Abstract
Several choices are available for cervical interbody fusion after anterior cervical discectomy. A recent option is dense cancellous allograft (CS) which is characterized by an open-matrix structure that may promote vascularization and cellular penetration during early osseous integration. However, the biomechanical stability of CS should be comparable to that of the tricortical iliac autograft (AG) and fibular allograft (FA) to be an acceptable alternative to these materials. The purpose of this study was to compare the initial biomechanical stability of CS to that of AG and FA in a one-level anterior cervical discectomy and interbody fusion (ACDF) model. Twelve human cervical spines (C3–T1) were loaded in six modes of motion and evaluated under three conditions: (1) intact, (2) after ACDF using CS, AG, and FA in alternating sequences, and (3) after ACDF with anterior plating. Three reflective markers were placed on the adjacent vertebral bodies. Intervertebral motion was measured with a video-based motion-capture system (MacReflex, Qualisys, Sweden). Torques were applied to a maximum of 2.0 N m. The range-of-motion and neutral-zone values measured in each loading mode were compared. No graft material displayed significant differences in biomechanical stability in any of the tested loading modes, suggesting that the initial stability of CS is comparable to that of AG and FA. Anterior cervical plating significantly increased biomechanical stability in all modes.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- ACDF:
-
Anterior cervical discectomy and interbody fusion
- AG:
-
Tricortical iliac autograft
- AGP:
-
ACDF with AG followed by application of an anterior cervical plate
- CS:
-
Dense cancellous allograft cervical spacer
- CSP:
-
ACDF with CS followed by application of an anterior cervical plate
- FA:
-
Freeze-dried fibular allograft
- FAP:
-
ACDF with FA followed by application of an anterior cervical plate
- NZ:
-
Neutral zone
- ROM:
-
Range of motion
- SD:
-
Standard deviation
References
Alvarez JA, Hardy RW Jr (1999) Anterior cervical discectomy for one- and two-level cervical disc disease: the controversy surrounding the question of whether to fuse, plate, or both. Crit Rev Neurosurg 9:234–251
Balabhadra RSV, Kim DK, Zhang HY (2004) Anterior cervical fusion using dense cancellous allografts and dynamic plating. Neurosurgery 54:1405–1411
Bishop RC, Moore KA, Hadley MN (1996) Anterior cervical interbody fusion using autogeneic and allogeneic bone graft substrate: a prospective comparative analysis. J Neurosurg 85:206–210
Bohlman HH, Emery SE, Goodfellow DB, Jones PK (1993) Robinson anterior cervical discectomy and arthrodesis for cervical radiculopathy. Long-term follow-up of one hundred and twenty-two patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am 75:1298–1307
Brodke DS, Zdeblick TA (1992) Modified Smith–Robinson procedure for anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. Spine 17:S427–S430
Buttermann GR, Glazer PA, Bradford DS (1996) The use of bone allografts in the spine. Clin Orthop 324:75–85
Cauthen JC, Kinard RE, Vogler JB, Jackson DE, DePaz OB, Hunter OL, Wasserburger LB, Williams VM (1998) Outcome analysis of noninstrumented anterior cervical discectomy and interbody fusion in 348 patients. Spine 23:188–192
Cherry C (2002) Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion for cervical disc disease. Aorn J 76:998–1004, 1007, 1008; quiz 1009–1012
Connolly PJ, Esses SI, Kostuik JP (1996) Anterior cervical fusion: outcome analysis of patients fused with and without anterior cervical plates. J Spinal Disord 9:202–206
DePalma AF, Rothman RH, Lewinnek GE, Canale ST (1972) Anterior interbody fusion for severe cervical disc degeneration. Surg Gynecol Obstet 134:755–758
Emery SE, Bohlman HH, Bolesta MJ, Jones PK (1998) Anterior cervical decompression and arthrodesis for the treatment of cervical spondylotic myelopathy. Two to seventeen-year follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg Am 80:941–951
Geer CP, Papadopoulos SM (1999) The argument for single-level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion with anterior plate fixation. Clin Neurosurg 45:25–29; discussion 21
Goel VK, Clausen JD (1998) Prediction of load sharing among spinal components of a C5–C6 motion segment using the finite element approach. Spine 23:684–691
Heidecke V, Rainov NG, Burkert W (1998) Anterior cervical fusion with the Orion locking plate system. Spine 23:1796–1802; discussion 1803
Kaiser MG, Haid RW Jr, Subach BR, Barnes B, Rodts GE Jr (2002) Anterior cervical plating enhances arthrodesis after discectomy and fusion with cortical allograft. Neurosurgery 50:229–236; discussion 236–238
Kandziora F, Pflugmacher R, Schafer J, Born C, Duda G, Haas NP, Mittlmeier T (2001) Biomechanical comparison of cervical spine interbody fusion cages. Spine 26:1850–1857
Katsuura A, Hukuda S, Imanaka T, Miyamoto K, Kanemoto M (1996) Anterior cervical plate used in degenerative disease can maintain cervical lordosis. J Spinal Disord 9:470–476
Khan S, Sama A, Sandhu HS (2001) Bone graft substitutes in spine surgery. Curr Opin Orthpaedics 12:216–222
Maciejczak A, Ciach M, Radek M Jr, Radek A, Awrejcewicz J (2001) Immediate stiffness of the C5–C6 segment after discectomy with the Cloward technique: an in vitro biomechanical study on a human cadaveric model. Neurosurgery 49:1399–1408
Malloy KM, Hilibrand AS (2002) Autograft versus allograft in degenerative cervical disease. Clin Orthop 394:27–38
Martin GJ Jr, Haid RW Jr, MacMillan M, Rodts GE Jr, Berkman R (1999) Anterior cervical discectomy with freeze-dried fibula allograft. Overview of 317 cases and literature review. Spine 24:852–858; discussion 858–859
Mohr RA, Brodke DS (2005) Fixed versus dynamic cervical plates: how to choose the proper plate. Curr Opin Orthopaedics 16:194–199
Natarajan RN, Chen BH, An HS, Andersson GB (2000) Anterior cervical fusion: a finite element model study on motion segment stability including the effect of osteoporosis. Spine 25:955–961
Olsewski JM, Garvey TA, Schendel MJ (1994) Biomechanical analysis of facet and graft loading in a Smith–Robinson type cervical spine model. Spine 19:2540–2544
Pelker RR, Friedlaender GE, Markham TC (1983) Biomechanical properties of bone allografts. Clin Orthop 174:54–57
Pintar FA, Yoganandan N, Voo L (1998) Effect of age and loading rate on human cervical spine injury threshold. Spine 23:1957–1962
Portnoy HD (2001) Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. Surg Neurol 56:178–180
Rapoff AJ, O’Brien TJ, Ghanayem AJ, Heisey DM, Zdeblick TA (1999) Anterior cervical graft and plate load sharing. J Spinal Disord 12:45–49
Schnee CL, Freese A, Weil RJ, Marcotte PJ (1997) Analysis of harvest morbidity and radiographic outcome using autograft for anterior cervical fusion. Spine 22:2222–2227
Schulte K, Clark CR, Goel VK (1989) Kinematics of the cervical spine following discectomy and stabilization. Spine 14:1116–1121
Seiler JG III, Johnson J (2000) Iliac crest autogenous bone grafting:donor site complications. J South Orthop Assoc 9:91–97
Shapiro S (1996) Banked fibula and the locking anterior cervical plate in anterior cervical fusions following cervical discectomy. J Neurosurg 84:161–165
Shapiro S, Connolly P, Donnaldson J, Abel T (2001) Cadaveric fibula, locking plate, and allogeneic bone matrix for anterior cervical fusions after cervical discectomy for radiculopathy or myelopathy. J Neurosurg 95:43–50
Shimamoto N, Cunningham BW, Dmitriev AE, Minami A, McAfee PC (2001) Biomechanical evaluation of stand-alone interbody fusion cages in the cervical spine. Spine 26:E432–E436
Silber JS, Anderson DG, Daffner SD, Brislin BT, Leland JM, Hilibrand AS, Vaccaro AR, Albert TJ (2003) Donor site morbidity after anterior iliac crest bone harvest for single-level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. Spine 28:134–139
Smith MD, Cody DD (1993) Load-bearing capacity of corticocancellous bone grafts in the spine. J Bone Joint Surg Am 75:1206–1213
Troyanovich SJ, Stroink AR, Kattner KA, Dornan WA, Gubina I (2002) Does anterior plating maintain cervical lordosis versus conventional fusion techniques? A retrospective analysis of patients receiving single-level fusions. J Spinal Disord Tech 15:69–74
Vaccaro AR, Cirello J (2002) The use of allograft bone and cages in fractures of the cervical, thoracic, and lumbar spine. Clin Orthop 394:19–26
Wang JC, McDonough PW, Endow K, Kanim LE, Delamarter RB (1999) The effect of cervical plating on single-level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. J Spinal Disord 12:467–471
White A III, Panjabi MM (1990) Clinical biomechanics of the spine, 2nd edn. JB Lippincott-Raven, Philadelphia
Whitecloud TS III (1999) Modern alternatives and techniques for one-level discectomy and fusion. Clin Orthop 359:67–76
Wigfield CC, Nelson RJ (2001) Nonautologous interbody fusion materials in cervical spine surgery: how strong is the evidence to justify their use? Spine 26:687–694
Young WF, Rosenwasser RH (1993) An early comparative analysis of the use of fibular allograft versus autologous iliac crest graft for interbody fusion after anterior cervical discectomy. Spine 18:1123–1124
Zdeblick TA, Ducker TB (1991) The use of freeze-dried allograft bone for anterior cervical fusions. Spine 16:726–729
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
An erratum to this article can be found at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00586-006-0146-4
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ryu, S.I., Lim, J.T., Kim, SM. et al. Comparison of the biomechanical stability of dense cancellous allograft with tricortical iliac autograft and fibular allograft for cervical interbody fusion. Eur Spine J 15, 1339–1345 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00586-005-0047-y
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00586-005-0047-y