A WUSCHEL-related homeobox 3B gene, depilous (dep), confers glabrousness of rice leaves and glumes
- First online:
Glabrousness is an important agricultural trait for the practical breeding of rice. In this study, depilous (dep), the gene responsible for glabrous leaves and glumes of rice was identified by map-based cloning.
The dep gene encodes a WUSCHEL-related homeobox 3B that was fine-mapped to a 22-kb region on the short arm of chromosome 5 using progenies derived from crosses between Koshihikari (pubescent) and GLSL15, an Oryza glaberrima chromosome segment substitution line (glabrous). Complementation tests confirmed the conditioning of the glabrous phenotype by the dep gene. Phylogenetic analysis showed that dep groups with the WOX3 family of plant-specific homeobox transcription factors that are involved in regulating lateral organ development. Localization of dep in the nucleus indicates the function of the gene as a transcription factor. Spatial expression of the gene was observed in the base of young shoots, the leaf sheath, midrib, young roots and nodal structures.
The identification and cloning of dep will not only provide basis for future research on the elucidation of the molecular mechanisms underlying trichome formation in rice but will also aid in breeding programs for the development of glabrous varieties.
Keywordsdepilous Rice Trichomes Glabrous Leaves Glumes WUSCHEL-related homeobox
Trichomes are specialized structures that originate from the aerial epidermis and develop as hair-like projections that extend from the epidermal surface ([Serna and Martin 2006];[Werker 2000];[Johnson 1975]). They differ considerably in cellular composition, density, morphology, location and, depending on whether they are glandular or non-glandular, in function. In most plant species, non-glandular trichomes function to lessen the heat load of leaves, reduce transpiration rates, and enhance freezing tolerance and herbivore resistance. Glandular trichomes on the other hand, not only offer physical resistance but also provide chemical protection against biotic and abiotic challenges ([Serna and Martin 2006];[Martin and Glover 2007]; Bandyopadhyay et al.;[Werker 2000];[Mauricio and Rauscher 1997];[Johnson 1975]).
In rice (Oryza sativa), trichomes on the leaf blade take the form of hairs or bristles (Yamamoto et al.;[Hoshikawa 1975]). The hairs are two-celled, cylindrical appendages that are arranged between nerves on the epidermis on either side of the leaves. Bristle type trichomes on the other hand, are one- or two-celled outgrowths, and may be of type Ia, Ib or II. The bristle type Ia trichomes are commonly found on the adaxial side of the leaf and are slightly longer than the type Ib. Both the hair and the bristle type II trichomes are located on the adaxial and abaxial leaf surfaces. The bristle type Ia and Ib trichomes as well as the hairs run perpendicular to the leaf surface, whereas the bristle type II are oriented parallel to the leaf blade. Both bristle type Ia and Ib trichomes are conical in shape despite differences in size and location, indicating that they may have been derived from the same origin (Yamamoto et al.). The bristle type trichomes, regardless of length or orientation, have also been described as prickle hairs (Islam et al.) or macrohair, whereas the hair has also been referred to as microhair (Kobayashi et al.; Shimizu et al.).
The reduction or absence of the bristle type trichomes on the surface of the leaves and the glumes defines the glabrous phenotype in rice. This trait has been considered as selectively neutral, with neither a known selective advantage nor disadvantage. However, in areas where rice culture remains manual, the glabrous trait is fairly valued since the lack of trichomes reduces skin irritation and itching among workers during harvesting, threshing, drying and milling of rice ([Rutger and Mackill 2001]; Makenzie et al.). In the U.S., cultivation of glabrous varieties has been an important part of the rice industry. Initially valued for hand harvesting and threshing because they cause less itching, the glabrous varieties became more prized due to their higher bulk density compared with pubescent varieties ([Rutger and Mackill 2001]). The higher bulk density due to the close packing of the glabrous kernels saves valuable space during storage and transportation (Varnamkhasti et al.;[Rutger and Mackill 2001]). Glabrous varieties have also been known to create less dust during processing. At present, virtually all U.S. rice varieties, as well as many Australian varieties that share U.S. parentage, are glabrous ([Rutger and Mackill 2001]).
The recessive allele gl1 and its duplicate pair gl2 have been reported to control glabrousness in both the leaves and glumes of rice (Yamamoto et al.;[Nagao and Takahashi 1963];[Sastry and Seetharaman 1980]; Sato et al.). Linkage maps associated gl1 with restriction fragment length polymorphism markers mapped on chromosome 5 (14.3±7.4 cM from RG182 and 20.9±8.3 cM from RG403) (Yu et al.; Yu et al.). To date, however, the gene controlling the trait has yet to be identified and characterized. We report here the identification and cloning of depilous (dep), the gene regulating trichome formation in rice leaves and glumes. This gene was identified by positional cloning using a previously identified glabrous chromosome segment substitution line (GLSL15) carrying an introgressed fragment from the African cultivated rice, O. glaberrima in the background of O. sativa subsp. japonica cv. Koshihikari. dep encodes a WUSCHEL-related homeobox 3B protein that belongs to a class of transcription factors regulating lateral organ development.
Phenotype of the substitution line, GLSL15
Genetic analysis and fine-scale mapping of the dep gene
Map-based cloning of the dep gene
Structure, phylogeny and comparative sequence analysis of dep encoding a WUSCHEL-related homeobox 3B protein
Sequencing of dep showed 3 amino acid substitutions (G23V, V14A and T34A) and a serine deletion (S32del) in the O. glaberrima allele relative to the Koshihikari allele. To determine which of these mutations causes the glabrous phenotype, sequencing of dep in glabrous rice mutants, as well as in a natural population of pubescent and glabrous O. glaberrima lines was also carried out. Sequence analysis showed that both glabrous and pubescent lines of O. glaberrima carry the same amino acid substitutions and deletion relative to Koshihikari. In addition, dep sequence in the glabrous rice mutants studied was similar to that of Koshihikari. Together, these results indicate that none of the sequence variations observed is responsible for the glabrous trait in rice. Sequencing of the 2-kb region upstream of dep also did not show any difference between O. glaberrima and Koshihikari.
Subcellular localization and spatial expression of dep
Glabrous mutants exhibiting a few or total lack of trichomes in the leaves have been reported for a wide range of species. In A. thaliana, considerable progress has been made in elucidating the molecular mechanisms involved in trichome initiation, morphogenesis and patterning (Szymanski et al.). To date, the specification of trichome formation in Arabidopsis has been demonstrated to require the interaction of bHLH, MYB and WD repeat proteins in a functional complex (Zhao et al.; Tominaga et al.; Hauser et al.). In cotton (Gossypium arboretum), similar protein complexes have been reported to control trichome formation. GaMYB2, an Arabidopsis GLABRA1 (GL1) orthologue in cotton, has been reported to have an amino acid motif for interaction with a bHLH protein. GaMYB2 expressed in A. thaliana under the control of GL1 promoter fully restored trichome formation in a gl1 mutant. GhMYB109 is another R2R3 MYB gene identified in upland cotton (G. hirsutum). Like GaMYB2, it also has a conserved motif for interaction with R-like bHLH proteins. Two other functional homologues of the Arabidopsis TRANSPARENT TESTA GLABRA were identified in cotton and both genes encode WD repeat proteins (Humphries et al.; Wang et al.; Suo et al.;[Serna and Martin 2006]). Despite parallelisms in the model system for trichome regulation in Arabidopsis and cotton, similar multimeric complexes among MYB, bHLH and WD protein repeats have not been associated with trichome formation in species outside the Rosid division to which Arabidopsis and cotton both belong. In fact, different regulatory genes have been demonstrated to induce the formation of the various types of trichomes, as in the case of Asterids ([Serna and Martin 2006]). Furthermore, many plant species produce different types of trichomes that appear to be independently regulated (Moose et al.).
In our study, dep, the gene responsible for the glabrous phenotype in rice, was mapped and identified by positional cloning. The rice substitution line, GLSL15 exhibits a glabrous phenotype that is characterized by the absence of trichomes on the leaf blade and the glumes. This line has the full genomic constitution of cv. Koshihikari except for a 3.15-Mb stretch of chromosome 5 of O. glaberrima. Glabrousness in this substitution line has been associated with the introgressed fragment of O. glaberrima (Shim et al.).
Rough mapping of dep identified the location of the gene between 0–2.3 cM (RM159) and 28.6-31.4 cM (RM13) on the short arm of chromosome 5, coinciding with the reported rice gl1 identified between 3.8 and 24.8 cM, also on the short arm of chromosome 5. Genotyping and phenotyping of a total of 8252 F2 and F3 lines showed a monogenic and recessive control of the trait similar to previous reports on the monogenic control of glabrousness (Li et al.;[Foster and Rutger 1978]). A slight distortion in genetic segregation for the trait was observed and this may be due to the preferential fertilization of a particular gametic genotype. Segregation distortion has been frequently observed at the gl1 locus in indica x glabrous japonica crosses and changes in the segregation ratio for gl1 have been reportedly caused by the unequal chances of fertilization of the female gametes (Sato et al.).
Fine-scale mapping narrowed the candidate region for dep into a 22-kb stretch covering 4 annotated genes that encode ORFs for a retrotransposon protein (LOC_05g02710), a hypothetical protein (LOC_05g02720), a WUSCHEL-related homoebox 3B (LOC_05g02730, dep) and an expressed protein (LOC_05g02740). In silico analysis showed that LOC_05g02710 contains a transposase DDE domain that has not been previously associated with any regulatory pathways for trichome formation. Blastp searches showed that LOC_05g02720 has a MYB/SANT-like DNA binding domain that has been reported to play regulatory roles in defense response and developmental processes in plants (Barg et al.; Yanhui et al.). In Arabidopsis, small MYB proteins including TRIPTYCHON (TRY), CAPRICE (CPC), TRICHOMELESS1 and ENHANCER OF TRY AND CPC 1, 2 and 3 have been identified as negative regulators of trichome initiation and patterning in the shoots (Wada et al.; Kirik et al.; Wang et al.). However, such regulatory proteins have been associated with trichome formation in species only within the Rosid division ([Serna and Martin 2006]; Moose et al.). LOC_05g02740 is a single-copy gene with a predicted protein length of 56 amino acids. Blastp searches indicate that orthologues of this gene in maize and sorghum have not been characterized as well. Another gene located within the candidate region is LOC_05g02730, which encodes a WUSCHEL-related homeobox 3B. WUSCHEL homeobox genes belong to a family of plant-specific transcription factors that have been shown to carry out specialized functions in key developmental processes in plants, including stem cell fate regulation, embryonic patterning and organ formation (Van der Graaf et al.; Haecker et al.). Expression and functional analysis of WOX3 in Arabidopsis (PRS) and maize (NS1 and NS2) demonstrated that WOX3 is required in the recruitment of founder cells from the lateral compartment of shoot meristems that will later form the lateral and marginal regions of leaves and leaf orthologues. Null mutations in PRS of Arabidopsis resulted in defects in lateral sepal development and the elimination of the knife-edge cells in the marginal regions of the abaxial and adaxial sepal. Overexpression of the gene, on the other hand, resulted in the formation of multicellular bulges with trichomes on the stem and peduncle of the plant. Such structures were shown to be outgrowths of the epidermal cells ([Matsumoto and Okada 2001]). In maize, ns1 and ns2 mutations resulted in narrow leaves, with complete deletion of tooth hairs on the margins, as well as stem curvature and shortened internodes (Scanlon et al.).
In our study, complementation tests showed that genomic fragments covering the ORF of dep could restore the formation of bristle type trichomes on the leaf blade and the glumes of glabrous rice, indicating the role of this gene in trichome formation. However, it does not influence the formation of aerial appendages in the leaf margin. Phylogenetic analysis showed that dep groups with the reported WOX3 branch carrying duplications of the PRS/NS branch in the WOX3 lineage. While members of both clades relate to leaf development, PRS/NS orthologues are expressed in the lateral domain whereas those of the WOX3 duplicate clade are expressed in the base of developing phytomers in the shoot meristem (Shimizu et al.; Nardmann et al.;[Nardmann and Werr 2006]). Such differences in expression domains have been shown to be indicative of sub-functionalization of duplicate genes as a means to escape mutational decay (Nardmann et al.;[Lynch and Force 2000]). Grouping of dep with the members of the WOX3 duplicate branch suggests that dep may have arisen as a duplicate gene and was preserved by acquiring a sub-function that differs with respect to tissue expression specificity. This may account for the ability of dep to affect trichome formation in the leaf blade and glumes but not in the margins of the leaves. The localization of dep in the nucleus is consistent with the reported features of transcription factors.
Comparative sequence analysis for dep failed to identify the causal mutation that conditions the glabrous phenotype in rice, suggesting a possible epigenetic regulation of the gene responsible for the trait.
Despite being a selectively neutral trait, interest in the glabrous phenotype in rice remains due to the practical advantages of cultivating glabrous varieties. In this study, dep encoding a WUSCHEL-related homeobox 3B protein was identified as the gene controlling glabrousness in rice leaves and glumes. The identification and cloning of dep will not only provide basis for future research on the elucidation of the molecular mechanisms underlying trichome development (i.e. initiation, distribution and patterning) in rice, but will also facilitate the efficient breeding for glabrous rice varieties using marker-aided selection.
Oryza glaberrima Acc IRGC104038, O. sativa subsp japonica cv. Koshihikari and a chromosome segment substitution line (GLSL15) previously identified as having glabrous leaves and glumes were used in this study (Shim et al.). The plant materials were either grown in the greenhouses of the Laboratory of Plant Molecular Biosystem or under natural conditions in the research field of Nagoya University, Togo, Aichi, Japan. Seedlings of the plant materials were first raised in the greenhouse for 30 days before transplanting them in the field.
Leaf ultrastructure of glabrous rice plants
The presence or absence of trichomes on the leaves of 1 ½- or 2-month-old plants was determined by running a forefinger along the length of the leaf blade starting from the tip and going to the base while holding the tip of the leaf. Glabrous leaves offered no resistance to this action due to the absence of bristle type trichomes. To closely examine the leaf ultrastructure of the plant materials, scanning electron microscopy was employed. Leaves of Koshihikari, O. glaberrima and GLSL15 were sampled in vials, fixed in FAA (50% ethanol, formalin and glacial acetic acid at 18:1:1 ratio) solution and dehydrated using a graded series of acetone washes (30, 50, 70, 80, 90, 95, 99 and 100%). The samples were further dehydrated by critical point drying for 1 h at 35°C and 1200 psi using liquid CO2 as the transitional fluid. Samples were then mounted in a specimen stub, ion-coated and examined under a scanning electron microscope (Hitachi S-2600N). The presence of trichomes on the glumes was determined by manual examination and by checking the hulls under a light microscope.
Linkage analysis and mapping of dep
To fine-map dep, a total of 600 F2 plants generated by crossing GLSL15 with Koshihikari, as well as 7652 F3 plants generated from F2 lines with informative recombination points, were genotyped using SSRs and newly developed insertion/deletion (indel)-based and derived cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (dCAPS; Neff et al.) markers targeting the putative location of the gene. Genomic DNA from the mapping population was extracted using the TPS method. SSRs, and indel and dCAPS markers were amplified using standard PCR protocols and run in 3% agarose gel with ethidium bromide.
Indel and dCAPS markers were designed based on the existing sequence alignment of Nipponbare and 93–11, as well as sequence alignments of the initial 62-kb candidate region for dep in Koshihikari and O. glaberrima. The alignment was generated using the GENETYX-MAC/ATSQ (ver. 15.0.5) software.
Three sets of complementation tests were carried out parallel to fine mapping to identify the gene controlling glabrousness in rice. Koshihikari BAC (CRC26L16) covering the putative location of the glabrous gene was screened to confirm the presence of markers within the candidate gene region. To develop a sub-library of the clone, the BAC was either completely digested with Asc II and Bam HI, or partially digested with Hind III to generate differently sized fragments. These fragments were run in 1% low-melting agarose, eluted using the GELase system (Epicentre Biotechnologies, Madison, WI, USA) and ligated to the binary vector, TAC7. The binary vector was also digested with the same set of enzymes and separately treated with cow intestine alkaline phosphatase (CIAP) to prevent self-ligation. Ligation was performed using the Takara DNA Ligation Kit LONG (Takara, Otsu, Japan), following the manufacturer’s specifications. The recombinant plasmid was then transformed to Escherichia coli strain DH10B by electroporation and plated in LB medium with kanamycin. Plasmid DNA extraction followed by digestion using the appropriate enzyme was carried out to verify the presence of an insert. Alongside this, direct plasmid sequencing using the primer pair R3: 5′-AAT TAG GCC CGG GCG GAT-3′ and L3: 5′-GGC CGC GGC CGG CCG TCG −3′ was carried out to estimate the size and determine the map position of the insert. Recombinant plasmids harbouring inserts that cover the candidate gene region were separately introduced to Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain EH105 by electroporation (Hood et al.) and used to transform a glabrous substitution line in cv. T65 background following the methods of Hiei et al. (). Transformants were selected in a medium containing 50 mg hygromycin/l. The hygromycin-resistant plants were transplanted in the soil and maintained under greenhouse conditions at an ambient temperature of 30°C and 16 h light: 8 h dark photoperiod. Sub-clones used for subsequent complementation tests were derived from clones that restored the pubescent phenotype in the glabrous rice donor used for transformation.
Phylogenetic and sequence analysis for dep
The genomic sequence of dep, along with the 2-kb region upstream of the gene was amplified by PCR from the genomic DNA of O. glaberrima, Koshihikari, glabrous rice mutants in a T65 background and a natural population of glabrous and pubescent O. glaberrima lines. The obtained amplicons were purified using the Promega Wizard Genomic DNA Purification Kit, sequenced using the Applied Biosystems 3130xl Genetic Analyzer and analysed using Genetyx-MAC/ATSQ. Orthologues of the translated dep were retrieved by homology searches using Blastx in the National Center for Biotechnology Information and Rice Annotation Project databases. The retrieved protein sequences were aligned by Clustalx ver. 2.0 using the default settings (Larkin et al.). Phylogenetic analysis based on the Neighbor-Joining method was performed using SplitsTree4 ver. 4.11.3 ([Huson and Bryant 2006]). The accuracy of the inferred phylogenetic relationship was determined by bootstrapping using 1000 replicates.
The coding sequence of dep was ligated into the pA7-GFP plasmid vector to construct a dep-GFP fusion protein driven by the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter. The constructs were then introduced into onion epidermal cells by particle bombardment. The GFP signal was viewed by confocal laser microscopy.
To determine the spatial expression of dep, the promoter region (including an 80-bp proximal region) of the gene was digested with the appropriate enzymes and fused to the GUS coding sequence via ligation to the pBl101 plasmid vector. The promoter-GUS fusion construct was then digested from the pBl101 plasmid, cloned into Hm-12 and transformed to E. coli by electroporation. Recombinant plasmid DNA extracted from E. coli was used for transfection in A. tumefaciens that was in turn used for plant transformation. Tissue samples from transgenic plants were stained for 12 h under dark conditions with X-Gluc solution (5.7 mM 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-β-D-glucuronide, 1.5 mM K3Fe(CN)6, 0.9% Triton-X 100) before viewing under a stereomicroscope.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.