A replication of the study ‘Adverse effects of spinal manipulation: a systematic review’
- Peter Tuchin
- … show all 1 hide
To assess the significance of adverse events after spinal manipulation therapy (SMT) by replicating and critically reviewing a paper commonly cited when reviewing adverse events of SMT as reported by Ernst (J Roy Soc Med 100:330–338, 2007).
Replication of a 2007 Ernst paper to compare the details recorded in this paper to the original source material. Specific items that were assessed included the time lapse between treatment and the adverse event, and the recording of other significant risk factors such as diabetes, hyperhomocysteinemia, use of oral contraceptive pill, any history of hypertension, atherosclerosis and migraine.
The review of the 32 papers discussed by Ernst found numerous errors or inconsistencies from the original case reports and case series. These errors included alteration of the age or sex of the patient, and omission or misrepresentation of the long term response of the patient to the adverse event. Other errors included incorrectly assigning spinal manipulation therapy (SMT) as chiropractic treatment when it had been reported in the original paper as delivered by a non-chiropractic provider (e.g. Physician).
The original case reports often omitted to record the time lapse between treatment and the adverse event, and other significant clinical or risk factors. The country of origin of the original paper was also overlooked, which is significant as chiropractic is not legislated in many countries. In 21 of the cases reported by Ernst to be chiropractic treatment, 11 were from countries where chiropractic is not legislated.
The number of errors or omissions in the 2007 Ernst paper, reduce the validity of the study and the reported conclusions. The omissions of potential risk factors and the timeline between the adverse event and SMT could be significant confounding factors. Greater care is also needed to distinguish between chiropractors and other health practitioners when reviewing the application of SMT and related adverse effects.
- Harlan WR Jr: Research on complementary and alternative medicine using randomized controlled trials. J Altern Complement Med 2001,7(Suppl 1):S45-S52. CrossRef
- UK BEAM Trial Team: United Kingdom back pain exercise and manipulation (UK BEAM) randomised trial: cost effectiveness of physical treatments for back pain in primary care. BMJ 2004, 329: .doi:10.1136/bmj.38282.607859.AE.
- Meade TW, Dyer S, Browne W, et al.: Randomized comparison of chiropractic and hospital outpatient management for low back pain: Results from an extended follow up. Br Med J 1995, 311:349–351. CrossRef
- Bronfort G, Evans R, Anderson AV, Svendsen MS, Bracha Y, Grimm RH: Spinal Manipulation, Medication, or Home Exercise With Advice for Acute and Subacute Neck Pain: A Randomized Trial. Ann Intern Med 2012, 156:1–10.
- Jull G, Trott P, Potter H, Zito G, Niere K, Shirley D, et al.: A randomized controlled trial of exercise and manipulative therapy for cervicogenic headache. Spine 2002, 27:1835–1843. CrossRef
- Tuchin PJ, Pollard H, Bonello R: A RCT of Chiropractic SMT and migraine. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2000, 23:91–95. CrossRef
- Chou R, Qaseem A, Snow V, et al.: Diagnosis and treatment of low back pain: a joint clinical practice guideline from the American College of Physicians and the American Pain Society. Ann Intern Med 2007, 147:478–491.
- Bronfort G, Haas M, Evans R, Triano J: Effectiveness of manual therapies: the UK evidence report. Chiropr Osteopat 2010, 18:3–36. CrossRef
- Airaksinen O, Brox JI, Cedraschi C, et al.: Chapter 4. European guidelines for the management of chronic nonspecific low back pain. Eur Spine J 2006,15(Suppl 2):S192-S300. CrossRef
- Chaibi A, Tuchin PJ, Russell M: Manual Therapies for Migraine A Systematic Review of the Literature. J Headache 2011. doi:10.1007/s10194-011-0296-6.
- Thiel HW, Bolton JE, Docherty S, Portlock JC: Safety of Chiropractic Manipulation of the Cervical Spine. A Prospective National Survey. Spine 2007, 32:2375–2378. CrossRef
- Hurwitz EL, Morgenstern H, Harber P, et al.: A Randomized Trial of Chiropractic Manipulation and Mobilization for Patients with Neck Pain: Clinical Outcomes from the UCLA Neck-Pain Study. Am J Publ Health 2002, 92:100. CrossRef
- Rubinstein SM, et al.: The benefits outweigh the risks for patients undergoing chiropractic care for neck pain: a prospective, multicenter, cohort study. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2007,30(6):408–418. CrossRef
- Cagnie B, Vinck E, Beernaert A, Cambier D: How common are side effects of spinal manipulation and can these side effects be predicted? Man Ther 2004, 9:151–156. CrossRef
- Ernst E: Vascular accidents after neck manipulation: cause or coincidence? Int J Clin Pract 2010, 64:673–677. CrossRef
- Haldeman S, Kohlbeck FJ, McGregor M: Unpredictability of cerebrovascular ischaemia associated with cervical spine manipulation therapy. Spine 2002, 27:49–55. CrossRef
- Ernst E: Adverse effects of spinal manipulation: a systematic review. J Roy Soc Med 2007, 100:330–338. CrossRef
- Debette S, Leys D: Cervical-artery dissections: predisposing factors, diagnosis, and outcome. Lancet Neurol 2009, 8:668–678. CrossRef
- Chatzikonstantinou A, Wolf ME, Hennerici MG: Ischemic stroke in young adults: classification and risk factors. J Neurol , : . doi:10.1007/s00415-011-6234-3
- Chandra A, Suliman A, Angle N: Spontaneous dissection of the carotid and vertebral arteries: the 10-year UCSD experience. Ann Vasc Surg 2007, 21:178–185. CrossRef
- Gallai V, Caso V, Paciaroni M, et al.: Mild hyperhomocystaeinemia: a possible risk factor for cervical artery dissection. Stroke 2001, 32:714–718. CrossRef
- Grau AJ, Brandt T, Buggle F, et al.: Association of cervical artery dissection with recent infection. Arch Neurol 1999, 56:851–856. CrossRef
- Brandt T, Orberk E, Weber R, et al.: Pathogenesis of cervical artery dissections: association with connective tissue abnormalities. Neurology 2001, 57:24–30. CrossRef
- Campos CR, Evaristo EF, Yamamoto FI, et al.: Spontaneous cervical carotid and vertebral arteries dissection: study of 48 patients. Arq Neuropsiquiatr 2004, 62:492–498. CrossRef
- Morandi X, et al.: Caudal spinal cord ischemia after lumbar vertebral manipulation. Joint Bone Spine 2004, 71:334–337. CrossRef
- Chen H-C, Hsu P-W, Lin C-Y, Tzaan W-C: Symptomatic hematoma of cervical ligamentum flavum. Spine 2005, 30:E489-E491. CrossRef
- Se’dat J, Dib M, Mahagne MH, Lonjon M, Paquis P: Stroke after chiropractic manipulation as a result of extracranial postero-inferior cerebellar artery dissection. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2002, 25:588–590. CrossRef
- Beck J, Raabe A, Seifert V: Intracranial hypotension after chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003, 74:820–826. CrossRef
- Oehler J, et al.: Vertebralisdissektion nach chiropraktischer behandlung. Der Orthopade 2003, 32:911–913. CrossRef
- Saxler G, Barden B: Extensive spinal epidural haematoma – an uncommon entity following cervical chiropractic manipulation. Z Orthop Grenzgeb 2004, 142:79–84. CrossRef
- Suh S-I, Koh S-B, Choi E-J, et al.: Intracranial hypotension induced by cervical spine chiropractic manipulation. Spine 2005, 30:E340-E342. CrossRef
- Yokota J, Amakusa Y, Tomita Y, Takahashi S: The medial medullary infarction (Dejerine syndrome) following chiropractic neck manipulation. No To Shinkei 2003, 55:121–125.
- Izquierdo-Casas J, et al.: Diseccion vertebral como causa del syndrome de enclaustramiento y opciones terapeuticas con fibrinolisis intraarterial durante la fase aguda. Rev Neurol 2004, 38:1139–1141.
- Menendez-Gonzalez M, et al.: Sindrome do Wallemberg secundario a diseccion de la arteria vertegral por manipulacion quiropractica. Rev Neurol 2003, 37:837–839.
- Tome F, Barriga A, Espejo L: Herniacion discal multiple tras manipulacion quiropractica cervical. Revista de Medicina de la Universidad de Navarra 2004, 48:39–41.
- Terrett AGJ: Misuse of the literature by medical authors in discussing spinal manipulative therapy injury. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1995, 18:203–210.
- Cyriax J: Textbook of Orthopaedic Medicine. Volume one: Diagnosis of Soft Tissue Lesions. 8th edition. London: Baillière Tindall; 1982.
- Jeret JS: More complications of spinal manipulation. Stroke 2001, 32:1136–1137. CrossRef
- Siegel D, Neiders T: Vertebral artery dissection and pontine infarction after chiropractic manipulation. Am J Emerg Med 2001, 19:172–173. CrossRef
- Parwar BL, Fawzi AA, Arnold AC, Schwartz SD: Horner’s syndrome and dissection of the internal carotid artery after chiropractic manipulation of the neck. Am J Ophthalmol 2001, 131:523–524. CrossRef
- Schram DJ, Vosik W: Diaphragmatic paralysis following cervical chiropractic manipulation: case report and review. Complementary/Alternative Medicine for Asthma 2001, 119:638–640.
- Stevinson C, Honan W, Cooke B, Ernst E: Neurological complications of cervical spine manipulation. J Roy Soc Med 2001, 94:107–110.
- Jeret JS, Bluth M: Stroke following chiropractic manipulation. Report of three cases and review of the literature. Cerebrovasc Dis 2002, 13:210–213. CrossRef
- Jay WM, Shah MI, Schneck MJ: Bilateral occipital-parietal hemorrhagic infarctions following chiropractic cervical manipulation. Semin Ophthalmol 2003, 18:205–209. CrossRef
- Nadgir RN, Loevner LA, Ahmed T, Chalela J, Slawek K, Imbesi S: Simultaneous bilateral internal carotid and vertebral artery dissection following chiropractic manipulation: case report and review of the literature. Neuroradiol 2003, 45:311–314.
- Wenban AB: Inappropriate use of the title chiropractor and the term chiropractic manipulation in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature. Chiropr Osteopat 2006, 14:1–7. CrossRef
- A replication of the study ‘Adverse effects of spinal manipulation: a systematic review’
- Open Access
- Available under Open Access This content is freely available online to anyone, anywhere at any time.
Chiropractic & Manual Therapies
- Online Date
- September 2012
- Online ISSN
- BioMed Central
- Additional Links
- Spinal manipulative therapy
- Adverse effects
- Peter Tuchin (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Macquarie University, Bld E5A Rm 355, Waterloo Rd, North Ryde, Sydney, NSW, 2109, Australia