Abstract
The mass/count distinction attracts a lot of attention among cognitive scientists, possibly because it involves in fundamental ways the relation between language (i.e. grammar), thought (i.e. extralinguistic conceptual systems) and reality (i.e. the physical world). In the present paper, I explore the view that the mass/count distinction is a matter of vagueness. While every noun/concept may in a sense be vague, mass nouns/concepts are vague in a way that systematically impairs their use in counting. This idea has never been systematically pursued, to the best of my knowledge. I make it precise relying on supervaluations (more specifically, ‘data semantics’) to model it. I identify a number of universals pertaining to how the mass/count contrast is encoded in the languages of the world, along with some of the major dimensions along which languages may vary on this score. I argue that the vagueness based model developed here provides a useful perspective on both. The outcome (besides shedding light on semantic variation) seems to suggest that vagueness is not just an interface phenomenon that arises in the interaction of Universal Grammar (UG) with the Conceptual/Intentional System (to adopt Chomsky’s terminology), but it is actually part of the architecture of UG.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barker C. (1992) Group terms in English: Representing groups as atoms. Journal of Semantics 9: 69–93
Barner D., Snedeker J. (2005) Quantity judgments and individuation: Evidence that mass nouns count. Cognition 97: 41–66
Borer H. (2005) Structuring sense. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Bunt H. (1979) Ensembles and the formal semantic properties of mass terms. In: Pelletier F. J. (eds) Mass terms: Some philosophical problems. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Carlson, G. (1997). Reference to kinds in English. Ph. D. Dissertation, University of Massachusetts at Amherst. Published in 1980 by Garland, NY.
Cheng L., Sybesma R. (1998) Yi-wang Tang, yi-ge Tang: Classifiers and massifiers. Tsing Hua Journal of Chinese Studies XXVIII(3): 385–412
Chierchia, G. (1984). Topics in the syntax and semantic of infinitives and gerunds. Ph. D. Dissertation, University of Massachusetts at Amherst. Published in 1989 by Garland, NY.
Chierchia G. (1998a) Plurality of mass nouns and the notion of ‘semantic parameter’. In: Rothstein S. (eds) Events and grammar. Kluwer, Dordrecth
Chierchia G. (1998b) Reference to kinds across languages. Natural Language Semantics 6: 339–405
Chierchia G. (2004) Scalar implicature polarity phenomena and the syntax/pragmatics interface. In: Belletti A. (eds) Structures and beyond. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Chierchia G. (2005) Definites, locality, and intentional identity. In: Carlson G., Pelletier J. (eds) Reference and quantification. CSLI, Stanford
Chierchia G., Turner R. (1988) Semantics and property theory. Linguistics and Philosophy 11: 261–302
Chierchia, G., Fox, D., & Spector, B. (2008). The grammatical theory of scalar implicatures. In C. Maierborn, K. von Heusinger, & P. Portner (Eds.), Semantics: An international handbook of natural language meaning. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter (forthcoming).
Dayal V. (2004) Number marking and (in)definiteness in kind terms. Linguistics and Philosophy 27(4): 393–450
Fine K. (1975) Truth, vagueness and logic. Synthese 30: 265–300
Fox C. (1998) Plurals and mass terms in property theory. In: Hamm F., Hinrichs E. (eds) Plurality and quantification. Kluwer, Dordrecth
Gajewski, J. (2002). L-analyticity and natural language. Manuscript, University of Connecticut at Storrs.
Gallin D. (1975) Intensional and higher order logic. North Holland, Amsterdam
Gillon B. (1992) Towards a common semantics for English count and mass nouns. Linguistics and Philosophy 15: 597–640
Gillon, C. (2009). Mass, count and plurality in Innu-aimun. Paper presented at SULA V, Harvard/MIT, May 2009.
Grimshaw J. (2000) Extended projection and locality. In: Coopmans P., Everaert M., Grimshaw J. (eds) Lexical specification and insertion. J. Benjamins, Amsterdam
Hauser, M., & Spaulding, B. (2006). Wild rhesus monkeys generate causal inferences about possible and impossible physical transformations in the absence of experience. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, 103, 18.
Heim, I. (1982). The semantics of definite and indefinite noun phrases. Ph. D. Dissertation, University of Massachusetts at Amherst. Published in 1989 by Garland, NY.
Higginbotham J. (1994) Mass and count quantifiers. Linguistics and Philosophy 17: 447–480
Horn L. (1989) A natural history of negation. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Huang, J. (2006). Analyticity, variation and change. In International conference of East Asian Linguistics, University of Toronto.
Ionin T., Matushansky O. (2006) The composition of complex cardinals. Journal of Semantics 23: 315–360
Kamp H. (1975) Two theories about adjectives. In: Keenan E. (eds) Formal semantics of natural language. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kennedy C. (2007) Vagueness and grammar: The semantics of relative and absolute gradable adjectives. Linguistics and Philosophy 30: 1–45
Kiparsky P. (1982) From cyclic phonolophy to lexical phonology. In: van der Hulst H., Smith N. (eds) The structure of phonological representation. Foris, Dordrecht
Klein E. (1980) A semantics for positive and comparative adjectives. Linguistics and Philosophy 4: 1–45
Kratzer A. (1989) An investigation into the lumps of thought. Linguistics and Philosophy 12: 607–653
Krifka, M. (2008). Masses and countables. Paper presented and the workshop “The Syntax and Semantics of Measurement”, University of Tromsø.
Kurafuji, T. (2003). Plural morphemes, definiteness and the notion of semantic parameter. In The proceedings of the third GLOW in Asia.
Landman F. (1989) Groups I. Linguistics and Philosophy 12: 559–605
Landman F. (1991) Structures for semantics. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Landman F. (2004) Indefinites and the type of sets. Blackwell, Oxford
Lasersohn P. (1999) Pragmatic halos. Language 75: 522–551
Levinson S. (2000) Presumptive meaning. MIT Press, Cambridge
Li Y.-H. A. (1999) Plurality in a classifier language. Journal of East Asian Language 8: 75–99
Link, G. (1983). The logical analysis of plural and mass terms: A lattice theoretic approach. In R. Bäuerle, C. Schwarze, & A. von Stechow (Eds.), Meaning, use and interpretation of language (pp. 302–323). Berlin: de Gruyer.
Lonning J.-T. (1987) Mass terms and quantifiers. Linguistics and Philosophy 10: 1–52
Longobardi G. (1994) Reference and proper names: A theory of N-movement in syntax and logical form. Linguistic Inquiry 25: 609–665
Mathieu, E. (2009). On the count/mass distinction in Ojibwe. Paper presented at the workshop on parts and quantities, University of British Columbia, November 2007.
McGee V., McLaughlin B. (1998) Vagueness by Timothy Williamson. Linguistics and Philosophy 21: 221–235
Moro A. (2008) The boundaries of Babel. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Pelletier J., Schubert L. (1989) Mass expressions. In: Gabbay D., Guenthner F. (eds) Handbook of philsophical logic. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Pinkal M. (1989) Imprecise concepts and quantification. In: Bartsch R., van Benthem J., Emde Boas P. (eds) Semantics and contextual expressions. Foris, Dordrecht
Quine W. (1960) Word and object. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Quine W. (1969) Ontological relativity and other essays. Columbia University Press, NY
Rothstein, S. (2008). Counting and the mass/count distinction, ms. Bar Ilan University, Tel Aviv.
Sauerland, U. (2003). A new semantics for number. In R. Young & Y. Zhou (Eds.), Proceedings of SALT 13. Ithaca, NY: CLC Publications, Cornell University
Schwarzschild R. (1996) Pluralities. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Schwarzschild, R. (2007). Mass nouns and stubbornly distributive predicates. Paper presented at the Harvard Colloquium Series, September 2007, STUBs/ Pluralities
Soja N., Carey S., Spelke E. (1991) Ontological categories guide young children’s inductions of word meanings: Object terms and substance terms. Cognition 38: 179–211
Spector B. (2007) Aspects of the pragmatics of plural morphology: On higher-order implicatures. In: Sauerland U., Stateva P. (eds) Presuppositions and implicatures in compositional semantics. Palgrave-Macmillan, Hampshire, UK
Steriade D. (2008) A pseudo-cyclic effect in romanian morphophonology. In: Bachrach A., Nevins A. (eds) Inflectional identity. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Tsoulas, G. (2006). Plurality of mass nouns and the grammar of number. Paper presented at the 29th glow meeting, Barcelona.
Van Fraassen B. (1971) Formal semantics and logic. McMillan, NY
Veltman, F. (1985). Logics for conditional. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Amsterdam.
Wilhelm A. (2008) Bare Nouns in Dëne Sułine. Natural Language Semantics 16: 39–68
Williamson T. (1994) Vagueness. Routledge, London
Zamparelli, R. (2008). Bare predicate nominals in romance languages. In H. Høeg Müller & A. Klinge (Eds.), Essays on nominal determination. John Benjamins.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chierchia, G. Mass nouns, vagueness and semantic variation. Synthese 174, 99–149 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-009-9686-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-009-9686-6