Hepatitis B virus infected physicians and disclosure of transmission risks to patients: A critical analysis
The potential for transmission of blood-borne pathogens such as hepatitis B virus from infected healthcare workers to patients is an important and difficult issue facing healthcare policymakers internationally. Law and policy on the subject is still in its infancy, and subject to a great degree of uncertainty and controversy. Policymakers have made few recommendations regarding the specifics of practice restriction for health care workers who are hepatitis B seropositive. Generally, they have deferred this work to vaguely defined "expert panels" which will have the power to dictate the conditions under which infected health care workers may continue to practice.
In this paper we use recent Canadian policy statements as a critical departure point to propose more specific recommendations regarding disclosure of transmission risks in a way that minimizes practice restriction of hepatitis B seropositive health care workers without compromising patient safety. The range of arguments proposed in the literature are critically examined from the perspective of ethical analysis.
A process for considering the ethical implications of the disclosure of the sero-status of health care workers is advanced that considers the varied perspectives of different stakeholders.
- Gostin, LO (2000) A proposed national policy on health care workers living with HIV/AIDS and other blood-borne pathogens. JAMA 284: pp. 1965-2970 CrossRef
- Ristinen, E, Mamtani, R (1998) Ethics of transmission of hepatitis B virus by health-care workers. Lancet 352: pp. 1381-1383 CrossRef
- Tereskerz, PM, Pearson, RD, Jagger, J (1999) Infected physicians and invasive procedures: national policy and legal reality. Milbank Q 77: pp. 511-529 CrossRef
- Blatchford, O, O'Brien, SJ, Blatchford, M, Taylor, A (2000) Infectious health care workers: should patients be told?. J Med Ethics 26: pp. 27-33 CrossRef
- Daniels, N (1995) Seeking Fair Treatment: From the AIDS Epidemic to National Health Care Reform. Oxford University Press, New York
- Murphy, T (1994) Health care workers with HIV and a patient's right to know. J Med Phil 19: pp. 553-569
- Flanagan, W (1993) AIDS-related risks in the health care setting: HIV testing of health care workers and patients. Queen's Law Journal 18: pp. 71-128
- Logan, MK (1995) Who's afraid of whom? Courts require HIV-infected doctors to obtain informed consent of patients. DePaul Law Review 44: pp. 483-511
- De Ville, KA (1994) Nothing to fear but fear itself: HIV-infected physicians and the law of informed consent. J Law Med Ethics 22: pp. 163-175 CrossRef
- Karrel, AI (1995) HIV-infected physicians: how best to protect the public?. CMAJ 152: pp. 1059-1062
- Hoey, J (1998) When the physician is the vector [editorial]. CMAJ 159: pp. 45-46
- Glantz, LH, Mariner, WK, Annas, GJ (1992) Risky business: setting public health policy for HIV-infected health care professionals. Milbank Q 70: pp. 43-79 CrossRef
- Gostin, L (1990) The HIV-infected health care professional: public policy, discrimination, and patient safety. Law Med Health Care 18: pp. 303-310
- Barnes, M, Rango, NA, Burke, GR, Chiarello, L (1990) The HIV-infected health care professional: employment policies and public health. Law Med Health Care 18: pp. 311-330
- Lo, B, Steinbrook, R (1992) Health care workers infected with the human immunodeficiency virus: the next steps. JAMA 267: pp. 1100-1105 CrossRef
- Mahoney, FJ (1999) Update on diagnosis, management, and prevention of hepatitis B virus infection. Clin Microbiol Rev 12: pp. 351-366
- Proceedings of the Consensus Conference on Infected Health Care Workers: Risk for Transmission of Bloodborne Pathogens. In: Laboratory Centre for Disease Control, Health Canada; 1998.
- Transmission of hepatitis B to patients from four infected surgeons without hepatitis B e antigen. The Incident Investigation Teams and others. New England Journal of Medicine 1997, 336:178–184.
- McQuillan, GM, Coleman, PJ, Kruszon-Moran, D, Moyer, LA, Lambert, SB, Margolis, HS (1999) Prevalence of hepatitis B virus infection in the United States:The National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys, 1976 through 1994. Am J Public Health 89: pp. 14-18
- Lemon, S, Thomas, D (1997) Vaccines to prevent viral hepatitis. N Eng J Med 336: pp. 196-204 CrossRef
- Bain, VG, Ma, M Acute viral hepatitis. In: Thomson, ABR, Shaffer, EA eds. (1997) First principles of gastroenterology, the basis of disease and an approach to management Edited by Thomson ABR, Shaffer EA. pp. 479–492. Canadian Association of Gastroenterology;, Edmonton, pp. 479-492
- Prevention of transmission of hepatitis B. CMAJ 159: pp. 71-76
- From the Centers for Disease Control: recommendations for preventing transmission of human immunodeficiency virus, hepatitis B virus to patients during exposure-prone invasive procedures. JAMA 1991, 266:771–776.
- Picard, E, Robertson, G (1996) Legal liability of doctors and hospitals in Canada. Carswell, Scarborough
- Beauchamp, TL, Childress, JF (1996) Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Oxford University Press, New York
- Pinching, AJ (2000) Commentary. Infectious health care workers: should patients be told?. J Med Ethics 26: pp. 34-36 CrossRef
- Slovenko, R (1994) Informed consent: information about the physician. Medicine and Law 13: pp. 467-472
- Behringer Estate v. Princeton Medical Center. In: A. 2d, vol. 592. pp. 1251: N.J. Superior Court; 1991, 1251.
- The APIC statement on purposes for and elements of patient notification programs related to the health care worker infected with the human immunodeficiency virus or the hepatitis B "e" antigen. American Journal of Infection Control 19: pp. 30A-33A CrossRef
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6939/2/4/prepub
- Hepatitis B virus infected physicians and disclosure of transmission risks to patients: A critical analysis
- Open Access
- Available under Open Access This content is freely available online to anyone, anywhere at any time.
BMC Medical Ethics
- Online Date
- October 2001
- Online ISSN
- BioMed Central
- Additional Links
- Author Affiliations
- 1. PGY-1 McGill University, Faculty of Medicine, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
- 2. Department of Humanities and Languages, University of New Brunswick, Hazen Hall, Room 104, Saint John, New Brunswick, E2L 4L5, Canada
- 3. Primary Care Research Unit, Sunnybrook and Women's College Health Sciences Centre, Department of Family and Community Medicine and Public Health Sciences and Joint Centre for Bioethics, University of Toronto, 2075 Bay view Avenue – A 100, Toronto, Ontario, M4N 3M5, Canada