers and incentives for community-owned means of energy production and use? Energy Policy 36:4401–4405. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2008.09.032
Wamsler C, Luederitz C, Brink E (2014) Local levers for change: mainstreaming ecosystem-based adaptation into municipal planning to foster sustainability transitions. Glob Environ Chang 29:189–201. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2014.09.008
Warren CR, McFadyen M (2010) Does community ownership affect public attitudes to wind energy? A case study from south-west Scotland. Land use policy 27:204–213. doi:10.1016/j.landusepol.2008.12.010
Weick KE (1984) Small wins: redefining the scale of social problems. Am Psychol 39:40–49. doi:10.1037/0003-066X.39.1.40
Westley F, Olsson P, Folke C et al (2011) Tipping toward sustainability: emerging pathways of transformation. Ambio 40:762–780. doi:10.1007/s13280-011-0186-9
Wiek A, Iwaniec D (2013) Quality criteria for visions and visioning in sustainability science. Sustain Sci. doi:10.1007/s11625-013-0208-6
Wittmayer JM, Schäpke N (2014) Action, research and participation: roles of researchers in sustainability transitions. Sustain Sci 483–496. doi:10.1007/s11625-014-0258-4
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the reviewer and the editor Masaru Yarime for their helpful suggestions on an earlier version of this article. Many thanks to James Patterson and Stefan Partelow for discussing and commenting on the article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Handled by Masaru Yarime, Graduate School of Public Policy (GraSPP), University of Tokyo, Japan.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Luederitz, C., Abson, D.J., Audet, R. et al. Many pathways toward sustainability: not conflict but co-learning between transition narratives. Sustain Sci 12, 393–407 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-016-0414-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-016-0414-0