User Modeling, Adaptation, and Personalization

Volume 8538 of the series Lecture Notes in Computer Science pp 25-36

The Magic Barrier of Recommender Systems – No Magic, Just Ratings

  • Alejandro BellogínAffiliated withCiudad Universitaria de Cantoblanco, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid
  • , Alan SaidAffiliated withDelft University of Technology
  • , Arjen P. de VriesAffiliated withCentrum Wiskunde & Informatica

* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.

Get Access


Recommender Systems need to deal with different types of users who represent their preferences in various ways. This difference in user behaviour has a deep impact on the final performance of the recommender system, where some users may receive either better or worse recommendations depending, mostly, on the quantity and the quality of the information the system knows about the user. Specifically, the inconsistencies of the user impose a lower bound on the error the system may achieve when predicting ratings for that particular user.

In this work, we analyse how the consistency of user ratings (coherence) may predict the performance of recommendation methods. More specifically, our results show that our definition of coherence is correlated with the so-called magic barrier of recommender systems, and thus, it could be used to discriminate between easy users (those with a low magic barrier) and difficult ones (those with a high magic barrier). We report experiments where the rating prediction error for the more coherent users is lower than that of the less coherent ones. We further validate these results by using a public dataset, where the magic barrier is not available, in which we obtain similar performance improvements.