Abstract
We compared two methods routinely used to conduct bird community surveys: point counts and transects. Our aim was to look for differences between these two methods regarding detection of bird richness and abundances. Additionally, we analyzed if one of the methods provided higher correlation of bird data with vegetation structure as an important habitat descriptor. From September 2014 to January 2015, we surveyed birds in 264 point counts and 258 transects spread across the southern Brazilian grasslands. We conducted one method in direct sequence of the other, in the same place with the same observers and at the same weather conditions. We standardized data to eliminate the effort bias caused by area covered and time employed in each method. Total abundance of birds recorded by the two methods did not differ (point counts 4753 and transects 4436, P = 0.31), but we found a significant difference in species richness (point counts 187 and transects 173, P = 0.01). Abundance of birds sampled with the transect method showed a slightly higher correlation with vegetation height (r2 = 0.07; P = 0.004) than the point counts method (r2 = 0.03; P = 0.05). While results from both methods were similar, richness detection was more effective in point counts, indicating that this method might be more useful than it currently is. We discuss potential factors that may influence effectiveness of both methods and suggest issues that should be addressed in further research in order to develop standardized sampling methods for bird communities.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Ayres M., Ayres-Jr M., Ayres D.L. & Santos A.A.S. 2007. BioEstat 5.0: aplicações estatísticas nas áreas das ciencias biológicas e médicas. Belém: Sociedade Civil Mamirauá (MCT-CNPq).
Azpiroz A.B. & Blake J.G. 2016. Associations of grassland birds with vegetation structure in the northern Campos of Uruguay. Condor 118:12–23.
Azpiroz A.B., Isacch J.P., Dias R.A., Di Giacomo A.S., Fontana C.S. & Palarea C.M. 2012. Ecology and conservation of grassland birds in southeastern South America: a review. Journal of Field Ornithology 83:217–246.
Bibby C.J., Burgess N.D., Hill D.A. & Mustoe S.H. 2000. Bird census techniques. London: Academic Press.
Blondel J., Ferry C. & Frochot B. 1970. La méthode des indices ponctuels d’abondance (I.P.A.) ou des relevés d>avifaune par “stations d’écoute”. Alauda 38:55–71.
Buckland S.T., Anderson D.R., Burnham K.P., Laake J.L., Borchers D.L. & Thomas L. 2001. Introduction to distance sampling: estimating abundance of biological populations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Buckland S.T. 2006. Point-transect surveys for songbirds: robust methodologies. Auk 123:345–357.
Cardoni D.A., Isacch J.P. & Iribarne O. 2015. Avian responses to varying intensity of cattle production in Spartina densiflora saltmarshes of south-eastern South America. Emu 115:12–19.
Codesido M., González-Fischer C. & Bilenca D. 2008. Asociaciones entre diferentes patrones de uso de la tierra y ensambles de aves en agroecosistemas de la región pampeana, Argentina. Ornitología Neotropical 19:575–585.
Derner J.D., Lauenroth W.K., Stapp P. & Augustine D.J. 2009. Livestock as ecosystem engineers for grassland bird habitat in the western Great Plains of North America. Rangeland Ecology & Management 62:111–118.
Dias R.A., Bastazini V.A.G., Gonçalves M.S.S., Bonow F.C. & Müller S.C. 2013. Shifts in composition of avian communities related to temperate-grassland afforestation in southeastern South America. Iheringia, Série Zoologia 103:12–19.
Dias R.A., Gianuca A.T., Vizentin-Bugoni J., Gonçalves M.S.S., Bencke G.A. & Bastazini V.A.G. 2017. Livestock disturbance in Brazilian grasslands influences avian species diversity via turnover. Biodiversity and Conservation 26:2473–2490.
Diefenbach D.R., Brauning D.W., Mattice J.A. & Thompson-III F.R. 2003. Variability in grassland bird counts related to observer differences and species detection rates. Auk 120:1168–1179.
Dotta G., Phalan B., Silva T.W., Green R. & Balmford A. 2016. Assessing strategies to reconcile agriculture and bird conservation in the temperate grasslands of South America. Conservation Biology 30:618–627.
Emlen J.T 1971. Population densities of birds derived from transect counts. Auk 88:323–342.
Fedrigo J.K., Ataide P.F., Azambuja-Filho J., Oliveira L.V., Jaurena M., Laca E.A., Overbeck G.E. & Nabinger C. 2018. Temporary grazing exclusion promotes rapid recovery of species richness and productivity in a long-term overgrazed Campos grassland. Restoration Ecology 26: 677–685.
Fontana C.S., Dotta G., Kelm-Marques C., Repenning M., Agne C.E. & Santos R.J. 2016. Conservation of grassland birds in south Brazil: a land management perspective. Natureza & Conservação 14:83–87.
Golding J.D. & Dreitz V.J. 2016. Comparison of removal-based methods for estimating abundance of five species of prairie songbirds. Journal of Field Ornithology 87:417–426.
Iknayan K.J., Tingley M.W., Furnas B.J. & Beissinger S.R. 2014. Detecting diversity: emerging methods to estimate species diversity. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 29:97–106.
Isacch J.P., Bo M.S., Maceira N.O., Demaría M.R & Peluc S. 2003. Composition and seasonal changes of the bird community in the west Pampa grasslands of Argentina. Journal of Field Ornithology 74:59–65.
Isacch J.P., Cardoni D.A. & Iribarne O.O. 2014. Diversity and habitat distribution of birds in coastal marshes and comparisons with surrounding upland habitats in southeastern South America. Estuaries and Coasts 37:229–239.
Järvinen O. 1978. Estimating relative densities of land birds by point counts. Annales Zoologici Fennici 15:290–293.
Järvinen O. & Väisänen R.A. 1979. Changes in bird populations as criteria of environmental changes. Holarctic Ecology 2: 75–80.
Karr J.R & Roth R.R. 1971. Vegetation structure and avian diversity in several new world areas. American Naturalist 105: 423–435.
Leidinger J.L.G., Gossner M.M., Weisser W.W., Koch C., Rosadio-Cayllahua Z.L., Podgaiski L.R., Duarte M.M., Araújo A.S.F., Overbeck G.E., Hermann J.M., Kollmann J. & Meyer S.T. 2017. Historical and recent land use affects ecosystem functions in subtropical grasslands in Brazil. Ecosphere 8: e02032.
Magnusson W., Braga-Neto R., Pezzini F., Baccaro F., Bergallo H., Penha J., Rodrigues D., Verdade L.M., Lima A., Albernaz A.L., Hero J.M., Lawson B., Castilho C., Drucker D., Franklin E., Mendonça F., Costa F., Galdino G., Castley G., Zuanon J., Vale J., Santos J.L.C., Luizão R., Cintra R., Barbosa R.I., Lisboa A., Koblitz R.V., Cunha C.N. & Mendes-Pontes A.R. 2013. Biodiversidade e monitoramento ambiental integrado. Santo André: Áttema Editorial.
Marone L. 1991. Habitat features affecting bird spatial distribution in the Monte Desert, Argentina. Ecologia Austral 1:77–86.
Marone L., Casenave J.L. & Cueto V.R. 1997. Patterns of habitat selection by wintering and breeding granivorous birds in the central Monte desert, Argentina. Revista Chilena de Historia Natural 70:73–81.
Matsuoka S.M., Mahon C.L., Handel C.M., Sólymos P., Bayne E.M., Fontaine P.C. & Ralph C.J. 2014. Reviving common standards in point-count surveys for broad inference across studies. Condor 116:599–608.
Mekonen S. 2017. Birds as biodiversity and environmental indicator. Advances in Life Science and Technology 60:16–22.
Nichols J.D., Hines J.E., Sauer J.R., Fallon F.W., Fallon J.E. & Heglund P.J. 2000. A double-observer approach for estimating detection probability and abundance from point counts. Auk 117:393–408.
Overbeck G.E., Müller S.C., Fidelis A., Pfadenhauer J., Pillar V.D., Blanco C.C., Boldrini I.I., Both R. & Forneck E.D. 2007. Brazil’s neglected biome: the south Brazilian Campos. Perspectives in Plant Ecology, Evolution and Systematics 9:101–116.
Overbeck G.E., Scasta J.D., Furquim F.F., Boldrini I.I., Weir J.R. 2018. The south Brazilian grasslands - a South American tallgrass prairie? Parallels and implications of fire dependency. Perspectives in Ecology and Conservation 16:24–30.
Patterson M.P. & Best L.B. 1996. Bird abundance and nesting success in Iowa CRP fields: the importance of vegetation structure and composition. American Midland Naturalist 135:153–167.
Piacentini V.Q., Aleixo A., Agne C.E., Maurício G., Pacheco J.F., Bravo G.A., Brito G.R.R., Naka L.N., Olmos F., Posso S., Silveira L.F., Betini G.S., Carrano E., Franz I., Lees A.C., Lima L.M., Pioli D., Schunck F., Amaral F.R., Bencke G.A., Cohn-Haft M., Figueiredo L.F., Straube F.C. & Cesari E. 2015. Annotated checklist of the birds of Brazil by the Brazilian Ornithological Records Committee. Revista Brasileira de Ornitologia 23:91–298.
R Core Team. 2016. R: a language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
Ralph C.J., Geupel G.R., Pyle P., Martin T.E. & DeSante D.F. 1993. Handbook of field methods for monitoring landbirds. Albany: UNL Faculty Publications.
Ralph C.J., Sauer J.R. & Droege S. 1995. Monitoring bird populations by point counts. Albany: Pacific Southwest Research Station.
Ralph C.J. & Scott J.M. 1981. Estimating numbers of terrestrial birds, v. 6 (Studies in Avian Biology). Lawrence: Allen Press.
Recher H.F. 1969. Bird species diversity and habitat diversity in Australia and North America. American Naturalist 103:75–80.
Rodrigues R.C. & Prado P.I. 2018. Sampling methods affect observed response of bird species richness to vegetation structure in Brazilian savannas. Condor 120:402–413.
Silva T.W., Dotta G. & Fontana C.S. 2015. Structure of avian assemblages in grasslands associated with cattle ranching and soybean agriculture in the Uruguayan savanna ecoregion of Brazil and Uruguay. Condor 117:53–63.
Willson M.F. 1974. Avian community organization and habitat structure. Ecology 55:1017–1029.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Fontana, C.S., Chiarani, E., da Silva Menezes, L. et al. Bird surveys in grasslands: do different count methods present distinct results?. Rev. Bras. Ornitol. 26, 116–122 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03544422
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03544422