Ethics in the trenches
- Mark Noble PhD
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
The increasing understanding of stem cell biology has opened up the possibility of using cell transplantation to treat a large variety of diseases. The medical need to identify optimal therapies is being challenged, however, by some members of society who seek to impose on this scientific quest their views—generally associated with particular religious beliefs—of what constitutes allowable research. This conflict mirrors earlier battles, extending over 150 years, between those implementing inoculation and vaccination to protect against smallpox and those who felt this to be unethical for religious reasons. For the many individuals who might benefit from the potential of stem cell medicine, such prolonged debate is unacceptable.
In this review, conflicts in this debate are examined by holding opponents of embryonic stem cell (ESC) research to the standards applied to the science. The challenge of identifying optimal cells for tissue repair is juxtaposed with misrepresentations of stem cell science by those opposed to ESC research. Absolutist views on ethics are juxtaposed with examples of the bad science and unethical acts that occur when dogmatic religious filters and definitions of human-ness are forced upon scientific discussions. Finally, after considering how opponents of ESC research may, ironically, enhance commercial demand for cells derived from fetuses aborted for personal reasons of the mother, 10 proposals are offered that would—if followed by all participants in this debate—produce more ethically balanced discussions and a more comprehensive body of data from which evidence-based conclusions can be drawn.
- Young MJ, Ray J, Whiteley SJ, Klassen H, and Gage FH. Neuronal differentiation and morphological integration of hippocampal progenitor cells transplanted to the retina of immature and mature dystrophic rats. Mol Cell Neurosci 2000;16:197–205. CrossRef
- Klassen HJ, Ng TF, Kurimoto Y, et al. Multipotent retinal progenitors express developmental markers, differentiate into retinal neurons, and preserve light-mediated behavior. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2004;45:4167–4173. CrossRef
- Davies JE, Huang C, Proschel C, Noble M, Mayer-Proschel M, and Davies SJA. Astrocytes derived from glial restricted precursor cells promote spinal cord repair. J Biology 2006; in press.
- Lu P, Jones LL, and Tuszynski MH. BDNF-expressing marrow stromal cells support extensive axonal growth at sites of spinal cord injury. Exp Neurol 2005;191:344–360. CrossRef
- Hill CE, Proschel C, Noble M, et al. Acute transplantation of glial-restricted precursor cells into spinal cord contusion injuries: survival, differentiation, and effects on lesion environment and axonal regeneration. Exp Neurol 2004;190:289–310. CrossRef
- Hess DC, Hill WD, Martin-Studdard A, Carroll J, Brailer J, and Carothers J. Bone marrow as a source of endothelial cells and NeuN-expressing cells after stroke. Stroke 2002;33:1362–1368. CrossRef
- Borlongan CV, Evans A, Yu G, and Hess DC. Limitations of intravenous human bone marrow CD133+ cell grafts in stroke rats. Brain Res 2005;28;1048:116–122. CrossRef
- Lagasse E, Connors H, Al-Dhalimy M, et al. Purified hematopoietic stem cells can differentiate into hepatocytes in vivo. Nat Med 2000;6:1229–1234. CrossRef
- Wang X, Willenbring H, Akkari Y, et al. Cell fusion is the principal source of bone-marrow-derived hepatocytes. Nature 2003;422:897–901. CrossRef
- Weimann JM, Charlton CA, Brazelton TR, Hackman RC, and Blau HM. Contribution of transplanted bone marrow cells to Purkinje neurons in human adult brains. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2003;100(4):2088–2093. CrossRef
- Weimann JM, Johansson CB, Trejo A, and Blau HM. Stable reprogrammed heterokaryons form spontaneously in Purkinje neurons after bone marrow transplant. Nat Cell Biol 2003;5:959–966. CrossRef
- http://www.micatholicconference.org/pdf/focus/focus_200108-StemCellResearch.pdf. Michigan Catholic Conference, Volume 29, No. 3, August 2001.
- Stem cell reality check. Human Life of Washington. Retrieved April 2006 from http://www.humanlife.net/stemcellrealitycheck.html
- Stem cell reality check #1. Secretariat for Pro-Life Activities, United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. Retrieved April 2006 from http://www.usccb.org/prolife/issues/bioethic/stemfax1.htm
- Atala A, Bauer SB, Soker S, Yoo JJ, and Retik AB. Tissue-engineered autologous bladders for patients needing cystoplasty. Lancet 2006; in press.
- Rudin J. The Baptizing of America: The Religious Right’s Plans for the Rest of Us. New York: Thunder’s Mouth Press, 2006.
- Evangelical scientists refute gravity with new ‘intelligent galling.’ The Onion 2005; August 17. Retrieved April 2006 from http://www.theonion.com/content/node/39512.
- Pacholczyk T. Making sense out of bioethics: a spectacular stem cell scandal. The Diocese of Scranton, Pennsylvania. Retrieved April 2006 from http://www.dioceseofscranton.org/You%20Should%20Know/StemCellScandal.asp. Accessed April 2006.
- Howard B. Neuroscientist priest speaks with TC on the latest bioethical issues. Texas Catholic Online http://texascatholic.com/default.asp?NodeId=891.AccessedApril2006.
- “Life on the balance.” Online postings. Open Book 2005; May 27. Retrieved April 2006 from http://amywelborn.typepad.com/openbook/2005/05/life_on_the_bal.html
- White AD. Chapter XII.10, “Theological opposition to inoculation, vaccination and the use of anesthetics,” in A History of the Warfare of Science with Theology in Christendom. 1896. Available at http://abob.libs.uga.edu/bobk/whitewtc.html or http://cscs.umich.edu/~crshalizi/White/
- Philipkoski K. Stem-cell patient roasts lawmaker. Wired 2005; June 20. Retrieved April 2006 from http://www.wired.com/news/medtech/1,67728-1.html
- http://www.mocatholic.org/StemCell-Cloning/Columbia KOFC.pdf. Ends vs. Means, by Thomas A. Szyszkiewicz, 2005.
- Treatments from adult stem cells. Oregon Right to Life 2006. Retrieved April 2006 from http://www.ortl.org/stem-cell-cloning/treatments.php
- Neill S. The human touch. The Catholic Virginian 2006; January 30 (Editorial). Retrieved April 2006 from http://www.catholicvirginian.org/archive/2006/2006vol81iss7/pages/editorials.htm
- www.cathmed.org/newsroom/current/frcstemcell.pdf. Stem Cell Research, Cloning & Human Embryos, by Dr. Tadeusz Pacholezyk (Family Research Council).
- Kelly K. Expert debunks myths of embryonic stem-cell research. The Catholic Key 2001. Retrieved April 2006 from http://catholickey.org/index.php3?gif=news.gifόde=viewissue=20050415→ticle_id=3389
- Gilmer T. SCI restoration: the nose knows. New Mobility Magazine 2005; May. Retrieved April 2006 from http://www.newmobility.com/review_article.cfm?id=1007⇂tion=browse
- Amador MJ and Guest JD. An appraisal of ongoing experimental procedures in human spinal cord injury. J Neurol Phys Ther 2005;29:70–86.
- Ethics in the trenches
Stem Cell Reviews
Volume 1, Issue 4 , pp 345-376
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Humana Press
- Additional Links
- Mark Noble PhD (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Department of Biomedical Genetics, Aba Institute for Biomedical Sciences, University of Rochester Medical Center, 14642, Rochester, NY