Abstract
Purpose
The development of spinal implants marks a watershed in the evolution of metastatic spine tumour surgery (MSTS), which has evolved from standalone decompressive laminectomy to instrumented stabilization and decompression with reconstruction when necessary. Fusion may not be feasible after MSTS due to poor quality of graft host bed along with adjunct chemotherapy and/or radiotherapy postoperatively. With an increase in the survival of patients with spinal tumours, there is a probability of an increase in the rate of implant failure. This review aims to help establish a clear understanding of implants/constructs used in MSTS and to highlight the fundamental biomechanics of implant/construct failures.
Methods
Published literature on implant failure after spine surgery and MSTS has been reviewed. The evolution of spinal implants and their role in MSTS has been briefly described. The review defines implant/construct failures using radiological parameters that are practical, feasible, and derived from historical descriptions. We have discussed common modes of implant/construct failure after MSTS to allow further understanding, interception, and prevention of catastrophic failure.
Results
Implant failure rates in MSTS are in the range of 2–8%. Variability in patterns of failure has been observed based on anatomical region and the type of constructs used. Patients with construct/implant failures may or may not be symptomatic and present either as early (< 3months) or late failures (> 3months). It has been noted that not all the implant failures after MSTS result in revisions.
Conclusion
Based on the observed radiological criteria and clinical presentations, we have proposed a clinico-radiological classification for implant/construct failure after MSTS.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Lee BH, Kim TH, Chong HS, Moon ES, Park JO, Kim HS, Kim SH, Lee HM, Cho YJ, Kim KN, Moon SH (2013) Prognostic factor analysis in patients with metastatic spine disease depending on surgery and conservative treatment: review of 577 cases. Ann Surg Oncol 20:40–46
Street J, Berven S, Fisher C, Ryken T (2009) Health related quality of life assessment in metastatic disease of the spine: a systematic review. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 34:S128–S134
Street J, Lenehan B, Berven S, Fisher C (2010) Introducing a new health-related quality of life outcome tool for metastatic disease of the spine: content validation using the international classification of functioning, disability, and health; on behalf of the Spine Oncology Study Group. Spine 35:1377–1386
Amankulor NM, Xu R, Iorgulescu JB, Chapman T, Reiner AS, Riedel E, Lis E, Yamada Y, Bilsky M, Laufer I (2014) The incidence and patterns of hardware failure after separation surgery in patients with spinal metastatic tumors. Spine J 14:1850–1859
Bellato RT, Teixeira WG, Torelli AG, Cristante AF, de Barros TE, de Camargo OP (2015) Late failure of posterior fixation without bone fusion for vertebral metastases. Acta Ortop Bras 23:303–306
Gokaslan ZL, Laufer I, Wolinsky JP (2013) Evolution of spinal instrumentation. World Neurosurg 80:243–244
Peek RD, Wiltse LL (1990) History of spinal fusion. In: Cotler JM, Cotler HB (eds) Spinal fusion: science and Technique, 1st edn. Springer, Verlag, New York, pp 3–8
Hibbs RA (1912) A further consideration of an operation for Pott’s disease of the spine: with report of cases from the service of the New York Orthopaedic Hospital. Ann Surg 55:682–688
Albee FH (2007) Transplantation of a portion of the tibia into the spine for Pott’s disease: a preliminary report 1911. Clin Orthop Relat Res 460:14–16
King D (1948) Internal fixation for lumbosacral fusion. J Bone Jt Surg Am 30A:560–565
Harrington PR (1962) Treatment of scoliosis. Correction and internal fixation by spine instrumentation. J Bone Jt Surg Am 44-A:591–610
Roy-Camille R, Roy-Camille M, Demeulenaere C (1970) Osteosynthesis of dorsal, lumbar, and lumbosacral spine with metallic plates screwed into vertebral pedicles and articular apophyses. Presse Med 78:1447–1448
Steffee AD, Biscup RS, Sitkowski DJ (1986) Segmental spine plates with pedicle screw fixation. A new internal fixation device for disorders of the lumbar and thoracolumbar spine. Clin Orthop Relat Res 203:45–53
Kabins MB, Weinstein JN (1991) The history of vertebral screw and pedicle screw fixation. Iowa Orthop J 11:127
Bakar D, Tanenbaum JE, Phan K, Alentado VJ, Steinmetz MP, Benzel EC, Mroz TE (2016) Decompression surgery for spinal metastases: a systematic review. Neurosurg Focus 41:E2
Kumar N, Malhotra R, Zaw AS, Maharajan K, Naresh N, Kumar A, Vallayappan B (2017) Evolution in treatment strategy for metastatic spine disease: presently evolving modalities. Eur J Surg Oncol 43(9):1784–1801
Kostuik JP, Errico TJ, Gleason TF, Errico CC (1988) Spinal stabilization of vertebral column tumors. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 13:250–256
Patchell RA, Tibbs PA, Regine WF, Payne R, Saris S, Kryscio RJ, Mohiuddin M, Young B (2005) Direct decompressive surgical resection in the treatment of spinal cord compression caused by metastatic cancer: a randomised trial. Lancet 366:643–648
Fourney DR, Abi-Said D, Lang FF, McCutcheon IE, Gokaslan ZL (2001) Use of pedicle screw fixation in the management of malignant spinal disease: experience in 100 consecutive procedures. J Neurosurg 94:25–37
Bilsky MH, Laufer I, Burch S (2009) Shifting paradigms in the treatment of metastatic spine disease. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 34:S101–S107
Wang JC, Boland P, Mitra N, Yamada Y, Lis E, Stubblefield M, Bilsky MH (2004) Single-stage posterolateral transpedicular approach for resection of epidural metastatic spine tumors involving the vertebral body with circumferential reconstruction: results in 140 patients. Invited submission from the joint section meeting on disorders of the spine and peripheral nerves, March 2004. J Neurosurg Spine 1:287–298
Tomita K, Kawahara N, Baba H, Tsuchiya H, Nagata S, Toribatake Y (1994) Total en bloc spondylectomy for solitary spinal metastases. Int Orthop 18:291–298
Fourney DR, Abi-Said D, Rhines LD, Walsh GL, Lang FF, McCutcheon IE, Gokaslan ZL (2001) Simultaneous anterior–posterior approach to the thoracic and lumbar spine for the radical resection of tumors followed by reconstruction and stabilization. J Neurosurg 94:232–244
Sundaresan N, Steinberger AA, Moore F, Sachdev VP, Krol G, Hough L, Kelliher K (1996) Indications and results of combined anterior–posterior approaches for spine tumor surgery. J Neurosurg 85:438–446
Li H, Gasbarrini A, Cappuccio M, Terzi S, Paderni S, Mirabile L, Boriani S (2009) Outcome of excisional surgeries for the patients with spinal metastases. Eur Spine J 18:1423–1430
Boriani S, Bandiera S, Donthineni R, Amendola L, Cappuccio M, De Iure F, Gasbarrini A (2010) Morbidity of en bloc resections in the spine. Eur Spine J 19:231–241
Cahill DW, Kumar R (1999) Palliative subtotal vertebrectomy with anterior and posterior reconstruction via a single posterior approach. J Neurosurg 90:42–47
Zuckerman SL, Laufer I, Sahgal A, Yamada YJ, Schmidt MH, Chou D, Shin JH, Kumar N, Sciubba DM (2016) When less is more: the indications for MIS techniques and separation surgery in metastatic spine disease. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 41(Suppl 20):S246–S253
Guzik G (2016) Quality of life of patients after surgical treatment of cervical spine metastases. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 17:315
Petteys RJ, Spitz SM, Goodwin CR, Abu-Bonsrah N, Bydon A, Witham TF, Wolinsky JP, Gokaslan ZL, Sciubba DM (2016) Factors associated with improved survival following surgery for renal cell carcinoma spinal metastases. Neurosurg Focus 41:E13
Okamoto T, Neo M, Fujibayashi S, Ito H, Takemoto M, Nakamura T (2012) Mechanical implant failure in posterior cervical spine fusion. Eur Spine J 21:328–334
Sanden B, Olerud C, Petren-Mallmin M, Johansson C, Larsson S (2004) The significance of radiolucent zones surrounding pedicle screws. Definition of screw loosening in spinal instrumentation. J Bone Jt Surg Br 86:457–461
Schatzker J, Horne JG, Sumner-Smith G (1975) The effect of movement on the holding power of screws in bone. Clin Orthop Relat Res 111:257–262
Aghayev E, Zullig N, Diel P, Dietrich D, Benneker LM (2014) Development and validation of a quantitative method to assess pedicle screw loosening in posterior spine instrumentation on plain radiographs. Eur Spine J 23:689–694
Mahar AT, Brown DS, Oka RS, Newton PO (2006) Biomechanics of cantilever “plow” during anterior thoracic scoliosis correction. Spine J 6:572–576
Schlenk RP, Stewart T, Benzel EC (2003) The biomechanics of iatrogenic spinal destabilization and implant failure. Neurosurg Focus 15:E2
Gatt CJ Jr, Hosea TM, Palumbo RC, Zawadsky JP (1997) Impact loading of the lumbar spine during football blocking. Am J Sports Med 25:317–321
Panjabi MM (1988) Biomechanical evaluation of spinal fixation devices: I. A conceptual framework. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 13:1129–1134
Kim T-K, Cho W, Youn SM, Chang U-K (2016) The effect of perioperative radiation therapy on spinal bone fusion following spine tumor surgery. J Korean Neurosurg Soc 59:597–603
Tortolani PJ, Park AE, Louis-Ugbo J, Attallah-Wasef ES, Kraiwattanapong C, Heller JG, Boden SD, Yoon ST (2004) The effects of doxorubicin (adriamycin) on spinal fusion: an experimental model of posterolateral lumbar spinal arthrodesis. Spine J 4:669–674
Mesfin A, Sciubba DM, Dea N, Nater A, Bird JE, Quraishi NA, Fisher CG, Shin JH, Fehlings MG, Kumar N, Clarke MJ (2016) Changing the adverse event profile in metastatic spine surgery: an evidence-based approach to target wound complications and instrumentation failure. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 41(Suppl 20):S262–S270
Oda K, Shibayama Y, Abe M, Onomura T (1998) Morphogenesis of vertebral deformities in involutional osteoporosis. Age-related, three-dimensional trabecular structure. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23:1050–1055 (discussion 1056)
Rohlmann A, Graichen F, Bergmann G (2000) Influence of load carrying on loads in internal spinal fixators. J Biomech 33:1099–1104
Rohlmann A, Graichen F, Weber U, Bergmann G (2000) 2000 Volvo Award winner in biomechanical studies: monitoring in vivo implant loads with a telemeterized internal spinal fixation device. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 25:2981–2986
Sasso RC, Renkens K, Hanson D, Reilly T, McGuire RA Jr, Best NM (2006) Unstable thoracolumbar burst fractures: anterior-only versus short-segment posterior fixation. J Spinal Disord Tech 19:242–248
Ponnusamy KE, Iyer S, Gupta G, Khanna AJ (2011) Instrumentation of the osteoporotic spine: biomechanical and clinical considerations. Spine J 11:54–63
Greenberg EJC, Chu FCH, Dwyer AJ, Ziminski EM, Dimich AB, Laughlin JS (1972) Effects of radiation therapy on bone lesions as measured by 47Ca and 85Sr local kinetics. J Nucl Med 13:747–751
Libshitz HI, Hortobagyi GN (1981) Radiographic evaluation of therapeutic response in bony metastases of breast cancer. Skelet Radiol 7:159–165
Kumar N, Malhotra R, Maharajan K, Zaw AS, Wu PH, Makandura MC, Po Liu GK, Thambiah J, Wong HK (2017) Metastatic spine tumor surgery: a comparative study of minimally invasive approach using percutaneous pedicle screws fixation versus open approach. Clin Spine Surg 30(8):E1015–1021
Cunha SSD, Sarmento VA, Ramalho LMP, Freitas ACd, Almeida Dd, Tavares ME, Souza JC, Veeck EB, Costa NPd (2007) Effects of radiotherapy on bone tissues. Radiol Bras 40:189–192
Siebler T, Shalet SM, Robson H (2002) Effects of chemotherapy on bone metabolism and skeletal growth. Horm Res 58(Suppl 1):80–85
Greep NC, Giuliano AE, Hansen NM, Taketani T, Wang HJ, Singer FR (2003) The effects of adjuvant chemotherapy on bone density in postmenopausal women with early breast cancer. Am J Med 114:653–659
Boden SD (1998) The biology of posterolateral lumbar spinal fusion. Orthop Clin N Am 29:603–619
Bouchard JA, Koka A, Bensusan JS, Stevenson S, Emery SE (1994) Effects of irradiation on posterior spinal fusions. A rabbit model. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 19:1836–1841
Pedreira R, Abu-Bonsrah N, Karim Ahmed A, De la Garza-Ramos R, Rory Goodwin C, Gokaslan ZL, Sacks J, Sciubba DM (2017) Hardware failure in patients with metastatic cancer to the spine. J Clin Neurosci 45:166–171
Harel R, Chao S, Krishnaney A, Emch T, Benzel EC, Angelov L (2010) Spine instrumentation failure after spine tumor resection and radiation: comparing conventional radiotherapy with stereotactic radiosurgery outcomes. World Neurosurg 74:517–522
Quraishi NA, Rajabian A, Spencer A, Arealis G, Mehdian H, Boszczyk BM, Edwards KL (2015) Reoperation rates in the surgical treatment of spinal metastases. Spine J 15:S37–S43
Krag MH (1991) Biomechanics of thoracolumbar spinal fixation: a review. Spine 16:S84–S99
Gercek E, Arlet V, Delisle J, Marchesi D (2003) Subsidence of stand-alone cervical cages in anterior interbody fusion: warning. Eur Spine J 12:513–516
de Ruiter GC, Lobatto DJ, Wolfs JF, Peul WC, Arts MP (2014) Reconstruction with expandable cages after single- and multilevel corpectomies for spinal metastases: a prospective case series of 60 patients. Spine J 14:2085–2093
Chiu YC, Yang SC, Kao YH, Tu YK (2015) Single posterior approach for circumferential decompression and anterior reconstruction using cervical trabecular metal mesh cage in patients with metastatic spinal tumour. World J Surg Oncol 13:256
Wilke HJ, Kemmerich V, Claes LE, Arand M (2001) Combined anteroposterior spinal fixation provides superior stabilisation to a single anterior or posterior procedure. J Bone Jt Surg Br 83:609–617
Placantonakis DG, Laufer I, Wang JC, Beria JS, Boland P, Bilsky M (2008) Posterior stabilization strategies following resection of cervicothoracic junction tumors: review of 90 consecutive cases. J Neurosurg Spine 9:111–119
Le H, Balabhadra R, Park J, Kim D (2003) Surgical treatment of tumors involving the cervicothoracic junction. Neurosurg Focus 15:1–7
Mazel C, Hoffmann E, Antonietti P, Grunenwald D, Henry M, Williams J (2004) Posterior cervicothoracic instrumentation in spine tumors. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 29:1246–1253
Mohi Eldin MM, Ali AM (2014) Lumbar transpedicular implant failure: a clinical and surgical challenge and its radiological assessment. Asian Spine J 8:281–297
Vrionis FD, Small J (2003) Surgical management of metastatic spinal neoplasms. Neurosurg Focus 15:E12
She C, Shi GL, Xu W, Zhou XZ, Li J, Tian Y, Li J, Li WH, Dong QR, Ren PG (2016) Effect of low-dose X-ray irradiation and Ti particles on the osseointegration of prosthetic. J Orthop Res 34:1688–1696
Shen FH, Marks I, Shaffrey C, Ouellet J, Arlet V (2008) The use of an expandable cage for corpectomy reconstruction of vertebral body tumors through a posterior extracavitary approach: a multicenter consecutive case series of prospectively followed patients. Spine J 8:329–339
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Financial disclosures
None.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kumar, N., Patel, R., Wadhwa, A.C. et al. Basic concepts in metal work failure after metastatic spine tumour surgery. Eur Spine J 27, 806–814 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00586-017-5405-z
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00586-017-5405-z