Abstract
There have been a number of criticisms, based on visual processes, of the Australian view that colour is an objective property of the world. These criticisms have led to subjective theories about colour. These visual processes (metamers, retinex theory, opponent processes, simultaneous contrast, colour constancy, subjective colours) have been examined and it is suggested that they do not carry their supposed critical weight against an objective theory. In particular, it is argued that metamers don’t occur in nature and primate colour vision evolved without metamers. Thus normal colour vision occurs without the problem of metamers. This argument, in conjunction with evidence against the critical roles of opponent processes and retinex theory in colour vision, is taken to suggest that colour can be given a photon energy/wavelengthrealism explanation. This proposal allows an account of the many microstructural bases of colour generation put forward by Nassau (1983). It is argued that neither disjunctive realism or reflectance realism are adequate objective explanations of colour.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Akins, K. and M. Hahn: 2000, ‘The Peculiarity of Colour’, in S. Davis (ed.), Colour Perception, Vol. IX, Vancouver Studies in Cognitive Science, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Allman, J. M.: 1999, Evolving Brains, Freeman, New York.
Anstis, S., B. Rogers, and J. Henry: 1978, ‘Interactions between Simultaneous Contrast and Coloured Afterimages’, Vision Research 18, 899–911.
Arend L. and A. Reeves: 1986, ‘Simultaneous Color Constancy’, Journal of the Optical Society of America A 3, 1743–1754.
Armstrong, D. M.: 1968, A Materialist Theory of Mind, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
Armstrong. D. M.: 1980, The Nature of Mind, University of Queensland Press, Brisbane.
Armstrong, D. M.: 1987, ‘Smart and the Secondary Qualities’, in P. Petitt, R. Sylvan, and J. Norman (eds), Metaphysics and Morality: Essays in Honour of J. J. C. Smart, Blackwell, Oxford, pp. 1–15.
Armstrong, D. M.: 1993, ‘Reply to Campbell’, in J. Bacon, K. Campbell, and L. Reinhardt (eds), Ontology, Causality and Mind, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 268–273.
Barlow, H. B. and P. Foldiak: 1989, ‘Adaptation and Decorrelation in the Cortex’, in R. M. Dubin, C. Miall, and G. J. Mitchison (eds), The Computing Neuron, Addison-Wesley, Workingham.
Benham, E. C.: 1894, ‘Notes’, Nature 51, 113–114.
Berlin, B. and P. Kay: 1969, Basic Color Terms: Their Universality and Evolution, University of California Press, Berkeley.
Boghossian, P. A. and J. D. Velleman: 1989, ‘Colour as a Secondary Quality’, Mind 98, 81–103.
Boynton, R. M.: 1979, Human Color Vision, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York.
Boynton, R. M.: 1997, ‘Insights Gained from Naming the OSA Colors’, in C. L. Hardin and L. Maffi (eds), Color Categories in Thought and Language, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 135–150.
Brackel, J. van: 1993, ‘The Plasticity of Categories: the Case of Colour’, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 44, 103–135.
Brackel, J. van and B. A. C. Saunders: 1997, ‘On the Existence of a Fixed Number of Unique Opponent Hues’, in C. Dickinson, I. Murray, and D. Carden (eds), John Dalton’s Colour Vision Legacy, Taylor Francis, London, pp. 393–402.
Brady, J. S.: 1954, ‘The Role of Frequency Selective Reverberatory Nets in Cerebral Function’, E. E. G. Clin. Neurophysiol. 6, 469–472.
Brainard, D. H. and B. A. Wandell: 1986, ‘Analysis of the Retinex Theory of Color Vision’, Journal of the Optical Society of America A 3, 1651–1661.
Byrne, A. and D. R. Hilbert: 1997a, Readings on Color, Volume 1: The Philosophy of Color, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Byrne, A. and D. R. Hilbert: 1997b, Readings on Colour, Volume 2: The Science of Color, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Campbell, K.: 1969, ‘Colours’, in R. Brown and C. D. Rollins (eds), Contemporary Philosophy in Australia, Allen and Unwin, London, pp. 132–157.
Campbell, K.: 1972, ‘Primary and Secondary Qualities’, Canadian Journal of Philosophy 11, 219–232.
Campbell, K.: 1993, ‘David Armstrong and Realism about Colour’, in J. Bacon, K. Campbell, and L. Reinhardt (eds), Ontology, Causality and Mind., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 249–268.
Charles-Dominique, P.: 1993, ‘Speciation and Coevolution: An Interpretation of Frugivory Phenomena’, Vegetatio 107/108, 75–84.
Clark, A.: 1996, ‘True Theories, False Colors’, Philosophy of Science (Proceedings) 63, S143–S150.
Day, R. H. and W. R. Webster: 1989, ‘Negative Afterimages and the McCollough Effect’, Perception and Psychophysics 46, 419–424.
Dedrick, D.: 1996, ‘Can Colors be Reduced to Anything?’, Philosophy of Science (Proceedings) 63, 134–142.
Derrington, A. M., J. Krauskopf, and P. Lennie: 1984, ‘Chromatic Mechanisms in Lateral Geniculate Nucleus of Macaque’, Journal of Physiology 357, 241–265.
DeValois, R. L. and K. K. DeValois: 1993, ‘A Multi-stage Color Model’, Vision Research 33, 1053–1065.
DeValois, R. L., I. Abramov, and G. H. Jacobs: 1966, ‘Analysis of Response Patterns of LGN Cells’, Journal of the Optical Society of America 56, 966–877.
D’Zmura, M.: 1991, ‘Color in Visual Search’, Vision Research 31, 951–966.
Endler, J. A.: 1993, ‘The Color of Light in Forests and Its Implications”, Ecological Monographs 63, 1–27.
Forsyth, D. A.: 1990, ‘Colour Constancy’, in A. Blake and T. Troscianko (eds), AI and the Eye, John Wiley and Sons, New York, pp. 201–228.
Gold, I.: 1999, ‘Dispositions and the Central Problem of Color’, Philosophical Studies 93, 21–44.
Gouras, P. and H. Eggers: 1983, ‘Responses of Primate Retinal Ganglion Cells to Moving Spectral Contrast’, Vision Research 23, 1175–1182.
Gouras P. and H. Eggers: 1984, ‘Hering’s Opponent Colour Channels do not Exist in Primate Retinogeniculate Pathway’, Ophthalamic Research 16, 31–35.
Guth, S. L.: 1991, ‘Model for Color Vision and Light Adaptation’, Journal of the Optical Society of America, A 8, 976–993.
Hall, R. J.: 1996, ‘The Evolution of Color Vision without Colors’, Philosophy of Science (Proceedings) 63, S125–S133.
Hardin, C. L.: 1988, Color for Philosophers, Hackett, Indianapolis.
Hardin, C. L.: 1991, ‘Reply to Teller’, Philosophical Psychology 4, 61–64.
Hardin, C. L.: 1992, ‘The Virtues of Illusion’, Philosophical Studies 68, 371–373
Helmholtz, H.: 1924, in J. P. C. Southall (ed.), Physiological Optics, 3 volumes, Optical Society of America, Rochester.
Helson, H. and V. B. Jeffers: 1940, ‘Fundamental Problems in Color Vision. II. Hue, Lightness, and Saturation of Selective Samples in Chromatic Illumination’, Journal of Experimental Psychology 26, 1–27.
Hering, E.: 1920/1964, Outlines of a Theory of the Light Sense, Translated by L. M. Hurvich and D. Jameson, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Hilbert, D. R.: 1987, Color and Color Perception: A Study in Anthropocentric Realism, CSLI, Stanford.
Hurlbert, A.: 1997, ‘Colour Vision’, Current Biology 7, 400–402.
Hurvich, L. M. and D. Jameson: 1957, ‘An Opponent Process Theory of Color Vision’, Psychological Review 64, 456–470.
Jackson, F. C.: 1996, ‘The Primary Quality View of Color’, in J. E. Tomberlin (ed.), Philosophical Perspectives, 10, Metaphysics, Blackwell, Cambridge, pp. 199–220.
Jackson, F. C. and R. Pargetter: 1987, ‘An Objectivists Guide to Subjectivism about Color’, Revue International de Philosophie 68, 221–263.
Jacobs, G. H., M. Neitz, J. F. Deegan, and J. Neitz: 1996, ‘Trichromatic Colour Vision in New World Monkeys’, Nature 382, 156–158.
Jameson, K. and R. G. D’Andrade: 1997, ‘It’s not Really Red, Green, Yellow, Blue: An Inquiry into Perceptual Color Space’, in C. L. Hardin and L. Maffi (eds), Color Categories in Thought and Language, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 295–319.
Johnston, M.: 1992, ‘How to Speak of the Colors’, Philosophical Studies 68, 221–263.
Kaiser, P. K. and R. M. Boynton: 1996, Human Color Vision, Optical Society of America, Washington.
Kauzmann, W.: 1957, Quantum Chemistry, Academic Press, New York.
Krauskopf, J.: 1997, ‘The Paucity of Evidence for Cardinal Mechanisms’, in C. Dickinson, I. Murray, and D. Carden (eds), John Dalton’s Colour Vision Legacy, Taylor Francis, London, pp. 431–440.
Krauskopf, J., D. R. Williams, and D. W. Heeley: 1982, ‘Cardinal Directions of Colour Space’, Vision Research 22, 1123–1131.
Krauskopf, J., Hai-Jung Wu, and B. Farell: 1997, ‘Coherence, Cardinal Directions and Higher-order Mechanisms’, Vision Research 36, 1235–1245.
Krauskopf, J., D. R. Williams, M. B. Mandler, and A. M. Brown: 1986, ‘Higher Order Color Mechanisms’, Vision Research 26, 23–32.
Land, E. H.: 1977, ‘The Retinex Theory of Color Vision’, Scientific American 237(6), 108–128.
Land, E. H.: 1983, ‘Recent Advances in Retinex Theory and Some Implications for Cortical Computations: Color Vision and the Natural Image’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 80, 5163–5169.
Land, E. H. and J. J. McCann: 1971, ‘Lightness and Retinex Theory’, Journal of the Optical Society of America 61, 1–11.
Lindburg, D. G.: 1977, ‘Feeding Behaviour and Diet of Rhesus Monkeys (Macaca Mulatta) in Siwalik Forest in North India’, in T. H. Clutton-Brock (ed.), Primate Ecology, Academic Press, London, pp. 223–250.
Livingstone M. S. and D. H. Hubel: 1984, ‘Anatomy and Physiology of a Color System in the Primate Visual Cortex’, The Journal of Neuroscience 4, 309–356.
Lund, D. H.: 1994, Perception, Mind and Personal Identity: a Critique of Materialism, University Press of America, Lanham.
Lycan, W. G.: 1987, Consciousness, Bradford Books/MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Lythgoe, J. N.: 1979, The Ecology of Vision, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
MacAdam, D. L.: 1985, Color Measurement: Theme and Variations, Springer-Verlag, New Yor k.
Maloney, L. T.: 1986, ‘Evaluation of Linear Models of Surface Reflectance with Small Numbers of Parameters’, Journal of the Optical Society of America A 3, 1673–1683.
Matthen, M.: 1988, ‘Biological Functions and Perceptual Content’, Journal of Philosophy 85, 5–27.
Matthen, M.: 1999, ‘The Disunity of Color’, The Philosophical Review 108, 47–84.
Maund, B.: 1994, Colours: Their Nature and Representation, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
McCann, J. J., S. P. McKee, and T. H. Taylor: 1976, ‘Quantitative Studies in Retinex Theory’, Vision Research 16, 445–458.
McGilvray, J. A.: 1983, ‘To Color’, Synthese 54, 37–70.
McGilvray, J. A.: 1994, ‘Constant Colors in the Head’, Synthese 100, 197–239.
McGilvray, J. A.: 1996, ‘Making Colored Objects’, in M. Marion and R. S. Cohen (eds), Quebec Studies in the Philosophy of Science II, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Netherlands, pp. 81–97.
Mollon, J. D.: 1989, ‘Tho’ She Kneel’d in that Place Where They Grew -’, Journal of Experimental Biology 146, 21–38.
Mollon, J. D.: 1991, ‘Uses and Evolutionary Origins of Primate Colour Vision’, in J. R. Cronly-Dillon and R. L. Gregory (eds), Evolution of the Eye and Visual System, Visi on and Visual Dysfunction, Vol. 2, MacMillan, London, pp. 306–319.
Mollon, J. D.: 1995, ‘Seeing Colour’, in T. Lamb and J. Bourriau (eds), Colour: Art and Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 127–150.
Mollon, J. D.: 1997, ‘”On the Basis of Velocity Cues Alone”: Some Perceptual Themes 1946-1996’, The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 50A, 859–878.
Mollon, J. D. and C. R. Cavonius: 1987, ‘The Chromatic Antagonisms of Opponent Process Theory Are Not the Same as Those Revealed in Studies of Detection and Discrimination’, in G. Verriest (ed.), Colour Vision Deficiencies, Martinus Nijhoff/Dr W Junk Publishers, Dordrecht, pp. 473–483.
Mollon, J. D. and G. Jordan: 1997, ‘On the Nature of Unique Hues’, in C. Dickinson, I. Murray, and D. Carden (eds), John Dalton’s Colour Vision Legacy, Taylor Francis, London, pp. 381–392.
Nassau, K.: 1980, ‘The Causes of Color’, Scientific American 243(4), 106–203.
Nassau, K.: 1983, The Physics and Chemistry of Color, John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Nathans, J., T. P. Piantanida, R. L. Eddy, T. B. Shows, and D. S. Hogness: 1986, ‘Molecular Genetics of Inherited Variation in Human Color Vision’, Science 232, 203–210.
Osorio, D. and T. R. J. Bossomaier: 1992, ‘Human Cone-pigment Spectral Sensitivities and the Reflectance of Natural Surfaces’, Biological Cybernetic 67, 217–222.
Osorio, D. and Vorobyev, M.: 1996, ‘Colour Vision as an Adaptation to Frugivory in Primates’, Proc. R. Soc. B 263, 593–599.
Saunders, B. A. C. and J. van Brackel: 1997, ‘Are There Nontrivial Constraints on Colour Categorization ?’, Behavioral and Brain Sciences 20, 167–228.
Shepard, R. N.: 1997, ‘The Perceptual Organization of Colors: An Adaptation to Regularities of the Terrestrial World?’, in A. Byrne and D.R. Hilbert (eds), Readings on Color, Volume 2: The Science of Color, The MIT Press, Cambridge MA.
Smart, J. J. C.: 1959, ‘Sensations and Brain Processes’, Philosophical Review LXVIII, 141-156. Reprinted in C. V. Borst (ed.), The Mind/Brain Identity Theory, MacMillan, London, 1970, pp. 52–66.
Smart, J. J. C.: 1975, ‘On Some Criticisms of a Physicalist Theory of Colors’, in Chung-Ying Cheng (ed.), Philosophical Aspects of the Mind-Body Problem, University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu, pp. 54–63.
Smart, J. J. C.: 1995, ‘“Looks Red” and Dangerous Talk’, Philosophy 70, 545–554.
Stout, G. F.: 1904, ‘Primary and Secondary Qualities’, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 4, 141–160.
Svaetichin, G. and E. F. MacNichol: 1958, ‘Retinal Mechanisms for Chromatic and Achromatic Vision’, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 74, 385–404.
Teller, D. Y.: 1991, ‘Simpler Arguments Might Work Better’, Philosophical Psychology 4, 51–60.
Thompson, E.: 1995, Colour Vision, Routledge, London.
Tolliver, J. T.: 1994, ‘Interior Colors’, Philosophical Topics 22, 411–441.
Valberg, A. and B. Lange-Malecki: 1990, ‘“Colour Constancy” in Mondrian Patterns: a Partial Cancellation of Physical Chromaticity Shifts by Simultaneous Contrast’, Visi on Research 30, 371–380.
Walraven, P. L.: 1962, On the Mechanisms of Colour Vision, Institute for Perception RVO-TNO, The Netherlands.
Watkins, M.: 1997, ‘Colours and Causes: A Reply to Jackson and Pargetter’, Dialogue 36, 281–285.
Webster, M. A.: 1996, ‘Human Colour Perception and its Adaptation’, Network: Computation in Neural Systems 7, 587–634.
Webster, M. A. and J. D. Mollon: 1991, ‘Changes in Colour Appearance Following Post-Receptoral Adaptation’, Nature 349, 235–238.
Webster, M. A. and J. D. Mollon: 1993, ‘Contrast Adaptation Dissociates Different Measures of Luminous Efficiency’, Journal of the Optical Society of America A 10, 1332–1340.
Webster, M. A. and J. D. Mollon: 1994, ‘The Influence of Contrast Adaptation on Color Appearance’, Vision Research 34, 1993–2020.
Webster, M. A. and J. D. Mollon: 1997, ‘Adaptation and the Color Statistics of Natural Images’, Vision Research 37, 3283–3298.
Westphal, J.: 1987, Colour: Some Philosophical Problems from Wittgenstein, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
Wright, W. D.: 1959, ‘Colour Vision: A Field of Unsolved Problems’, New Scientist 6, 447–449.
Yoshioka, T., Dow, B. M., and Vautin, R. G.: 1996a, ‘Neuronal Mechanisms of Color Categorization in Areas V1, V2 and V4 of Macaque Monkey Visual Cortex’, Behavioural Brain Research 76, 51–70.
Yoshioka T. and Dow, B. M.: 1996b, ‘Color, Orientation and Cytochrome Oxidase Reactivity in Areas V1, V2 and V4 of Macaque Monkey Visual Cortex’, Behavioural Brain Research 76, 71–88.
Young, R. A.: 1977, ‘Some Observations on Temporal Coding of Color Vision: Psycho-physical Results’, Vision Research 17, 957–965.
Young, R. A.: 1987, ‘Color Vision and the Retinex Theory’, Science 238, 1731–1732.
Zrenner, E.: 1985, ‘The Zero Signal Detector’, in T. Ottoson and S. Zeki (eds), Central and Peripheral Mechanisms of Colour Vision, MacMillan, London, pp. 165–182.
Zrenner, E., Abramov, I., Akita, M., Cowey, A., Livingstone, M., and Valberg, A.: 1990, ‘Color Perception: Retina to Cortex’, in L. Spillman and J. S. Werner (eds), Visual Perception: The Neurophysiological Foundations, Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 163–204.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Webster, W.R. Wavelength Theory of Colour Strikes Back: The Return of the Physical. Synthese 132, 303–334 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020345513372
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020345513372