Comments and Reply

The European Physical Journal C

, Volume 68, Issue 1, pp 119-123

Open Access This content is freely available online to anyone, anywhere at any time.

Comments and Reply on: “Study of multi-muon events produced in \(p\bar{p}\) interactions at \(\sqrt{s}=1.96\) TeV”; T. Aaltonen et al. (The CDF Collaboration)

  • Siegfried BethkeAffiliated withMPI für Physik Email author 
  • , T. AaltonenAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaDivision of High Energy Physics, Department of Physics, University of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
  • , J. AdelmanAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
  • , B. Álvarez GonzálezAffiliated withMPI für PhysikInstituto de Fisica de Cantabria, CSIC-University of Cantabria
  • , S. AmerioAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-TrentoIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, University of Padova
  • , D. AmideiAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of Michigan
  • , A. AnastassovAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryNorthwestern University
  • , J. AntosAffiliated withMPI für PhysikComenius UniversityInstitute of Experimental Physics
  • , G. ApollinariAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , A. ApresyanAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , T. ArisawaAffiliated withBaylor UniversityWaseda University
    • , A. ArtikovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikJoint Institute for Nuclear Research
    • , W. AshmanskasAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , P. AzzurriAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, Scuola Normale Superiore
    • , W. BadgettAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , B. A. BarnettAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaThe Johns Hopkins University
    • , V. BartschAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity College London
    • , D. BeecherAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity College London
    • , S. BehariAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaThe Johns Hopkins University
    • , G. BellettiniAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Pisa
    • , D. BenjaminAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , D. BiselloAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-TrentoIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, University of Padova
    • , I. BizjakAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity College London
    • , C. BlockerAffiliated withBrandeis University
    • , B. BlumenfeldAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaThe Johns Hopkins University
    • , A. BocciAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , V. BoisvertAffiliated withBaylor UniversityUniversity of Rochester
    • , G. BollaAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , D. BortolettoAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , J. BoudreauAffiliated withUniversity of AthensUniversity of Pittsburgh
    • , A. BridgemanAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , L. BrigliadoriAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-Trento
    • , C. BrombergAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMichigan State University
    • , E. BrubakerAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , J. BudagovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikJoint Institute for Nuclear Research
    • , H. S. BuddAffiliated withBaylor UniversityUniversity of Rochester
    • , S. BuddAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , S. BurkeAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , K. BurkettAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , G. BusettoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-TrentoIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, University of Padova
    • , P. BusseyAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaGlasgow University
    • , K. L. ByrumAffiliated withArgonne National Laboratory
    • , S. CabreraAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , C. CalanchaAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryCentro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
    • , M. CampanelliAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMichigan State University
    • , F. CanelliAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , B. CarlsAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , R. CarosiAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • , S. CarrilloAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , B. CasalAffiliated withMPI für PhysikInstituto de Fisica de Cantabria, CSIC-University of Cantabria
    • , M. CasarsaAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , A. CastroAffiliated withIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare BolognaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna, University of Bologna
    • , P. CatastiniAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Siena
    • , D. CauzAffiliated withBaylor UniversityIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/UdineUniversity of Trieste/Udine
    • , V. CavaliereAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Siena
    • , S. H. ChangAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , Y. C. ChenAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia Sinica
    • , M. ChertokAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , G. ChiarelliAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • , G. ChlachidzeAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , K. ChoAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , D. ChokheliAffiliated withMPI für PhysikJoint Institute for Nuclear Research
    • , J. P. ChouAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaHarvard University
    • , K. ChungAffiliated withMPI für PhysikCarnegie Mellon University
    • , Y. S. ChungAffiliated withBaylor UniversityUniversity of Rochester
    • , C. I. CiobanuAffiliated withUniversity of AthensLPNHE, Universite Pierre et Marie Curie/IN2P3-CNRS, UMR7585
    • , M. A. CiocciAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Siena
    • , A. ClarkAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Geneva
    • , D. ClarkAffiliated withBrandeis University
    • , G. CompostellaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-Trento
    • , M. E. ConveryAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , J. ConwayAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , M. CordelliAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaLaboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
    • , G. CortianaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-TrentoIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, University of Padova
    • , C. A. CoxAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , D. J. CoxAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , F. CrescioliAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Pisa
    • , C. Cuenca AlmenarAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , J. CuevasAffiliated withMPI für PhysikInstituto de Fisica de Cantabria, CSIC-University of Cantabria
    • , J. C. CullyAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of Michigan
    • , D. DagenhartAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , M. DattaAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , T. DaviesAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaGlasgow University
    • , P. de BarbaroAffiliated withBaylor UniversityUniversity of Rochester
    • , M. Dell’OrsoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Pisa
    • , L. DemortierAffiliated withBaylor UniversityThe Rockefeller University
    • , J. DengAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , M. DeninnoAffiliated withIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
    • , G. P. di GiovanniAffiliated withUniversity of AthensLPNHE, Universite Pierre et Marie Curie/IN2P3-CNRS, UMR7585
    • , B. Di RuzzaAffiliated withBaylor UniversityIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/UdineUniversity of Trieste/Udine
    • , J. R. DittmannAffiliated withBaylor University
    • , S. DonatiAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Pisa
    • , J. DoniniAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-Trento
    • , T. DorigoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-Trento
    • , J. EfronAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryThe Ohio State University
    • , R. ErbacherAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , D. ErredeAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , S. ErredeAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , R. EusebiAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , W. T. FedorkoAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , J. P. FernandezAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryCentro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
    • , R. FieldAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , G. FlanaganAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , R. ForrestAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , M. J. FrankAffiliated withBaylor University
    • , M. FranklinAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaHarvard University
    • , J. C. FreemanAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , I. FuricAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , M. GallinaroAffiliated withBaylor UniversityThe Rockefeller University
    • , J. GalyardtAffiliated withMPI für PhysikCarnegie Mellon University
    • , F. GarbersonAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of California
    • , J. E. GarciaAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Geneva
    • , A. F. GarfinkelAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , K. GenserAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , H. GerberichAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , D. GerdesAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of Michigan
    • , V. GiakoumopoulouAffiliated withUniversity of Athens
    • , P. GiannettiAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • , K. GibsonAffiliated withUniversity of AthensUniversity of Pittsburgh
    • , J. L. GimmellAffiliated withBaylor UniversityUniversity of Rochester
    • , C. M. GinsburgAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , N. GiokarisAffiliated withUniversity of Athens
    • , M. GiordaniAffiliated withBaylor UniversityIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/UdineUniversity of Trieste/Udine
    • , P. GirominiAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaLaboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
    • , G. GiurgiuAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaThe Johns Hopkins University
    • , V. GlagolevAffiliated withMPI für PhysikJoint Institute for Nuclear Research
    • , D. GlenzinskiAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , N. GoldschmidtAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , A. GolossanovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , G. GomezAffiliated withMPI für PhysikInstituto de Fisica de Cantabria, CSIC-University of Cantabria
    • , M. GoncharovAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMassachusetts Institute of Technology
    • , O. GonzálezAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryCentro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
    • , I. GorelovAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaHarvard University
    • , A. T. GoshawAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , K. GoulianosAffiliated withBaylor UniversityThe Rockefeller University
    • , A. GreseleAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-TrentoIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, University of Padova
    • , S. GrinsteinAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaHarvard University
    • , J. Guimaraes da CostaAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaHarvard University
    • , Z. Gunay-UnalanAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMichigan State University
    • , K. HahnAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMassachusetts Institute of Technology
    • , S. R. HahnAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , B.-Y. HanAffiliated withBaylor UniversityUniversity of Rochester
    • , J. Y. HanAffiliated withBaylor UniversityUniversity of Rochester
    • , F. HappacherAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaLaboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
    • , M. HareAffiliated withBaylor UniversityTufts University
    • , R. M. HarrisAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , M. HartzAffiliated withUniversity of AthensUniversity of Pittsburgh
    • , K. HatakeyamaAffiliated withBaylor UniversityThe Rockefeller University
    • , S. HewamanageAffiliated withBaylor University
    • , D. HidasAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , C. S. HillAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of California
    • , A. HockerAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , S. HouAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia Sinica
    • , R. E. HughesAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryThe Ohio State University
    • , J. HustonAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMichigan State University
    • , J. IncandelaAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of California
    • , A. IvanovAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , E. J. JeonAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , M. K. JhaAffiliated withIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
    • , S. JindarianiAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , W. JohnsonAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , M. JonesAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , K. K. JooAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , S. Y. JunAffiliated withMPI für PhysikCarnegie Mellon University
    • , J. E. JungAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , D. KarAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , Y. KatoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensOsaka City University
    • , B. KilminsterAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , D. H. KimAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , H. S. KimAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , H. W. KimAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , J. E. KimAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , M. J. KimAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaLaboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
    • , S. B. KimAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , Y. K. KimAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , L. KirschAffiliated withBrandeis University
    • , S. KlimenkoAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , B. KnutesonAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMassachusetts Institute of Technology
    • , B. R. KoAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , D. J. KongAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , J. KonigsbergAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , A. KorytovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , D. KropAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , N. KrumnackAffiliated withBaylor University
    • , M. KruseAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , V. KrutelyovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of California
    • , N. P. KulkarniAffiliated withBaylor UniversityWayne State University
    • , Y. KusakabeAffiliated withBaylor UniversityWaseda University
    • , S. KwangAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , A. T. LaasanenAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , S. LamiAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • , R. L. LanderAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , K. LannonAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryThe Ohio State University
    • , G. LatinoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Siena
    • , I. LazzizzeraAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-TrentoIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, University of Padova
    • , H. S. LeeAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , S. LeoneAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • , M. LindgrenAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , A. ListerAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , D. O. LitvintsevAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , M. LoretiAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-TrentoIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, University of Padova
    • , L. LovasAffiliated withMPI für PhysikComenius UniversityInstitute of Experimental Physics
    • , D. LucchesiAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-TrentoIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, University of Padova
    • , P. LukensAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , G. LunguAffiliated withBaylor UniversityThe Rockefeller University
    • , R. LysakAffiliated withMPI für PhysikComenius UniversityInstitute of Experimental Physics
    • , R. MadrakAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , K. MaeshimaAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , K. MakhoulAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMassachusetts Institute of Technology
    • , T. MakiAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaDivision of High Energy Physics, Department of Physics, University of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
    • , P. MaksimovicAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaThe Johns Hopkins University
    • , A. Manousakis-KatsikakisAffiliated withUniversity of Athens
    • , F. MargaroliAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , C. P. MarinoAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , V. MartinAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaGlasgow University
    • , R. Martínez-BallarínAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryCentro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
    • , M. MathisAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaThe Johns Hopkins University
    • , P. MazzantiAffiliated withIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
    • , P. MehtalaAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaDivision of High Energy Physics, Department of Physics, University of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
    • , P. MerkelAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , C. MesropianAffiliated withBaylor UniversityThe Rockefeller University
    • , T. MiaoAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , N. MiladinovicAffiliated withBrandeis University
    • , R. MillerAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMichigan State University
    • , C. MillsAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaHarvard University
    • , A. MitraAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia Sinica
    • , G. MitselmakherAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , N. MoggiAffiliated withIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna
    • , C. S. MoonAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , R. MooreAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , A. MukherjeeAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , R. MumfordAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaThe Johns Hopkins University
    • , M. MussiniAffiliated withIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare BolognaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna, University of Bologna
    • , J. NachtmanAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , I. NakanoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensOkayama University
    • , A. NapierAffiliated withBaylor UniversityTufts University
    • , V. NeculaAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , O. NorniellaAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , E. NurseAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity College London
    • , S. H. OhAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , Y. D. OhAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , I. OksuzianAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , T. OkusawaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensOsaka City University
    • , R. OravaAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaDivision of High Energy Physics, Department of Physics, University of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
    • , S. Pagan GrisoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Padova-TrentoIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, University of Padova
    • , E. PalenciaAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , V. PapadimitriouAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , A. A. ParamonovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , B. ParksAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryThe Ohio State University
    • , G. PaulettaAffiliated withBaylor UniversityIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/UdineUniversity of Trieste/Udine
    • , M. PauliniAffiliated withMPI für PhysikCarnegie Mellon University
    • , D. E. PellettAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , A. PenzoAffiliated withBaylor UniversityIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
    • , T. J. PhillipsAffiliated withMPI für PhysikDuke University
    • , G. PiacentinoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • , L. PineraAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , K. PittsAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , O. PoukhovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikJoint Institute for Nuclear Research
    • , F. PrakoshynAffiliated withMPI für PhysikJoint Institute for Nuclear Research
    • , A. PronkoAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , F. PtohosAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , E. PueschelAffiliated withMPI für PhysikCarnegie Mellon University
    • , A. RahamanAffiliated withUniversity of AthensUniversity of Pittsburgh
    • , N. RanjanAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , I. RedondoAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryCentro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
    • , V. RekovicAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of New Mexico
    • , F. RimondiAffiliated withIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare BolognaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna, University of Bologna
    • , A. RobsonAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaGlasgow University
    • , T. RodrigoAffiliated withMPI für PhysikInstituto de Fisica de Cantabria, CSIC-University of Cantabria
    • , E. RogersAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , S. RolliAffiliated withBaylor UniversityTufts University
    • , R. RoserAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , M. RossiAffiliated withBaylor UniversityIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
    • , R. RossinAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of California
    • , A. RuizAffiliated withMPI für PhysikInstituto de Fisica de Cantabria, CSIC-University of Cantabria
    • , J. RussAffiliated withMPI für PhysikCarnegie Mellon University
    • , V. RusuAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , W. K. SakumotoAffiliated withBaylor UniversityUniversity of Rochester
    • , L. SantiAffiliated withBaylor UniversityIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/UdineUniversity of Trieste/Udine
    • , K. SatoAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , A. Savoy-NavarroAffiliated withUniversity of AthensLPNHE, Universite Pierre et Marie Curie/IN2P3-CNRS, UMR7585
    • , P. SchlabachAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , E. E. SchmidtAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , M. A. SchmidtAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , M. SchmittAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryNorthwestern University
    • , T. SchwarzAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , L. ScodellaroAffiliated withMPI für PhysikInstituto de Fisica de Cantabria, CSIC-University of Cantabria
    • , A. SedovAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , S. SeidelAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of New Mexico
    • , Y. SeiyaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensOsaka City University
    • , A. SemenovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikJoint Institute for Nuclear Research
    • , L. Sexton-KennedyAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , F. SforzaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • , A. SfyrlaAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , S. Z. ShalhoutAffiliated withBaylor UniversityWayne State University
    • , S. ShiraishiAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , M. ShochetAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , A. SidotiAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • , A. SisakyanAffiliated withMPI für PhysikJoint Institute for Nuclear Research
    • , A. J. SlaughterAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , J. SlaunwhiteAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryThe Ohio State University
    • , K. SliwaAffiliated withBaylor UniversityTufts University
    • , J. R. SmithAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , A. SohaAffiliated withUniversity of California
    • , V. SorinAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMichigan State University
    • , P. SquillaciotiAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Siena
    • , R. St. DenisAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaGlasgow University
    • , D. StentzAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryNorthwestern University
    • , J. StrologasAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of New Mexico
    • , G. L. StryckerAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of Michigan
    • , J. S. SuhAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , A. SukhanovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , I. SuslovAffiliated withMPI für PhysikJoint Institute for Nuclear Research
    • , R. TakashimaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensOkayama University
    • , R. TanakaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensOkayama University
    • , M. TecchioAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of Michigan
    • , P. K. TengAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia Sinica
    • , K. TerashiAffiliated withBaylor UniversityThe Rockefeller University
    • , J. ThomAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , A. S. ThompsonAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaGlasgow University
    • , G. A. ThompsonAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , P. Ttito-GuzmánAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryCentro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
    • , S. TokarAffiliated withMPI für PhysikComenius UniversityInstitute of Experimental Physics
    • , K. TollefsonAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryMichigan State University
    • , S. TorreAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaLaboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
    • , D. TorrettaAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , P. TotaroAffiliated withBaylor UniversityIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/UdineUniversity of Trieste/Udine
    • , S. TourneurAffiliated withUniversity of AthensLPNHE, Universite Pierre et Marie Curie/IN2P3-CNRS, UMR7585
    • , M. TrovatoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa
    • , S.-Y. TsaiAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia Sinica
    • , S. VallecorsaAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Geneva
    • , N. van RemortelAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaDivision of High Energy Physics, Department of Physics, University of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics
    • , A. VarganovAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of Michigan
    • , E. VatagaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, Scuola Normale Superiore
    • , F. VázquezAffiliated withMPI für PhysikUniversity of Florida
    • , G. VelevAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , C. VellidisAffiliated withUniversity of Athens
    • , V. VeszpremiAffiliated withBaylor UniversityPurdue University
    • , M. VidalAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryCentro de Investigaciones Energeticas Medioambientales y Tecnologicas
    • , R. VidalAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , I. VilaAffiliated withMPI für PhysikInstituto de Fisica de Cantabria, CSIC-University of Cantabria
    • , R. VilarAffiliated withMPI für PhysikInstituto de Fisica de Cantabria, CSIC-University of Cantabria
    • , T. VineAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity College London
    • , M. VogelAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of New Mexico
    • , G. VolpiAffiliated withUniversity of AthensIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare PisaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Pisa, University of Pisa
    • , R. G. WagnerAffiliated withArgonne National Laboratory
    • , R. L. WagnerAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , T. WakisakaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensOsaka City University
    • , S. M. WangAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia Sinica
    • , B. WhitehouseAffiliated withBaylor UniversityTufts University
    • , E. WicklundAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , S. WilburAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , P. WittichAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , S. WolbersAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , C. WolfeAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , T. WrightAffiliated withArgonne National LaboratoryUniversity of Michigan
    • , X. WuAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Geneva
    • , K. YamamotoAffiliated withUniversity of AthensOsaka City University
    • , U. K. YangAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , Y. C. YangAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , K. YoritaAffiliated withMPI für PhysikEnrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago
    • , T. YoshidaAffiliated withUniversity of AthensOsaka City University
    • , G. B. YuAffiliated withBaylor UniversityUniversity of Rochester
    • , I. YuAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaArgonne National LaboratoryCenter for High Energy Physics, Kyungpook National UniversitySeoul National UniversitySungkyunkwan UniversityKorea Institute of Science and Technology InformationChonnam National University
    • , S. S. YuAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , J. C. YunAffiliated withMPI für PhysikFermi National Accelerator Laboratory
    • , A. ZanettiAffiliated withBaylor UniversityIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste/Udine
    • , X. ZhangAffiliated withInstitute of Physics, Academia SinicaUniversity of Illinois
    • , S. ZucchelliAffiliated withIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare BolognaIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Bologna, University of Bologna

Abstract

The European Physical Journal C—Particles and Fields—publishes scientific manuscripts of relevance to the scientific community following careful and strict peer reviewing and, whenever appropriate and necessary, through discussion with the authors, so as to optimise scientific content and style of presentation prior to publication. In some cases significant disagreement between authors and referees (and/or editors) of the journal cannot be resolved despite all efforts and best of intentions. While the journal—notwithstanding any appeals—retains the right to reject such manuscripts, the editors of this journal may decide, in cases deemed of exceptional interest and potential significance for the field, to accept the manuscript for publication, to amend it by “comments” of the editor(s) in charge and, if appropriate, by a “reply” of the authors of the commented manuscript.

The present comment is on “Study of multi-muon events produced in \(p\bar{p}\) interactions at \(\sqrt{s}=1.96\) TeV” by T. Aaltonen et al. (the CDF Collaboration, Eur. Phys. J. C, 2010, doi:10.​1140/​epjc/​s10052-010-1336-0).