Randomized controlled trial of education and feedback for implementation of guidelines for acute low back pain Authors
Cite this article as: Schectman, J.M., Schroth, W.S., Verme, D. et al. J GEN INTERN MED (2003) 18: 773. doi:10.1046/j.1525-1497.2003.10205.x
OBJECTIVE: The effect of clinical guidelines on resource utilization for complex conditions with substantial barriers to clinician behavior change has not been well studied. We report the impact of a multifaceted guideline implementation intervention on primary care clinician utilization of radiologic and specialty services for the care of acute low back pain.
DESIGN: Physician groups were randomized to receive guideline education and individual feedback, supporting patient education materials, both, or neither. The impact on guideline adherence and resource utilization was evaluated during the 12-month period before and after implementation.
PARTICIPANTS: Fourteen physician groups with 120 primary care physician and associate practitioners from 2 group model HMO practices.
INTERVENTIONS: Guideline implementation utilized an education/audit/feedback model with local peer opinion leaders. The patient education component included written and videotaped materials on the care of low back pain.
MAIN RESULTS: The clinician intervention was associated with an absolute increase in guideline-consistent behavior of 5.4% in the intervention group versus a decline of 2.7% in the control group ( P=.04). The patient education intervention produced no significant change in guideline-consistent behavior, but was poorly adopted. Patient characteristics including duration of pain, prior history of low back pain, and number of visits during the illness episode were strong predictors of service utilization and guideline-consistent behavior.
CONCLUSIONS: Implementation of an education and feedback-supported acute low back pain care guideline for primary care clinicians was associated with an increase in guideline-consistent behavior. Patient education materials did not enhance guideline effectiveness. Implementation barriers could limit the utility of this approach in usual care settings.
low back pain
Grant support: Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, Public Health Service, Department of Health and Human Services, Grant #: RO1 HS07069.
Davis DA, Taylor-Vaisey A. Translating guidelines into practice. A systematic review of theoretic concepts, practical experience and research evidence in the adoption of clinical practice guidelines. Can Med Assoc J. 1997;157:408–16.
Kosecoff J, Kanouse DE, Rogers WH. Effects of the National Institutes of Health Consensus Development Program on physician practice. JAMA. 1987;258:2708–13.
Lomas J, Anderson GM, Domnick-Pierre K, Vayda E, Enkin MW, Hannah WJ. Do practice guidelines guide practice? The effect of a consensus statement on the practice of physicians. N Engl J Med. 1989;321:1306–11.
Ford LG, Hunter CP, Diehr P, Frederick RW, Yates J. Effects of patient management guidelines on physician practice patterns: the community hospital oncology program experience. J Clin Oncol. 1987;5:504–12.
Eisenberg JM. Physician utilization—the state of research about physicians practice patterns. Med Care. 1985;23:461–83.
Schroeder SA. Strategies for reducing medical costs by changing physicians’ behavior. Efficacy and impact on quality of care. Intern J Tech Assess Health Care. 1987;3:39–50.
Cherkin DC, Deyo RA, Street JM, Barlow W. Pitfalls of patient education. Limited success of a program for back pain in primary care. Spine. 1996;21:345–55.
Cherkin DC, Deyo RA, Berg AO. Evaluation of a physician education intervention to improve primary care for low back pain. II. Impact on patients. Spine. 1991;16:1173–8.
Cherkin DC, Deyo RA, Berg AO, Bergman JJ, Lishner DM. Evaluation of a physician education intervention to improve primary care for low back pain. I. Impact on physicians. Spine. 1991;16:1168–72.
Lewis LM, Lasater LC, Ruoff BE. Failure of a chest pain clinical policy to modify physician evaluation and management. Ann Emerg Med. 1995;25:9–14.
Lee TH, Pearson SD, Johnson PA, et al. Failure of information as an intervention to modify clinical management. A time-series trial in patients with acute chest pain. Ann Intern Med. 1995;122:434–7.
Schwartz LM, Woloshin S, Welch HG. Trends in diagnostic testing following a national guideline for evaluation of dyspepsia. Arch Intern Med. 1996;156:873–5.
Lomas J, Enkin M, Anderson GM, Hannah WJ, Vayda E, Singer J. Opinion leaders vs. audit and feedback to implement practice guidelines: delivery after previous cesarean section. JAMA. 1991;265:2202–7.
Soumerai SB, McLaughlin TJ, Gurwitz JH, et al. Effect of local medical opinion leaders on quality of care for acute myocardial infarction: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA. 1998;279:1392–4.
Berwick DM, Coltin KL. Feedback reduces test use in a health maintenance organization. JAMA. 1986;255:1450–4.
Schroeder SA, Kenders K, Cooper JK, Piemme TE. Use of laboratory tests and pharmaceuticals. JAMA. 1973;225:969–73.
Holmboe E, Scranton R, Sumption K, Hawkins R. Effect of medical record audit and feedback on residents’ compliance with preventive health care guidelines. Acad Med. 1998;73:901–3.
Gemson DH, Ashford AR, Dickey LL, et al. Putting prevention into practice. Impact of a multifaceted physician education program on preventive services in the inner city. Arch Intern Med. 1995;155:2210–6.
Karuza J, Calkins E, Feather J, Hershey CO, Katz L, Majeroni B. Enhancing physician adoption of practice guidelines. Dissemination of influenza vaccination guideline using a small-group consensus process. Arch Intern Med. 1995;155:625–32.
Goldberg HI, Wagner EH, Fihn SD, et al. A randomized controlled trial of CQI teams and academic detailing: can they alter compliance with guidelines? Joint Comm J Qual Improv. 1998;24:130–42.
Soumerai SB, Avorn J. Principles of educational outreach (“academic detailing”) to improve clinical decision making. JAMA. 1990;263:549–56.
Weingarten SR, Riedinger MS, Conner L, et al. Practice guidelines and reminders to reduce duration of hospital stay for patients with chest pain. An interventional trial. Ann Intern Med. 1994;120:257–63.
Shiffman RN, Liaw Y, Brandt CA, Corb GJ. Computer-based guideline implementations systems: a systematic review of functionality and effectiveness. J Am Med Informatics Assoc. 1999;6:104–14.
Frymoyer JW. Back pain and sciatica. N Engl J Med. 1988;318:291–300.
Cypress BK. Characteristics of physician visits for back symptoms: a national perspective. Am J Public Health. 1985;73:389–95.
Kelsey JL, White AA, Pastides H, Bisbee GE. The impact of musculoskeletal disorders on the population of the United States. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1979;61-A:959–64.
Hart LG, Deyo RA, Cherkin DC. Physician office visits for low back pain. Frequency, clinical evaluation, and treatment patterns from a U.S. national survey. Spine. 1995;20:11–8.
Frymoyer JW, Cats-Baril WL. An overview of the incidences and costs of low back pain. Orthop Clin North Am. 1991;22:263–71.
Malmivaara A, Hakkinen U, Aro T, et al. The treatment of acute low back pain—bed rest, exercises, or ordinary activity? N Engl J Med. 1995;332:351–5.
Carey TS, Garrett J, Jackman A, McLaughlin C, Fryer J, Smucker DR. The North Carolina Back Pain Project. The outcomes and costs of care for acute low back pain among patients seen by primary care practitioners, chiropractors, and orthopedic surgeons. N Engl J Med. 1996;333:913–7.
Liang M, Komaroff AL. Roentgenograms in primary care patients with acute low back pain. Arch Intern Med. 1982;142:1108–12.
Deyo RA, Loeser JD, Bigos SJ. Herniated lumbar intervertebral disk. Ann Int Med. 1990;112:598–603.
Kaplan DM, Knapp M, Romm FJ, Velez R. Low back pain and x-ray films of the lumbar spine: a prospective study in primary care. South Med J. 1986;79:811–4, 47–50.
Deyo RA. Early diagnostic evaluation of low back pain. J Gen Intern Med. 1986;1:328–38.
Deyo RA. Conservative therapy for low back pain. JAMA. 1986;250:1057–62.
Wiesel SW, Cuckler JM, Deluca F, Jones F, Zelde MS, Rothman RH. Acute low back pain: an objective analysis of conservative therapy. Spine. 1980;5:324–30.
Von Korff M, Barlow W, Cherkin DC, Deyo RA. Effects of practice style in managing back pain. Ann Intern Med. 1994;121:187–95.
Bigos S, Bowyer O, Braen G, et al. Acute low back problems in adults. Clinical Practice Guideline No. 14. Rockville, MD; Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, Public Health Service. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services; 1994. AHCPR publication no. 95-0642.
Schroth WS, Schectman JM, Elinsky EG, Panagides JC. Utilization of medical services for the treatment of acute low back pain: conformance with clinical guidelines. J Gen Int Med. 1992;7:486–91.
Freeborn DK, Shye D, Mullooly JP, Eraker S, Romeo J. Primary care physicians’ use of lumbar spine imaging tests: effect of guidelines and practice pattern feedback. J Gen Int Med. 1997;12:619–25.
Roland MA, Morris R. A study of the natural history of back pain. Spine. 1983;8:141–4.
Deyo RA. Comparative validity of the sickness impact profile and shorter scales for functional assessment in low-back pain. Spine. 1986;11:951–4.
Hart LG, Deyo RA, Cherkin DC. Physician office visits for low back pain: frequency, clinical evaluation, and treatment patterns from a US national survey. Spine. 1995;20:11–9.
Suarez-Almazor ME, Belseck E, Russell AS, Mackel JV. Use of lumbar radiographs for the early diagnosis of low back pain: proposed guidelines would increase utilization. JAMA. 1997;277:1782–6.
Deyo RA, Diehl AK. Lumbar spine films in primary care: current use and effects of selective ordering criteria. J Gen Intern Med. 1986;1:20–5.
Tunis SR, Hayward RS, Wilson MC, et al. Internists’ attitudes about clinical practice guidelines. Ann Intern Med. 1994;120:956–63.
Cherkin DC, Deyo RA, Wheeler K, Ciol MA. Physician variation in diagnostic testing for low back pain. Who you see is what you get. Arthritis Rheum. 1994;37:15–22.
Little P, Smith L, Cantrell T, Chapman J, Langridge J, Pickering R. General practitioners’ management of acute back pain: a survey of reported practice compared with clinical guidelines. BMJ. 1996;312:485–8.
Cherkin DC, Deyo RA, Wheeler K, Ciol MA. Physician views about treating low back pain. The results of a national survey. Spine. 1995;20:1–9.
Carpenter CE, Johnson NE, Rosenfeld JF. The impact of clinical guidelines on practice patterns: doing more versus doing less. Am J Med Qual. 1998;13:98–103.
Saunders KW, Von Korff M, Pruitt SD, Moore JE. Prediction of physician visits and prescription medicine use for back pain. Pain. 1999;83:369–77.
Wilson IB, Dukes K, Greenfield S, Kaplan S, Hillman B. Patients’ role in the use of radiology testing for common office practice complaints. Arch Intern Med. 2001;161:256–63.
McPhillips-Tangum CA, Cherkin DC, Rhodes LA, Markham C. Reasons for repeated medical visits among patients with chronic back pain. J Gen Intern Med. 1998;13:289–95.
Espeland A, Baerheim A, Albrektsen G, Korsbrekke K, Larsen JL. Patients’ views on importance and usefulness of plain radiography for low back pain. Spine. 2001;26:1356–63.
Shye D, Freeborn DK, Romeo J, Eraker S. Understanding physicians’ imaging test use in low back pain care: role of focus groups. Int J Qual Health Care. 1998;10:83–91.
Eve R, Golton I, Hodgkin P, Munro J, Musson G. Beyond guidelines: promoting clinical change in the real world. J Manag Med. 1996;10:16–25.
Cohen SJ. Efficacy, effectiveness, and sustainability. Translating research into improvements in health care. Med Care. 2000;38:449–50.
Deyo RA, Diehl AK, Rosenthal M. Reducing roentgenography use. Arch Intern Med. 1987;147:141–5.
Cherkin DC, Deyo RA, Street JH, Hunt M, Barlow W. Pitfalls in patient education: limited success of a program for back pain in primary care. Spine. 1996;21:345–55.
Berwick DM, Budman S, Feldstein M. No clinical effect of back schools in an HMO. A randomized prospective trial. Spine. 1989;14:338–44.
Turner JA. Educational and behavioral interventions for back pain in primary care. Spine. 1996;21:2851–9.
Carey TS, Garrett J. Patterns of ordering diagnostic tests for patients with acute low back pain. Ann Intern Med. 1996;125:807–14.
Engel CC, Von Korff M, Katon WJ. Back pain in primary care: predictors of high health care costs. Pain. 1996;65:197–204.
Ryynanen OP, Lehtovirta J, Soimakallio S, Takala J. General practitioners’ willingness to request plain lumbar spine radiographic examinations. Eur J Radiol. 2001;37:47–53.
Cherkin DC, Deyo RA, Battie M, Street J, Barlow W. A comparison of physical therapy, chiropractic manipulation, and provision of an educational booklet for the treatment of patients with low back pain. N Engl J Med. 1998;339:1021–9.
Von Korff M, Moore JC. Steped care for back pain: activating approaches for primary care. Ann Intern Med. 2001;134:911–7.
McGuirk B, King W, Bovind J, Lowry J, Bogduk N. Safety, efficacy, and cost-effectiveness of evidence-based guidelines for the management of acute low back pain in primary care. Spine. 2001;26:2615–22.
Schwartz JS, Shulkin DJ. Teaching an old dog new tricks. J Gen Intern Med. 1995;10:353–4.
Wise CG, Billi JE. A model for practice guideline adaptation and implementation: empowerment of the physician. Jt Comm J Qual Improv. 1995;21:465–76.
Backer TE. Integrating behavioral and systems strategies to change clinical practice. Jt Comm J Qual Improv. 1995;21:339–43.
© Society of General Internal Medicine 2003