Abstract
We provide a novel test of information-based theories of price clustering by examining trade, order, and the National Best Bid and Offer (NBBO) quote price clustering during periods when information is removed from the market. We use a natural experiment of short-sale restrictions resulting from Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Rule 201 to more effectively determine the impact of information on price clustering. We find evidence of increased price clustering for trades, orders, and NBBO prices during short-sale restrictions. Overall, our findings indicate that short-sale restrictions harm the price discovery process and lead to a reduction in market efficiency.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
We define price clustering as the tendency of trade prices to fall on an ending digit of zero or five.
Securities Exchange Act Release No. 34–61,595 (Feb. 26, 2010), 75 FR 11232 (Mar. 10, 2010).
We further describe SEC Rule 201 restrictions in Section 3.
Increased liquidity or noise trading could be a result of margin calls, portfolio rebalancing, herding behavior, etc. We do not attempt to disentangle the motivation of trades.
Researchers have made similar arguments regarding trading halts. Arak and Cook (1997), for example, find that daily price limits, a type of circuit breaker used in futures markets, provide a stabilizing effect. Thus, our paper contributes to the literature regarding all types of trading disruptions, such as halts or restrictions.
For example, SEC Regulation-SHO was for a specific time period in which specific securities were subject to the NYSE bid price test or NYSE’s uptick rule and NASDAQ’s bid price.
Additionally, Jain et al. (2012) state that the SEC adopted Rule 201 to help prevent potentially manipulative short selling and bear raids in an effort to ensure investor confidence. Jain et al. (2012) indicate that the ultimate regulatory goal was to restrict short selling in only a few securities in an attempt to preserve liquidity and price efficiency-related benefits.
The fixings refer to the practice of the London gold market where firms meet and set a price that clears the market. This occurs twice daily, once in the morning at 10:30 am, and once in the afternoon at 3:00 pm.
Harris defines volatility as the five day standard deviation of a stock price.
The SEC repealed the NYSE and NASDAQ price tests in July 2007.
References
Alexander A, Peterson M (2007) An analysis of trade-size clustering and its relation to stealth trading. J Financ Econ 84:435–471
Arak M, Cook R (1997) Do daily price limits act as magnets? The case of Treasury bond futures. J Financ Serv Res 12(1):5–20
Aşçıoğlu A, Comerton-Forde C, McInish T (2007) Price clustering on the Tokyo stock exchange. Financ Rev 42(2):289–301
Ball C, Torous W, Tschoegel A (1985) The degree of price resolution: the case of the gold market. Journal of Futures Market 5:29–43
Bessembinder H, Kaufman HM (1997) A comparison of trade execution costs for NYSE and NASDAQ-listed stocks. J Financ Quant Anal 32:287–310
Blau B, Van Ness B, Van Ness R (2012) Trade size and price clustering: the case of short sales and the suspension of price tests. J Financ Res 35(2):159–182
Boehme, R. D., B. R. Danielsen, and S. M. Sorescu, S. M., 2006, Short-sale constraints, differences of opinion, and overvaluation. J Financ Quant Anal, 41 (02), 455–487.
Boehmer E, Jones CM, Zhang X (2008) Which shorts are informed? J Financ 63:491–527
Boehmer E, Jones CM, Zhang X (2013) Shackling short sellers: the 2008 shorting ban. Rev of Financ Stud 26(6):1363-1400
Chang EC, Cheng JW, Yu Y (2007) Short-sales constraints and price discovery: evidence from the Hong Kong market. J Financ 62(5):2097–2121
Christie W, Schultz P (1994) Why do NASDAQ market makers avoid odd-eighth quotes? J Financ 49:1813–1840
Christie W, Harris J, Schultz P (1994) Why did NASDAQ market makers stop avoiding odd-eighth quotes? J Financ 49:1841–1860
Christophe S, Ferri M, Angel J (2004) Short-selling prior to earnings announcements. J Financ 59:1845–1875
Chung K, Van Ness B, Van Ness R (2004) Trading costs and quote clustering on the NYSE and NASDAQ after decimalization. J Financ Res 37:309–328
Comerton-Forde C, Tang K (2009) Anonymity, liquidity and fragmentation. J Financ Mark 12:337–367
Davis R, Van Ness B, Van Ness R (2014) Clustering of trade prices by high-frequency and non-high-frequency trading firms. Financ Rev 49:421–433
Diamond D, Verrecchia R (1987) Constraints on short selling and asset price adjustment to private information. J Financ Econ 18:277–312
Diether KB, Lee K, Werner IM (2009) Short-selling strategies and return predictability. Rev Financ Stud 22:575–607
Dyl E, Maberly E (1992) Odd-lot transactions around the turn of the year and the January effect. J Financ Quant Anal 27:591–604
Figlewski S (1981) The informational effects of restrictions on short sales: some empirical evidence. J Financ Quant Anal 16:463–476
Hannan T (1994) Asymmetric price rigidity and the responsiveness of customers to price changes: the case of deposit interest rates. J Financ Serv Res 8:257–267
Harris L (1991) Stock price clustering and discreteness. Rev Financ Stud 4:389–415
Hauser S, Kedar-Levy H, Pilo B, Shurki I (2006) The effect of trading halts on the speed of price discovery. J Financ Serv Res 29(1):83–99
Huang R, Stoll H (2001) Tick size, bid-ask spreads, and market structure. J Financ Quant Anal 36:503–522
Ikenberry D, Weston J (2007) Clustering in US stock prices after decimalization. European Financial Management 14:30–54
Jain C, Jain P, McInish T (2012) Short selling: the impact of SEC rule 201 of 2010. Financ Rev 47:37–64
Johnson H (2014) Odd lot trades: the behavior, characteristics, and information content, over time. Financ Rev 49:669–684
Johnson H, Van Ness B, Van Ness R (2016) Are all odd-lots the same? Odd-lot transactions by order submission and trader type, working paper. University, Kansas State
Kandel S, Sarig O, Wohl A (2001) Do investors prefer round stock prices? Evidence from Israeli IPO auctions. Journal of Banking and Finance 25:1543–1551
Kolasinski AC, Reed AV, Thornock JR (2010) Can short restrictions result in more informed short selling? evidence from the 2008 regulations, working paper, University of Washington
Kolasinski A, Reed A, Thornock J (2013) Can short restrictions actually increase informed short selling? Financ Manag 42:155–181
Lakonishok J, Maberly E (1990) The weekend effect: trading patterns of individual and institutional investors. J Financ 45:231–243
Madura J, Richie N, Tucker AL (2006) Trading halts and price discovery. J Financ Serv Res 30:311–3228
Miller EM (1977) Risk, uncertainty, and divergence of opinion. J Financ 32:1151–1168
Mola S, Loughran T (2004) Discounting and clustering in seasoned equity offering prices. J Financ Quant Anal 39:1–23
Niederhoffer V (1965) Clustering of stock prices. Oper Res 13:258–265
Niederhoffer V (1966) A new look at clustering of stock prices. J Bus 39:309–313
Nilsson R (2008) The value of shorting. Journal of Banking and Finance 32:880–891
O’Hara M, Yao C, Ye M (2014) What’s not there: odd lots and market data. J Financ 69:2199–2236
Osbourne M (1962) Periodic structure in the Brownian motion of stock prices. Oper Res 10:345–379
Shikilko A, Van Ness B, Van Ness R (2012) Short selling and intraday price pressures. Financ Manag 41:345–370
Sopranzetti B, Datar V (2002) Price clustering in foreign exchange spot markets. J Financ Mark 5:411–417
Upson J, Johnson H, McInish T (2015) Orders verses trades on the consolidated tape, working paper. University of Texas at El Paso
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Davis, R.L., Jurich, S.N., Roseman, B.S. et al. Short-Sale Restrictions and Price Clustering: Evidence from SEC Rule 201. J Financ Serv Res 54, 345–367 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10693-017-0272-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10693-017-0272-7