Abstract
We examine the effect of economic policy uncertainty (EPU) on the financial reporting quality of US firms over 1999–2015. We use accruals-based earnings management as a proxy for financial reporting quality and the index of Baker et al. (Quart J Econ 131:1539–1636, 2016) as an EPU measure to show that they exhibit a positive and significant association. We also find a causal effect by employing three political polarization instruments for EPU. In a cross-sectional analysis, we further show that the positive relationship between EPU and earnings management strengthens for firms operating in politically sensitive industries, for firms in more financial distress, and during recessionary periods. We also provide evidence that increased financial constraints facilitate the positive relationship between EPU and earnings management. These findings are robust to the use of alternative measures of economic policy uncertainty and when we employ real earnings management as a dependent variable. These results indicate that managers aim to provide outsiders with an improved financial position of the company when EPU is high. Our findings suggest that investors, analysts, creditors, and regulators should be wary of firms’ financial reporting quality in periods of high economic policy uncertainty.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
In more detail, Baker et al. (2016) show that economic policy uncertainty reacts more strongly than financial uncertainty to incidents that involve major policy concerns such as political battles over government spending and taxation.
We recognize that economic policy uncertainty and financial uncertainty measures, such as the option implied volatility of stocks, exhibit correlation. However, as Baker et al. (2016) argue, economic policy uncertainty and financial uncertainty display also a distinct variation. For example, Baker et al. (2016) show that economic policy uncertainty reflects more strongly than financial uncertainty to periods of uncertainty regarding significant economic policies such as government spending and taxation. Several other studies provide empirical evidence that although economic policy uncertainty and financial uncertainty are related, they also display distinct traits (Pastor and Veronesi 2017; Tiwari et al. 2019; Bialkowski et al. 2021). We also address the correlation between economic policy uncertainty and financial uncertainty in our empirical tests regarding endogeneity in Sect. 4.3 of the paper. We thank an anonymous Referee for motivating us to carefully distinguish economic policy uncertainty from financial uncertainty theoretically (i.e., in terms of the hypotheses development) and empirically.
For example, the rising uncertainty about an important economic policy, which is the trade policy regarding China, during President’s Trump administration. The eventual increase in tariffs on imported goods from China to the US have led several US firms with production facilities in China to incur significant adjustment and compliance costs. Such costs comprise the costs of relocation of production from China to other countries, revamping supply chains, hire and train new employees in the new locations and investment in new machinery and equipment. As an illustration, Associated Press (2019) reports that Xcel Brands, a US-based clothing company, has moved production from China to Vietnam, Cambodia, Bangladesh and Canada in response to the increasing trade policy uncertainty and trade barriers between US and China. CNBC (2019) reports that several others US companies made similar moves as Xcel Brands incurring significant adjustment costs.
There is anecdotal evidence on the prompt response of managers to uncertainty around future economic policies. For example, in response to the result of the 2016 UK “Brexit” referendum, the CEO of JP Morgan Jamie Dimon suggests that ‘If the EU imposes new conditions on Britain … the worst-case scenario is we would have to move some thousands of employees to other branches in the euro zone’ (Reuters 2016). This shows that managers respond promptly and look at the most recent information available to devise their strategies to adapt to the rising uncertainty. As another example, the tariffs on China imposed by President Trump’s administration in 2018 has increased economic policy uncertainty in the US and the business world. Many managers in the US have reacted to these announcements quickly, as they aim to decrease any negative effects on the profitability of firms. In that respect, the CEO of Primex Family of Companies, Mr Paul Shekoski examines the option of relocating all his production activities in Mexico to avoid the increased costs due to tariffs (Fortune 2019). Such anecdotal evidence supports the use of contemporaneous economic policy uncertainty measures in academic research about the effects of such uncertainty on firm outcomes.
We thank an anonymous Referee for pointing out these issues and motivating us to perform additional test to address these concerns.
During the period of the study (1999–2015), four US presidential elections have occurred (i.e., in 2000, 2004, 2008, and 2012).
We estimate Eq. (6) using data with just the time dimension (i.e. the 17 observations that represent the 17 years of the study). This is because the variables that we use in Eq. (6) are macroeconomic variables. Results are similar when we estimate Eq. (6) with the firm level dataset (i.e., by assigning the macroeconomic variables at each firm-year data point).
In the change regression (model 3 of Panel A in Table 6) we do not include firm fixed effects as these are wiped out by construction in such a regression. Ho et al. (2018) posit that the change regression is also a good robustness test for the firm fixed effects regression because the former is free from bias stemming from firm-level omitted variables that are constant over time. In the other specifications of Panel A in Table 6 (models 1 and 2) we include firm fixed effects. We report the results from the fixed effects specifications in order to economize space, but the results are similar when we do not use firm fixed effects.
The 2SLS-IV estimation results are similar when we do not use firm fixed effects.
As an additional test to address endogeneity concerns, we use the two-step system generalized method of moments (GMM) estimator. The analysis using this estimator is available in the internet appendix and the results are available in Table IA.1 of the internet appendix. The results continue to lend support to hypothesis H1.
Higher values of the KZ index imply increased financial constraints. See Table 1 for the formula we use to calculate the KZ index.
The Sobel (1982) test has to be significant (i.e., p-value < 0.10) to reject the null of no channel effect.
\(\Delta CA_{i,t}\) is the change of current assets from the to the previous year (t-1) to current year (t), \(\Delta CL_{i,t}\) is the change of current liabilities from the previous year (t-1) and the current year (t), \(\Delta Cash_{i,t}\) is the change of cash between the previous year (t-1) and the current year (t). \(\Delta STDEBT_{i,t}\) is the change in debt in current liabilities from the previous year (t-1) to the current year (t).
\(CFO_{i,t} = NIBE_{i,t} - TA_{i,t}\), where \(NIBE_{i,t}\) is firm’s net income before extraordinary items. \(TA_{i,t} = \Delta CA_{i,t} - \Delta CL_{i,t} - \Delta Cash_{i,t} + \Delta STDEBT_{i,t} - DEPN_{i,t}\). and~stands~for~firm's~total~accruals~in~the~current~year (t) \(DEPN_{i,t}\) is the firm’s value of depreciation expenses in the current year (t).
References
Arif S, Marshall N, Yohn TL (2016) Understanding the relation between accruals and volatility: a real options-based investment approach. J Account Econ 62:65–86
Arouri M, Estay C, Rault C, Roubaud D (2016) Economic policy uncertainty and stock markets: Long-run evidence from the US. Financ Res Lett 18:136–141
Ashraf BN, Shen Y (2019) Economic policy uncertainty and banks’ loan pricing. J Financ Stabil 44:100695
Azzimonti M (2018) Partisan conflict and private investment. J Mon Econ 93:114–131
Badertscher B, Shroff N, White H (2013) Externalities of public firm presence: evidence from private firms’ investment decisions. J Fin Econ 109:682–706
Baker SR, Bloom, N (2013) Does uncertainty drive business cycles? Using disasters as natural experiments. National bureau of economic research working 19475
Baker SR, Bloom N, Davis SJ (2016) Measuring economic policy uncertainty. Quart J Econ 131:1539–1636
Baker TA, Lopez TJ, Reitenga AL, Ruch GW (2019) The influence of CEO and CFO power on accruals and real earnings management. Rev Quant Finance Account 52(1):325–345
Bergstresser D, Philippon T (2006) CEO incentives and earnings management. J Financ Econ 80(3):511–529
Bhattacharya U, Daouk H, Welker M (2003) The world pricing of earnings opacity. Account Rev 78:641–678
Bialkowski JP, Dang HD, Wei X (2021) High policy uncertainty and low implied market volatility–an academic puzzle? J Financ Econ (forthcoming)
Biddle G, Hilary G, Verdi R (2009) How does financial reporting quality relate to investment efficiency? J Acc Econ 48:112–131
Bird A, Karolyi SA, Ruchti T (2017) Political uncertainty and corporate transparency. Available at SSRN 2986678
Bloom N (2009) The Impact of Uncertainty Shocks. Econometrica 77:623–685
Bloom N (2014) Fluctuations in uncertainty. J Econ Pers 28:153–176
Bonaime A, Gulen H, Ion M (2018) Does policy uncertainty affect mergers and acquisitions? J Fin Econ 129(3):531–558
Boone AL, Kim A, White JT (2018) Political uncertainty and firm disclosure. Vanderbilt owen graduate school of management research paper
Bordo MD, Duca JV, Koch C (2016) Economic policy uncertainty and the credit channel: aggregate and bank level U.S. evidence over several decades. J Financ Stabil 26:90–106
Boutchkova M, Doshi H, Durnev A, Molchanov A (2012) Precarious politics and return volatility. Rev Financ Stud 25(4):1111–1154
Bowen RM, Dutta S, Zhu P (2018) Are financially constrained firms more prone to financial restatements? Available at SSRN 3211497
Brogaard J, Detzel A (2015) The asset-pricing implications of government economic policy uncertainty. Manag Sci 61(1):3–18
Brown S, Dutordoir M, Veld C, Veld-Merkoulova Y (2019) What is the role of institutional investors in corporate capital structure decisions? A survey analysis. J Corp Financ 58:270–286
Bruns W, Merchant K (1990) The dangerous morality of managing earnings. Manag Acc 72(2):22–25
Burgstahler D, Dichev I (1997) Earnings management to avoid earnings decreases and losses. J Acc Econ 24:99–126
Bushman R, Smith A (2001) Financial accounting information and corporate governance. J Acc Econ 32:237–333
Cai G, Li W, Tang Z (2020) Religion and the method of earnings management: evidence from China. J Bus Ethics 161(1):71–90
Chan YC, Saffar W, Wei KJ (2021) How economic policy uncertainty affects the cost of raising equity capital: evidence from seasoned equity offerings. J Financ Stabil 53:100841
Charitou A, Lambertides N, Trigeorgis L (2011) Distress risk, growth and earnings quality. Abacus 47:158–181
Chen PF, Lee CC, Zeng JH (2019) Economic policy uncertainty and firm investment: evidence from the US market. App Econ 51(31):3423–3435
CNBC (2019) More than 50 companies reportedly pull production out of China due to trade war. Article in press. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/07/18/more-than-50-companies-reportedly-pull-production-out-of-china-due-to-trade-war.html
Cohen DA, Zarowin P (2011) Do firms lean against the wind. Earnings management and stock market return. Working paper
Cohen DA, Dey A, Lys TZ (2008) Real and accrual-based earnings management in the pre-and post-Sarbanes-Oxley periods. Account Rev 83(3):757–787
Conrad J, Cornell B, Landsman W (2002) When is bad news really bad news? J Financ 57:2507–2531
Dai L, Ngo P (2021) Political uncertainty and accounting conservatism. Eur Account Rev 30(2):277–307
Dai L, Zhang B (2019) Political uncertainty and finance: a survey. Asia-Pacific J Financ Stud 48(3):307–333
Datta S, Doan T, Iskandar-Datta M (2019) Policy uncertainty and the maturity structure of corporate debt. J Financ Stabil 44:1–12
DeAngelo H, DeAngelo L, Skinner DJ (1994) Accounting choice in troubled companies. J Account Econ 17:113–143
Dechow PM, Dichev ID (2002) The quality of accruals and earnings: the role of accrual estimation errors. Account Rev 77(s-1):35–59
Dechow P, Sloan R, Sweeney A (1995) Detecting earnings management. Account Rev 70:193–225
Dechow P, Ge W, Schrand C (2010) Understanding earnings quality: a review of the proxies their determinants and their consequences. J Acc Econ 50:344–401
DeFond ML, Jiambalvo J (1994) Debt covenant violation and manipulation of accruals. J Account Econ 17:145–176
DeFond ML, Park CW (2001) The reversal of abnormal accruals and the market valuation of earnings surprises. Account Rev 76:375–404
Ding R, Li J, Wu Z (2018) Government affiliation, real earnings management, and firm performance: the case of privately held firms. J Bus Res 83:138–150
Drake MS, Mayberry MA, Wilde JH (2018) Pushing the future back: the impact of policy uncertainty on the market pricing of future earnings. J Bus Financ Account 45:895–927
Drobetz W, El Ghoul S, Guedhami O, Janzen M (2018) Policy uncertainty, investment, and the cost of capital. J Financ Stabil 39:28–45
Duong HN, Nguyen JH, Nguyen M, Rhee SG (2020) Navigating through economic policy uncertainty: the role of corporate cash holdings. J Corp Financ 62:1–22
Durnev A (2010) The real effects of political uncertainty: elections and investment sensitivity to stock prices. Available at SSRN 1549714
Dye RA (1988) Earnings management in an overlapping generations model. J Account Res 26(2):195–235
Farrell K, Unlu E, Yu J (2014) Stock repurchases as an earnings management mechanism: the impact of financing constraints. J Corp Financ 25:1–15
Fortune (2019) CEOs are scrambling to avoid trump tariffs and survive trade war. Article in press. https://fortune.com/2019/02/07/us-china-trade-war-trump-tariffs/
Francis J, LaFond R, Olsson P, Schipper K (2005) The market pricing of accruals quality. J Account Econ 39(2):295–327
Francis BB, Hasan I, Zhu Y (2014) Political uncertainty and bank loan contracting. J Empir Financ 29:281–286
Gilson S (1989) Management turnover and financial distress. J Financ Econ 25:241–262
Graham JR, Harvey CR, Rajgopal S (2005) The economic implications of corporate financial reporting. J Account Econ 40(1–3):3–73
Gulen H, Ion M (2016) Policy uncertainty and corporate investment. Rev Financ Studies 29(3):523–564
Gungoraydinoglu A, Çolak G, Öztekin Ö (2017) Political environment, financial intermediation costs, and financing patterns. J Corp Financ 44:167–192
Guo H, Jiang X (2011) Accruals and the conditional equity premium. J Account Res 49:187–221
He G, Ren H (2017) Are financially constrained firms susceptible to a stock price crash? WBS finance group research paper, 239
Healy PM (1985) The effect of bonus schemes on accounting decisions. J Account and Econ 7(1–3):85–107
Herron MC, Cram D, Lavin J, Silver J (1999) Measurement of political effects in the United States economy: a study of the 1992 presidential election. Econ Politics 11:51–81
Hirshleifer D, Hou K, Teoh S (2009) Accruals, cash flows, and aggregate stock returns. J Financ Econ 91:389–406
Ho PH, Lin CY, Linh TTT (2018) The dark side of bank CEO risk-taking incentives: evidence from bank lending decisions. Available at SSRN 3416023
Iatridis G, Kadorinis G (2009) Earnings management and firm financial motives: a financial investigation of UK listed firms. Int Rev Financ Anal 18(4):164–173
Iqbal U, Gan C, Nadeem M (2020) Economic policy uncertainty and firm performance. Appl Econ Lett 27(10):1–6
Jens CE (2017) Political uncertainty and investment: Causal evidence from U.S. gubernatorial elections. J Financ Econ 124:563–579
Jiang JX, Petroni KR, Wang IY (2010) CFOs and CEOs: who have the most influence on earnings management? J Financ Econ 96(3):513–526
Jin X, Chen Z, Yang X (2019) Economic policy uncertainty and stock price crash risk. Account Financ 58(5):1291–1318
Jones J (1991) Earnings management during import relief investigations. J Account Res 29:193–228
Julio B, Yook Y (2012) Political uncertainty and corporate investment cycles. J Financ 67(1):45–83
Julio B, Yook Y (2016) Political uncertainty and cross-border flows of capital. J Int Econ 103:13–26
Kang W, Wang J (2018) Oil shocks, policy uncertainty and earnings surprises. Rev Quant Finance Account 51:375–388
Kang Q, Liu Q, Qi R (2010) Predicting stock market returns with aggregate discretionary accruals. J Account Res 48:815–858
Kang W, Lee K, Ratti RA (2014) Economic policy uncertainty and firm-level investment. J Macroecon 39:42–53
Kaplan SN, Zingales L (1997) Do investment-cash flow sensitivities provide useful measures of financing constraints? Q J Econ 112(1):169–215
Kaviani MS, Kryzanowski L, Maleki H, Savor P (2020) Policy uncertainty and corporate credit spreads. J Financ Econ 138(3):838–865
Kim J, Kim Y, Zhou J (2017) Languages and earnings management. J Account Econ 63:288–306
Ko JH, Lee CM (2015) International economic policy uncertainty and stock prices: wavelet approach. Econ Lett 134:118–122
Kurt AC (2018) How do financial constraints relate to financial reporting quality? Evidence from seasoned equity offerings. Eur Account Rev 27(3):527–557
Lambert R, Leuz C, Verrecchia R (2007) Accounting information, disclosure, and the cost of capital. J Account Res 45:385–420
Lang M, Maffett M (2011) Transparency and liquidity uncertainty in crisis periods. J Account Econ 52:101–125
Lang M, Lins KV, Maffett M (2012) Transparency, liquidity, and valuation: international evidence on when transparency matters most. J Account Res 50:729–774
Lel U (2019) The role of foreign institutional investors in restraining earnings management activities across countries. J Int Bus Stud 50(6):895–922
Leuz C, Wysocki PD (2016) The economics of disclosure and financial reporting regulation: evidence and suggestions for future research. J Account Res 54:525–622
Leuz C, Nanda D, Wysocki PD (2003) Earnings management and investor protection: an international comparison. J Financ Econ 69:505–527
Li L (2019) Economic policy uncertainty and corporate cash policy: international evidence. J Account Public Pol 38(6):106694
Liu L, Zhang T (2015) Economic policy uncertainty and stock market volatility. Financ Res Lett 15:99–105
MacKinnon DP, Dwyer JH (1993) Estimating mediated effects in prevention studies. Evaluation Rev 17(2):144–158
Nagar V, Scoenfeld J, Wellman L (2019) The effect of economic policy uncertainty on investor information asymmetry and management disclosure. J Account Econ 67:36–57
Nguyen Q, Kim T, Papanastassiou M (2018) Policy uncertainty, derivatives use, and firm-level FDI. J Intl Bus Stud 49(1):96–126
Pastor L, Veronesi P (2012) Uncertainty about government policy and stock prices. J Financ 67:1219–1264
Pastor L, Veronesi P (2013) Political uncertainty and risk premia. J Financ Econ 110:520–545
Pastor L, Veronesi P (2017) Explaining the puzzle of high policy uncertainty and low market volatility. VOX Column, 25
Pindyck RS (1982) Adjustment costs, uncertainty, and the behavior of the firm. Am Econ Rev 72(3):415–427
Associated Press (2019) Facing Trump’s tariffs, some companies move, change or wait. Article in press. https://apnews.com/article/ed4080f18c124564acc2d6537d21044f
Pustylnick I (2016) Use of Z-score in detection of revenue manipulations. Working paper. Paper presented at the 21-st international scientific conference economics and management, Brno, Czech Republic
Rae DW (1967) The political consequences of electoral laws. Yale University Press, New Haven
Reuters (2016) JPMorgan could move thousands of staff out of UK–report. Article in press. https://cn.reuters.com/article/britain-eu-jpmorgan-idCNL8N19T0WE
Rosner RL (2003) Earnings manipulation in failing firms. Contemp Account Res 20:361–408
Ryan SP (2012) The costs of environmental regulation in a concentrated industry. Econometrica 80(3):1019–1061
Shang L, Lin JC, Saffar W (2019) Does economic policy uncertainty drive corporate lobbying? Available at SSRN 3211764
Shroff N, Sun A, White H, Zhang W (2013) Voluntary disclosure and information asymmetry: evidence from the 2005 securities offering reform. J Account Res 51:1299–1345
Sobel ME (1982) Asymptotic confidence intervals for indirect effects in structural equation models. Sociol Methodol 13:290–312
Stein LCD, Wang CCY (2016) Economic uncertainty and earnings management. Working Paper 16–103, Harvard Business School
Teoh SH, Welch I, Wong TJ (1998) Earnings management and the underperformance of seasoned equity offerings. J Financ Econ 50(1):63–99
The New York Times (2019) The government shutdown was the longest ever: Here’s the history. Article in press. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/01/09/us/politics/longest-government-shutdown.html
Tiwari AK, Jana RK, Roubaud D (2019) The policy uncertainty and market volatility puzzle: evidence from wavelet analysis. Financ Res Lett 31:278–284
Tran QT (2021) Economic policy uncertainty and cost of debt financing: international evidence. N Am J Econ Financ 57:101419
Trueman B, Titman S (1988) An explanation for accounting income smoothing. J Account Res 3:127–139
Verrecchia R (2001) Essays on disclosure. J Account Econ 32:97–180
Waisman M, Ye P, Zhu Y (2015) The effect of political uncertainty on the cost of corporate debt. J Financ Stabil 16:106–117
Wang HJ, Li QY, Xin W (2014) Economic policy uncertainty, cash holding and market value. J Financ Res 9:53–68
Xu Z (2020) Economic policy uncertainty, cost of capital, and corporate innovation. J Bank Financ 111:105698
Xu H, Dao M, Wu J (2019) The effect of local political corruption on earnings quality. Rev Quant Finance Account 53:551–574
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bermpei, T., Kalyvas, A.N., Neri, L. et al. Does economic policy uncertainty matter for financial reporting quality? Evidence from the United States. Rev Quant Finan Acc 58, 795–845 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11156-021-01010-2
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11156-021-01010-2
Keywords
- Earnings management
- Economic policy uncertainty (EPU)
- Financial reporting quality
- Political sensitivity