Second campaign of microclimate monitoring in the carcer tullianum: temporal and spatial correlation and gradients evidenced by multivariate analysis
This paper discusses results obtained in the second monitoring campaign of the Carcer Tullianum, a particular hypogeum environment located in the historical centre of Rome (Italy). In the first paper we stressed the need to apply chemometric tools to this kind of studies in order to obtain full and significant information; really information on sampling design, sensors (type, number, position) and instrument validation seems to be not easy to find in literature for researches dealing with monitoring of indoor environments.
Also in this case three main parameters (temperature, humidity, illuminance) were monitored in the complex construction by an inexpensive self-assembled system along some horizontal and vertical vectors together with some measurements of oxygen, carbon dioxide and barometric pressure.
With respect to the first campaign, we used a higher number of sensors to cover a new excavated zone; for the same reason, as well as to take into account the presence of visitors, a different experimental design was adopted.
Different data treatments were applied to data coming from all the used sensors. A good view of the microclimate was obtained that also resulted coherent with the different position of the three rooms constituting the monitored site (Carcer, Tullianum, Convent). Classical time plots resulted useful to evidence the correlation of the main monitored parameters (T, RH% and illuminance) with macroclimate, as well as their delay in following macroclimate. Box-Whisker and Gain-Loss graphs evidenced at the best the microclimate differences between the three rooms; an almost hypogean microclimate was evidenced for the lower room (Tullianum) where humidity values range between 90 and 100% while lower values, but anyway higher than the external, and spread more widely were measured passing to Convent and Carcer with minimum values around 50% for the last. A scarce or very scarce correlation with macroclimate was evidenced for all the three main measured parameters. Lighting results mainly dependent on artificial light and only in few cases, but unfortunately in the most precious zone, illuminance exceeds values suggested by Normative.
Box-Whisker and Gain-Loss graphs allowed us to have the best view of the microclimate for all the monitored rooms. The influence of lighting by lamps on the other monitored parameters resulted overlapped and clearly topped the solar one. The worst situation was found in the Carcer, where the presence of the main chandelier worsens the state of the frescoed walls, already subjected to wide changes in temperature and humidity. Also the lighthouse located above the Convent provokes lighting exceeding values suggested by Normative while, as expected, LEDs resulted as suitable source of light from a conservation point of view.
Susanne Heidi Plattner, Patrizia Fortini and Maria Pia Sammartino contributed equally to this work
- Banham R: The Architecture of the Well-tempered Environment. Architectural Press, London; 1969. ISBN 13: 978–0226036984
- Nilsson LO: Interaction between microclimate and concrete a prerequisite for deterioration. Constr Build Mater 1996,10(5):301–308. CrossRef
- Giovanni V, Susanne Heidi P, Patrizia F, Serena Di G, Maria Pia S: Microclimate Monitoring in the Carcer Tullianum: Temporal and Spatial Correlation and Gradients Evidenced by Multivariate Analysis; First Campaign. Chem. Cent. J 2012,6(Suppl 2):S11. 1–17
- UNI 10586–1997: Condizioni climatiche per ambienti di conservazione di documenti grafici e caratteristiche degli alloggiamenti. Ente Nazionale Italiano di Unificazione, Rome; 1997.
- UNI 10829–1999: Beni di interesse storico artistico - Condizioni ambientali di conservazione – Misurazione ed analisi. Ente Nazionale Italiano di Unificazione, Rome; 1999.
- UNI 10969–2002: Beni culturali - Principi generali per la scelta e il controllo del microclima per la conservazione dei beni culturali in ambienti interni. Ente Nazionale Italiano di Unificazione, Rome; 2002.
- UNI 11120–2004: Beni culturali - Misurazione in campo della temperatura dell’aria e della superficie dei manufatti. Ente Nazionale Italiano di Unificazione, Rome; 2004.
- UNI 11131–2005: Beni culturali - Misurazione in campo dell’umidità dell’aria. Ente Nazionale Italiano di Unificazione, Rome; 2005.
- EN 15758:2010: Committee CEN/TC 346 - Conservation of cultural property. Procedures and instruments for measuring temperatures of the air and the surfaces of objects. European Committee For Standardization, Brussels; 2010.
- EN 15757:2010: Conservation of Cultural Property - Specifications for temperature and relative humidity to limit climate- induced mechanical damage inorganic hygroscopic materials. European Committee For Standardization, Brussels; 2010.
- EN 15759–1:2011; Committee CEN/TC 346: Conservation of cultural property - Indoor climate - Part 1: Guidelines for heating churches, chapels and other places of worship. European Committee For Standardization, Brussels; 2011.
- García-Diego F-J, Zarzo M: Microclimate monitoring by multivariate statistical control: The renaissance frescoes of the Cathedral of Valencia (Spain). J Cult Herit 2010,11(3):339–344. CrossRef
- Karner DB, Lombardi L, Marra F, Fortini P, Renne PR: Age of Ancient Monuments by Means of Building Stone Provenance: a Case Study of the Tullianum, Rome, Italy. J Archaeol Sci 2001,28(4):387–393. CrossRef
- Volta3D, Carcer-Tullianum, Mamertino, Foro Romano, Roma Virtual. http://archeoroma.beniculturali.it/carcer-tullianum/ accessed at jan. 2012 (unfortunately in FlashPlayer)
- Fortini P: Carcer tullianum il carcere mamertino al Foro romano. Mondadori Electa Ed, Rome; 1998. ISBN 8843566237.
- Hammer Ø, Harper DAT, Ryan PD: PAST: Paleontological Statistics Software Package for Education and Data Analysis. Palaeontol Electron 2001,4(1):9–19.
- Massart DL, Smeyers-Verbeke J, Caprona X, Schlesierb K: Visual Presentation of Data by Means of Box Plots. LC-GC Europe 2005,18(4):215–218.
- Cadima J, Jolliffe I: On Relationships Between Uncentred And Column-Centred Principal Component Analysis. Pak J Statist 2009,25(4):473–503.
- Brimblecombe P: The Composition Of Museum Atmospheres. Atmos Environ 1990,24b(1):1–8.
- Brimblecombe P, Lankester P: The impact of future climate on historic interiors. Sci Total Environ 2012, 417–418:248–254.
- Cataldo R, Leucci G, Siviero S, Pagiotti R, Angelini P: Diagnostic of the conservation state in the crypt of the Abbey of Montecorona: biological, microclimatic and geophysical evaluations. J Geophys Eng 2009,6(3):205–220. CrossRef
- La Gennusa M, Lascari G, Rizzo G, Scaccianoce G: Conflicting needs of the thermal indoor environment of museums: In search of a practical compromise. J Cult Herit 2008,9(2):125–134. CrossRef
- Dionisi P-Vici P, De Vincenzi M, Uzielli L: An analytical method for the determination of the climatic distance between different microclimates for the conservation of wooden cultural heritage objects. Stud Conserv 2011, 56:41–57.
- Second campaign of microclimate monitoring in the carcer tullianum: temporal and spatial correlation and gradients evidenced by multivariate analysis
- Open Access
- Available under Open Access This content is freely available online to anyone, anywhere at any time.
Chemistry Central Journal
- Online Date
- September 2012
- Online ISSN
- Chemistry Central
- Additional Links
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Rome University, La Sapienza, Math. Phy. Nat. Science Faculty, Piazzale A.Moro 5, 00185, Rome, Italy
- 2. Cultural Heritage Superintendence of Rome City Council, Pz. Lovatelli 35, 00185, Rome, Italy