Risks of therapeutic versus prophylactic neurectomies

Abstract

Introduction

Neuralgia due to a peripheral nerve injury may result in chronic pain, requiring a therapeutic surgical neurectomy. Meanwhile, some neurectomies are performed prophylactically, such as during inguinal mesh removal. Outcomes and risks associated with neurectomies are largely unknown despite consensus panels recommending them.

Methods

All patients who underwent neurectomy 2013–2020 were analyzed. Data collection included demographics, preoperative symptoms, and postoperative outcomes. Indications for neurectomy were categorized as “therapeutic” if the patient had preoperative neuralgia or “prophylactic” if neurectomy was deemed necessary intra-operatively.

Results

66 patients underwent 80 operations and a total of 122 neurectomies. On average, 1.5 neurectomies were performed per operation. Therapeutic neurectomies were performed in 42 (64%) patients and prophylactic in 34 (52%). The most commonly transected nerve was the ilioinguinal nerve. Average preoperative pain score was 5.8/10. On paired analysis, there was a significant reduction in pain after prophylactic neurectomy (2.5 points, p = 0.002) but not after therapeutic neurectomy. None of the nerves transected prophylactically had postoperative neuralgia, whereas 35% of the nerves transected therapeutically resulted in persistent or recurrent neuralgia (p < 0.001). To treat this, 21% required only nerve blocks and 9% required ablation or reoperative neurectomy. Three patients had complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS), a severe complication; all three were diagnosed with chronic pain syndrome pre-operatively.

Discussion

We demonstrate that prophylactic neurectomy is largely safe. In contrast, a therapeutic neurectomy had a 35% risk of persistent or recurrent neuralgia, 9% required additional ablative or reoperative neurectomy. Three patients advanced from chronic pain syndrome to CRPS. We recommend the decision to perform a neurectomy be judicious and selective, especially in patients with known chronic pain syndrome. Prior to planning surgical neurectomy, other less invasive modalities should be exhausted and patients should be aware of its risks.