Abstract
In an article in the August 2000 issue of Demography titled “Racial Differences in Birth Health Risk: A Quantitative Genetic Approach,” van den Oord and Rowe attempted to study the genetic and environmental factors contributing to the black/white gap in infant birth weight. Their findings indicate that this difference may be explained by shared environmental influences rather than by fetal genes. Yet the authors insisted in their conclusions that a strong genetic component still must play a role in determining the racial gap in birth weight, if only through maternal effects. The incompatibility between the authors’ findings and their conclusions is due largely to a weakness in their conceptualization of the relationship between race and biology. Their insistence that racial groups represent discrete genetic entities, coupled with a failure to account for interactions between biological and environmental processes, illustrates the methodological and ethical problems that threaten future interdisciplinary research on racial/ethnic disparities in health.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bhopal, R. 1999. “Comment.” American Journal of Public Health 89:784–85.
Bogin, B. 1995. “Plasticity and the Growth of Mayan Refugee Children Living in the United States.” Pp. 46–74 in Human Variability and Plasticity, edited by C.G.N. Mascie-Taylor and B. Bogin. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Brace, C.L. 1964. “A Nonracial Approach Towards Understanding of Human Diversity.” Pp. 103–52 in The Concept of Race, edited by A. Montagu. New York: Free Press.
—. 1982. “The Roots of the Race Concept in American Physical Anthropology.” Pp. 11–29 in A History of American Physical Anthropology, 1930–1980, edited by F. Spencer. New York: Academic Press.
—. 1996. “A Four-Letter Word Called ‘Race.’” Pp. 106–41 in Race and Other Misadventures: Essays in Honor of Ashley Montagu in His Ninetieth Year, edited by L.T. Reynolds and L. Lieberman. Dix Hills, NJ: General Hall.
Brace, C.L. and K.D. Hunt. 1990. “A Nonracial Craniofacial Perspective on Human Variation: A(ustralia) to Z(uni).” American Journal of Physical Anthropology 82:341–60.
Brace, C.L., D.P. Tracer, L.A. Yaroch, J. Robb, K. Brandt, and A.R. Nelson. 1993. “Clines and Clusters Versus ‘Race’: A Test in Ancient Egypt and the Case of a Death on the Nile.” Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 36:1–31.
Carey, J.R. 1997. “What Demographers Can Learn From Fruit Fly Actuarial Models and Biology.” Demography 34:17–30.
Cartmill, M. 1999. “The Status of the Race Concept in Physical Anthropology.” American Anthropologist 100:651–60.
Cherlin, A. 1999. “Going to Extremes: Family Structure, Children’s Well-Being, and Social Science.” Demography 36:421–28.
Collins, J.W. and R.J. David. 1997. “Urban Violence and African-American Pregnancy Outcome: An Ecologic Study.” Ethnicity and Disease 7:184–90.
Cooper, R. 1984. “A Note on the Biological Concept of Race and Its Application in Epidemiologic Research.” American Heart Journal 108:715–23.
Cooper, R. and R. David. 1986. “The Biological Concept of Race and Its Application to Public Health and Epidemiology.” Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 11(1):97–115.
Cramer, J.C. 1995. “Racial and Ethnic Differences in Birth Weight: The Role of Income and Financial Assistance.” Demography 32:231–47.
Crimmins, E.M. 1993. “Demography: The Past 30 Years, the Present, and the Future.” Demography 30:579–91.
Curtin, S.C. and J.A. Martin. 2000. Births: Preliminary Data for 1999. National Vital Statistics Reports 48(14). Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics.
Goodman, A.H. 1997. “Bred in the Bone.” The Sciences March/ April:20–25.
Hartl, D.L. and A.G. Clark. 1997. Principles of Population Genetics. 3rd ed. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates.
Hayward, M.D., E.M. Crimmins, T.P. Miles, and Y. Yang. 2000. “The Significance of Socioeconomic Status in Explaining the Racial Gap in Chronic Health Conditions.” American Sociological Review 65:910–30.
Herrnstein, R.J. and C. Murray. 1994. The Bell Curve: Intelligence and Class Structure in American Life. New York: Free Press.
Hirschman, C., R. Alba, and R. Farley. 2000. “The Meaning and Measurement of Race in the U.S. Census: Glimpses Into the Future.” Demography 37:381–93.
Hoffman, P. 1994. “The Science of Race.” Discover, November, p. 4.
Hummer, R.A., R.G. Rogers, and I.W. Eberstein. 1998. “Sociodemographic Differentials in Adult Mortality: A Review of Analytic Approaches.” Population and Development Review 24:553–78.
Kaufman, J.S., R.S. Cooper, and D.L. McGee. 1997. “Socioeconomic Status and Health in Blacks and Whites: The Problem of Residual Confounding and the Resiliency of Race.” Epidemiology 8(6):621–28.
Lasker, G.W. 1995. “The Study of Migrants as a Strategy for Understanding Human Biological Plasticity.” Pp. 110–14 in Human Variability and Plasticity, edited by C.G.N. Mascie-Taylor and B. Bogin. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
LaVeist, T.A. 1996. “Why We Should Continue to Study Race…but Do a Better Job: An Essay on Race, Racism and Health.” Ethnicity and Disease 6:21–29.
LeClere, F.B., R.G. Rogers, and K.D. Peters. 1997. “Ethnicity and Mortality in the United States: Individual and Community Correlates.” Social Forces 76:169–97.
Livingstone, F.B. 1964. “On the Nonexistence of Human Races.” Pp. 46–60 in The Concept of Race, edited by A. Montagu. New York: Free Press.
Marks, J. 1994. “Racial Categories and Cultural Constructs Masquerading as Biology.” Natural History, December, pp. 32-35.
—. 1995. Human Biodiversity: Genes, Race, and History. New York: Aldine.
McDermott, R. 1998. “Ethnics, Epidemiology and the Thrifty Gene: Biological Determinism as a Health Hazard.” Social Science and Medicine 47:1189–95.
Montagu, A. 1942. Man’s Most Dangerous Myth: The Fallacy of Race. New York: Harper.
—. 1964. “The Concept of Race.” Pp. 12–28 in The Concept of Race, edited by A. Montagu. New York: Free Press.
Muntaner, C., F.J. Nieto, and P. O’Campo. 1996. “The Bell Curve: On Race, Social Class and Epidemiologic Research.” American Journal of Epidemiology 114:531–36.
Pritchard, D.J. 1995. “Plasticity in Early Development.” Pp. 18–45 in Human Variability and Plasticity, edited by C.G.N. Mascie-Taylor and B. Bogin. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Roberts, D.F. 1995. “The Pervasiveness of Plasticity.” Pp. 1–17 in Human Variability and Plasticity, edited by C.G.N. Mascie-Taylor and B. Bogin. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Rushton, J.P. 1991. “Mongoloid-Caucasoid Differences in Brain Size From Military Samples.” Intelligence 15:351–59.
Stern, M.P. and C.V. González. 2000. “Are There Differences in the Incidence and Prevalence of Diabetes Between Mexican Americans and Mexicans Living in Mexico?” Presented at the Seventeenth International Diabetes Federation Congress, Mexico City.
Templeton, A.R. 1999. “Human Races: A Genetic and Evolutionary Perspective.” American Anthropologist 100:632–50.
Udry, J.R. 1994. “The Nature of Gender.” Demography 31:561–73.
van den Oord, E.J.C.G. and D. Rowe. 2000. “Racial Differences in Birth Health Risk: A Quantitative Genetic Approach.” Demography 37:285–98.
Wilcox, A.J. and I.T. Russell. 1989. “Birthweight and Perinatal Mortality: III. Towards a New Method of Analysis.” International Journal of Epidemiology 15:188–96.
Williams, D.R. 1997. “Race and Health: Basic Questions, Emerging Directions.” Annuals of Epidemiology 7:322–33.
Williams, D.R. and C. Collins. 1995. “U.S. Socioeconomic and Racial Differences in Health: Patterns and Explanations.” Annual Review of Sociology 21:349–86.
Williams, D.R., R. Lavizzo-Mourey, and R.C. Warren. 1994. “The Concept of Race and Health Status in America.” Public Health Reports 109:26–41.
Wise, P.H. 1993. “Confronting Racial Disparities in Infant Mortality: Reconciling Science and Politics.” American Journal of Preventative Medicine (supp.) 9(6):7–16.
Witzig, R. 1996. “The Medicalization of Race: Scientific Legitimization of a Flawed Social Construct.” Annals of Internal Medicine 125:675–79.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
The author gratefully acknowledges the comments of C. Loring Brace, Robert A. Hummer, and Dennis J. Donahue. Demography, Volume 38-Number 4, November 2001
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Frank, R. The misuse of biology in demographic research on racial/ethnic differences: A reply to van den oord and rowe. Demography 38, 563–567 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1353/dem.2001.0034
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/dem.2001.0034