Abstract
Two of the most frequently used methods of pollen counting on slides from Hirst type traps are evaluated in this paper: the transverse traverse method and the longitudinal traverse method. The study was carried out during June–July 1996 and 1997 on slides from a trap at Worcester, UK. Three pollen types were selected for this purpose: Poaceae, Urticaceae and Quercus. The statistical results show that the daily concentrations followed similar trends (p < 0.01, R-values between 0.78–0.96) with both methods during the two years, although the counts were slightly higher using the longitudinal traverses method. Significant differences were observed, however, when the distribution of the concentrations during 24 hour sampling periods was considered. For more detailed analysis, the daily counts obtained with both methods were correlated with the total number of pollen grains for the taxon over the whole slide, in two different situations: high and low concentrations of pollen in the atmosphere. In the case of high concentrations, the counts for all three taxa with both methods are significantly correlated with the total pollen count. In the samples with low concentrations, the Poaceae and Urticaceae counts with both methods are significantly correlated with the total counts, but none of Quercus counts are. Consideration of the results indicates that both methods give a reasonable approximation to the count derived from the slide as a whole. More studies need be done to explore the comparability of counting methods in order to work towards a Universal Methodology in Aeropalynology.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Comtois P., Alcázar P. and Neron D.: 1999, Pollen count statistics and its relevance to precision. Aerobiologia 15, 19–28.
Dominguez E., Galán C., Villamandos F. and Infante F.: 1991, Handling and evaluation of the data from the aerobiological sampling. Monografías REA/EAN 1, 131–141.
Emberlin J., Jones S., Bailey J., Caulton E., Corden J., Dubbets S., Evans J., McDonagh N., Millington W., Mullins J., Russel R. and Spencer T.: 1994, Variation in the start of the Grass pollen season at selected sites in the United Kingdom. 1987–1992. Grana 33, 94–99.
Galan C., Tormo R., Cuevas J., Infante F. and Dominguez E.: 1991, Theoretical daily variation patterns of airborne pollen in the South-west of Spain. Grana 30, 229–234.
Kapyla M.: 1981, Diurnal variation of non arboreal pollen in the air in Finland. Grana 20, 55–59.
Kapyla M.: 1984, Diurnal variation of tree pollen in the air in Finland. Grana 23, 167–176.
Kapyla M. and Penttinen A.: 1981, An evaluation of the microscopical counting methods of the tape in Hirst-Burkard pollen and spore trap. Grana 20, 131–141.
Makinen Y.: 1981, Random sampling in the study of microscopic slides. Rep. Aerobiol. Lab. Univ. Turku 5, 27–43.
Mandrioli, P.: 1990, The Italian Aeroallergen Network. Sampling and Counting Method. Aerobiologia 6(2/1), 5–7.
Norris-Hill J. and Emberlin J.: 1991, Diurnal variation of pollen concentration in the air of north-central London. Grana 30, 229–234.
Tormo R., Muñoz A. and Silva I.: 1996, Sampling in Aerobiology. Differences between traverses along the length of the slide in Hirst spore traps. Aerobiologia 12, 161–166.
Trigo M.M., Recio M., Toro F.J. and Cabezudo B.: 1996, Intradiurnal fluctuations of airborne pollen in Malaga (S.Spain): a quantitative method. In M.J. Aira, V. Jato, I. Iglesias and C. Galan (eds). Actas of 1st European Symposium on Aerobiology. pp. 46–47.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cariñanos, P., Emberlin, J., Galán, C. et al. Comparison of two pollen counting methods of slides from a hirst type volumetric trap. Aerobiologia 16, 339–346 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026577406912
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026577406912