Abstract
Hip fracture accounts for a large number of hospitalizations, thereby causing substantial economic burden. Majority (> 90%) of all hip fractures are associated to sideways fall. Studies on sideways fall usually involve loading at quasi-static or at constant displacement rate, which neglects the physics of actual fall. Understanding femur resonance frequency and associated mode shapes excited by dynamic loads is also critical. Two commercial extramedullary implants, proximal femoral locking plate (PFLP) and variable angle dynamic hip screw (VA-DHS), were chosen to carry out the preclinical assessments on a simulated Evans-I type intertrochanteric fracture. In this study, we hypothesized that the behavior of the implant depends on the loading types—axial static and transverse impact—and a rigid implanted construct will absorb less impact energy for sideways fall. The in silico models were validated using experimental measurements of full-field strain data obtained from a 2D digital image correlation (DIC) study. Under peak axial load of 3 kN, PFLP construct predicted greater axial stiffness (1.07 kN/mm) as opposed to VA-DHS (0.85 kN/mm), although the former predicted slightly higher proximal stress shielding. Further, with greater mode 2 frequency, PFLP predicted improved performance in resisting bending due to sideways fall as compared to the other implant. Overall, the PFLP implanted femur predicted the least propensity to adverse stress intensities, suggesting better structural rigidity and higher capacity in protecting the fractured femur against fall.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abe, S., N. Narra, R. Nikander, J. Hyttinen, R. Kouhia, and H. Sievänen. Impact loading history modulates hip fracture load and location: a finite element simulation study of the proximal femur in female athletes. J. Biomech. 76:136–143, 2018.
Ahn, J., and J. Bernstein. Fractures in brief: intertrochanteric hip fractures. Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res. 468(5):1450–1452, 2010.
Aldieri, A., M. Terzini, G. Osella, A. M. Priola, A. Angeli, A. Veltri, A. Audenino, and C. Bignardi. Osteoporotic hip fracture prediction: is T-score based criterion enough? A Hip Structural Analysis based model. J. Biomech. Eng. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1115/14040586.
Aminian, A., F. Gao, W. W. Fedoriw, L. Q. Zhang, D. M. Kalainov, and B. R. Merk. Vertically oriented femoral neck fractures: mechanical analysis of four fixation techniques. J. Orthop. Trauma. 21(8):544–548, 2007.
Bel, J. C. Pitfalls and limits of locking plates. Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 105(1S):S103–S109, 2019.
Biomechanical products catalog Sawbones: Test materials and composite bones. https://www.sawbones.com/media/assets/product/documents/biomechanical_catalog2020.pdf. Accessed 7 Dec 2020.
Braithwaite, R. S., N. F. Col, and J. B. Wong. Estimating hip fracture morbidity, mortality and costs. J. Am. Geriatrics Soc. 51:364–370, 2003.
Burstein, A. H., and V. H. Frankel. A standard test for laboratory animal bone. J Biomech. 4:155–158, 1971.
Butler, M., M. Forte, R. L. Kane, S. Joglekar, S. J. Duval, M. Swiontkowski, and T. Wilt. Treatment of common hip fractures. Evid. Rep. Technol. Assess. 184:1–85, 2009.
Chaim, S. H., D. P. Mukherjee, A. L. Ogden, R. H. Mayeux, K. K. Sadasivan, and J. A. Albright. A biomechanical study of femoral neck fracture fixation with the VHS Vari-Angle Hip Fixation System. Am. J. Orthop. 31(1 Suppl):22–24, 2002.
Chalise, P. K., A. K. Mishra, S. B. Shah, V. Adhikari, and R. P. Singh. Outcome of pertrochantric fracture of the femur treated with proximal femoral locking compression plate. Nepal Med. Coll. J. 14(4):324–327, 2012.
Chanda, S., A. Dickinson, S. Gupta, and M. Browne. Full-field in vitro measurements and in silico predictions of strain shielding in the implanted femur after total hip arthroplasty. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Part H. 229(8):549–559, 2015.
Courtney, A. C., E. F. Wachtel, E. R. Myers, and W. C. Hayes. Effects of loading rate on strength of the proximal femur. Calcif. Tissue Int. 55(1):53–58, 1994.
Crist, B. D., A. Khalafi, S. J. Hazelwood, and M. A. Lee. A biomechanical comparison of locked plate fixation with percutaneous insertion capability versus the angled blade plate in a subtrochanteric fracture gap model. J. Orthop. Trauma. 23(9):622–627, 2009.
Dickinson, A. S., A. C. Taylor, H. Ozturk, and M. Browne. Experimental validation of a finite element model of the proximal femur using digital image correlation and a composite bone model. J. Biomech. Eng. 133(1):014504, 2011.
Ferguson, S. J., U. P. Wyss, and D. R. Pichora. Finite element stress analysis of a hybrid fracture fixation plate. Med. Eng. Phys. 18:241–250, 1996.
Floyd, J. C., R. V. O’Toole, A. Stall, D. P. Forward, M. Nabili, D. Shillingburg, A. Hsieh, and J. W. Nascone. Biomechanical comparison of proximal locking plates and blade plates for the treatment of comminuted subtrochanteric femoral fractures. J. Orthop. Trauma. 23(9):628–633, 2009.
Floyd, M. W., J. C. France, and D. F. Hubbard. Early experience with the proximal femoral locking plate. Orthopedics. 36(12):1488–1494, 2013.
Forward, D. P., C. J. Doro, R. V. O’Toole, H. Kim, J. C. Floyd, M. F. C. H. SciadiniTuren, A. H. Hsieh, and J. W. Nascone. A biomechanical comparison of a locking plate, a nail, and a 95° angled blade plate for fixation of subtrochanteric femoral fractures. J. Orthop. Trauma. 26(6):334–40, 2012.
Gilchrist, S., K. K. Nishiyama, P. de Bakker, P. Guy, S. K. Boyd, T. Oxland, and P. A. Cripton. Proximal femur elastic behaviour is the same in impact and constant displacement rate fall simulation. J. Biomech. 47(15):3744–3749, 2014.
Gokhale, N. S., S. S. Deshpande, S. V. Bedekar, and A. N. Thite, Practical finite element analysis, , 2008.
GOM Correlate. GOM—Precise Industrial 3D Metrology. Braunschweig, Germany. https://www.gom.com. accessed on 7 September 2019.
Grassi, L., S. P. Väänänen, M. Ristinmaa, J. S. Jurvelin, and H. Isaksson. How accurately can subject-specific finite element models predict strains and strength of human femora? Investigation using full-field measurements. J. Biomech. 49(5):802–806, 2016.
Grisso, J. A., J. L. Kelsey, B. L. Strom, G. Y. Chiu, G. Maislin, L. A. O’Brien, S. Hoffman, and F. Kaplan. Risk factors for falls as a cause of hip fracture in women. The Northeast Hip Fracture Study Group. N. Engl. J. Med. 324(19):1326–31, 1991.
Haentjens, P., P. Autier, M. Barette, K. Venken, D. Vanderschueren, and S. Boonen. Hip fracture study group. Survival and functional outcome according to hip fracture type: a one-year prospective cohort study in elderly women with an intertrochanteric or femoral neck fracture. Bone. 41(6):958–64, 2007.
Hasenboehler, E. A., J. F. Agudelo, S. J. Morgan, W. R. Smith, D. J. Hak, and P. F. Stahel. Treatment of complex proximal femoral fractures with the proximal femur locking compression plate. Orthopedics. 30(8):618–623, 2007.
Hensley, S., M. Christensen, S. Small, D. Archer, E. Lakes, and R. Rogge. Digital image correlation techniques for strain measurement in a variety of biomechanical test models. Acta Bioeng. Biomech. 19(3):187–195, 2017.
Huang, H. M., L. C. Pan, S. Y. Lee, C. L. Chiu, K. H. Fan, and K. N. Ho. Assessing the implant/bone interface by using natural frequency analysis. Oral Surg. Oral Med. Oral Pathol. Oral Radiol. Endod. 90(3):285–291, 2000.
Islam, A. B. M. S., M. Jameel, and M. Z. Jumaat. Seismic isolation in buildings to be a practical reality: behavior of structure and installation technique. J. Eng. Technol. Res. 3(4):99–117, 2011.
Jazinizadeh, F., H. Mohammadi, and C. E. Quenneville. Comparing the fracture limits of the proximal femur under impact and quasi-static conditions in simulation of a sideways fall. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 103:103593, 2020.
Jensen, J. S. Classification of trochanteric fractures. Acta Orthop. Scand. 51(5):803–810, 1980.
Jetté, B., V. Brailovski, C. Simoneau, M. Dumas, and P. Terriault. Development and in vitro validation of a simplified numerical model for the design of a biomimetic femoral stem. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 77:539–550, 2018.
Johnson, B., J. Stevenson, R. Chamma, A. Patel, S.-J. Rhee, C. Lever, I. Starks, and P. J. Roberts. Short-term follow-up of pertrochanteric fractures treated using the proximal femoral locking plate. J. Orthop. Trauma. 28(5):283–287, 2014.
Katz, Y., and Z. Yosibash. New insights on the proximal femur biomechanics using Digital Image Correlation. J. Biomech. 101:109599, 2020.
Keyak, J. H. Relationships between femoral fracture loads for two load configurations. J. Biomech. 33(4):499–502, 2000.
Keyak, J. H., S. A. Rossi, K. A. Jones, C. M. Les, and H. B. Skinner. Prediction of fracture location in the proximal femur using finite element models. Med. Eng. Phys. 23(9):657–664, 2001.
Khalil, T. B., D. C. Viano, and L. A. Taber. Vibrational characteristics of the embalmed human femur. J. Sound Vib. 75(3):417–436, 1981.
Latifi, M. H., K. Ganthel, S. Rukmanikanthan, A. Mansor, T. Kamarul, and M. Bilgen. Prospects of implant with locking plate in fixation of subtrochanteric fracture: experimental demonstration of its potential benefits on synthetic femur model with supportive hierarchical nonlinear hyperelastic finite element analysis. Biomed. Eng. 11(23):1–18, 2012.
Lewis, G. Properties of acrylic bone cement: state of the art review. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 38(2):155–182, 1997.
Link, T. M., V. Vieth, R. Langenberg, N. Meier, A. Lotter, D. Newitt, and S. Majumdar. Structure analysis of high resolution magnetic resonance imaging of the proximal femur: in vitro correlation with biomechanical strength and BMD. Calcif. Tissue Int. 72:156–165, 2003.
Lotz, J. C., E. J. Cheal, and W. C. Hayes. Fracture prediction for the proximal femur using finite element models: Part II—Nonlinear analysis. J. Biomech. Eng. 113(4):361–365, 1991.
Lotz, J. C., E. J. Cheal, and W. C. Hayes. Stress distributions within the proximal femur during gait and falls: implications for osteoporotic fracture. Osteoporos. Int. 5(4):252–261, 1995.
Lunsjö, K., L. Ceder, J. Tidermark, P. Hamberg, B. E. Larsson, B. Ragnarsson, R. W. Knebel, I. Allvin, K. Hjalmars, S. Norberg, P. Fornander, A. Hauggaard, and L. Stigsson. Extramedullary fixation of 107 subtrochanteric fractures: a randomized multicenter trial of the Medoff sliding plate versus 3 other screw-plate systems. Acta Orthop. Scand. 70(5):459–466, 1999.
Mardani-Kivi, M., A. Mirbolook, S. Khajeh Jahromi, and M. Rouhi Rad. Fixation of intertrochanteric fractures: dynamic hip screw versus locking compression plate. Trauma Mon. 18(2):67–70, 2013.
Mayhew, P. M., C. D. Thomas, J. G. Clement, N. Loveridge, T. J. Beck, W. Bonfield, C. J. Burgoyne, and J. Reeve. Relation between age, femoral neck cortical stability, and hip fracture risk. Lancet. 366(9480):129–135, 2005.
Nag, P., and S. Chanda. Biomechanical design prognosis of two extramedullary fixation devices for subtrochanteric femur fracture: a finite element study. Med. Biol. Eng. Comput. 59(2):271–285, 2021.
Nevitt, M. C., S. R. Cummings, S. Kidd, and D. Black. Risk factors for recurrent nonsyncopal falls. A prospective study. JAMA. 261(18):2663–2668, 1989.
Nieves, J. W., J. P. Bilezikian, J. M. Lane, T. A. Einhorn, Y. Wang, M. Steinbuch, and F. Cosman. Fragility fractures of the hip and femur: incidence and patient characteristics. Osteoporos. Int. 21(3):399–408, 2010.
Nishiyama, K. K., S. Gilchrist, P. Guy, P. Cripton, and S. K. Boyd. Proximal femur bone strength estimated by a computationally fast finite element analysis in a sideways fall configuration. J. Biomech. 46(7):1231–1236, 2013.
Nowotarski, P. J., B. Ervin, B. Weatherby, J. Pettit, R. Goulet, and B. Norris. Biomechanical analysis of a novel femoral neck locking plate for treatment of vertical shear Pauwel’s type C femoral neck fractures. Injury. 43(6):802–806, 2012.
Oger, P., V. Katz, N. Lecorre, and P. Beaufils. Fracture of the great trochanter treated by dynamic hip screw plate: measure of impaction according to fracture type. Rev. Chir. Orthop. 84:539–545, 1998.
Oh, C.-W., J.-J. Kim, Y.-S. Byun, J.-K. Oh, J.-W. Kim, S.-Y. Kim, B.-C. Park, and H.-J. Lee. Minimally invasive plate osteosynthesis of subtrochanteric femur fractures with a locking plate: a prospective series of 20 fractures. Arch. Orthop. Trauma Surg. 129(12):1659–65, 2009.
Pérez, M. A., and B. Seral-García. A finite element analysis of the vibration behaviour of a cementless hip system. Comput. Methods Biomech. Biomed. Eng. 16(9):1022–1031, 2013.
Ravi, G. O., and S. Saheb. Study of proximal femoral locking compression plate in extra capsular fracture neck of femur. Int. J. Res. Med. Sci. 3(12):3726–3733, 2017.
Reina-Romo, E., J. Rodríguez-Vallés, and J. A. Sanz-Herrera. In silico dynamic characterization of the femur: physiological versus mechanical boundary conditions. Med. Eng. Phys. S1350–4533(18):30090, 2018.
Robinovitch, S. N., W. C. Hayes, and T. A. McMahon. Prediction of femoral impact forces in falls on the hip. J. Biomech. Eng. 113(4):366–374, 1991.
Rossman, T., S. Uthamaraj, A. Rezaei, S. McEligot, H. Giambini, I. Jasiuk, M. J. Yaszemski, L. Lu, and D. Dragomir-Daescu. A method to estimate cadaveric femur cortical strains during fracture testing using digital image correlation. J. Vis. Exp. 127:54942, 2017.
Saini, P., R. Kumar, V. Shekhawat, N. Joshi, M. Bansal, and S. Kumar. Biological fixation of comminuted subtrochanteric fractures with proximal femur locking compression plate. Injury. 44(2):226–231, 2013.
Saudan, M., A. Lübbeke, C. Sadowski, N. Riand, R. Stern, and P. Hoffmeyer. Pertrochanteric fractures: is there an advantage to an intramedullary nail? A randomized, prospective study of 206 patients comparing the dynamic hip screw and proximal femoral nail. J. Orthop. Trauma. 16(6):86–93, 2002.
Schileo, E., L. Balistreri, L. Grassi, L. Cristofolini, and F. Taddei. To what extent can linear finite element models of human femora predict failure under stance and fall loading configurations? J. Biomech. 47(14):3531–3538, 2014.
Schileo, E., F. Taddei, L. Cristofolini, and M. Viceconti. Subject-specific finite element models implementing a maximum principal strain criterion are able to estimate failure risk and fracture location on human femurs tested in vitro. J. Biomech. 41(2):356–367, 2008.
Seinsheimer, F. Subtrochanteric fractures of the femur. J. Bone Joint Surg. Am. 60(3):300–306, 1978.
Setiobudi, T., Y. H. Ng, C. T. Lim, S. Liang, K. Lee, and S. D. De. Clinical outcome following treatment of stable and unstable intertrochanteric fractures with dynamic hip screw. Ann. Acad. Med. 40(11):482–487, 2011.
Sommer, C., E. Gautier, M. Müller, D. L. Helfet, and M. Wagner. First clinical results of the Locking Compression Plate (LCP). Injury. 34(2):B43–B54, 2003.
Subash, Y., S. Vishnu, and Damodharan,. Management of unstable intertrochanteric fractures with proximal femoral locking plate—a prospective study of 30 patients. Int. J. Res. Pharm. Sci. 12(1):274–279, 2021.
Sutton, M. A., J. H. Yan, V. Tiwari, H. W. Schreier, and J. J. Orteu. The effect of out-of-plane motion on 2D and 3D digital image correlation measurements. Opt. Lasers Eng. 46(10):746–757, 2008.
Synthes© Incorporation or its affiliates 4.5 mm LCP Proximal Femur Plates. Part of the synthes periarticular LCP plating system. Technique Guide, 2010.
Thrun, M., C. Finfrock, A. Clarke, and K. Clarke. Effects of unloading on subsequent yielding behavior in 304 stainless steel. Front. Mater. 7:615361, 2021. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmats.2020.615361.
Tomaszewski, P. K., N. Verdonschot, S. K. Bulstra, and G. J. Verkerke. A comparative finite-element analysis of bone failure and load transfer of osseointegrated prostheses fixations. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 38(7):2418–2427, 2010.
Tonino, A. J., C. L. Davidson, P. J. Klopper, and L. A. Linclau. Protection from stress in bone and its effects. Experiments with stainless steel and plastic plates in dogs. J. Bone Joint Surg. 58(1):107–113, 1976.
Villette, C. C., and A. T. M. Phillips. Rate and age-dependent damage elasticity formulation for efficient hip fracture simulations. Med. Eng. Phys. 61:1–12, 2018.
Wang, J., X.-L. Ma, J.-X. Ma, D. Xing, Y. Yang, S.-W. Zhu, B.-Y. Ma, Y. Chen, R. Feng, H.-B. Jia, and J.-T. Yu. Biomechanical analysis of four types of internal fixation in subtrochanteric fracture models. Orthop. Surg. 6(2):128–136, 2014.
Wieser, K., and R. Babst. Fixation failure of the LCP proximal femoral plate 45./5.0 in patients with missing posteromedial support in unstable per-, inter-, and subtrochanteric fractures of the proximal femur. Arch. Orthop. Trauma Surg. 130(10):1281–1287, 2010.
Wirtz, C., F. Abbasi, D. S. Evangelopoulos, S. Kohl, K. A. Siebenrock, and A. Krüger. High failure rate of trochanteric fracture osteosynthesis with proximal femoral locking compression plate. Injury. 44(6):751–756, 2013.
Zanetti, E. M., and A. L. Audenino. Thermoelastic stress analysis by means of a standard thermocamera. Exp. Tech. 31(2):42–50, 2007.
Zanetti, E. M., and A. L. Audenino. Differential thermography for experimental, full-field stress analysis of hip arthroplasty. J. Mech. Med. Biol. 10(3):515–529, 2010. https://doi.org/10.1142/S0219519410003496.
Zha, G. C., Z.-L. Chen, X.-B. Qi, and J.-Y. Sun. Treatment of pertrochanteric fractures with a proximal femur locking compression plate. Injury. 42(11):1294–1299, 2011.
Zhang, Z., X. Zhang, W. Chen, et al. A high-efficient energy regenerative shock absorber using supercapacitors for renewable energy applications in range extended electric vehicle. Appl. Energy. 178:177–188, 2016.
Zhong, B., Y. Zhang, C. Zhang, and C.-F. Luo. A comparison of proximal femoral locking compression plates with dynamic hip screws in extracapsular femoral fractures. Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 100(6):663–668, 2014.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to acknowledge the computational facilities available at the Biomechanics Laboratory, Biosciences and Bioengineering, Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, India, which has helped carry out this study. The authors would also like to acknowledge Dr. Sourabh Boruah, Harris Orthopaedics Laboratory, Harvard Medical School, Boston, USA for pertinent inputs for the experimental work. The study has been partially supported by SERB, India (Grant no. SRG/2019/000235). The travel related to the study was partially supported by Fulbright Trust, USA.
Conflict of interest
None declared.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Associate Editor Stefan M. Duma oversaw the review of this article.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Nag, P., Borgohain, B., Ahmed, K.A. et al. The Influence of Static Load and Sideways Impact Fall on Extramedullary Bone Plates Used to Treat Intertrochanteric Femoral Fracture: A Preclinical Strength Assessment. Ann Biomed Eng 50, 1923–1940 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-022-03013-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-022-03013-z