Combined corrections for attenuation, depthdependent blur, and motion in cardiac SPECT: A multicenter trial
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
The diagnostic accuracy of cardiac single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) is limited by image-degrading factors, such as heart or subject motion, depthdependent blurring caused by the collimator, and photon scatter and attenuation. We developed correction approaches for motion, depth-dependent blur, and attenuation and performed a multicenter validation.
Methods and Results
Motion was corrected both transversely and axially with a cross-correlation technique. Depth-dependent blurring was corrected by first back-projecting each projection and then applying a depth-dependent Wiener filter row by row. Attenuation was corrected with an iterative, nonuniform Chang algorithm, based on a transmission scan-generated attenuation map. We validated these approaches in 112 subjects, including 36 women (20 healthy volunteers, 8 angiographically normal patients, and 8 patients with coronary artery disease [CAD]found by means of angiography) and 76 men (23 healthy volunteers, 10 angiographically normal patients, and 43 patients with CAD found by means of angiography). Either technetium 99m or thallium 201 was used for emission; either gadolinium 153 or Tc-99m was used for transmission. Images were reconstructed and blindly interpreted with a 5-point scale for receiver operating characteristic analysis in 2 ways: motion correction plus a Butterworth filter, and combined motion and blur and attenuation corrections. The interpretation by means of consensus was for the overall presence of CAD and vascular territory. The receiver operating characteristic curves for overall presence and each of the 3 main coronary arteries were all shifted upward and to the left and had larger areas under the curve, for combined corrections compared with motion correction and Butterworth. Sensitivity/specificity for motion correction and Butterworth were 84/69, 64/71, 32/94, and 71/81 overall for the left anterior descending, the right coronary artery, and circumflex territories, respectively, compared with 88/92, 77/93, 50/97, and 74/95, respectively, for the combined corrections.
The proposed combined corrections for motion, depth-dependent blur, and attenuation significantly improve diagnostic accuracy, when compared with motion correction alone.
- DePuey EG, Garcia EV. Optimal specificity of thallium-201 SPECT through recognition of imaging artifacts. J Nucl Med 1989;30:441–9.
- Wackers FJT. Artifacts in planar and SPECT myocardial perfusion imaging. Am J Cardiac Imaging 1992;6:42–58.
- DePuey EG. How to detect and avoid myocardial perfusion SPECT artifacts. J Nucl Med 1994;35:699–702.
- El Fakhri GN, Buvat I, Pelegrini M, Benali H, Almeida P, Bendriem B, et al. Respective roles of scatter, attenuation, depth-dependent collimator response and finite spatial resolution in cardiac single-photon emission tomography quantitation: A Monte Carlo study. Eur J Nucl Med 1999;26:437–46. CrossRef
- Eisner R, Churchwell A, Noever T, Nowak D, Cloninger K, Dunn D, et al. Quantitative analysis of the tomographic thallium-201 myocardial bullseye display: Critical role of correcting for patient motion. J Nucl Med 1988;29:91–7.
- Geckle WJ, Frank TL, Links JM, Becker LC. Correction for patient and organ movement in SPECT: Application to exercise thallium-201 cardiac imaging. J Nucl Med 1988;29:441–50.
- Germano G, Chua T, Kavanagh PB, Kiat H, Berman DS. Detection and correction of patient motion in dynamic and static myocardial SPECT using a multi-detector camera. J Nucl Med 1993;34:1349–55.
- Leslie WD, Dupont JO, McDonald D, Peterdy AE. Comparison of motion correction algorithms for cardiac SPECT. J Nucl Med 1997;38:785–90.
- O’Connor MK, Kanal KM, Gebhard MW, Rossman PJ. Comparison of four motion correction techniques in SPECT imaging of the heart: A cardiac phantom study. J Nucl Med 1998;39:2027–34.
- Formiconi AR, Pupi A, Passeri A. Compensation of spatial system response in SPECT with conjugate gradient reconstruction technique. Phys Med Biol 1989;34:69–84. CrossRef
- Xia W, Lewitt RM, Edholm PR. Fourier correction for spatially variant collimator blurring in SPECT. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 1995;14:100–15. CrossRef
- Axelsson B, Msaki P, Israelsson A. Subtraction of Compton-scattered photons in single-photon emission computerized tomography. J Nucl Med 1984;25:490–4.
- Jaszczak RJ, Greer KL, Floyd CE, Harris CC, Coleman RE. Improved SPECT quantification using compensation for scattered photons. J Nucl Med 1984;25:893–900.
- Floyd CE, Jaszczak RJ, Greer KL, Coleman RE. Deconvolution of Compton scatter in SPECT. J Nucl Med 1985;26:403–8.
- Gilardi MC, Bettinardi V, Todd-Pokropek A, Milanesi L, Fazio F. Assessment and comparison of three scatter correction techniques in single photon emission computed tomography. J Nucl Med 1988;29:1971–9.
- Mukai T, Links JM, Douglass KH, Wagner HN. Scatter correction in SPECT using non-uniform attenuation data. Phys Med Biol 1988;33:1129–40. CrossRef
- King MA, Hademenos GJ, Glick SJ. A dual-photopeak window method for scatter correction. J Nucl Med 1992;33:605–12.
- Ichihara T, Ogawa K, Motomura N, Kubo A, Hashimoto S. Compton scatter compensation using the triple-energy window method for single- and dual-isotope SPECT. J Nucl Med 1993;34:2216–21.
- Ljungberg M, King MA, Hademenos GJ, Strand SE. Comparison of four scatter correction methods using Monte Carlo simulated source distributions. J Nucl Med 1994;35:143–51.
- Buvat I, Rodriguez-Villafuerte M, Todd-Pokropek A, Benali H, Di Paola R. Comparative assessment of nine scatter correction methods based on spectral analysis using Monte Carlo simulations. J Nucl Med 1995;36:1476–88.
- Frey EC, Tsui BMW, Perry JR. Simultaneous acquisition of emission and transmission data for improved thallium-201 cardiac SPECT imaging using a technetium-99m transmission source. J Nucl Med 1992;33:2238–45.
- Ficaro EP, Fessler JA, Shreve PD, Kritzman JN, Rose PA, Corbett JR. Simultaneous transmission/emission myocardial perfusion tomography. Circulation 1996;93:463–73.
- King MA, Tsui BMW, Pan TS. Attenuation compensation for cardiac single-photon emission computed tomographic imaging: Part 1. Impact of attenuation and methods of estimating attenuation maps. J Nucl Cardiol 1995;2:513–24. CrossRef
- King MA, Tsui BMW, Pan TS, Glick SJ, Soares EJ. Attenuation compensation for cardiac single-photon emission computed tomographic imaging: Part 2. Attenuation compensation algorithms. J Nucl Cardiol 1996;3:55–63. CrossRef
- Prvulovich EM, Lonn AHR, Bomanji JB, Jarritt PH, Ell PJ. Effect of attenuation correction on myocardial thallium-201 distribution in patients with a low likelihood of coronary artery disease. Eur J Nucl Med 1997;24:266–75.
- Kluge R, Sattler B, Seese A, Knapp WH. Attenuation correction by simultaneous emission-transmission myocardial single-photon emission tomography using a technetium-99m-labeled radiotracer: Impact on diagnostic accuracy. Eur J Nucl Med 1997;24:1107–14.
- Chouraqui P, Livschitz S, Sharir T, Wainer N, Wilk M, Moalem I, et al. Evaluation of an attenuation correction method for thallium-201 myocardial perfusion tomographic imaging of patients with low likelihood of coronary artery disease. J Nucl Cardiol 1998;5:369–77. CrossRef
- Gallowitsch HJ, Sykora J, Mikosch P, Kresnik E, Unterweger O, Molnar M, et al. Attenuation-corrected thallium-201 single-photon emission tomography using a gadolinium-153 moving line source: Clinical value and the impact of attenuation correction on the extent and severity of perfusion abnormalities. Eur J Nucl Med 1998;25:220–8. CrossRef
- Gallowitsch HJ, Unterweger O, Mikosch P, Kresnik E, Sykora J, Grimm G, et al. Attenuation correction improves the detection of viable myocardium by thallium-201 cardiac tomography in patients with previous myocardial infarction and left ventricular dysfunction. Eur J Nucl Med 1999;26:459–66. CrossRef
- Galt JR, Cullom SJ, Garcia EV. SPECT quantification: A simplified method of attenuation and scatter correction for cardiac imaging. J Nucl Med 1992;33:2232–7.
- Hashimoto J, Ogawa K, Kubo A, Ichihara T, Motomura N, Takayama T, et al. Application of transmission scan-based attenuation compensation to scatter-corrected thallium-201 myocardial single-photon emission tomographic images. Eur J Nucl Med 1998;25:120–7. CrossRef
- Glick SJ, Penney BC, King MA, Byrne CL. Noniterative compensation for the distance-dependent detector response and photon attenuation in SPECT imaging. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 1994;13:363–74. CrossRef
- Gilland DR, Jaszczak RJ, Wang H, Turkington TG, Greer KL, Coleman RE. A 3D model of non-uniform attenuation and detector response for efficient iterative reconstruction in SPECT. Phys Med Biol 1994;39:1–15. CrossRef
- Tsui BMW, Frey EC, Zhao X, Lalush DS, Johnston RE, McCartney WH. The importance and implementation of accurate 3D compensation methods for quantitative SPECT. Phys Med Biol 1994;39:509–30. CrossRef
- Liang Z, Turkington TG, Gilland DR, Jaszczak RJ, Coleman RE. Simultaneous compensation for attenuation, scatter and detector response for SPECT reconstruction in three dimensions. Phys Med Biol 1992;37:587–603. CrossRef
- Hendel RC, Berman DS, Cullom SJ, Follansbee W, Heller GV, Kiat H, et al. Multicenter clinical trial to evaluate the efficacy of correction for photon attenuation and scatter in SPECT myocardial perfusion imaging. Circulation 1999;99:2742–9.
- Rigo P, Van Boxem P, Foulon J, Safi M, Engdahl J, Links J. Quantitative evaluation of a comprehensive motion, resolution, and attenuation correction program: Initial experience. J Nucl Cardiol 1998;5:458–68. CrossRef
- Tan P, Bailey DL, Meikle SR, Eberl S, Fulton RR, Hutton BF. A scanning line source for simultaneous emission and transmission measurements in SPECT. J Nucl Med 1993;34:1752–60.
- Cauvin JC, Boire JY, Maublant JC, Bonny JM, Zanca M, Veyre A. Automatic detection of the left ventricular myocardium long axis and center in thallium-201 single photon emission computed tomography. Eur J Nucl Med 1992;19:1032–7.
- Hutton BF. Cardiac single-photon emission tomography: is attenuation correction enough? [invited editorial] Eur J Nucl Med 1997;24:713–5.
- Bartlett ML, Bacharach SL, Voipio-Pulkki LM, Dilsizian V. Artifactual inhomogeneities in myocardial PET and SPECT scans in normal subjects. J Nucl Med 1995;36:188–95.
- Eisner RL, Nowak DJ, Pettigrew R, Fajman W. Fundamentals of 180° acquisition and reconstruction in SPECT imaging. J Nucl Med 1986;27:1717–28.
- Links JM, Jeremy RW, Dyer SM, Frank TL, Becker LC. Wiener filtering improves quantification of regional myocardial perfusion with thallium- 201 SPECT. J Nucl Med 1990;31:1230–6.
- Engdahl JC, Links JM. A new approach to filtered back-projection reconstruction which facilitates depth-dependent blur correction [abstract]. J Nucl Med 1995;36:29P.
- Fintel DJ, Links JM, Brinker JA, Frank TL, Parker M, Becker LC. Improved diagnostic performance of exercise thallium-201 single photon emission computed tomography over planar imaging in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease: A receiver operating characteristic analysis. J Am Coll Cardiol 1989;13:600–12. CrossRef
- Tsui BMW, Edgerton ER, Gullberg GT, Gilland DR, Perry JR, McCartney WH, et al. Correction of nonuniform attenuation in cardiac SPECT imaging using iterative reconstruction algorithms. J Nucl Med 1989;30:497–507.
- Lalush DS, Tsui BMW. Improving the convergence of iterative filtered backprojection algorithms. Med Phys 1994;21:1283–6. CrossRef
- Tsui BMW, Frey EC, LaCroix KJ, Lalush DS, McCartney WH, King MA, et al. Quantitative myocardial perfusion SPECT. J Nucl Cardiol 1998;5:507–22. CrossRef
- Wackers FJT. Attenuation correction, or the emperor's new clothes? [editorial] J Nucl Med 1999;40:1310–2.
- Heikkinen J, Ahonen A, Kuikka JT, Rautio P. Quality of myocardial perfusion single-photon emission tomography imaging: Multicentre evaluation with a cardiac phantom. Eur J Nucl Med 1999;26: 1289–97. CrossRef
- Vidal R, Buvat I, Darcourt J, Migneco O, Desvignes P, Baudouy M, et al. Impact of attenuation correction by simultaneous emission/transmission tomography on visual assessment of Tl-201 myocardial perfusion images. J Nucl Med 1999;40:1301–9.
- Combined corrections for attenuation, depthdependent blur, and motion in cardiac SPECT: A multicenter trial
Journal of Nuclear Cardiology
Volume 7, Issue 5 , pp 414-425
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Additional Links
- Attenuation correction
- ROC analysis
- diagnostic accuracy
- Industry Sectors
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, 615 N Wolfe St, Room 2001, 21205-2179, Baltimore, MD
- 2. CHU, Liege, Belgium
- 3. Hotel-Dieu, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
- 4. Aultman Hospital, Canton, Ohio
- 5. SMV America, Twinsburg, Ohio