Why do physicians vary so widely in their referral rates? Authors
Cite this article as: Franks, P., Williams, G.C., Zwanziger, J. et al. J GEN INTERN MED (2000) 15: 163. doi:10.1046/j.1525-1497.2000.04079.x Abstract OBJECTIVE: To determine which physician practice and psychological factors contribute to observed variation in primary care physicians’ referral rates. DESIGN: Cross-sectional questionnaire-based survey and analysis of claims database. SETTING: A large managed care organization in the Rochester, NY, metropolitan area. PARTICIPANTS: Internists and family physicians. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Patient referral status (referred or not) was derived from the 1995 claims database of the managed care organization. The claims data were also used to generate a predicted risk of referral based on patient age, gender, and case mix. A physician survey completed by a sample of 182 of the physicians (66% of those eligible) included items on their practice and validated psychological scales on anxiety from uncertainty, risk aversiveness, fear of malpractice, satisfaction with practice, autonomous and controlled motivation for referrals and test ordering, and psychosocial beliefs. The relation between the risk of referral and the physician practice and psychological factors was examined using logistic regression. After adjustment for predicted risk of referral (case mix), patients were more likely to be referred if their physician was female, had more years in practice, was an internist, and used a narrower range of diagnoses (a higher Herfindahl index, also derived from the claims data). Of the psychological factors, only greater psychosocial orientation and malpractice fear was associated with greater likelihood of referral. When the physician practice factors were excluded from the analysis, risk aversion was positively associated with referral likelihood. CONCLUSIONS: Most of the explainable variation in referral likelihood was accounted for by patient and physician practice factors like case mix, physician gender, years in practice, speciality, and the Herfindahl index. Relatively little variation was explained by any of the examined physician psychological factors. Key words Primary health care physician’s practice paterns referral and consultation
This study was supported by a grant from the Agency for Policy Health Care and Research, R01 HS09397-01.
Download to read the full article text References
Roland MO, Bartholomew J, Morrell DC, McDermott A, Paul E. Understanding hospital referral rates: a user’s guide. BMJ. 1990;301:98–102.
Salem-Schatz S, Moore G, Rucker M, Pearson SD. The case for case-mix adjustment in practice profiling: when good apples look bad. JAMA. 1994;272:871–4.
Franks P, Zwanziger J, Mooney C, Sorbero M. Variations in primary care physician referral rates. Health Serv Res. 1999;34:323–9.
Nutting PA, Franks P, Clancy CM. Referral and consultation in primary care: do we understand what we’re doing? J Fam Pract. 1992;35:21–3.
Ludke RL. An examination of the factors that influence patient referral decisions. Med Care. 1982;20:782–96.
Rothert ML, Rovner DR, Elstein AS, Holzman GB, Holmes MM, Ravitch MM. Differences in medical referral decisions for obesity among family practitioners, general internists, and gynecologists. Med Care. 1984;22:42–55.
Metcalfe DH, Sischy D. Patterns of referral from family practice. J Fam Pract. 1974;1:34–8.
Cherkin DC, Rosenblatt RA, Hart LG, Schneeweiss R, LoGerfo J. The use of medical resources by residency-trained family physicians and general internists. Is there a difference? Med Care. 1987;25:455–69.
Shortell SM, Vahovich SG. Patient referral differences among specialties. Health Serv Res. 1975;10:146–61.
Mayer TR. Family practice referral patterns in a health maintenance organization. J Fam Pract. 1982;14:315–9.
Moore AT, Roland MO. How much variation in referral rates among general practitioners is due to chance? BMJ. 1989;298:500–2.
Wilkin D, Dornan C. General Practitioner Referrals to Hospital: A Review of Research and Its Implications for Policy and Practice. Manchester, UK: Centre for Primary Care Research, Department of General Practice, University of Manchester; 1990.
Clancy CM, Lanier D, Grady ML. Conference Summary Report. Research at the Interface of Primary and Specialty Care. Rockville, Md: Agency for Health Care Policy and Research; 1996. Publication AHCPR 96-0034.
Grol R, Whitfield M, De Maeseneer J, Mokkink H. Attitudes to risk taking in medical decision making among British, Dutch and Belgian general practitioners. Br J Gen Pract. 1990;40:134–6.
Zaat JOM, van Eijk JTM. General practitioners’ uncertainty, risk preference, and use of laboratory tests. Med Care. 1992;30:846–54.
Pearson SD, Goldman L, Orav EJ, et al. Triage decisions for emergency department patients with chest pain: do physicians’ risk attitudes make the difference? J Gen Intern Med. 1995;10:557–64.
Allison JJ, Kiefe CI, Cook EF, Gerrity MS, Orav EJ, Centor R. The association of physician attitudes about uncertainty and risk taking with resource use in a Medicare HMO. Med Decis Making. 1998;18:320–9.
Williams GC, Deci EL. Internalization of biopsychosocial values by medical students: a test of self-determination theory. J Pers Soc Psychol 1996;70:767–9.
Williams GC, Wiener MW, Markakis KM, Reeve J, Deci EL. Medical students’ motivation for internal medicine. J Gen Intern Med. 1994;9:327–33.
Ryan RM, Connell JP. Perceived locus of causality and internalization: examining reasons for acting in two domains. J Pers Soc Psychol 1989;57:749–61.
Williams GC, Deci EL. The importance of supporting autonomy in medical education. Ann Intern Med. 1998;129:303–8.
Miller ME, Hui SL, Tierney WM, McDonald CJ. Estimating physician costliness: an empirical Bayes approach. Med Care. 1993;31:YS16-YS28.
Weiner JP, Starfield BH, Steinwachs DM, Mumford LM. Development and application of a population-oriented measure of ambulatory care case-mix. Med Care. 1991;29:452–72.
Starfield B, Weiner J, Mumford L, Steinwachs D. Ambulatory care groups: a categorization of diagnoses for research and management. Health Serv Res. 1991;26:53–74.
Franks P, Clancy CM, Nutting PA. Defining primary care: empirical analyses of the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey. Med Care. 1997;35:655–68.
Reynolds GA, Chitnis JG, Roland MO. General practitioner outpatient referrals: do good doctors refer more patients to hospital? BMJ. 1991;302:1250–2.
Calman NS, Hyman RB, Licht W. Variability in consultation rates and practitioner level of diagnostic certainty. J Fam Pract. 1992;35:31–8.
Linn LS, Yager J, Cope D, Leake B. Health status, job satisfaction, job stress, and life satisfaction among academic and clinical faculty. JAMA. 1986;254:2775–82.
Gerrity MS, DeVellis RF, Earp JA. Physicians’ reactions to uncertainty in patient care: a new measure and new insights. Med Care. 1990;28:724–36.
Gerrity M, White K. Physicians’ reactions to uncertainty: refining the constructs and scales. Motivation and Emotion. 1995;19: 175–91.
Jackson DN. Jackson Personality Inventory Manual. Goshen, NY: Research Psychologists Press; 1975.
Ashworth CD, Williamson PR, Montano D. A scale to measure physician beliefs about psychosocial aspects of patient care. Soc Sci Med. 1984;19:1235–8.
Levinson W, Roter D. Physicians’ psychosocial beliefs correlate with their patient communication skills. J Gen Intern Med. 1995;10:375–9.
Liang KY, Zeger SL. Regression analysis for correlated data. Annu Rev Public Health. 1993;14:43–68.
Fiscella K, Franks P. Risk aversion and costs: comparisons of family physicians and general internists. J Fam Pract. 2000;49:12–6.
Franks P, Clancy CM. Referrals of adult patients from primary care: demographic disparities and their relationship to HMO insurance. J Fam Pract. 1997;45:47–53.
PubMed Copyright information
© Society of General Internal Medicine 2000