Abstract
Purpose
Palm biodiesel life cycle studies have been mainly performed for Asia and focused on greenhouse gas (GHG) intensity. The purpose of this article is to present an environmental life cycle assessment (LCA) of biodiesel produced in Portugal from palm oil (PO) imported from Colombia, addressing the direct effects of land-use change (LUC), different fertilization schemes, and biogas management options at the extraction mill.
Methods
An LC inventory and model of PO biodiesel was implemented based on data collected in five Portuguese biodiesel plants and in a palm plantation and extraction mill in the Orinoquía Region of Colombia. The emissions due to carbon stock changes associated with LUC were calculated based on the Colombian oil palm area expansion from 1990 to 2010 and on historical data of vegetation cleared for planting new palm trees. Five impact categories were assessed based on ReCiPe and CML-IA methods: GHG intensity, freshwater and marine eutrophication, photochemical oxidant formation, terrestrial acidification. A sensitivity analysis of alternative allocation approaches was performed.
Results and discussion
Palm plantation was the LC phase which contributed the most to eutrophication and acidification impacts, whereas transportation and oil extraction contributed the most to photochemical oxidation. An increase in carbon stock due to LUC associated with the expansion of Colombian oil palm was calculated (palm is a perennial crop with higher carbon stock than most previous land-uses). The choice of the fertilization scheme that leads to the lowest environmental impacts is contradictory among various categories. The use of calcium ammonium nitrate (followed by ammonium sulfate) leads to the lowest acidification and eutrophication impacts. The highest GHG intensity was calculated for calcium ammonium nitrate, while the lowest was for ammonium sulfate and poultry manure. Biogas captured and flared at the oil extraction mill instead of being released into the atmosphere had the lowest impacts in all categories (GHG intensity reduced by more than 60 % when biogas is flared instead of released).
Conclusions
Recommendation on the selection of the fertilization scheme depends on the environmental priority. ReCiPe and CML showed contradictory results for eutrophication and photochemical oxidation; however, uncertainty may impair strong recommendations. GHG intensity and photochemical oxidation impacts can be significantly reduced if biogas is flared instead of being released. However, more efficient biogas management should be implemented in order to reduce the impacts further.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Achten WMJ, Van den Bempt P, Almeida J, Mathis E, Muys B (2010) Life cycle assessment of a palm oil system with simultaneous production of biodiesel and cooking oil in Cameroon. Environ Sci Technol 44(12):4809–4815
Althaus HJ, Chudacoff M, Hischier R, Jungbluth N, Osses M, Primas A (2007) Life Cycle Inventories of Chemicals. Final report ecoinvent data v2.0. Volume: 8. Swiss Centre for LCI, Empa - TSL. Dübendorf, Switzerland
Angarita EY, Lora ES (2009) The energy balance in the palm oil-derived methyl ester (PME) life cycle for the cases in Brazil and Colombia. Renew Energy 34:2905–2913
Asman WAH (1992) Ammonia emission in Europe: updated emission and emission variations. Rep. 228471008. Bilthoven, the Netherlands: National Inst. of Public Health and Environmental Protection
Audsley E, Brander M, Chatterton J, Murphy-Bokern D, Webster C, Williams A (2009) How Low Can We Go? An Assessment of Greenhouse Gas Emissions from the UK Food System and the Scope to Reduce Them by 2050. WWF-UK
Bauer C (2007). Holzenergie. Sachbilanzen von Energiesystemen. Final report No. 6 ecoinvent data v2.0. Editors: Dones R. Volume: 6. Swiss Centre for LCI, PSI. Dübendorf and Villigen, Switzerland
Bouwman AF, Boumans LJM, Batjes NH (2002a) Emissions of N2O and NO from fertilised fields: summary of available measurement data. Glob Biogeochem Cycles 16:1058. doi:10.1029/2001GB001811
Bouwman AF, Boumans LJM, Batjes NH (2002b) Modeling global annual N2O and NO emissions from fertilised fields. Glob Biogeochem Cycles 16:1080. doi:10.1029/2001GB001812
Castanheira ÉG, Freire F (2011) Environmental performance of palm oil biodiesel in a life-cycle perspective. IEEE International Symposium on Sustainable Systems and Technology (ISSST), Chicago, 16–18 May 2011. doi:10.1109/ISSST.2011.5936843
Castanheira ÉG, Acevedo H, Freire F (2014) Greenhouse gas intensity of palm oil produced in Colombia addressing alternative land use change and fertilization scenarios. Appl Energy 114:958–967
Castanheira ÉG, Grisoli R, Coelho S, Silva GA, Freire F (2015) Life-cycle assessment of soybean-based biodiesel in Europe: comparing grain, oil and biodiesel import from Brazil. J Clean Prod 102:188–201
Cavalett O, Chagas MF, Seabra JEA, Bonomi A (2013) Comparative LCA of ethanol versus gasoline in Brazil using different LCIA methods. Int J Life Cycle Assess 18:647–658
Cederberg C, Martin Persson U, Neovius K, Molander S, Clift R (2011) Including carbon emissions from deforestation in the carbon footprint of Brazilian beef. Environ Sci Technol 45(5):1773–1779
Cenipalma (2010) Analisis multitemporal de coberturas en areas de interes para el cultivo de la palma. (Multi-temporal analysis of coverage in areas of interest for oil palm cultivation.) 2000–2002; 2005–2007. Cenipalma - Centro de Investigación en Palma de Aceite. 2010. Internal report. Bogota.
Choo YM, Muhamad H, Hashim Z, Subramaniam V, Puah CW, Tan YA (2011) Determination of GHG contributions by subsystems in the oil palm supply chain using the LCA approach. Int J Life Cycle Assess 16:669–681
Corley RHV, Tinker PB (2003) The Oil Palm. World Agriculture Series, 4th edn. Oxford, UK, Blackwell Publishing
Dreyer LC, Niemann AL, Hauschild MZ (2003) Comparison of three different LCIA methods: EDIP97, CML2001 and eco-indicator 99. Int J Life Cycle Assess 8:191–200
EC‐JRC (2011) International Reference Life Cycle Data System (ILCD) Handbook ‐ Recommendations for Life Cycle Impact Assessment in the European context. First edition. Luxemburg: European Commission‐Joint Research Centre ‐ Institute for Environment and Sustainability
Erisman JW, Grinsven H, Leip A, Mosier A, Bleeker A (2009) Nitrogen and biofuels; an overview of the current state of knowledge. Nutr Cycl Agroecosyst 86:211–223
European Commission (2009) Directive 2009/28/EC of the European Parliament and of the council of 23 April 2009 on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources and amending and subsequently repealing Directives 2001/77/EC and 2003/30/EC, Official Journal of the European Union, L140/16 of 5.6.2009
European Commission (2010a) Report from the Commission on indirect land-use change related to biofuels and bioliquids, COM (2010) 811 final. Brussels 22(12):2010
European Commission (2010) Commission Decision of 10 June 2010 on guidelines for the calculation of land carbon stocks for the purpose of Annex V to Directive 2009/28/EC, Official Journal of the European Union, L151/19 of 17.6.2010
Faist Emmenegger M, Heck T, Jungbluth N (2007) Erdgas. Sachbilanzen von Energiesystemen. Final report No. 6 ecoinvent data v2.0. Editors: Dones R.. Volume: 6. Swiss Centre for LCI, PSI. Dübendorf and Villigen, Switzerland
Faist Emmenegger M, Reinhard J, Zah R (2009) Sustainability Quick Check for Biofuels – intermediate background report. With contributions from T. Ziep, R. Weichbrodt, Prof. Dr. V. Wohlgemuth, FHTW Berlin and A. Roches, R. Freiermuth Knuchel, Dr. G. Gaillard, Agroscope Reckenholz-Tänikon. Dübendorf, Switzerland
FAO and IFA (2001) Global estimates of gaseous emissions of NH3, NO and N2O from agricultural land. First version, published by Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) and International Fertilizer Industry Association (IFA). Rome, 2001
FAO (2013) FAOSTAT. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Available at: http://www.fao.org/economic/est/prices
Fedepalma (2009) Anuario estadistico 2009—la agroindustria de la palma de aceite en Colombia. Bogota, Colombia
Finkbeiner M (2013) Indirect land use change (iLUC) within life cycle assessment (LCA) e scientific robustness and consistency with international standards. Berlin, Germany: Association of the German Biofuel Industry, Verband der ӧlsaatenverarbeitenden Industriein Deutschland; 2013
Frischknecht R, Fantke P, Tschümperlin L, Niero M, Antón A, Bare J, Boulay AM, Cherubini F, Hauschild MZ, Henderson A, Levasseur A, McKone TE, Michelsen O, Milà i Canals L, Pfister S, Ridoutt B, Rosenbaum RK, Verones F, Vigon B, Jolliet O (2016) Global guidance on environmental life cycle impact assessment indicators: progress and case study. Int J Life Cycle Assess 21:429–442
Garcia R, Marques P, Freire F (2014) Life-cycle assessment of electricity in Portugal. Appl Energ 134:563–572
Goedkoop M, Heijungs R, Huijbregts M, Schryver A, Struijs J, van Zelm R (2012) 2012) ReCiPe 2008: a life cycle impact assessment method which comprises harmonised category indicators at the midpoint and the endpoint level; First edition (revised. Characterisation, Report I
Guinée J, Gorrée M, Heijungs R, Huppes G, Kleijn R, de Koning A, Huijbregts M (2002) Handbook on Life Cycle Assessment – Operational Guide to the ISO Standards. I. LCA in Perspective; IIa: Guide; IIb: Operational Annex III: Scientific Background. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers
Hansen SB, Olsen SI, Ujang Z (2012) Greenhouse gas reductions through enhanced use of residues in the life cycle of Malaysian palm oil derived biodiesel. Bioresour Technol 104:358–366
Harsono SS, Prochnow A, Grundmann P, Hansen A, Hallmann C (2012) Energy balances and greenhouse gas emissions of palm oil biodiesel in Indonesia. GCB Bioenergy 4:213–228
Hassan MNA, Jaramillo P, Griffin WM (2011) Life cycle GHG emissions from Malaysian oil palm bioenergy development: the impact on transportation sector’s energy security. Energy Policy 39:2615–2625
Henson IE, Ruiz RR, Romero HM (2012) The greenhouse gas balance of the oil palm industry in Colombia : a preliminary analysis. II. Greenhouse gas emissions and the carbon budget. Agron Colombiana 30:370–378
IEA (2009) Electricity/Heat in Colombia in 2008. International Energy Agency-IEA, Paris, France
IFA (2013) Statistics-IFADATA. IFA-International Fertilizer Industry Association, Available at: http://www.fertilizer.org/ifa/ifadata/results
IPCC (2006) IPCC guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories. Prepared by the National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme, Eggleston, H.S., Buendia, L., Miwa, K., Ngara, T., Tanabe, K. (Eds.). Hayama, Japan: Institute for Global Environmental Strategies
IPCC (2007) IPCC Fourth Assessment Report: Climate Change 2007. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 2007. Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, USA: Cambridge University Press
Jolliet O, Frischknecht R, Bare J, Boulay A-M, Bulle C, Fantke P, Gheewala S, Hauschild M, Itsubo N, Margni M, McKone TE, Canals LM, Postuma L, Prado-Lopez V, Ridoutt B, Sonnemann G, Rosenbaum RK, Seager T, Struijs J, van Zelm R, Vigon B, Weisbrod A (2014) Global guidance on environmental life cycle impact assessment indicators: findings of the scoping phase. Int J Life Cycle Assess 19:962–967
Jungbluth N (2007) Erdöl. Sachbilanzen von Energiesystemen. Final report No. 6 ecoinvent data v2.0. Editors: Dones R. Volume: 6. Swiss Centre for LCI, PSI. Dübendorf and Villigen, Switzerland
Jungbluth N, Chudacoff M, Dauriat A, Dinkel F, Doka G, Faist Emmenegger M, Gnansounou E, Kljun N, Spielmann M, Stettler C, Sutter J (2007) Life Cycle Inventories of Bioenergy. Final report ecoinvent data v2.0. Volume: 17. Swiss Centre for LCI, ESU. Duebendorf and Uster, Switzerland
Kaewmai R, Kittikun H, Musikavong C (2012) Greenhouse gas emissions of palm oil mills in Thailand. Int J Greenh Gas Con 11:141–151
Klepper O, Beusen AHW, Meinardi CR (1995) Modelling the flow of nitrogen and phosphorus in Europe: from loads to coastal seas. RIVM report 451501004, RIVM, Bilthoven, the Nederlands
Lam MK, Lee KT (2011) Renewable and sustainable bioenergies production from palm oil mill effluent (POME): win-win strategies toward better environmental protection. Biotechnol Adv 29:124–41
Lam MK, Lee KT, Mohamed AR (2009) Life cycle assessment for the production of biodiesel: a case study in Malaysia for palm oil versus jatropha oil. Biofuels Bioprod Bioref 3:601–12
Lechon Y, Cabal H, Sáez R (2011) Life cycle greenhouse gas emissions impacts of the adoption of the EU Directive on biofuels in Spain. Effect of the import of raw materials and land use changes. Biomass Bioenerg 35:2374–2384
Malça J, Freire F (2010) Uncertainty analysis in biofuel systems: an application to the life cycle of rapeseed oil. J Ind Ecol 14:322–334
Malça J, Freire F (2011) Life-cycle studies of biodiesel in Europe: a review addressing the variability of results and modeling issues. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 15:338–351
Manik Y, Halog A (2012) A meta-analytic review of life cycle assessment and flow analyses studies of palm oil biodiesel. Integr Environ Assess Manag 9(1):134–141
Muñoz I, Schmidt JH, Brandão M, Weidema BP (2014) Avoiding the streetlight effect: Rebuttal to ‘Indirect land use change (iLUC) within life cycle assessment (LCA) – scientific robustness and consistency with international standards’ by prof. Dr. Matthias Finkbeiner. 2.‐0 LCA consultants, Aalborg 17th September 2014
Nemecek T, Kägi T (2007) Life Cycle Inventories of Swiss and European Agricultural Production Systems. Final report ecoinvent V2.0 No. 15a., Agroscope Reckenholz-Taenikon Research Station ART, Swiss Centre for Life Cycle Inventories, Zurich and Dübendorf, Switzerland
OECD-FAO (2013) OECD – FAO Agricultural Outlook 2013–2022 Highlights. Available at: http://www.oecd.org/
Papong S, Chom-In T, Noksa-nga S, Malakul P (2010) Life cycle energy efficiency and potentials of biodiesel production from palm oil in Thailand. Energy Policy 38:226–233
Patthanaissaranukool W, Polprasert C, Englande AJ (2013) Potential reduction of carbon emissions from Crude Palm Oil production based on energy and carbon balances. Appl Energy 102:710–717
Pinzon L (2012) Colombia: Biofuels annual. Colombian Biofuels Use Close to reaching E10 and B10 Levels. Gain Report. US Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC
Pleanjai S, Gheewala SH (2009) Full chain energy analysis of biodiesel production from palm oil in Thailand. Appl Energy 86:S209–S214
Prasuhn V (2006) Erfassung der PO4-Austräge für die Ökobilanzierung SALCA Phosphor. Agroscope Reckenholz - Tänikon ART, 20 p
Queiroz AG, França L, Ponte MX (2012) The life cycle assessment of biodiesel from palm oil (“dendê”) in the Amazon. Biomass Bioenerg 36:50–59
Reijnders L, Huijbregts MAJ (2008) Palm oil and the emission of carbon-based greenhouse gases. J Clean Prod 16:477–482
Reijnders L, Huijbregts MAJ (2011) Nitrous oxide emissions from liquid biofuel production in life cycle assessment. Curr Opin Environ Sust 3(5):432–437
Reinhard J, Zah R (2009) Global environmental consequences of increased biodiesel consumption in Switzerland: consequential life cycle assessment. J Clean Prod 17:S46–S56
Rincón V (2009) Dinámica de la expansión del área cultivada com palma de aceite y su impacto en la cobertura del suelo: Zona Oriental palmera de Colombia (1972–2009). MSc. Universitat de Girona, Girona, Spain
Rodrigues TO, Caldeira-Pires A, Luz S, Frate CA (2014) GHG balance of crude palm oil for biodiesel production in the northern region of Brazil. Renew Energ 62:516–521
Romero-Ruiz MH, Flantua SG, Tansey K, Berrio JC (2012) Landscape transformations in savannas of northern South America: land use/cover changes since 1987 in the Llanos Orientales of Colombia. Appl Geogr 32:766–776
Schmidt JH (2007) Life cycle assessment of rapeseed oil and palm oil. Ph.D. thesis, Part 3: Life cycle inventory of rapeseed oil and palm oil. Department of Development and Planning, Aalborg University
Schmidt JH (2010) Comparative life cycle assessment of rapeseed oil and palm oil. Int J Life Cycle Assess 15:183–197
Schmidt JH, Weidema BP, Brandão M (2015) A framework for modelling indirect land use changes in life cycle assessment. J Clean Prod 99:230–238
Siangjaeo S, Gheewala SH, Unnanon K, Chidthaisong A (2011) Implications of land use change on the life cycle greenhouse gas emissions from palm biodiesel production in Thailand. Energy Sustain Dev 15:1–7
Silalertruksa T, Gheewala SH (2012) Environmental sustainability assessment of palm biodiesel production in Thailand. Energy 43:306–314
Souza SP, Pacca S, Ávila MT, Borges JLB (2010) Greenhouse gas emissions and energy balance of palm oil biofuel. Renew Energ 35:2552–2561
Souza SP, Ávila MT, Pacca S (2012) Life cycle assessment of sugarcane ethanol and palm oil biodiesel joint production. Biomass Bioenerg 44:70–79
Spielmann M, Dones R, Bauer C (2007) Life Cycle Inventories of Transport Services. Final report ecoinvent Data v2.0, Vol. 14, Dübendorf and Villigen, Switzerland, Swiss Centre for LCI, PSI
Stichnothe H, Schuchardt F (2010) Comparison of different treatment options for palm oil production waste on a life cycle basis. Int J Life Cycle Assess 15(9):907–915
Stichnothe H, Schuchardt F (2011) Life cycle assessment of two palm oil production systems. Biomass Bioenerg 35(9):3976–3984
Sutter J (2007) Life Cycle Inventories of Highly Pure Chemicals. Final report ecoinvent Data v2.0. Editors: 0. Volume: 19. Swiss Centre for LCI, ETHZ. Duebendorf and St. Gallen, Switzerland
Thamsiriroj T, Murphy JD (2009) Is it better to import palm oil from Thailand to produce biodiesel in Ireland than to produce biodiesel from indigenous Irish rape seed? Appl Energy 86:595–604
USDA (1999) Soil Taxonomy. A Basic System of Soil Classification for Making and Interpreting Soil Surveys. Agriculture Handbook. Number 436, United States Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service
van der Voet E, Lifset RJ, Luo L (2010) Life-cycle assessment of biofuels, convergence and divergence. Biofuels 1(3):435–449
Van Zelm R, Huijbregts MAJ, Den Hollander HA, Van Jaarsveld HA, Sauter FJ, Struijs J, Van Wijnen HJ, Van de Meent D (2008) European characterization factors for human health damage of PM10 and ozone in life cycle impact assessment. Atmos Environ 42:441–453
Vázquez-Rowe I, Rege S, Marvuglia A, Thénie J, Haurie A, Benetto E (2013) Application of three independent consequential LCA approaches to the agricultural sector in Luxembourg. Int J Life Cycle Assess 18(8):1593–1604
von Uexküll HR, Fairhurst TH (1991) Fertilizing for high yield and quality. The oil palm. IPI, Bern, 79 p
Wicke B, Dornburg V, Junginger M, Faaij A (2008) Different palm oil production systems for energy purposes and their greenhouse gas implications. Biomass Bioenerg 32:1322–1337
World Bank (2013) World Bank Commodity Price Data. World Bank. Available at: http://www.indexmundi.com/commodities/?commodity=food-price-index
Yee KF, Tan KT, Abdullah AZ, Lee KT (2009) Life cycle assessment of palm biodiesel: revealing facts and benefits for sustainability. Appl Energy 86:S189–S196
Acknowledgments
The research presented in this article was supported by the Portuguese Science and Technology Foundation (FCT) projects: PTDC/SEN-TRA/117251/2010 (Extended “well-to-wheels” assessment of biodiesel for heavy transport vehicles) and PTDC/EMS-ENE/1839/2012 (Sustainable mobility: Perspectives for the future of biofuel production). This work was also framed under the Energy for Sustainability Initiative of the University of Coimbra-Portugal, MIT-Portugal Program and supported by the R&D project EMSURE (Energy and Mobility for Sustainable Regions, CENTRO 07 0224 FEDER 002004). Érica Castanheira gratefully acknowledges financial support from FCT, through grant SFRH/BD/60328/2009.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Responsible editor: Isabel Quispe
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Castanheira, É.G., Freire, F. Environmental life cycle assessment of biodiesel produced with palm oil from Colombia. Int J Life Cycle Assess 22, 587–600 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-016-1097-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-016-1097-6