Does reflection have an effect upon case-solving abilities of undergraduate medical students?
Reflection on professional experience is increasingly accepted as a critical attribute for health care practice; however, evidence that it has a positive impact on performance remains scarce. This study investigated whether, after allowing for the effects of knowledge and consultation skills, reflection had an independent effect on students’ ability to solve problem cases.
Data was collected from 362 undergraduate medical students at Ghent University solving video cases and reflected on the experience of doing so. For knowledge and consultation skills results on a progress test and a course teaching consultation skills were used respectively. Stepwise multiple linear regression analysis was used to test the relationship between the quality of case-solving (dependent variable) and reflection skills, knowledge, and consultation skills (dependent variables).
Only students with data on all variables available (n = 270) were included for analysis. The model was significant (Anova F(3,269) = 11.00, p < 0.001, adjusted R square 0.10) with all variables significantly contributing.
Medical students’ reflection had a small but significant effect on case-solving, which supports reflection as an attribute for performance. These findings suggest that it would be worthwhile testing the effect of reflection skills training on clinical competence.
- Boud D, Keogh R, Walker D: Reflection: Turning experience into learning. Kogan Page, London; 1985.
- Atkins S, Murphy K: Reflection - A Review of the Literature. J Adv Nurs 1993,18(8):1188–1192. CrossRef
- Sandars J: The use of reflection in medical education: AMEE Guide No. 44. Medical Teacher 2009,31(8):685–695. CrossRef
- Koole S, Dornan T, Aper L, Scherpbier A, Valcke M, Cohen-Schotanus J, Cohen-Schotanus J, Derese A: Factors confounding the assessment of reflection: a critical review. BMC Med Educ 2011, 11:104. CrossRef
- Schön DA: The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action. Basic Books, New York; 1983.
- Epstein RM, Hundert EM: Defining and assessing professional competence. JAMA 2002, 287:226–235. CrossRef
- Robertson K: Reflection in professional practice and education. Aust Fam Physician 2005,34(9):781–783.
- Kjaer NK, Maagaard R, Wied S: Using an online portfolio in postgraduate training. Medical Teacher 2006,28(8):708–712. CrossRef
- Scottish Deans’ Medical Curriculum Group: Learning Outcomes for the Medical Undergraduate in Scotland: A Foundation for Competent and Reflective Practitioners. 3rd edition. 2007. http://www.scottishdoctor.org/resources/scottishdoctor3.doc [accessed January 17th 2011
- General Medical Council: Tomorrow’s Doctors. GMC, London; 2009. http://www.gmc-uk.org/TomorrowsDoctors_2009.pdf_39260971.pdf [accessed October 28th 2010]
- Dutch Federation of University Medical Centres: The 2009 framework for undergraduate medical education in the Netherlands. http://www.nfu.nl/fileadmin/documents/Raamplan2009engelstalige_versie.pdf [accessed January 17th 2011
- Lockyer J, Gondocz ST, Thivierge RL: Knowledge translation: the role and place of practice reflection. J Contin Educ Health Prof 2004,24(1):50–56. CrossRef
- Plack MM, Greenberg L: The Reflective Practitioner: Reaching for Excellence in Practice. Pediatrics 2005,116(6):1546–1552. CrossRef
- Evans AW, McKenna C, Oliver M: Self-assessment in medical practice. J R Soc Med 2002,95(10):511–513. CrossRef
- Mann K, Gordon J, MacLeod A: Reflection and reflective practice in health professions education: a systematic review. Advances in Health Sciences Education 2009,14(4):595–621. CrossRef
- Mamede S, Schmidt HG: The structure of reflective practice in medicine. Medical Education 2004,38(12):1302–1308. CrossRef
- Boenink AD, Oderwald AK, de Jonge P, van Tilburg W, Smal JA: Assessing student reflection in medical practice. The development of an observer-rated instrument: reliability, validity and initial experiences. Medical Education 2004,38(4):368–377. CrossRef
- Sobral DT: An appraisal of medical students' reflection-in-learning. Medical Education 2000,34(3):182–187. CrossRef
- Sargeant JM, Mann KV, van der Vleuten CP, Metsemakers JF: Reflection: a link between receiving and using assessment feedback. Advances in Health Sciences Education 2009,14(3):399–410. CrossRef
- Sargeant J, Mann K, Sinclair D, van der Vleuten C, Metsemakers J: Understanding the influence of emotions and reflection upon multi-source feedback acceptance and use. Advances in Health Sciences Education 2008,13(3):275–288. CrossRef
- Sobral DT: Medical students' reflection in learning in relation to approaches to study and academic achievement. Medical Teacher 2001,23(5):508–513.
- Mattick K, Dennis I, Bradley P, Bligh J: Content specificity: is it the full story? Statistical modelling of a clinical skills examination. Medical Education 2008,42(6):589–599. CrossRef
- Wimmers PF, Fung CC: The impact of case specificity and generalisable skills on clinical performance: a correlated traits-correlated methods approach. Medical Education 2008,42(6):580–588. CrossRef
- Van der Veken J, Valcke M, De Maeseneer J, Schuwirth L, Derese A: Impact on knowledge acquisition of the transition from a conventional to an integrated contextual medical curriculum. Medical Education 2009,43(7):704–713. CrossRef
- de Leng BA, Dolmans DHJM, van de Wiel MWJ, Muijtjens AMM, van der Vleuten CPM: How video cases should be used as authentic stimuli in problem-based medical education. Medical Education 2007,41(2):181–188. CrossRef
- Hayes AF, Krippendorff K: Answering the Call for a Standard Reliability Measure for Coding Data. Communication Methods and Measures 2007,1(1):77–89. CrossRef
- Moon JA: Reflection in learning and professional development: theory and practice. Kogan Page, London; 1999.
- Koole S, Dornan T, Aper L, De Wever B, Scherpbier A, Valcke M, Cohen-Schotanus J, Derese A: Using video-cases to assess student reflection: Development and validation of an instrument. BMC Med Educ 2012, 12:22. CrossRef
- Popham WJ: What's wrong–and what's right–with rubrics. Educational Leadership 1997,55(2):72–75.
- Andrade HG: Using rubrics to promote thinking and learning. Educational Leadership 2000,57(5):13–18.
- van der Vleuten CPM, Schuwirth LWT, Muijtjens AMM, Thoben AJNM, Cohen-Schotanus J, Van Boven CPA: Cross institutional collaboration in assessment: a case on progress testing. Medical Teacher 2004,26(8):719–725. CrossRef
- Albano MG, Cavallo F, Hoogenboom R, Magni F, Majoor G, Manenti F, Schuwirth L, Stiegler I, vanderVleuten C: An international comparison of knowledge levels of medical students: The Maastricht Progress Test. Medical Education 1996,30(4):239–245. CrossRef
- Korthagen F, Vasalos A: Levels in reflection: core reflection as a means to enhance professional growth. Teachers and Teaching: theory and practice 2005,11(1):47–71. CrossRef
- Bourner T: Assessing reflective learning. Education + Training 2003,45(5):267–272. CrossRef
- Mezirow J and Associates: Learning as Transformation: Critical Perspectives on a Theory in Progress. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco; 2000.
- Wass V, Van der Vleuten C, Shatzer J, Jones R: Assessment of clinical competence. Lancet 2001,24(357):945–949. CrossRef
- Desmedt E: Research into the Theoretical Base of Learning Styles in View of Educational Applications in a University Setting. PhD thesis, Ghent University; 2008.
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6920/12/75/prepub
- Does reflection have an effect upon case-solving abilities of undergraduate medical students?
- Open Access
- Available under Open Access This content is freely available online to anyone, anywhere at any time.
BMC Medical Education
- Online Date
- August 2012
- Online ISSN
- BioMed Central
- Additional Links
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Centre for Educational Development, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium
- 2. Department of Educational Development and Research, Faculty of Health, Medicine and Life Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands
- 3. Institute for Medical Education, Faculty of Health, Medicine and Life Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands
- 4. Department of Educational Studies, Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium
- 5. Centre for Research and Innovation in Medical Education, University of Groningen and University Medical Centre Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands