Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis: Choosing the “Good Enough” Child
- Helen Watt
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) raises serious moral questions concerning the parent-child relationship. Good parents accept their children unconditionally: they do not reject/attack them because they do not have the features they want. There is nothing wrong with treating a child as someone who can help promote some other worthwhile end, providing the child is also respected as an end in him or herself. However, if the child's presence is not valued in itself, regardless of any further benefits it brings, the child is not being treated as an end in the full sense of the term. In this paper, I argue that these principles apply to human embryos, as well as to born human offspring: the human moral subject is a bodily being, whose interests and rights begin with the onset of his or her bodily life. The rights of the living, bodily human individual include a right not to be attacked/abandoned because of his or her genetic profile. PGD is harmful to the parent-child relationship, and we give mixed messages to parents by expecting them to show unconditional commitment to offspring after birth, while inviting them to take a very different approach at the prenatal stage.
- Austriaco, N. (2003) The Pre-Implantation Embryo Revisited: A Two-Celled Individual or Two Individual Cells? Linacre Quarterly 70(2), 121–126.
- Braine, D. (1993) The Human Person: Animal and Spirit. London: Duckworth.
- Chappell, T. (1998) Understanding Human Goods: A Theory of Ethics. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
- Fisher, A. (1991) Individuogenesis and a Recent Book by Fr Norman Ford. Anthropotes 7(2), 199–235.
- Grisez, G., Boyle, J., and Finnis, J. (1987) Practical Principles, Moral Truth and Ultimate Ends. American Journal of Jurisprudence 32, 99–151.
- Henderson, M. (2003) The Woman Who Keeps Watch on Scientists' Acts of Creation. Times August 30. www.timesonline.co.uk/printFriendly/0,,1-2-797389,00.html, viewed on 02/09/2003
- Highfield, R. (2003) Time Running Out for Sick Boy Caught in Pro-Life Protest. Telegraph April 1. www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2003/04/01/nzain01.xml&sSheet=/ (accessed on 1/4/2003)
- Hogben, M. (1998) What Size Is an Embryo's Soul? Human Life Review 24, 88–93.
- Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. (2003) Sex Selection: Options for Regulation: A Report on the HFEA's 2002-03 Review of Sex Selection Including a Discussion of Legislative and Regulatory Options. London: HFEA.
- McWhinnie, A. (1996) Outcome for Families Created by Assisted Conception Programmes. Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics 13(4), 363–365.
- Munthe, C. (2001) Divisibility and the Moral Status of Embryos. Bioethics 15(5/6), 382–397.
- Oderberg, D. (1997) Modal Properties, Moral Status and Identity. Philosophy and Public Affairs 26, 259–298.
- Oderberg, D. (2000) Moral Theory: A Non-Consequentialist Approach. Oxford: Blackwell.
- Olson, E. (1997) The Human Animal. New York: Oxford University Press.
- Orofino, M., Argiolu, F., Sanna, M., Rosatelli, M., Tuveri, T., Scalas, M., Badiali, M., Cossu, P., Puddu, R., Lai, M., Cao, A. (2003) Fetal HLA Typing in Beta-Thalassaemia: Implications for Haemopoietic Stem-Cell Transplantation. Lancet 362, 41–42.
- Prentice, D. (2002) Witness Statement made on 6 October (Exhibits DP/1-2) to the High Court hearing of R (on the application of Quintavalle) v. Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority  2 All ER 105;  3 All ER 257.
- Saunders, P. (2003) Designer Babies. Triple Helix 24, 4.
- Verkaik, R. (2003) Britain's First 'Designer Baby' Prompts Call for Law Change. Independent June 20, p. 1.
- Watt, H. (2000) Life and Death in Healthcare Ethics: A Short Introduction. London: Routledge.
- Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis: Choosing the “Good Enough” Child
Health Care Analysis
Volume 12, Issue 1 , pp 51-60
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Kluwer Academic Publishers-Plenum Publishers
- Additional Links
- embryo biopsy
- genetic testing
- preimplantation genetic diagnosis
- tissue typing
- Helen Watt (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Linacre Centre for Healthcare Ethics, London, United Kingdom