The European Physical Journal C

, Volume 68, Issue 1, pp 119–123

Comments and Reply on: “Study of multi-muon events produced in \(p\bar{p}\) interactions at \(\sqrt{s}=1.96\) TeV”; T. Aaltonen et al. (The CDF Collaboration)

Authors

    • MPI für Physik
  • T. Aaltonen
    • Division of High Energy Physics, Department of PhysicsUniversity of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
  • J. Adelman
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • B. Álvarez González
    • Instituto de Fisica de CantabriaCSIC-University of Cantabria
  • S. Amerio
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareUniversity of Padova
  • D. Amidei
    • University of Michigan
  • A. Anastassov
    • Northwestern University
  • J. Antos
    • Comenius University
    • Institute of Experimental Physics
  • G. Apollinari
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • A. Apresyan
    • Purdue University
  • T. Arisawa
    • Waseda University
  • A. Artikov
    • Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
  • W. Ashmanskas
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • P. Azzurri
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaScuola Normale Superiore
  • W. Badgett
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • B. A. Barnett
    • The Johns Hopkins University
  • V. Bartsch
    • University College London
  • D. Beecher
    • University College London
  • S. Behari
    • The Johns Hopkins University
  • G. Bellettini
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Pisa
  • D. Benjamin
    • Duke University
  • D. Bisello
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareUniversity of Padova
  • I. Bizjak
    • University College London
  • C. Blocker
    • Brandeis University
  • B. Blumenfeld
    • The Johns Hopkins University
  • A. Bocci
    • Duke University
  • V. Boisvert
    • University of Rochester
  • G. Bolla
    • Purdue University
  • D. Bortoletto
    • Purdue University
  • J. Boudreau
    • University of Pittsburgh
  • A. Bridgeman
    • University of Illinois
  • L. Brigliadori
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
  • C. Bromberg
    • Michigan State University
  • E. Brubaker
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • J. Budagov
    • Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
  • H. S. Budd
    • University of Rochester
  • S. Budd
    • University of Illinois
  • S. Burke
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • K. Burkett
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • G. Busetto
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareUniversity of Padova
  • P. Bussey
    • Glasgow University
  • K. L. Byrum
    • Argonne National Laboratory
  • S. Cabrera
    • Duke University
  • C. Calancha
    • Centro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
  • M. Campanelli
    • Michigan State University
  • F. Canelli
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • B. Carls
    • University of Illinois
  • R. Carosi
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
  • S. Carrillo
    • University of Florida
  • B. Casal
    • Instituto de Fisica de CantabriaCSIC-University of Cantabria
  • M. Casarsa
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • A. Castro
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare BolognaUniversity of Bologna
  • P. Catastini
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Siena
  • D. Cauz
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
    • University of Trieste/Udine
  • V. Cavaliere
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Siena
  • S. H. Chang
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • Y. C. Chen
    • Institute of PhysicsAcademia Sinica
  • M. Chertok
    • University of California
  • G. Chiarelli
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
  • G. Chlachidze
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • K. Cho
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • D. Chokheli
    • Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
  • J. P. Chou
    • Harvard University
  • K. Chung
    • Carnegie Mellon University
  • Y. S. Chung
    • University of Rochester
  • C. I. Ciobanu
    • LPNHEUniversite Pierre et Marie Curie/IN2P3-CNRS, UMR7585
  • M. A. Ciocci
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Siena
  • A. Clark
    • University of Geneva
  • D. Clark
    • Brandeis University
  • G. Compostella
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
  • M. E. Convery
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • J. Conway
    • University of California
  • M. Cordelli
    • Laboratori Nazionali di FrascatiIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
  • G. Cortiana
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareUniversity of Padova
  • C. A. Cox
    • University of California
  • D. J. Cox
    • University of California
  • F. Crescioli
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Pisa
  • C. Cuenca Almenar
    • University of California
  • J. Cuevas
    • Instituto de Fisica de CantabriaCSIC-University of Cantabria
  • J. C. Cully
    • University of Michigan
  • D. Dagenhart
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • M. Datta
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • T. Davies
    • Glasgow University
  • P. de Barbaro
    • University of Rochester
  • M. Dell’Orso
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Pisa
  • L. Demortier
    • The Rockefeller University
  • J. Deng
    • Duke University
  • M. Deninno
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
  • G. P. di Giovanni
    • LPNHEUniversite Pierre et Marie Curie/IN2P3-CNRS, UMR7585
  • B. Di Ruzza
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
    • University of Trieste/Udine
  • J. R. Dittmann
    • Baylor University
  • S. Donati
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Pisa
  • J. Donini
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
  • T. Dorigo
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
  • J. Efron
    • The Ohio State University
  • R. Erbacher
    • University of California
  • D. Errede
    • University of Illinois
  • S. Errede
    • University of Illinois
  • R. Eusebi
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • W. T. Fedorko
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • J. P. Fernandez
    • Centro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
  • R. Field
    • University of Florida
  • G. Flanagan
    • Purdue University
  • R. Forrest
    • University of California
  • M. J. Frank
    • Baylor University
  • M. Franklin
    • Harvard University
  • J. C. Freeman
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • I. Furic
    • University of Florida
  • M. Gallinaro
    • The Rockefeller University
  • J. Galyardt
    • Carnegie Mellon University
  • F. Garberson
    • University of California
  • J. E. Garcia
    • University of Geneva
  • A. F. Garfinkel
    • Purdue University
  • K. Genser
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • H. Gerberich
    • University of Illinois
  • D. Gerdes
    • University of Michigan
  • V. Giakoumopoulou
    • University of Athens
  • P. Giannetti
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
  • K. Gibson
    • University of Pittsburgh
  • J. L. Gimmell
    • University of Rochester
  • C. M. Ginsburg
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • N. Giokaris
    • University of Athens
  • M. Giordani
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
    • University of Trieste/Udine
  • P. Giromini
    • Laboratori Nazionali di FrascatiIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
  • G. Giurgiu
    • The Johns Hopkins University
  • V. Glagolev
    • Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
  • D. Glenzinski
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • N. Goldschmidt
    • University of Florida
  • A. Golossanov
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • G. Gomez
    • Instituto de Fisica de CantabriaCSIC-University of Cantabria
  • M. Goncharov
    • Massachusetts Institute of Technology
  • O. González
    • Centro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
  • I. Gorelov
    • Harvard University
  • A. T. Goshaw
    • Duke University
  • K. Goulianos
    • The Rockefeller University
  • A. Gresele
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareUniversity of Padova
  • S. Grinstein
    • Harvard University
  • J. Guimaraes da Costa
    • Harvard University
  • Z. Gunay-Unalan
    • Michigan State University
  • K. Hahn
    • Massachusetts Institute of Technology
  • S. R. Hahn
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • B.-Y. Han
    • University of Rochester
  • J. Y. Han
    • University of Rochester
  • F. Happacher
    • Laboratori Nazionali di FrascatiIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
  • M. Hare
    • Tufts University
  • R. M. Harris
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • M. Hartz
    • University of Pittsburgh
  • K. Hatakeyama
    • The Rockefeller University
  • S. Hewamanage
    • Baylor University
  • D. Hidas
    • Duke University
  • C. S. Hill
    • University of California
  • A. Hocker
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • S. Hou
    • Institute of PhysicsAcademia Sinica
  • R. E. Hughes
    • The Ohio State University
  • J. Huston
    • Michigan State University
  • J. Incandela
    • University of California
  • A. Ivanov
    • University of California
  • E. J. Jeon
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • M. K. Jha
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
  • S. Jindariani
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • W. Johnson
    • University of California
  • M. Jones
    • Purdue University
  • K. K. Joo
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • S. Y. Jun
    • Carnegie Mellon University
  • J. E. Jung
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • D. Kar
    • University of Florida
  • Y. Kato
    • Osaka City University
  • B. Kilminster
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • D. H. Kim
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • H. S. Kim
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • H. W. Kim
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • J. E. Kim
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • M. J. Kim
    • Laboratori Nazionali di FrascatiIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
  • S. B. Kim
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • Y. K. Kim
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • L. Kirsch
    • Brandeis University
  • S. Klimenko
    • University of Florida
  • B. Knuteson
    • Massachusetts Institute of Technology
  • B. R. Ko
    • Duke University
  • D. J. Kong
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • J. Konigsberg
    • University of Florida
  • A. Korytov
    • University of Florida
  • D. Krop
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • N. Krumnack
    • Baylor University
  • M. Kruse
    • Duke University
  • V. Krutelyov
    • University of California
  • N. P. Kulkarni
    • Wayne State University
  • Y. Kusakabe
    • Waseda University
  • S. Kwang
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • A. T. Laasanen
    • Purdue University
  • S. Lami
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
  • R. L. Lander
    • University of California
  • K. Lannon
    • The Ohio State University
  • G. Latino
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Siena
  • I. Lazzizzera
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareUniversity of Padova
  • H. S. Lee
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • S. Leone
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
  • M. Lindgren
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • A. Lister
    • University of California
  • D. O. Litvintsev
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • M. Loreti
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareUniversity of Padova
  • L. Lovas
    • Comenius University
    • Institute of Experimental Physics
  • D. Lucchesi
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareUniversity of Padova
  • P. Lukens
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • G. Lungu
    • The Rockefeller University
  • R. Lysak
    • Comenius University
    • Institute of Experimental Physics
  • R. Madrak
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • K. Maeshima
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • K. Makhoul
    • Massachusetts Institute of Technology
  • T. Maki
    • Division of High Energy Physics, Department of PhysicsUniversity of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
  • P. Maksimovic
    • The Johns Hopkins University
  • A. Manousakis-Katsikakis
    • University of Athens
  • F. Margaroli
    • Purdue University
  • C. P. Marino
    • University of Illinois
  • V. Martin
    • Glasgow University
  • R. Martínez-Ballarín
    • Centro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
  • M. Mathis
    • The Johns Hopkins University
  • P. Mazzanti
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
  • P. Mehtala
    • Division of High Energy Physics, Department of PhysicsUniversity of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
  • P. Merkel
    • Purdue University
  • C. Mesropian
    • The Rockefeller University
  • T. Miao
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • N. Miladinovic
    • Brandeis University
  • R. Miller
    • Michigan State University
  • C. Mills
    • Harvard University
  • A. Mitra
    • Institute of PhysicsAcademia Sinica
  • G. Mitselmakher
    • University of Florida
  • N. Moggi
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
  • C. S. Moon
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • R. Moore
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • A. Mukherjee
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • R. Mumford
    • The Johns Hopkins University
  • M. Mussini
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare BolognaUniversity of Bologna
  • J. Nachtman
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • I. Nakano
    • Okayama University
  • A. Napier
    • Tufts University
  • V. Necula
    • Duke University
  • O. Norniella
    • University of Illinois
  • E. Nurse
    • University College London
  • S. H. Oh
    • Duke University
  • Y. D. Oh
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • I. Oksuzian
    • University of Florida
  • T. Okusawa
    • Osaka City University
  • R. Orava
    • Division of High Energy Physics, Department of PhysicsUniversity of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
  • S. Pagan Griso
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareSezione di Padova-Trento
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica NucleareUniversity of Padova
  • E. Palencia
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • V. Papadimitriou
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • A. A. Paramonov
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • B. Parks
    • The Ohio State University
  • G. Pauletta
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
    • University of Trieste/Udine
  • M. Paulini
    • Carnegie Mellon University
  • D. E. Pellett
    • University of California
  • A. Penzo
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
  • T. J. Phillips
    • Duke University
  • G. Piacentino
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
  • L. Pinera
    • University of Florida
  • K. Pitts
    • University of Illinois
  • O. Poukhov
    • Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
  • F. Prakoshyn
    • Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
  • A. Pronko
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • F. Ptohos
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • E. Pueschel
    • Carnegie Mellon University
  • A. Rahaman
    • University of Pittsburgh
  • N. Ranjan
    • Purdue University
  • I. Redondo
    • Centro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
  • V. Rekovic
    • University of New Mexico
  • F. Rimondi
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare BolognaUniversity of Bologna
  • A. Robson
    • Glasgow University
  • T. Rodrigo
    • Instituto de Fisica de CantabriaCSIC-University of Cantabria
  • E. Rogers
    • University of Illinois
  • S. Rolli
    • Tufts University
  • R. Roser
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • M. Rossi
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
  • R. Rossin
    • University of California
  • A. Ruiz
    • Instituto de Fisica de CantabriaCSIC-University of Cantabria
  • J. Russ
    • Carnegie Mellon University
  • V. Rusu
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • W. K. Sakumoto
    • University of Rochester
  • L. Santi
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
    • University of Trieste/Udine
  • K. Sato
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • A. Savoy-Navarro
    • LPNHEUniversite Pierre et Marie Curie/IN2P3-CNRS, UMR7585
  • P. Schlabach
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • E. E. Schmidt
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • M. A. Schmidt
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • M. Schmitt
    • Northwestern University
  • T. Schwarz
    • University of California
  • L. Scodellaro
    • Instituto de Fisica de CantabriaCSIC-University of Cantabria
  • A. Sedov
    • Purdue University
  • S. Seidel
    • University of New Mexico
  • Y. Seiya
    • Osaka City University
  • A. Semenov
    • Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
  • L. Sexton-Kennedy
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • F. Sforza
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
  • A. Sfyrla
    • University of Illinois
  • S. Z. Shalhout
    • Wayne State University
  • S. Shiraishi
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • M. Shochet
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • A. Sidoti
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
  • A. Sisakyan
    • Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
  • A. J. Slaughter
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • J. Slaunwhite
    • The Ohio State University
  • K. Sliwa
    • Tufts University
  • J. R. Smith
    • University of California
  • A. Soha
    • University of California
  • V. Sorin
    • Michigan State University
  • P. Squillacioti
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Siena
  • R. St. Denis
    • Glasgow University
  • D. Stentz
    • Northwestern University
  • J. Strologas
    • University of New Mexico
  • G. L. Strycker
    • University of Michigan
  • J. S. Suh
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • A. Sukhanov
    • University of Florida
  • I. Suslov
    • Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
  • R. Takashima
    • Okayama University
  • R. Tanaka
    • Okayama University
  • M. Tecchio
    • University of Michigan
  • P. K. Teng
    • Institute of PhysicsAcademia Sinica
  • K. Terashi
    • The Rockefeller University
  • J. Thom
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • A. S. Thompson
    • Glasgow University
  • G. A. Thompson
    • University of Illinois
  • P. Ttito-Guzmán
    • Centro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
  • S. Tokar
    • Comenius University
    • Institute of Experimental Physics
  • K. Tollefson
    • Michigan State University
  • S. Torre
    • Laboratori Nazionali di FrascatiIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
  • D. Torretta
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • P. Totaro
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
    • University of Trieste/Udine
  • S. Tourneur
    • LPNHEUniversite Pierre et Marie Curie/IN2P3-CNRS, UMR7585
  • M. Trovato
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
  • S.-Y. Tsai
    • Institute of PhysicsAcademia Sinica
  • S. Vallecorsa
    • University of Geneva
  • N. van Remortel
    • Division of High Energy Physics, Department of PhysicsUniversity of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
  • A. Varganov
    • University of Michigan
  • E. Vataga
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaScuola Normale Superiore
  • F. Vázquez
    • University of Florida
  • G. Velev
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • C. Vellidis
    • University of Athens
  • V. Veszpremi
    • Purdue University
  • M. Vidal
    • Centro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
  • R. Vidal
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • I. Vila
    • Instituto de Fisica de CantabriaCSIC-University of Cantabria
  • R. Vilar
    • Instituto de Fisica de CantabriaCSIC-University of Cantabria
  • T. Vine
    • University College London
  • M. Vogel
    • University of New Mexico
  • G. Volpi
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaUniversity of Pisa
  • R. G. Wagner
    • Argonne National Laboratory
  • R. L. Wagner
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • T. Wakisaka
    • Osaka City University
  • S. M. Wang
    • Institute of PhysicsAcademia Sinica
  • B. Whitehouse
    • Tufts University
  • E. Wicklund
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • S. Wilbur
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • P. Wittich
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • S. Wolbers
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • C. Wolfe
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • T. Wright
    • University of Michigan
  • X. Wu
    • University of Geneva
  • K. Yamamoto
    • Osaka City University
  • U. K. Yang
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • Y. C. Yang
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • K. Yorita
    • Enrico Fermi InstituteUniversity of Chicago
  • T. Yoshida
    • Osaka City University
  • G. B. Yu
    • University of Rochester
  • I. Yu
    • Center for High Energy PhysicsKyungpook National University
    • Seoul National University
    • Sungkyunkwan University
    • Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information
    • Chonnam National University
  • S. S. Yu
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • J. C. Yun
    • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
  • A. Zanetti
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
  • X. Zhang
    • University of Illinois
  • S. Zucchelli
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
    • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare BolognaUniversity of Bologna
Open AccessComments and Reply

DOI: 10.1140/epjc/s10052-010-1337-z

Abstract

The European Physical Journal C—Particles and Fields—publishes scientific manuscripts of relevance to the scientific community following careful and strict peer reviewing and, whenever appropriate and necessary, through discussion with the authors, so as to optimise scientific content and style of presentation prior to publication. In some cases significant disagreement between authors and referees (and/or editors) of the journal cannot be resolved despite all efforts and best of intentions. While the journal—notwithstanding any appeals—retains the right to reject such manuscripts, the editors of this journal may decide, in cases deemed of exceptional interest and potential significance for the field, to accept the manuscript for publication, to amend it by “comments” of the editor(s) in charge and, if appropriate, by a “reply” of the authors of the commented manuscript.

The present comment is on “Study of multi-muon events produced in \(p\bar{p}\) interactions at \(\sqrt{s}=1.96\) TeV” by T. Aaltonen et al. (the CDF Collaboration, Eur. Phys. J. C, 2010, doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-010-1336-0).

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2010