Abstract
In contrast to dark (illegal, covert, illicit) or bright (legal, overt, above-ground) networks, gray networks conduct a mixture of legal and illegal activities and have an organizational structure that may be only partially known. The goal of this research is to demonstrate techniques for using trace data from Venmo, a payment network, and Facebook, a social networking site, to understand the organizational structure of one particular gray network: a membership organization of self-described “Western chauvinists” called Proud Boys. Using publicly-available data from the Facebook API and from the Venmo web site, this research reveals the underlying organizational structure for this group as it grew and matured from October 2016–March 2019. The payment network is modeled as a one-mode directed network of payers and payees conducting transactions such as dues payments and activity fees. A two-mode network of the Venmo users and their memberships in Proud Boys groups on Facebook further illuminates the structure of the organization. Supplementary data from news reports and arrest records is used to confirm the findings from this network analysis. Results will be useful for understanding the extent to which trace data from online activities can expose the offline organizational structure of semi-clandestine groups.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
References
Culkin, R.: Proud boys: who are they? proud boys magazine (2017). https://officialproudboys.com/proud-boys/whoaretheproudboys. Accessed 29 Mar 2019. http://archive.li/BoO1k. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
Proud boys chapters. http://proudboysusa.com/chapters. Accessed 29 Mar 2019. http://archive.li/Vv7iR. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
The constitution and bylaws of proud boys international L.L.C (2018). https://www.scribd.com/document/394310661/Proud-Boys-Redacted-Bylaws-Adopted-11–25-2018. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Proud boys website. http://proudboysusa.com. Accessed 13 Apr 2019. https://archive.is/SxVq9. Accessed 8 Aug 2018
Coaston, J.: The Proud Boys, the bizarre far-right street fighters behind violence in New York. explained. Vox (2018). https://www.vox.com/2018/10/15/17978358/proud-boys-gavin-mcinnes-manhattan-gop-violence. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Bazile, P.: How to survive driving through Islamberg with the Proud Boys. Proud Boys Magazine (2017). https://officialproudboys.com/columns/how-to-survive-driving-through-islamberg-with-the-proud-boys. Accessed 29 Mar 2019. http://archive.li/5OfCa. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
Feuer, A., Peters, J.W.: Fringe groups revel as protests turn violent. New York Times (2017). https://nytimes.com/2017/06/02/us/politics/white-nationalists-alt-knights-protests-colleges.html. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
KATU News. Judge issues arrest warrant for Proud Boys member Tusitala “Tiny” Toese (2019). https://katu.com/news/local/judge-issues-arrest-warrant-for-proud-boys-member-tusitala-tiny-toese. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Feuer, A., Winston, A.: Founder of Proud Boys says he’s arranging surrender of men in brawl. New York Times (2018). https://nytimes.com/2018/10/19/nyregion/the-proud-boys-gavin-mcinnes-arrested.html. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Moritz-Rabson, D.: Former Proud Boys lawyer suspended by Texas bar after series of alleged threats, slurs (2019). https://www.newsweek.com/proud-boys-lawyer-suspended-texas-bar-after-threats-1340618. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Roettgers, J.: Twitter shuts down accounts of Vice co-founder Gavin McInnes, Proud Boys ahead of ‘Unite the Right’ rally. Variety (2018). https://variety.com/2018/digital/news/twitter-shuts-down-accounts-of-vice-co-founder-gavin-mcinnes-proud-boys-ahead-of-unite-the-right-rally-1202902397. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Matthews, K.: Facebook, Instagram ban far-right Proud Boys and founder. AP News (2018). https://apnews.com/2714b6a697d34f59982c398a235858e7. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Wilson, J.: Who are the Proud Boys, ‘western chauvinists’ involved in political violence? The Guardian (2018). https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jul/14/proud-boys-far-right-portland-oregon. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Barrouquere, B.: Skinhead ‘Irv’ among five charged in Proud Boys’ New York City assault. Southern Poverty Law Center (2018). https://www.splcenter.org/hatewatch/2018/10/22/skinhead-irv-among-five-charged-proud-boys-new-york-city-assault. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Sommer, W.: Proud Boys founder Gavin McInnes claims he’s quitting far-right group. Daily Beast (2018). https://www.thedailybeast.com/proud-boys-founder-gavin-mcinnes-quits-far-right-group. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
The Elders. Official statement: We’re not going anywhere. Proud Boys Magazine (2018). https://officialproudboys.com/uncategorized/official-statement-were-not-going-anywhere. Accessed 29 Mar 2019. http://archive.li/EokfM. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
The Elders. Announcing the new Proud Boys bylaws, and our chairman. Proud Boys Magazine (2018). https://officialproudboys.com/uncategorized/announcing-the-new-proud-boys-bylaws-and-our-chairman. Accessed 29 Mar 2019. http://archive.li/ugrdc. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
Langton, A.: Tweet (2018). https://twitter.com/AsherLangton/status/1067605372234551297. Accessed 29 Mar 2019. http://archive.li/phFhW. Accessed 28 Nov 2018
Crosbie, J.: Proud Boys failed to redact their new dumb bylaws and accidentally doxxed their ‘Elders’. Splinter (2018). https://splinternews.com/proud-boys-failed-to-redact-their-new-dumb-bylaws-and-a-1830700905. Accessed 29 Mar 2019
Cunningham, D., Everton, S.: Murphy, P: Understanding Dark Networks. Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham (2016)
Roberts, N., Everton, S.F.: Strategies for combating dark networks. J. Soc. Struct. 12(2), 1–32 (2011)
Shetty, J., Adibi, J.: Discovering important nodes through graph entropy: the case of the Enron email database. In: Proceedings of the Knowledge Discovery in Databases Conference (KDD), Chicago, IL, USA. ACM (2005)
Erickson, B.: Secret societies and social structure. Soc. Forces 60(1), 188–210 (1981)
Baker, W.E., Faulkner, R.R.: The social organization of conspiracy: illegal networks in the heavy electrical equipment industry. Am. Soc. Rev. 58, 837–860 (1993)
Krebs, V.E.: Mapping networks of terrorist cells. Connections 24(3), 43–52 (2002)
Morselli, C., Giguère, C., Petit, K.: The efficiency/security trade-off in criminal networks. Soc. Netw. 29(1), 143–153 (2007)
Xu, J., Chen, H.: The topology of dark networks. Commun. ACM 51(16), 58–65 (2008)
Morselli, C.: Hells angels in springtime. Trends in Organized Crime 12, 145–158 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12117-009-9065-1
Magouirk, J., Atran, S., Sageman, M.: Connecting terrorist networks. Stud. Conflict Terror. 31, 1–16 (2008)
Kalm, K.: Illicit network structures in cyberspace. In: 5th International Conference on Cyber Conflict, pp. 1–13 (2013)
MiIward, H.B., Raab, J.: Dark networks as problems revisited: adaptation and transformation of Islamic terror organizations since 9/11. In: 8th Public Management Research Conference (2005)
Milward, H.B., Raab, J.: Dark networks as organizational problems: Elements of a theory. Int. Public Manag. J. 9(3), 333–360 (2006)
Venmo Help Center. Payment activity and privacy. https://help.venmo.com/hc/en-us/articles/210413717-Payment-Activity-Privacy. Accessed 8 Apr 2019
United States before the Federal Trade Commission. In the matter of PAYPAL, Inc., a corporation. 1623102. Docket C-4651. (2018). https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/cases/1623102_c-4651_paypal_venmo_complaint_final.pdf. Accessed 8 Apr 2019
Moynihan, C., Winston, A.: Far-right Proud Boys reeling after arrests and scrutiny. New York Times (2018). https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/23/nyregion/gavin-mcinnes-proud-boys-nypd.html. Accessed 8 Apr 2019
Official Proud Boys Magazine. https://officialproudboys.com. Accessed 8 Apr 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/*/officialproudboys.com. Accessed 25 Apr 2017
Hampton, R.: In praise of Venmo humor. Slate (2018). https://slate.com/human-interest/2018/07/venmo-transaction-humor-scrolling-through-the-emojis-and-jokes-of-the-payment-platform.html. Accessed 8 Apr 2019
Facebook. What are the privacy settings for groups? (n.d.) https://www.facebook.com/help/220336891328465. Accessed 8 Apr 2019
Facebook. An update on our plans to restrict data access (2018). https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2018/04/restricting-data-access. Accessed 8 Apr 2019
Hatmaker, T.: Facebook bans the Proud Boys, cutting the group off from its main recruitment platform. TechCrunch (2018). https://techcrunch.com/2018/10/30/facebook-proud-boys-mcinnes-kicked-off. Accessed 8 Apr 2019
Disser, N.: Gavin McInnes and his Proud Boys want to make men great again. Bedford + Bowery (2016). http://bedfordandbowery.com/2016/07/gavin-mcinnes-and-his-proud-boys-want-to-make-white-men-great-again. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
Offenhartz, J.: Anti-Fascist protesters clash with ‘Proud Boys’ as Gavin McInnes speaks at NYU. Gothamist (2017). http://gothamist.com/2017/02/03/nyu_proud_boy_protest.php. Accessed 9 Apr 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20170320150155/. Accessed 20 Mar 2017
Barnes, L.: Proud Boys founder disavows violence at Charlottesville but one of its members organized the event. Think Progress (2017). https://thinkprogress.org/proud-boys-founder-tries-and-fails-to-distance-itself-from-charlottesville-6862fb8b3ae9. Accessed 13 Apr 2019
Obeidallah, D.: Trump-supporting bigots to target upstate New York Muslims. The Daily Beast (2017). https://www.thedailybeast.com/trump-supporting-bigots-to-target-upstate-new-york-muslims. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
WestFest. Official Proud Boys Magazine. https://officialproudboys.com/tag/westfest. Accessed 9 Apr 2019. http://archive.is/LKasN. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
Biggs, J.: “There’s a shit ton of proud boys in downtown Austin tonight and they have taken over. (This is a pic of one view. There are many more)”. Twitter (2018). Original Twitter URL: https://twitter.com/rambobiggs/status/977388616161943553. Accessed 9 Apr 2019. http://archive.li/uxKmj. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
Madani, D.: Two Proud Boys members plead guilty in New York City brawl case. NBC News (2019). https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/two-proud-boys-members-plead-guilty-new-york-city-brawl-n978481. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
Wilson, J.: Proud Boys founder Gavin McInnes quits ‘extremist’ far-right group. The Guardian (2018). https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/nov/22/proud-boys-founder-gavin-mcinnes-quits-far-right-group. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
The Elders. RELEASE: Proud Boys statement on J.L. Van Dyke. Proud Boys Magazine (2018). https://officialproudboys.com/uncategorized/release-proud-boys-statement-on-j-l-van-dyke. Accessed 9 Apr 2019. http://archive.li/JBCjd. Accessed 2 Dec 2018
Zielinski, A.: Proud Boy arrested in Multnomah County for June assault. Portland Mercury (2019). https://www.portlandmercury.com/blogtown/2019/03/12/26142565/proud-boy-arrested-in-multnomah-county-for-June-assaul. Accessed 9 Apr 2019
Gephi. https://gephi.org
Hu, Y.: Efficient, high-quality force directed graph drawing. Math. J. 10(1), 37–71 (2005)
Borgatti, S.P.: 2-Mode concepts in social network analysis. Encycl. Complex. Syst. Sci. 6, 8279–8291 (2009)
Martin, S., Brown, W.M., Klavans, R., Boyack, K.W.: OpenOrd: an open-source toolbox for large graph layout. Vis. Data Anal. 7868, 786806 (2011)
Kessler, S.V., et al.: United States District Court for the Western District of Virginia. https://www.integrityfirstforamerica.org/sites/default/files/Complaint.pdf
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2019 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this paper
Cite this paper
Squire, M. (2019). Understanding Gray Networks Using Social Media Trace Data. In: Weber, I., et al. Social Informatics. SocInfo 2019. Lecture Notes in Computer Science(), vol 11864. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-34971-4_14
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-34971-4_14
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-34970-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-34971-4
eBook Packages: Computer ScienceComputer Science (R0)