Summary
Formularies, in one form or another, have been in existence for nearly 100 years. Beginning simply as a list of available agents, the formulary has evolved into a complex system which acts as a guide to prescribing practices. As the importance of the formulary has increased, so has the need for formulary managers to make an appropriate decision about each drug’s formulary status. Several systematic approaches to drug evaluations have been developed to aid in the decision process. However, while some reviews of drug utilisation contain fairly rigorous analyses of their clinical efficacy, very few include an economic evaluation that goes beyond the cost of drug acquisition, preparation, distribution and administration. This is surprising, since formulary managers rank economic data second only to clinical data when making formulary decisions. In the past this apparent oversight has been due, in part, to the absence of a sophisticated model which can both approximate a drug’s true economic impact and express cost and quality in similar terms.
The explosion of new and very expensive biotechnology drugs into the market has the potential to improve patient care significantly. Such drugs also have the potential to increase institutional pharmacy budgets significantly; with some analysts predicting a spending of $US60 million yearly for these drugs by the year 2000, critical evaluation will be mandatory.
Fortunately, advances in the relatively new science of pharmacoeconomics have made it possible to conduct appropriate estimates of the true economic impact of new drug therapies. Pharmacoeconomic studies can be very useful in evaluating drugs for formulary inclusion and in assessing the effects of formulary changes on institutional budgets. Cost-effectiveness and cost-benefit analyses, utilising decision analysis models and/or data gathered from clinical studies, are used most frequently. Relatively simple models can be used to evaluate drugs within the same class if sufficient published data on their clinical efficacy and safety are available. More complex analyses are necessary when comparing dissimilar agents or when comparing agents with non-drug therapy. Pharmacoeconomic studies have frequently been used to demonstrate that very substantial direct costs of drug therapy are often offset by equal or greater reductions in other institutional direct and indirect patient care costs. Pharmacoeconomic studies have also been used to calculate the relative cost-effectiveness of drug therapies for different disease states, although such evaluations are more useful to governmental and regulatory agencies than to individual institutions.
Several potential limitations to the use of data from pharmacoeconomic studies exist. Careful evaluation of study design from both an economic and clinical viewpoint is necessary. In addition, the applicability of results obtained in other clinical settings must be evaluated carefully. Joint ventures between pharmacoeconomists and clinicians would be most helpful in ensuring well designed studies.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anadan JV. Reducing the number of formulary theophylline preparations. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 38: 511–513, 1981
Anderson C, Schroeder C, Schmidt D, Wilkins N. Utilization of an analytical rating tool (A.R.T.) to assist in H2 antagonist. Abstract. ASHP Midyear Clinical Meeting 24: HMO–10, 1989
Archambault GF. Revised (1969) JCAH standards for pharmaceutical services compared with medicare standards of 1967. Part 2. Hospital Formulary Management 5: 13–15, 1970
Bakke OM. How many drugs do we need? World Health Forum 7: 252–255, 1986
Ballesteros MA, Hogan DL, Koss MA, Isenberg JI. Bolus or intravenous infusion of ranitidine: effects on gastric pH and acid secretion: a comparison of relative efficacy and cost. Annals of Internal Medicine 112: 334–339, 1990
Barriere SL. Controversies in antimicrobial therapy: formulary decisions on third. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 43: 625–629, 1986
Callahan CW Jr. Cost-effectiveness of antibiotic therapy for otitis media in a military pediatric clinic. Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal 7: 622–625, 1988
Calvo MV, Fruns I, Dominguez Gil A. Decision analysis applied to selection of histamine H2 receptor antagonists. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 47: 2002–2006, 1990
Canafax DM, Gruber SA, Chan GL, Miles CJ, Matas AJ, et al. The pharmacoeconomics of renal transplantation: increased drug costs with decreased hospitalization costs. Pharmacotherapy 10: 205–210, 1990
Cano SB, Fujita NK. Formulary evaluation of third-generation cephalosporins using decision analysis. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 45: 566–569, 1988
Castellano AR, Nettleman MD. Cost and benefit of secondary prophylaxis for Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia. Journal of the American Medical Association 266: 820–824, 1991
Chase K. Total formulary review–the easy way. Hospital Pharmacy 19: 159–162, 1984
Chow MS. Focus on thrombolytic therapy: update on formulary considerations. Hospital Formulary 25: 161–162, 171–172, 174–175, 1990
Coppola P. Reducing costs with formulary limitation of H2-receptor antagonists in a community hospital. Hospital Pharmacy 26: 126–129, 1991
Dacey LJ, Dow RW, McDaniel MD, Walsh DB, Zwolak RM, Cronenwett JL. Cost-effectiveness of intraarterial thrombolytic therapy. Archives of Surgery 123: 1218–1223, 1988
Dao TD. Cost-effectiveness of drug therapy: the basic ingredients. Hospital Therapy 1: 39–45, 1990a
Dao TD. Cost-effectiveness: the current status. Hospital Therapy 3: 339–349, 1990b
Dao TD. Cost-effectiveness of drug therpay: balancing price and value: a public policy prespective. Hospital Therapy 11: 1391–1396, 1990c
Davey PG, Duncan ID, Edward D, Scott AC. Cost-benefit analysis of cephradine and mezlocillin prophylaxis for abdominal and vaginal hysterectomy. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 95: 1170–1177, 1988
DeLaet L, Iteen C. DUE as a means to evaluate the impact of formulary choices in a staff model. Abstract. ASHP Annual Meeting 47: P–163D, 1990
Di Pietro C. Financial evaluation of cephalosporin formulary management. Abstract. ASHP Annual Meeting 46: P–67D, 1989
Edelson JT, Weinstein MD, Tosteson AN, Williams, L, Lee TH, Goldman L. Long-term cost-effectiveness of various initial monotherapies for mild to moderate hypertension. Journal of the American Medical Association 263: 407–413, 1990
Ford LC. Cost of antibiotic prophylaxis in cesarean section. Drug Intelligence and Clinical Pharmacy 20: 592–593, 1986
Ford LC, Hammil HA, Lebherz TB. Cost-effective use of antibiotic prophylaxis for cesarean section. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 157: 506–510, 1987
Foster GE, Bourke JB, Bolwell J, Dorien J, Balfour TW, et al. Clinical and economic consequences of wound sepsis after appendectomy and their modification by metronidazole or povidone iodine. Lancet 1: 769–771, 1981
Foulke GE, Siepler J. Antiulcer therapy: an exercise in formulary management. Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology 12 (Suppl. 2): S64–S68, 1990
Freedberg KA, Tosteson AN, Cohen CJ, Cotton DJ. Primary prophylaxis for Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia in HIV-infected people with CD4 counts below 200/mm3: a cost-effective analysis. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 4: 521–531, 1991
Freund DA, Dittus RS. Principles of pharmacoeconomic analysis of drug therapy. PharmacoEconomics 1: 20–31, 1992
Fuhs DW, Bertil KJ. Comparison of antimicrobial susceptibilities and patient-specific information to aid formulary decisions. Abstract. ASHP Midyear Clinical Meeting 24: P–102E, 1989
Gabrilove JL, Jakubowski A, Scher H, Sternberg C, Wong G, et al. Effect of granulocyte colony-stimulating factor on neutropenia and associated morbidity due to chemotherapy for transitional-cell carcinoma of the urothelium. New England Journal of Medicine 318: 1414–1422, 1988
Garcia de Ancos JL, Roberts JA, Dusheiko GM. An economic evaluation of the costs of alpha-interferon treatment of chronic active hepatitis due to hepatitis B or C virus. Journal Hepatology 11 (Suppl. 1): S11–18, 1990
Geweke J, Weisbrod BA. Clinical evaluation versus economic evaluation: the case of a new drug. Medical Care 20: 821–830, 1982
Goodwin PJ, Feld R, Evans WK, Pater J. Cost-effectiveness of cancer chemotherapy: an economic evaluation of a randomized trial in small-cell lung cancer. Journal of Clinical Oncology 6: 1537–1547, 1988
Granor RA, Young JR, Risius B, Ruschhaupt WF. Comparison of cost effectiveness of streptokinase and urokinase in the treatment of deep vein thrombosis. Annals of Vascular Surgery 1: 524–528, 1987
Guharoy S, Barajas M. Automatic substitution: cefotetan: a cost-effective replacement for cefoxitin. Abstract. ASHP Annual Meeting 46: P–87D, 1989
Harper JM. Conversion to ceftazidime from cefoperazone. Abstract. ASHP Annual Meeting 47: P–118D, 1990
Hay JW, Robin ED. Cost-effectiveness of alpha-1 antitrypsin replacement therapy in treatment of congenital chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. American Journal of Public Health 81: 427–433, 1991
Herve C, Castiel D, Gaillard M, Bolsvert R, Leroux V. Cost-benefit analysis of thrombolytic therapy. European Heart Journal 11: 1006–1010, 1990
Hillner BE, Smith TJ. Efficacy and cost-effectiveness of adjuvant chemotherapy in women with node-negative breast cancer: a decision-analysis model. New England Journal of Medicine 324: 160–168, 1991
Hillson SD, Rich EC. Two strategies for prophylaxis of fatal postoperative pulmonary embolism: cost-effective analysis. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 6: 470–479, 1990
Hoffmann RP. Perspectives on the hospital formulary. Hospital Pharmacy 19: 359–362, 1984
Holbein ME, Crane VS. Cephalosporin confusion-one simple solution? American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 48: 236, 1990
Hollenberg JP, Subak LL, Ferry JJ Jr, Bussel JB. Cost-effectiveness of splenectomy versus intravenous gamma globulin in treatment of chronic immune thrombocytopenic purpura in childhood. Journal of Pediatrics 112: 530–539, 1988
Huse DM, Oster G. The cost-efectiveness of drug therapy: application of the concept, part 3. Hospital Therapy 9: 1165–1172, 1990
Jaakkimainen L, Goodwin PJ, Pater J, Warde P, Murray N, Rap E. Counting the costs of chemotherapy in a national cancer institute of canada randomized trial in nonsmall-cell lung cancer. Journal of Clinical Oncology 8: 1301–1309, 1990
Jaeschke R, Guyatt GH, Cook D. Quality of life instruments in the evaluation of new drugs. PharmacoEconomics 1: 84–94, 1992
Jensen DM. Economic and health aspects of peptic ulcer disease and H2-receptor antagonists. American Journal of Medicine 81: 42–8, 1986
Karath BM, Kochis TR, Olah SF. Restricted antimicrobial formulary: promoting appropriate drug use and reducing total drug costs. Abstract. ASHP Midyear Clinical Meeting. 25: P-110D, 1990
Kawachi I, Malcolm LA. Treating mild to moderate hypertension: cost-effectiveness and policy implications. Journal of Cardiovascular Pharmacology 16 (Suppl. 7): S126–S128, 1990
Kreling DH, Knocke DJ, Hammel RW. Effects of an internal analgesic formulary restriction on Medicaid drug expenditures in Wisconsin. Medical Care 27: 34–44, 1989
Kresel JJ, Hutchings HC, MacKay DN, Weinstein MC, Read JL, et al. Application of decision analysis to drug selection for formulary addition. Hospital Formulary 22: 658–663, 673, 676, 1987
Lederle FA, Busch DL, Hatton KM, Nest MJ, Aske DM. Cost-effective treatment of constipation in the elderly: a randomized double-blind comparison of sorbitol and lactulose. American Journal of Medicine 89: 597–601, 1990
Lee JA, Thielke TS. Evaluating the economic impact of formulary decisions. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 46: 476, 478, 1989
Liang FZ, Greenberg RB, Hogan GF. New medicare conditions of participation for hospitals. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 44: 1119–1122, 1987
Lindgren-Furmaga EM, Schuna AA, Wolff NL, Goodfriend TL. Cost of switching hypertensive patients from enalapril maleate to lisinopril. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 481: 276–279, 1991
Lipman AG. WHO essential drugs list. Hospital Formulary 22: 742–743, 1987
Longe RL, Cross GW, Riley MW. Systematic approach to writing P and T drug reports. Hospital Formulary 13: 128–129, 1978
McCarron DA, Hare LE, Walker BR. Therapeutic and economic controversies in antihypertensive therapy. Journal of Cardiovascular Pharmacology 6 (Suppl. 5): S837–840, 1984
McGavock H. 1992 Euroformulary for general practice. International Pharmacy Journal 4: 62, 1990
McLean AJ, Harcourt DM, McCarthy PG, Dudley FJ, McNeil JJ. Relative effectiveness and costs of anti-ulcer medications as a basis for rational prescribing. Medical Journal of Australia 146: 431–433, 436-8, 442, 1987
Menzin J, Oster G. Cost-effectiveness of drug therapy: application of the concept, part 2. Hospital Therapy 7: 947–955, 1990
Meyer DA, Seaba HH. Cefotetan use in surgical prophylaxis: effective formulary replacement for cefoxitin? ASHP Midyear Clinical Meeting 25: P–207E, 1990
Meyers CE, Pierpaoli PG, Smith MA. Measurement of formulary inclusion costs. Hospital Formulary 16: 951–953, 957–958, 967–968, 970–971, 975–976, 1981
Mutnick AH, Szymusiak BA. Decision analysis: new approach to formulary decisions. Hospital Therapy 14: 24–26, 28–29, 32–34, 36, 38, 1989
Nettleman MD, Smith V, Moyer NP. Penicillin-resistant neisseria gonorrhoea in low prevalence areas: implications for cost-effective management. Sexually Transmitted Disease 17: 175–180, 1990
Nolly RJ, Skoutakis VA. Cost considerations of intravenously administered histamine2-receptor antagonists. DICP The Annals of Pharmacotherapy 23 (Suppl.): S23–S28, 1989
Nolte MJ, Sorrentino AC, Ernst TF. Therapeutic drug class reviews: systematic evaluation of the hospital formulary. ASHP Annual Meeting. 48: MCS–13, 1991
Oster G, Tuden RL, Colditz GA. Prevention of venous thromboembolism after general surgery. Cost-effectiveness analysis of alternative approaches to prophylaxis. American Journal of Medicine 82: 889–899, 1987a
Oster G, Tuden RL, Colditz GA. A cost-effectiveness analysis of prophylaxis against deep-vein thrombosis in major orthopedic surgery. Journal of the American Medical Association 257: 203–208, 1987b
Ozer H, Golomb HM, Zimmerman H:, Speigel RJ. Cost-benefit analysis of interferon alfa-2b in treatment of hairy cell leukemia. Journal of the Natlional Cancer Institutes 81: 594–602, 1989
Pearce MJ, Begg EJ. A review of limited lists and formularies: are they cost-effective? PharmacoEconomics 1: 191–202, 1992
Phelps DA, Pittman JR, Malone RL. Evaluation of cost effectiveness of ceftizoxime versus cefoxitin. ASHP Midyear Clinical Meeting 24: P–275E, 1989
Powers T, Bingham DH. Clinical and economic effect of ciprofloxacin as an alternative to injectable antimicrobial therapy. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 47: 1781–1784, 1990
Pym B, Sandstad J, Seville P, Byth K, Middleton WR, Talley NJ, Piper DW. Cost-effectiveness of Cimetidine maintenance therapy in chronic gastric and duodenal ulcer. Gastroenterology 99: 27–35, 1990
Ramirez-Ronda C, Colon M, Saavedra S, Sabbaj J, Corrado ML. Treatment of urinary tract infection with norfloxacin: analysis of cost. American Journal of Medicine 82: 75–78, 1987
Reves RR, Johnson PC, Ericsson CD, DuPont HL. A cost-effectiveness comparison of the use of antimicrobial agents for treatment or prophylaxis of travelers’ diarrhea. Archives of Internal Medicine 148: 2421–2427, 1988
Richton-Hewett S, Foster E, Apstein CS. Medical and economic consequences of a blinded oral anticoagulant brand change at a municipal hospital. Archives of Internal Medicine 148: 806–808, 1988
Roach AC, Kernodle DS, Kaiser AB. Selecting cost-effective antimicrobial prophylaxis in surgery: are we getting what we pay for: DICP The Annals of Pharmacotherapy 24: 183–185, 1990
Ross RN, Morris M, Sakowitz SR, Berman BA. Cost-effectiveness of including cromolyn sodium in the treatment program for asthma: a retrospective, record-based study. Clinical Therapeutics 10: 188–203, 1988
Rubio A, Averbuch M, LeHalpere A, Weintraub M. Educating the prescriber: patient outcome and economic results. Hospital Therapy 5: 639–659, 1990
Schumacher GE. Multiattribute utility (MAUT), identifying. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 48: 301–308, 1991
Scitovsky AA, Cline MW, Abrams DI. Effects of the use of AZT on the medical care costs of persons with AIDS in the first 12 months. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 3: 903–912, 1990
Segal R, Pathak DS. Formularly decision making: identifying factors that influence P&T committee drug evaluations. Hospital Formulary 23: 174–178, 1988
Senthilkumaran K, Shatz SM, Kalies RF. Computer-based support system for formulary decisions. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 44: 1362–1366, 1987
Sheridan WP, Morstyn G, Wolf M, Dodds A, Lusk J, et al. Granulocyte colony-stimulating factor and neutrophil recovery after high-dose chemotherapy and autologous bone marrow transplantation. Lancet 2: 891–894, 1989
Shibley L, Brown M, Schuttinga J, Rothenberg M, Whalen J. Cisplatin-based combination chemotherapy in the treatment of advanced-stage testicular cancencost-benefit analysis. Journal of the Natlional Cancer Institute 82: 186–192, 1990
Shulman KA, Lynn LA, Glick HA, Eisenberg JM. Cost-effectiveness of low-dose zidovudine therapy for asymptomatic patients with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. Annals of Internal Medicine 114: 798–802, 1991
Simmons ML, Vos J, Martens LL. Cost-utility analysis of thrombolytic therapy. European Heart Journal 12: 694–9, 1991
Smith DM, McKercher PL. Elimination of selected drug products from the Michigan medicaid formulary: a case study. Hospital Formulary 19: 366–372, 1984
Smith KS, Briceland LL, Nightingale CH, Quintiliani R. Formulary conversion of cefoxitin usage to cefotetan: experience at a large teaching hospital. DICP: the Annals of Pharmacotherapy 23: 1024–1030, 1989
Sochalski A, Sullman S, Andriole VT. Cost-effectiveness study of cefotetan versus cefoxitin and cefotetan versus combination antibiotic regimens. Amrican Journal of Surgery 155: 96–101, 1988
Sonnenberg A. Costs of medical and surgical treatment of duodenal ulcer. Gastroenterology 96: 1445–52, 1989
Stern RS, Thibodeau LA, Kleinerman RA, Parrish JA, Fitzpatrick TB, Bleich HL. Effect of methoxsalen pharmacotherapy on cost of treatment for psoriasis. Journal of the American Medical Association 245: 1913–1918, 1981
Stern RS. The benefits, costs and risks of topical tar preparation in the treatment of psoriasis: considerations of cost-effectiveness. Annals of the Academy of Medicine of Singapore 17: 473–476, 1988
Stonich T, Thornton J. Evaluating the economic and clinical outcornes of formulary decisions. Abstract. ASHP Midyear Clinical Meeting 24: MCS–77, 1989
Tartaglione TA. Choosing cephalosporins for the formulary. DICP The Annals of Pharmacotherapy 23 (Suppl.): S8–S12, 1989
Thielke TS, Charlson JT, Heckethorn D. Determining drug dispensing costs for use in cost-accounting systems. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 45: 844–847, 1988
Thompson D, Oster G. Cost-effectiveness of drug therapy: application of the concept part 1. Hospital Therapy 5: 663–679, 1990
Thompson MS. Decision analysis for program evaluation, pp. 235–262, Bollinger, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1981
Tierce JC, Meiler W, Berlow B, Gerth WC. Assessing the cost of albuterol inhalers in the Michigan and California medicaid programs: total cost-of-care approach. Clinical Therapeutics 11: 53–61, 1989
Tsevat J, Snydman DR, Pauker SG, Durand-Zaleski I, Werner BG, Leey AS. Which renal transplant patients should receive cytomegalovirus immune globulin: a cost-effectiveness analysis. Transplantation 52: 259–265, 1991
Tsevat J, Durand-Zaleski I, Pauker SG. Cost effectiveness of antibiotic prophylaxis for dental procedures in patients with artificial joints. American Journal of Public Health 79: 739–743, 1989
Tubman TR, Halliday HL, Normand C. Cost of surfactant replacement treatment for severe neonatal respiratory distress syndrome: a randomized controlled trail. British Medical Journal 301: 842–845, 1990
Tuggle DW, Hoelzer DJ, Tunell WP, Smith EI. The safety and cost-effectiveness of polyethylene glycol electrolyte solution bowel preparation in infants and children. Journal of Pediatric Surgery 22: 513–515, 1987
Washington AE, Browner WS, Korenbrot CC. Cost-effectiveness of combined treatment for endocervical gonorrhea. Journal of the American Medical Association 257: 2056–2060, 1987
Weeks JC, Tierney MR, Weinstein MC. Cost-effectiveness of prophylactic intravenous immune globulin in chronic lymphocytic leukemia. New England Journal of Medicine 325: 81–86, 1991
Weiner CP, Renk K, Klugman M. The therapeutic efficacy and cost-effectiveness of aggressive tocolysis for premature labor associated with premature rupture of the membranes. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 159: 216–22, 1988
Weinstein MC, Coley CM, Richter JM. Medical management of gallstones: a cost-effective analysis. Journal of General Internal Medicine 5: 277–284, 1990
Weiss JC, Melman ST. Cost-effectiveness in the choice of antibiotics for the initial treatment of otitis media in children: a decision analysis approach. Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal 7: 23–6, 1988
Wise GJ, Goldman WM, Goldberg PE, Rothernberg RG. Miconazole: a cost-effective antifungal genitourinary irrigant. Journal of Urology 138: 1413–1415, 1987
Wright DB. Antimicrobial formulary management: a case stydy in a teaching hospital. Pharmacotherapy 11: 27s–31s, 1991
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lipsy, R.J. Institutional Formularies. Pharmacoeconomics 1, 265–281 (1992). https://doi.org/10.2165/00019053-199201040-00004
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2165/00019053-199201040-00004