Abstract
This study examines company business ethics (BE) as one of the important factors of corporate valuation. It looks into the causal relations between the level of a company's ethical commitment and risk measures, and the association of both with the costs of equity capital (COC). The link between BE and firm value is examined by investigating (a) the degree of companies’ ethical commitment, (b) implied costs of capital and (c) the valuation of companies listed on the Korean stock market. Our results confirm the existence of a significantly negative association between the level of commitment to BE and the implied COC.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Unlike in the field of finance, in accounting literature the terms ‘implied costs of capital’ (the expected rates of returns) and ‘COC’ are often used interchangeably, despite the fact that the implied costs of capital (expected rates of returns) are not exactly equivalent to the COC unless market prices are efficient and analysts’ forecasts of earnings and accounting numbers are unbiased. In other words, it is possible to say the estimates of cost of capital are implied by market prices, analysts’ forecasts of earnings and accounting numbers. Another similar term, ‘weighted average cost of capital’, is not used in valuation unless the discount cash flow model is employed.
In a survey of financial executives, 75 per cent of CEOs said that they would sacrifice economic value to keep earnings rising smoothly (Fox, 2006).
Weak BE and corporate transparency along with poor corporate governance and disclosure inadequacy have also been suggested by business corporations as potential explanations for the so-called ‘Korea discount’ (Baek et al, 2004; Choi and Jung, 2008; Choi and Nakano, 2008; Botosan, 1997; Botosan and Plumlee, 2002; Poshakwale and Courtis, 2005; Dargenidou et al, 2006; Habib, 2006). ‘Korea discount’ is a term used to refer to the fact that in comparison with other countries, companies listed on the Korean stock market are Ceteris paribus substantially undervalued, and thus trade at a discount. This phenomenon can be observed despite similar levels of risk and the fact that the profitability of Korean firms is not lower than the profitability of similar companies in other countries (Guerrera, 2006; Suh and Sim, 2007). Other potential explanations found in the literature include the volatility of the Korean stock market (according to Chang (2005), investors in the Korean stock market bear the characteristics of short-term speculation), excessive restrictions (for example, short-selling restrictions) and weak financial systems (shareholder protection, pension funds restrictions and so on).
Different valuation models use different variables to express a company's CFP. For example, while the dividend discount model uses dividends as the numerator in the formula, the residual earnings model employs earnings and so on. In theory, these models are regarded as identical, as they only differ in the measures they use to express CFP.
Prior studies have used various proxies of CSP, such as (a) survey of corporate reputation as a proxy of CSP (Carroll, 1991), (b) Kinder-Lydenberg-Domini index as a measure of CSP (Waddock and Graves, 1997), (c) corporate philanthropy (Seifert et al, 2003; Brammer and Millington, 2005) or (d) the creation of their own index for social performance (Ruf et al, 1998).
Vogel (1991) comments that if company managers do not behave ethically, they will be punished in the form of media criticism or customer and employee dissatisfaction.
Ruf et al (1998) also constructed their own index for measuring CSP.
The conceptual model used in this study differs from Choi and Jung (2008, p. 452) in that although the referenced model only shows the association between firm value and BE, this study shows that the positive association between CV and BE can be explained by the cost of capital and growth. In other words, Choi and Jung established a link between BE and CV and our study suggests cost of capital and growth as linking factors.
Similarly, a bidirectional association between CSP and CFP has been reported previously (Waddock and Graves, 1997; Simpson and Kohers, 2002; Orlitzky et al, 2003; Orlitzky, 2005).
Similarly, Ruf et al (1998) develop an aggregate systematic measure for CSP index using the Analytic Hierarchy Process. They consider the relative importance of the dimensions by providing a weight (C i ) for each dimension as CSP j =∑ j S ij C i . In this study, equally weighted ethics dimensions were used to avoid subjective measurement error and tests were conducted taking into account the relative weights. Qualitatively, similar results were also obtained after the same analysis without the use of the weights.
Alternative financial measures were also tested as controlling variables. The results were qualitatively identical.
Although the study uses the terms COC and r interchangeably, in a mathematical formula r is preferred.
I also estimated COC from the PEG model (Easton, 2004) as follows: The result was qualitatively similar.
As of 31 December 2007, 745 companies were listed on the Korea Stock Exchange and 1,022 companies on KOSDAQ.
Prior studies suggest that, in general, companies listed in developing countries have a higher COC, because of (a) weaker financial systems (Chang, 2005), (b) poor corporate governance (Baek et al, 2004; Black et al, 2006; Hail and Leuz, 2006) and (c) lack of BE including corporate transparency (Botosan, 1997; Botosan and Plumlee, 2002; Baek et al, 2004; Poshakwale and Courtis, 2005; Dargenidou et al, 2006; Habib, 2006; Lambert et al, 2007; Choi and Jung, 2008; Choi and Nakano, 2008).
Pearson and Kendall's τ−b correlations were also tested. The results were not qualitatively different from the Spearman correlation.
The results of analyses conducted using other CFP proxies such as ROA are qualitatively similar.
Similarly, Preston and O’Bannon (1997) show that a time lag exists between CSP and CFP improvement.
After using other information environment proxies, we obtained qualitatively similar results, reflecting the fact that information measures such as trading volume and size variables are highly correlated with each other (Barth and Hutton, 2004).
For example, Fama and French (1997, 2002) conclude that COC estimated from historic beta is unavoidably imprecise.
The analysis was conducted with various proxy variables. The regression results were not sensitive to the choice of control variables.
The use of ROA draws similar conclusions.
We also used other variables for financial performance. The results were qualitatively similar.
Not tabulated.
The recent promotion of South Korea from the category of ‘emerging market’ to ‘developed status’ according to the FTSE stock market index, due to the improvement in market transparency, also seems to support this conjecture.
One of the plans of the Korean government to tackle unethical practices and increase information quality was the early and voluntary adoption of IFRS in 2009.
References
Agmon, T. and Findlay, M.C. (1982) Domestic political risk and stock valuation. Financial Analysts Journal 38 (6): 74–77.
Aupperle, K., Carroll, A. and Hatfield, J. (1985) An empirical examination of the relationship between corporate social responsibility and profitability. Academy of Management Journal 28 (2): 446–463.
Austin, N.K. (1994) The new corporate watchdogs. Working Woman 19 (1): 19–20.
Baek, J., Kang, J. and Park, K. (2004) Corporate governance and firm value: Evidence from the Korean financial crisis. Journal of Financial Economics 71 (2): 265–313.
Baginski, S. and Wahlen, J. (2003) Residual income, risk, intrinsic values and share prices. Accounting Review 78 (1): 327–351.
Barth, M. and Hutton, A. (2004) Analyst earnings forecast revisions and the pricing of accruals. Review of Accounting Studies 9 (1): 59–96.
Belsley, D., Kuh, E. and Welsch, R. (2004) Regression Diagnostics: Identifying Influential Data and Sources of Collinearity. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.
Black, B., Jang, H. and Kim, W. (2006) Does corporate governance predict firms’ market values? Evidence from Korea. Journal of Law, Economics & Organization 22 (2): 366–411.
Botosan, C. (1997) Disclosure level and the cost of equity capital. Accounting Review 72 (3): 323–349.
Botosan, C. and Plumlee, M. (2002) A re-examination of disclosure level and the expected cost of equity capital. Journal of Accounting Research 40 (1): 21–40.
Botosan, C. and Plumlee, M. (2005) Assessing alternative proxies for the expected risk premium. Accounting Review 80 (1): 21–54.
Brammer, S. and Millington, A. (2005) Corporate reputation and philanthropy: An empirical analysis. Journal of Business Ethics 61 (1): 29–44.
Brenner, S.N. (1992) Ethics programs and their dimensions. Journal of Business Ethics 11 (5–6): 391–399.
Callan, B.J. (1992) Predicting ethical values and training needs in ethics. Journal of Business Ethics 11 (10): 761–769.
Carlson, D.S. and Perrewe, P.L. (1995) Institutionalization of organizational ethics through transformational leadership. Journal of Business Ethics 14 (10): 829–838.
Carroll, A.B. (1991) Corporate social performance measurement: A commentary on methods for evaluating an elusive construct. Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy 12: 385–401.
Chang, K. (2005) Volatility, risk premium and Korea discount. Korean Journal of Financial Management 22 (2): 187–186.
Chen, F., Jorgensen, B.N. and Yoo, Y.K. (2004) Implied cost of equity capital in earnings-based valuation. Accounting and Business Research 34 (4): 323–344.
Cheng, C., Collins, D. and Huang, H. (2006) Shareholder rights, financial disclosure and the cost of equity capital. Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting 27 (1): 175–204.
Choi, T., Lee, E. and Pae, J. (2012) The equity premium puzzle: An empirical evidence for ‘Korea Discount’. Asia Pacific Journal of Accounting and Economics, forthcoming.
Choi, T. (2010) Meeting or Beating Analysts’ Forecasts: Empirical evidence of firms’ characteristics, persistence patterns and post-scandal changes. Seoul Journal of Business. 16 (2): 3–37.
Choi, T. and Jung, J. (2008) Ethical commitment, financial performance and valuation: An empirical investigation of Korean companies. Journal of Business Ethics 81 (2): 447–463.
Choi, T. and Nakano, C. (2008) The evolution of business ethics in Japan and Korea over the last decade. Human Systems Management 27 (3): 183–199.
Claus, J. and Thomas, J. (2001) Equity Premia as low as three per cent? Empirical evidence from analysts’ earnings forecasts for domestic and international stock markets. Journal of Finance 56 (5): 1629–1666.
Cochran, P. and Wood, R. (1984) Corporate social responsibility and corporate social performance. Academy of Management Journal 27 (1): 42–56.
Damodaran, A. (2003) Country risk and company exposure: Theory and practice. Journal of Applied Finance 13 (2): 63–76.
Dargenidou, C., McLeay, S. and Raonic, I. (2006) Expected earnings growth and the cost of capital: An analysis of accounting regime change in the European finance market. Abacus 42 (3–4): 388–414.
Daske, H. (2006) Economic benefits of adopting IFRS or US-GAAP: Have the expected costs of equity capital really decreased? Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 33 (3–4): 329–373.
Dean, P.J. (1992) Making codes of ethics ‘real’. Journal of Business Ethics 11 (4): 285–290.
Dhaliwal, D., Krull, L., Li, O. and Moser, W. (2005) Dividend taxes and implied cost of equity capital. Journal of Accounting Research 43 (5): 675–708.
Diamond, D. and Verrecchia, R. (1991) Disclosure, liquidity and the cost of capital. Journal of Finance 46 (4): 1325–1359.
Easley, D. and O'Hara, M. (2004) Information and the cost of capital. Journal of Finance 59 (4): 1553–1583.
Easton, P. (2004) PE ratios, PEG ratio and estimating the implied expected rate of return on equity capital. Accounting Review 79 (1): 73–96.
Easton, P. (2006) Use of forecasts of earnings to estimate and compare cost of capital across regimes. Journal of Business, Finance and Accounting 33 (3–4): 374–394.
Easton, P. and Monahan, S. (2005) An evaluation of accounting-based measures of expected returns. Accounting Review 80 (2): 501–538.
Easton, P. and Sommers, G. (2007) Effect of analysts’ optimism on estimates of the expected rate of return implied by earnings forecasts. Journal of Accounting Research 45 (5): 983–1015.
Easton, P., Taylor, G., Shroff, P. and Sougiannis, T. (2002) Using forecasts of earnings to simultaneously estimate growth and the rate of return on equity investment. Journal of Accounting Research 40 (3): 659–676.
Epstein, M.J., McEwen, R.A. and Spindle, R.M. (1994) Shareholder preferences concerning corporate ethical performance. Journal of Business Ethics 13 (6): 447–453.
Fama, E. and French, K. (1992) The cross-section of expected stock returns. Journal of Finance 42 (2): 427–465.
Fama, E. and French, K. (1997) Industry costs of equity. Journal of Financial Economics 43 (2): 153–193.
Fama, E. and French, K. (2002) The equity premium. Journal of Finance 57 (2): 637–659.
Fox, J. (2006) Why so short-sighted? Fortune 153 (7): 40–41.
Friedman, M. (1962) Capitalism and Freedom. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Gebhardt, W., Lee, C. and Swaminathan, B. (2001) Toward an implied cost of capital. Journal of Accounting Research 39 (1): 135–176.
Gelb, D. and Strawser, J. (2001) Corporate social responsibility and financial disclosures: An alternative explanation for increased disclosure. Journal of Business Ethics 33 (1): 1–13.
Genfan, H. (1987) Formalizing business ethics. Training and Development Journal 41 (11): 35–37.
Gode, D. and Mohanram, P. (2003) Inferring the cost of capital using the Ohlson-Juettner model. Review of Accounting Studies 8 (4): 399–431.
Gordon, R. and Gordon, M. (1997) The finite horizon expected return model. Financial Analysts Journal 53 (3): 52–61.
Griffin, J. and Mahon, J. (1997) The corporate social performance and corporate financial performance debate: 25 years of incomparable research. Business and Society 36 (1): 5–31.
Guerrera, F. (2006) Why Korea trades at a discount. Financial Times 11 March: 12.
Habib, A. (2006) Information risk and the cost of capital: Review of the empirical literature. Journal of Accounting Literature 25: 127–168.
Hail, L. (2002) The impact of voluntary corporate disclosures on the ex-ante cost of capital for Swiss firms. European Accounting Review 11 (4): 741–773.
Hail, L. and Leuz, C. (2006) International differences in the cost of equity capital: Do legal institutions and securities regulation matter? Journal of Accounting Research 44 (3): 485–531.
Harris, R., Marston, S., Mishra, D.R. and O'Brien, T. (2003) Ex Ante cost of equity estimates of S&P 500 firms: The choice between global and domestic CAPM. Financial Management 32 (3): 51–66.
He, Z. and Kryzanowski, L. (2007) Cost of equity for Canadian and US sectors. North American Journal of Economics and Finance 18 (2): 215–229.
Healy, P. and Palepu, K. (2001) Information asymmetry, corporate disclosure and the capital market: A review of the empirical disclosure literature. Journal of Accounting and Economics 31 (1–3): 405–440.
Jackson, T. et al (2000) Making ethical judgments: A cross-cultural management study. Asia Pacific Journal of Management 17 (3): 443–472.
Jo, H. and Kim, Y. (2008) Ethics and disclosure: A study of the financial performance of firms in the seasoned equity offering market. Journal of Business Ethics 80 (4): 855–878.
Johnson, H. (2003) Does it pay to be good? Social responsibility and financial performance. Business Horizons 46 (6): 34–40.
Koedijk, K.K. and van Dijk, M.A. (2004) Global risk factors and the cost of capital. Financial Analysts Journal 60 (2): 32–38.
Kulshreshtha, P. (2005) Business ethics versus economic incentives: Contemporary issues and dilemmas. Journal of Business Ethics 60 (4): 393–410.
Lambert, R., Leuz, C. and Verrecchia, R. (2007) Accounting information, disclosure and the cost of capital. Journal of Accounting Research 45 (2): 385–420.
Lee, C.Y. and Yoshihara, H. (1997) Business ethics of Korean and Japanese managers. Journal of Business Ethics 16 (1): 7–21.
Lopez, T. and Rees, L. (2002) The effect of beating and missing analysts’ forecasts on the information content of unexpected earnings. Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance 17 (2): 155–184.
Matsumoto, D. (2002) Management's incentives to avoid negative earnings surprise. Accounting Review 77 (3): 483–514.
McGuire, J., Sundgren, A. and Schneeweis, T. (1988) Corporate social responsibility and firm financial performance. Academy of Management Journal 31 (4): 854–872.
Modigliani, F. and Miller, M.H. (1958) The cost of capital, corporation finance and the theory of investment. American Economic Review 48 (3): 261–297.
Moore, G. (2001) Corporate social and financial performance: An investigation in the UK supermarket industry. Journal of Business Ethics 34 (3–4): 299–315.
Murphy, R.E. (1988) Implementing business ethics. Journal of Business Ethics 7 (12): 907–915.
O'Hanlon, J. and Steele, A. (2000) Estimating the equity risk premium using accounting fundamentals. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 27 (9): 1051–1083.
Ohlson, J. and Juettner-Nauroth, B. (2005) Expected EPS and EPS growth as determinants of value. Review of Accounting Studies 10 (2–3): 349–365.
Ohlson, J.A. (1995) Earnings, book values, and dividends in equity valuation. Contemporary Accounting Review 11 (2): 661–687.
Orlitzky, M. (2005) Social responsibility and financial performance: Trade-off or virtuous circle? University of Auckland Business Review 7 (1): 37–43.
Orlitzky, M., Schmidt, F. and Rynes, S. (2003) Corporate social and financial performance: A meta-analysis. Organization Studies 24 (3): 403–441.
Penman, S. (2006) Financial Statement Analysis and Security Valuation, 3rd edn. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Poshakwale, S. and Courtis, J. (2005) Disclosure level and cost of equity capital: Evidence from the banking industry. Managerial and Decision Economics 26 (7): 431–444.
Preston, L. and O'Bannon, D. (1997) The corporate social-financial performance relationship. Business and Society 36 (4): 419–434.
Roberts, R. (1992) Determinants of corporate social responsibility disclosure: An application of stakeholder theory. Accounting, Organizations and Society 17 (6): 595–612.
Ruf, B., Muralidhar, K., Brown, R., Janney, J. and Paul, K. (2001) An empirical investigation of the relationship between change in corporate social performance and financial performance: A stakeholder theory perspective. Journal of Business Ethics 32 (2): 143–156.
Ruf, B., Muralidhar, K. and Paul, K. (1998) The development of a systematic aggregate measure of corporate social performance. Journal of Management 24 (1): 119–133.
Sabal, J. (2004) The discount rate in emerging markets. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 16 (2–3): 155–166.
Sauser, J.W.I. (2005) Ethics in business: Answering the call. Journal of Business Ethics 58 (4): 345–357.
Schwartz, M.S., Dunfee, T.W. and Kline, M.J. (2005) Tone at the top: An ethics code for directors? Journal of Business Ethics 58 (1–3): 70–100.
Seifert, B., Morris, S. and Bartkus, B. (2003) Comparing big givers and small givers: Financial correlates of corporate philanthropy. Journal of Business Ethics 45 (3): 195–211.
Simpson, G. and Kohers, T. (2002) The link between corporate social and financial performance: Evidence from the banking industry. Journal of Business Ethics 35 (2): 97–109.
Sims, R.L. and Keon, T.L. (1999) Determinants of Ethical Decision-making: The relationship of the perceived organizational environment. Journal of Business Ethics 19 (4): 393–401.
Sims, R.R. (1992) The challenge of ethical behavior in organizations. Journal of Business Ethics 11 (7): 505–513.
Singer, A.W. (1995) 1-800-Snitch. Across the Board 32 (8): 16–20.
Skinner, D. and Sloan, R. (2002) Earnings surprises, growth expectation and stock returns: Or don’t let an earnings torpedo sink your portfolio. Review of Accounting Studies 7 (2–3): 289–312.
Spencer, B. and Taylor, G. (1987) A within and between analysis of the relationship between corporate social responsibility and financial performance. Akron Business and Economic Review 18 (3): 7–18.
Stanwick, P. and Stanwick, S. (1998) The relationship between corporate social performance and organizational size, financial performance and environmental performance. Journal of Business Ethics 17 (2): 195–204.
Suh, J. and Sim, S. (2007) Korea discount: Diagnosis and remedy. Asia-Pacific Journal of Financial Studies 36 (4): 621–655.
Taka, I. and Foglia, W.D. (1994) Ethical aspects of ‘Japanese leadership style’. Journal of Business Ethics 13 (2): 135–148.
Trevino, L.K. (1986) Ethical decision-making in organizations: A person-situation interactionist model. Academy of Management Review 11 (3): 601–617.
van der Merwe, R., Pitt, L. and Berthon, P. (2003) Are excellent companies ethical? Evidence from an industrial setting. Corporate Reputation Review 5 (4): 343–554.
Verschoor, C. (1998) A study of the link between a corporation's financial performance and its commitment to ethics. Journal of Business Ethics 17: 1509–1516.
Verschoor, C. (1999) Corporate performance is closely linked to a strong ethical commitment. Business and Society Review 104 (13): 407–415.
Vogel, D. (1991) Business ethics past and present. Public Interest 102 (1): 49–64.
Waddock, S.A. and Graves, S.B. (1997) The corporate social performance – Financial performance link. Strategic Management Journal 18 (4): 303–319.
Weeks, W.A. and Nantel, J. (1992) Corporate codes of ethics and sales force behavior: A case study. Journal of Business Ethics 11 (10): 753–760.
Weiss, J.W. (1994) Business Ethics: A Managerial, Stakeholder Approach. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Acknowledgements
I acknowledge the financial support provided by the KDI School of Public Policy and Management and I wish to thank the Center for Accounting Research and Education (CARE) of the University of Notre Dame for providing an excellent research environment and facilities. I appreciate the helpful comments from Peter Easton, Jinhan Pae, Martina Sipkova and seminar participants at the KDI School of Public Policy and Management. I extend my thanks to the anonymous referees. Finally, I gratefully acknowledge the helpful comments from Harukiyo Hasegawa, the general editor of Asian Business & Management.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Choi, T. Do ethical companies have lower implied cost of equity capital? Evidence from the Korean stock market. Asian Bus Manage 11, 219–246 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1057/abm.2011.32
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/abm.2011.32