Abstract
Environmental voluntary agreements with industries are becoming a popular alternative to traditional regulation. One reason may be that such agreements increase implementation cost efficiency. On the other hand, models of the political economy of environmental voluntary agreements point out that efficiency reducing agreements are also possible under certain conditions.
In this paper we interpret empirical evidence from case studies of environmental voluntary agreements using one such policy formulation and implementation model. When our sample is interpreted in this light the data suggests that environmental voluntary agreements may often be chosen in order to shift the responsibility for implementation to industrial organizations that are less sensitive to criticism from powerful environmental interest groups. When this explanation of an environmental voluntary agreement applies, the model predicts that the agreement will be less cost effective and achieve lower environmental performance than the traditional regulatory alternative which would otherwise have been adopted.
Although our findings are not conclusive nor necessarily representative they do suggest the worrying possibility that many of the environmental voluntary agreements being established today achieve lower environmental performance less cost effectively than the most likely traditional regulatory alternative.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
9. References
Chidiak, M., M. Glachant and L.G. Hansen, (1999), VAIE project task A final report-Theoretical Perspectives on the Efficiency of Voluntary Approaches to Promote Energy Efficiency, CERNA, Paris.
Glachant, M., (1994), The setting of Voluntary Agreements Between Industry and Government: Bargaining and Efficiency, Business Strategy and The Environment 3(2), 43–49.
Hansen, L.G. (1999) Environmental Regulation through Voluntary Agreements, in Voluntary Approaches in Environmental Policy, eds: C. Carraro and F. Leveque, Kluwer academic publishers, Dordrecht.
IEA, (1995), Survey on Voluntary Agreements: Status, Interim Report and Next Steps, IEA note.
11. Case Study References
Aggeri, F. & A. Hatchuel (1995), A Dynamic Model of Environmental Policies. The case of innovation oriented voluntary agreements, Nota di Lavoro 24.97, FEEM, February 1997.
Börkey, P. & M. Glachant (1997)’ Les engagements volontaires de l'industrie dans le domaine de l'environnement: nature et diversité, final report to the Ministry for the Environment Ademe (French Environment Agency), CERNA.
Croci E. & G. Pesaro (1997)’ Voluntary agreements in Italy: a new approach in environmental policy. in: ENER Bullettin, n. 20.97.
Croci E. & G. Pesaro (1997a), Gli accordi volontari in campo ambientale: evoluzione del quadro di riferimento' in: Economia delle Fonti di Energia e dell, Ambiente, n.3/97 [Environmental voluntary agreements: evolution of the reference framework].
Environmental Sociology and Social Methodology Group, Wageningen University (1998) Joint Environmental policy-making, Final Report, Wageningen, 1998.
Gebers, G. Biekart J-W.; Bizer, K.; Ingram, V. Jülich R., (1998), New Instruments for Sustainability — The Role of Environmental Agreements, Final Report and Annex Case Studies, Darmstadt.
Glachant, M. & T. Whiston (1997): Voluntary Agreements between Industry and Government — the case of Recycling Regulations' in: Environmental Policy in Europe: Industry, Competition and the Policy Process, edited by F. Lévêque, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK.
Glachant, M. (1995), DSD contre Eco-Emballages: Analyse comparée de l'efficacité des consortia de recyclage allemands, français et italiens, study for ADEME, CERNA.
Ingram, V. (1998), The Long Term Energy Efficiency Agreement with the Fine Ceramic Industry, (The Netherlands), in Öko Institut (1998) — Annex Case Studies, Darmstadt.
Ingram, V. (1998), The SUBAT Agreement (The Netherlands), in Öko Institut (1998) — Annex Case Studies, Darmstadt.
Jülich, R. (1998), The EDTA Agreement (Germany), in Öko-Institut (1998) — Annex Case Studies, Darmstadt.
Jülich, R. (1998), The Battery Agreement (Germany), in Öko-Institut (1998) — Annex Case Studies, Darmstadt.
Krarup, S., M. Togeby and K. Johannsen (1997), De første aftaler om energieffektivisering — Erfaringer fra 30 aftaler indgået i 1996, AKF. Working paper.
Misonne, D. (1998): The Agreement between the Walloon Region and the Cement Industry (Belgium), in Öko-Institut (1998) — Annex Case Studies, Darmstadt.
Misonne, D. (1998), The River Contract of the Upper-Meuse (Belgium), in Öko-Institut (1998) — Annex Case Studies, Darmstadt.
Öko Institut (1998), New Instruments for Sustainability, edited by B. Gebers, Final Report, Darmstadt 1998.
Quirion, P. (1994), La gestion des déchets d'emballages ménagers en France et en Allemagne: élements d'evaluation économique, DEA thesis, Université de Paris 1 Pathéon-Sorbonne.
Rennings, K., K.L. Brockmann & H. Bergmann (1997),Voluntary Agreements in Environmental Protection — Experiences in Germany and Future Perspectives, published as ZEW Discussion paper.
Rietbergen M., Farla J., Blok K. (1998), Quantitative Evaluation of Voluntary Agreements on Energy Efficiency, paper for the CAVA workshop in Ghent on November 26–27, 1998, 15 p.
Seyad, A., S. Baeke & M. De Clercq (1998), Success determining factors for negotiated agreements: A Comparative Case Study of the Belgian Electricity Supply Industry and the Packaging Sector, to be published in ”Co-operative Environmental Governance — Public-Private Agreements as a Policy Strategy”, edited by P. Glasbergen, Utrecht University.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2005 Springer
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Hansen, L. (2005). Aspects of the Political Economy of Environmental Voluntary Agreements. In: Croci, E. (eds) The Handbook of Environmental Voluntary Agreements. Environment & Policy, vol 43. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/1-4020-3356-7_4
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/1-4020-3356-7_4
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-1-4020-3355-1
Online ISBN: 978-1-4020-3356-8
eBook Packages: Earth and Environmental ScienceEarth and Environmental Science (R0)