Date: 05 Nov 2013

The Democratic Control of the Scientific Control of Politics

Download Book (3,844 KB) As a courtesy to our readers the eBook is provided DRM-free. However, please note that Springer uses effective methods and state-of-the art technology to detect, stop, and prosecute illegal sharing to safeguard our authors’ interests.
Download Chapter (187 KB)

Abstract

I discuss two popular but apparently contradictory theses:

  1. The democratic control of science – the aims and activities of science should be subject to public scrutiny via democratic processes of representation and participation.

  2. The scientific control of policy, i.e. technocracy – political processes should be problem-solving pursuits determined by the methods and results of science and technology.

Many arguments can be given for (T1), both epistemic and moral/political; I will focus on an argument based on the role of non-epistemic values in policy-relevant science. I will argue that we must accept (T2) as a result of an appraisal of the nature of contemporary political problems. Technocratic systems, however, are subject to serious moral and political objections; these difficulties are sufficiently mitigated by (T1). I will set out a framework in which (T1) and (T2) can be consistently and compellingly combined.