Abstract
In this article, we argue that feminist legal scholars should engage directly and explicitly with the question of evil. Part I summarises key facts surrounding the prosecution and life-long imprisonment of Myra Hindley, one of a tiny number of women involved in multiple killings of children in recent British history. Part II reviews a range of commentaries on Hindley, noting in particular the repeated use of two narratives: the first of these insists that Hindley is an icon of female evil; the second, less popular one, seeks to position her as a victim. In Part III, the article broadens out and we explain why we think feminist legal scholars should look at the question of evil. In large part, the emphasis is on anticipating the range of possible objections to this argument, and on trying to answer these objections by showing how a focus on evil might benefit feminist legal thinking – specifically in relation to the categories of perpetrator and victim and, more generally, in relation to laws motivated by a desire to secure women’s human rights.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arendt H., (1994). Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil. Penguin, Harmondsworth
Ballinger A., (2000). Dead Woman Walking: Executed Women in England and Wales 1900–1955. Ashgate, Aldershot
Bar On B.-A., (2003). “Terrorism, Evil, and Everyday Depravity”. Hypatia 18:157–163
Bell C., Fox M., (1996). “Telling Stories of Women Who Kill”. Social & Legal Studies 5:471–494
Bell V., (2005). “On the Critique of Secular Ethics: An Essay with Flannery O’Connor and Hannah Arendt”. Theory, Culture & Society 22/2:1–27
Benhabib S., (1992). Situating the Self: Gender, Community and Postmodernism in Contemporary Ethics. Polity, Cambridge
Bernstein R., (2005). The Abuse of Evil: The Corruption of Politics and Religion Since 9/11. Blackwell, New York
Birch H., (1993). “If Looks Could Kill: Myra Hindley and the Iconography of Evil”. In: Birch H., (eds) Moving Targets: Women, Murder and Representation. Virago, London, pp. 32–61
Bottomley, A., (2004) “Shock to Thought: An Encounter (of a Third Kind) with Legal Feminism”, Feminist Legal Studies 12/1:29–65
Butler J., (1993). Bodies That Matter: On the Discourses Limits of Sex. Routledge, London
Butler J., (2004). Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence. Verso, London
Cameron D., Fraser E., (1987). The Lust To Kill. Polity, Cambridge
Campbell, B., “Look Beyond that Menacing Stare”, Independent on Sunday (17 November 2002).
Card C., (2002). The Atrocity Paradigm: A Theory of Evil. OUP, New York
Charlesworth H., Chinkin C., (2000). The Boundaries of International Law: A Feminist Analysis. Manchester UP, Manchester
Cohen S., (2001). States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and Suffering. Polity, Cambridge
Collier R., (1997). “After Dunblane: Crime, Corporeality, and the (Hetero-)Sexing of the Bodies of Men”. Journal of Law & Society 24:177–198
Collier R., (1998). Masculinities, Crime and Criminology. Sage, London
Connolly W., (2000). “Refashioning the Secular”. In:Butler J., Guillory J., Thomas K., (eds) What’s Left of Theory?. Routledge, New York, pp. 157–191
Douglas M., (1966). Purity and Danger: An Analysis of Conceptions of Pollution and Taboo. Routledge, London
Fraser D., (2005). Law after Auschwitz: Towards a Jurisprudence of the Holocaust. Carolina Academic Press, Durham, NC
Frum D., Perle R., (2003). An End to Evil: How to Win the War on Terror. Random House, New York
Gurnham D., (2003). “The Moral Narrative of Criminal Responsibility and the Principled Justification of Tariffs for Murder: Myra Hindley and Thompson and Venables”. Legal Studies 23:605–623
Halley J., (2004). “Take a Break from Feminism?”. In: Knop K., (eds) Gender and Human Rights. OUP, Oxford, pp. 57–82
Hawkins, C., “The Monster Body of Myra Hindley”, Scan Journal of Media Arts Culture 1/3 (November 2004). [http://scan.net.au/]
Hudson B., (2003). Justice in the Risk Society: Challenging and Reaffirming Justice in Late Modernity. Sage, London
Jamieson R., (1999). “Genocide and the Social Production of Immorality”. Theoretical Criminology 3:131–146
Jewkes Y., (2004). Media & Crime. Sage, London
Johnson P.H., (1967). On Iniquity: Some Personal Reflections Arising Out of the Moors Murders. Macmillan, London
Kapur R., (2002). “The Tragedy of Victimization Rhetoric: Resurrecting the ‘Native’ Subject in International/Post-colonial Feminist Legal Rhetoric”. Harvard Human Rights Law Journal 15:1–38
Kennedy D., (2004). The Dark Sides of Virtue: Reassessing International Humanitarianism. Princeton UP, Princeton
Kennedy H., (1992). Eve Was Framed: Women and British Justice. Chatto & Windus, London
Kirsta A., (1994). Deadlier Than The Male. Harper Collins, London
Levi P., (1989). The Drowned and the Saved. Vintage, New York
McNay L., (2000). Gender and Agency: Reconfiguring the Subject in Feminist and Social Theory. Polity, Cambridge
McNay L., (2003). “Having it Both Ways: The Incompatibility of Narrative Identity and Communicative Ethics in Feminist Thought”. Theory, Culture & Society 20/6:1–20
Masters, B., “The Other Side of Evil”, Independent on Sunday (17 November 2002).
Mendieta, E., Review of ed. M.P. Lara, Rethinking Evil: Contemporary Perspectives, Hypatia 18/2 (2003), 208–213.
Millbank J., (1996). “From Butch to Butcher’s Knife: Film, Crime and Lesbian Sexuality”. Sydney Law Review 18:451–473
Millbank J., (2004). “It’s About This: Lesbians, Prison, Desire”. Social & Legal Studies 13:155–190
Morrissey B., (2002). “Crises of Representation, or Why Don’t Feminists Talk About Myra?”. Australian Feminist Law Journal 16:109–131
Morrissey B., (2003). When Women Kill: Questions of Agency and Subjectivity. Routledge, London
Neiman S., (2001). “What’s the Problem of Evil?”. In: Lara M.P., (eds) Rethinking Evil: Contemporary Perspectives. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp. 27–45
Neiman S., (2002). Evil in Modern Thought: An Alternative History of Philosophy. Princeton UP, Princeton
Orford A., (2003). Reading Humanitarian Intervention: Human Rights and the Use of Force in International Law. CUP, Cambridge
Padfield, N., “Tariffs in Murder Cases”, Criminal Law Review (2002), 192–204.
Razack S.H., (2004). Dark Threats and White Knights: The Somalia Affair, Peacekeeping and the New Imperialism. Toronto UP, Toronto
Ritchie J., (1988). Myra Hindley: Inside the Mind of a Murderess. Angus & Robertson, London
San Roque M., (1999). “Popular Trials/Criminal Fictions/Celebrity Feminism and the Bernardo/Homolka Case”. Australian Feminist Law Journal 13:38–65
Schone J., (2000). “The Hardest Case of All: Myra Hindley, Life Sentences, and the Rule of Law”. International Journal of the Sociology of Law 28:273–289
Schott, R.M., ed. Special Issue on “Feminist Philosophy and the Problem of Evil”, Hypatia 18/1 (2003a).
Schott, R.M., ed. “Feminist Philosophy and the Problem of Evil, Part II”, Hypatia 18/2 (2003b), 152–226.
Smart C., (1999). “A History of Ambivalence and Conflict in the Discursive Construction of the ‘Child Victim’ of Sexual Abuse”. Social & Legal Studies 8:391–409
Stanford, P., “Myra Hindley”, The Guardian (16 November 2002).
Storrs E., (2004). “‘Our Scapegoat’: An Exploration of Media Representations of Myra Hindley and Rosemary West”. Theology & Sexuality 11:9–28
Symposium, “Claudia Card’s Atrocity Paradigm”, Hypatia 19 (2004), 184–220.
Trunk I., (1996). Judenrat: The Jewish Councils in Eastern Europe under Nazi Occupation. Nebraska UP, Lincoln
Winter J., (2002). “The Truth Will Out? The Role of Judicial Advocacy and Gender in Verdict Construction”. Social & Legal Studies 11:343–367
Wykes M., (1998). “A Family Affair: Sex, the Press and the Wests”. In: Carter C., Branston G., Allan S., (eds) News, Gender and Power. Routledge, London, pp. 233–247
Young A., (1996). Imagining Crime: Textual Outlaws and Criminal Conversations. Sage, London
Young I.M., (2003). “The Logic of Masculinist Protection: Reflections on the Current Security State”. Signs 29:1–25
Zizek, S., “Against the Double Blackmail”, The Nation (21 May 1999).
Acknowledgments
Our thanks to David Fraser and the anonymous FLS reviewers for their comments on an earlier version of this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Murphy, T., Whitty, N. The Question of Evil and Feminist Legal Scholarship. Feminist Legal Stud 14, 1–26 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10691-006-9012-3
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10691-006-9012-3