Abstract
Contemporary legends – also called urban legends – are common throughout our society. Distinct from mere rumors passed around social media, anecdotes of pseudoscientific discoveries, or medical misinformation, contemporary legends are important because, rather than merely transmitting false ideas or information about medicine, they model distinct and primarily antagonistic patterns of interaction between patients and providers via their narrative components. And, while legends that patients tell about their distrust for doctors are fairly well-studied, less attention has been paid to the kinds of legends that providers tell about patients. Many of these legends portray the likely patient as foolish, incompetent, and the ultimate source of his or her own medical condition. A partial solution to the challenges created by clashing, mutually belittling narratives can be found in the principles of narrative medicine, which strives to replace a received, stereotyped narrative with an individualized narrative constructed together by provider and patient. This paper will provide a definition of contemporary medical legends, analyze the unique narrative structure, develop a brief taxonomy of common themes, and describe how the structure and theme elucidate interesting and previously unexamined tensions within the provider-patient relationship.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anthony, Susan. 1973. “Anxiety and Rumor.” The Journal of Social Psychology 89 (1): 91-98.
Bascom, William. 1965. “The Forms of Folklore: Prose Narratives.” The Journal of American Folklore 78 (307): 3-20.
Bateson, Gregory, Don D. Jackson, Jay Haley, and John H. Weakland. 1972. “Toward a Theory of Schizophrenia.” In Steps to an Ecology of Mind, edited by Gregory Bateson, 201-228 Northvale, New Jersey and London: Jason Aronson, Inc.
Ben-Amos, Dan. 1971. “Toward a Definition of Folklore in Context.” The Journal of American Folklore 84 (331): 3-15.
Bennett, Gillian. 2005. Bodies. University Press of Mississippi.
Boyes, Georgina. 1982. “Belief and Disbelief: An Examination of Reactions to the Presentation of Rumor Legends.” Perspectives in Contemporary Legend 1:64-78.
Briggs, Charles L. 2012. “Toward a New Folkloristics of Health.” Journal of Folklore Research 49 (3): 319-345.
Brunvand, Jan Harold. 2002. Encyclopedia of Urban Legends. W.W. Norton and Company.
-----. 2014. Too Good to be True. W.W. Norton and Company.
Caldeira, Olivia. 2015. “Exploring Esoteric and Exoteric Definitions of Disability: Inclusion, Segregation, and Kinship in a Special Olympics Group.” In Diagnosing Folklore, edited by Trevor J. Blank and Andrea Kitta, 41-64. University Press of Mississippi.
Campion-Vincent, Veronique. 2002. “Organ Theft Narratives as Medical and Social Critique.” Journal of Folklore Research 39 (1): 33-50.
Charon, Rita. 2006. Narrative Medicine: Honoring the Stories of Illness. Oxford University Press.
Conti, C. Richard. 2008. “Doctors are Caregivers or Providers? Patients are Clients?” Clinical Cardiology 31 (11): 505.
Corbie-Smith, Giselle, Stephen B Thomas, and Diane Marie M. St. George. 2002. “Distrust, Race, and Research.” Archives of Internal Medicine 162:2458-2463.
Crawford, Robert. 1980. “Healthism and the Medicalization of Everyday Life.” International Journal of Health Services 10 (3): 365-388.
Crossley, Michele L. 2002. Narrative, Memory, and Life Transitions. Huddersfield: University of Huddersfield Press.
Dale, Rodney. 1984. It’s True…It Happened to a Friend. Gerald Duckworth and Co.
Deber, Raisa B, Nancy Kraetschemer, Sara Urowitz, and Natasha Sharpe. 2005. “Patient, Consumer, Client, or Customer: What do People Want to be Called?” Health Expectations 8:345-351.
Dègh, Linda. 1991. “What is the legend after all?” Contemporary Legend 1 (1): 11-38.
DiFonzo, Nicholas and Prashant Bordia. 2007. “Rumor, Gossip, and Urban Legend.” Diogenes 213:19-35.
Dingwall, Robert. 1977. “’Atrocity Stories’ and Professional Relationships.” Sociology of Work and Occupations 4 (4): 371-396.
Doyle, Charles Clay and Lara Renee Knight. 2005. “On the Term ‘Urban Legend.’” Foaftale News, December. http://www.folklore.ee/FOAFtale/ftn63.pdf. Accessed 18 Feb 2018.
Dundes, Alan. 1962. “From Etic to Emic Units in the Structural Study of Folktales.” The Journal of American Folklore 75 (296): 95-105.
-----. 2007. “The Gomer: A Figure of American Hospital Folk Speech.” In The Meaning of Folklore, edited by Simon J. Bronner, 252-263. Logan, Utah: Utah State University Press.
Fine, Gary Allen. 1980. “The Kentucky-Fried Rat: Legends and Modern Society.” Journal of the Folklore Institute 17 (2/3): 222-243.
Foucault, Michel. 2003. The Birth of the Clinic. Routledge Classics.
Fox Tree, J. E., and M. S. Weldon. 2007. “Retelling Urban Legends.” American Journal of Psychology 120 (3): 459-476.
Frank, Arthur W. 2013. The Wounded Storyteller: Body, Illness & Ethics. University of Chicago Press.
Galanter, Marc. 1998. “An Oil Strike in Hell: Contemporary Legends about the Civil Justice System.” Arizona Law Review 40:717-752.
Gansler, Ted, S. Jane Henley, Kevin Stein, Eric J. Nehl, Carol Smigal, and Edwin Slaughter. 2005. “Sociodemographic Determinants of Cancer Treatment Health Literacy.” Cancer 104 (3): 653-660.
Geertz, Clifford. 1973. “Religion as a Cultural System.” In The Interpretation of Cultures, edited by Clifford Geertz, 87-125. New York: Basic Books Inc.
Golden, Janet. 2017. “’Doctors Don’t Do So Much Good’: Traditional Practices, Biomedicine and Infant Care in the 20th-Century United States.” Nursing History Reviews 25:86-102.
Guerin, Bernard and Yoshihiko Miyazaki. 2006. “Analyzing Rumors, Gossip, and Urban Legends through Their Conversational Properties.” The Psychological Record 56:23-34.
Hall, Mark A., Elizabeth Dugan, Beiyao Zheng, and Aneil K. Mishra. 2001. “Trust in Physicians and Medical Institutions: What Is It, Can It Be Measured, and Does It Matter?” The Milbank Quarterly 79 (4): 613-639.
Hevern, Vincent W. 2008. “Why Narrative Psychology Can’t Afford to Ignore the Body.” Journal of Social, Evolutionary, and Cultural Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0099343.
Hoax-Slayer, Archive. 2017. Brett Christensen, ed. Accessed 12/21/17. https://hoax-slayer.com.
Illich, Ivan. 1975. “The Medicalization of Life.” Journal of Medical Ethics 1:73-77.
Kleinman, Arthur. 1989. The Illness Narratives. New York: Basic Books Inc.
Lian, Olaug S. and Grue, Jan. 2017. “Generating a Social Movement Online Community through an Online Discourse: The Case of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis.” Journal of Medical Humanities 38:173-189.
Mullen, Patrick B. 1972. “Modern Legend and Rumor Theory.” Journal of the Folklore Institute 9 (2/3): 95-109.
Neuberger, Julia. 1999. “Let’s Do Away with ‘Patients.’” British Journal of Medicine 318:1756-1758.
Nicolaisen, W.F.H. 1982. “Legends as Narrative Response.” Perspectives in Contemporary Legend 1:167-178.
Ofri, Danielle. 2011. “The Provider Will See You Now.” The New York Times. December 29. https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/12/29/the-provider-will-see-you-now/?ref=health. Accessed 18 Feb 2018.
Oring, Elliott. 2008. “Legendry and the Rhetoric of Truth.” Journal of American Folklore 121 (480): 127-166.
Rose, Abigail, Nikki Peters, Judy A. Shea, and Katrina Armstrong. 2004. “Development and Testing of the Health Care System Distrust Scale.” Journal of General Internal Medicine 19:57-63.
Rosenhan, David L. 1973. “On Being Sane in Insane Places.” Science 179:250-258.
Russell, Emily, Dana H.Z. Robinson, Nancy J. Thompson, Jennie P. Perryman, and Kimberly R. Jacob Arricola. 2012. “Distrust in the Healthcare System and Organ Donation Intentions among African Americans.” Journal of Community Health 37 (1): 40-47.
Schiff, Brian. 2012. “The Function of Narrative: Toward a Narrative Psychology of Meaning.” Narrative Works 2 (1). https://journals.lib.unb.ca/index.php/NW/article/view/19497/21112. Accessed 12 Dec 2017.
Smith, Moira. 2009. “Humor, Unlaughter, and Boundary Maintenance.” The Journal of American Folklore 122 (484): 148-171.
Sontag, Susan. 1990. Illness as Metaphor and AIDS and Its Metaphors. New York: Picador. Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.
Stubbersfield, Joseph M., Jamshid J. Tehrani, and Emma G. Flynn. 2015. “Serial Killers, Spiders and Cybersex: Social and Survival Information Bias in the Transmission of Urban Legends.” British Journal of Psychology 106 (2): 288–307.
Swami, Viren, Stefan Stieger, Jakob Pietschnig, Ingo W. Nader, and Martin Voracek. 2012. “Using more than 10% of our Brains: Examining Belief in Science-related Myths from an Individual Differences Perspective.” Learning and Individual Differences 22:404-408.
Swann, William B., Jolanda Jetten, Angel Gomez, Harvey Whitehouse, and Brock Bastian. 2012. “When Group Membership Gets Personal: A Theory of Identity Fusion.” Psychological Review 119 (3): 441-456.
Toelken, Barre. 1979. The Dynamics of Folklore. Houghton Mifflin.
Urban Legends Online. 2017. Lisa Mazzuca, ed. Accessed 12/21/17. http://urbanlegendsonline.com/.
Urban Legends Reference Pages. 2017. David Mikkelson, ed. Accessed 12-21-17. https://www.snopes.com/.
Victor, Jeffrey S. 1993. “The Sociology of Contemporary Legends: A Review of the Use of the Concept by Sociologists.” Contemporary Legend 3:63-83.
Williams, Noel. 1982. “Problems in Defining Contemporary Legend.” Perspectives in Contemporary Legend 1:216-228.
Wyckoff, Donna. 1993. “Why a Legend? Contemporary Legends as Community Ritual.” Contemporary Legend 3:1-36.
-----. 2000. “’It has all the earmarks…’ Spotting Contemporary Legends Early, Predicting their Course.” Contemporary Legend New Series 3: 161-183.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
ESM 1
(XLSX 59 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Minser, J., Gibb, T. “I Know a Guy Who Once Heard…”: Contemporary Legends and Narratives in Healthcare. J Med Humanit 41, 323–340 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10912-019-09565-x
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10912-019-09565-x