Abstract
In 1991, the CDC recommended that health care workers (HCWs) infectedwith HIV or HBV (HbeAg positive) should be reviewed by an expert paneland should inform patients of their serologic status before engaging inexposure-prone procedures. The CDC, in light of the existing scientificuncertainty about the risk of transmission, issued cautiousrecommendations. However, considerable evidence has emerged since 1991suggesting that we should reform national policy. The data demonstratesthat risks of transmission of infection in the health care setting areexceedingly low. Current policy, moreover, does not improve patientsafety. At the same time, implementation of current national policy atthe local level poses significant human rights burdens on HCWs.Consequently, national policy should be changed to ensure patient safetywhile protecting the human rights of HCWs. This article proposes a newnational policy, including: (1) a program to prevent bloodborne pathogentransmission; (2) a responsibility placed on infected HCWs to promotetheir own health and well-being and to assure patient safety; (3) adiscontinuation of expert review panels and special restrictions forexposure-prone procedures; (4) a discontinuation of mandatorydisclosure of a HCW's inflection status; and (5) the imposition ofpractice restrictions if a HCW is unable to practice safely because of aphysical or mental impairment or failure to follow careful infectioncontrol techniques. A new national policy, focused on management of theworkplace environment and injury prevention, would achieve high levelsof patient safety without discrimination and invasion of privacy.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
AIDS/TB Committee of the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America (1997) Management of Healthcare Workers Infected with Hepatitis B Virus, Hepatitis C Virus, Human Immunodeficiency Virus, or Other Bloodborne Pathogens. Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology 18, 349–363.
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, Advisory Statement: Preventing the Transmission of Bloodborne Pathogens (viewed at www.aaos.org August 8, 2001).
American College of Surgeons (1999) Statement on the Surgeon and Hepatitis. Bulletin of the American College of Surgeons 84, 21–24.
American College of Surgeons (1998) Statement on the Surgeon and HIV Infection. Bulletin of the American College of Surgeons 83, 27–29.
Anonymous (1995) Hepatitis C virus transmission from health care worker to patient. Communicable Disease Report Weekly 5, 121.
Beekman, Susan E. et al. (1994) Temporal Association Between Implementation of Universal Precautions and a Sustained Progressive Decrease in Percutaneous Exposures to Blood. Clinical Infectious Diseases 18, 562–569.
Blanchard, Alain et al. (1998) Molecular Evidence for Nosocomial Transmission of Human Immunodeficiency Virus from a Surgeon to One of his Patients. Journal of Virology 72, 4537–4540.
Bradley v. Univ. of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Ctr., 3 F.3d 922, 924 (5th Cir. 1993).
Bragdon v. Abbott, 524 U.S. 624 (1998).
Bosch, Xavier (1998) Hepatitis C Outbreak Astounds Spain. Lancet 351, 1415.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2001) Updated U.S. Public Health Service Guidelines for the Management of Occupational Exposures to HBV, HCV and HIV and Recommendations for Postexposure Prophylaxis. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 50, RR-11, 1–52.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1998) Recommendations for Prevention and Control of Hepatitis C Virus (HCV) Infection and HCV-related Chronic Disease. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 47, RR-19, 1–39.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1993) Update: Investigations of Persons Treated by HIV-Infected Health-Care Workers. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 42, 329–331.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1991) Recommendations for Preventing Transmission of Human Immunodeficiency Virus and Hepatitis B Virus to Patients During Exposure-prone Invasive Procedures. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 40, RR-8, 1–9.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1989) Guidelines for Prevention of Transmission of Human Immunodeficiency Virus and Hepatitis B Virus to Health-Care and Public-Safety Workers. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 38(S‐6), 1–36.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Fact Sheet: Surveillance of Health Care Workers with HIV/AIDS (Atlanta: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2000) (viewed at http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/pubs/facts/hcwsurv.htm on August 8, 2001).
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Fact Sheet: HIV and Its Transmission (Atlanta: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1999) (viewed at http://www.cdc.gov/ nchstp/hiv_aids/pubs/facts/transmission.htm on August 8, 2001).
Ciesielski, Carol et al. (1994) The 1990 Florida Dental Investigation: The Press and the Science. Annals of Internal Medicine 121, 886–888.
Committee on Pediatric AIDS and Committee on Infectious Diseases (1999) Issues related to Human Immunodeficiency Virus Transmission in Schools, Child Care, Medical Settings, the Home, and Community. Pediatrics 104, 318–324.
Daniels, Norman (1992) HIV-infected Professionals, Patient Rights, and the 'switching' Dilemma. Journal of the American Medical Association 267, 1368–1371.
Donnely, Michael, et al. (1999) Are HIV Look Backs Worthwhile? Outcome of an Exercise to Notify Patients Treated by an HIV Infected Health Care Worker. Communicable Disease and Public Health 2, 126–129.
Duckworth, Georgia J. et al. (1999) Transmission of Hepatitis C Virus from a Surgeon to a Patient. Communicable Disease and Public Health 2, 188–192.
Esteban, Juan I. et al. (1996) Transmission of Hepatitis C by a Cardiac Surgeon. New England Journal of Medicine 334, 555–560.
Faya v. Almaraz, 620 A.2d 327 (Md. 1993).
Fisher, Eric S. (1997) Aidsphobia: A National Survey of Emotional Distress Claims for the Fear of Contracting AIDS. Tort and Insurance Law Journal 33, 169–226.
Forrest, Adam G. (1999) Is there a Significant Risk or High Probability of HIV Transmission from an Infected Health CareWorker to Others? The Sixth Circuit's Answer Lies in Mauro v. Borgess Medical Center. Creighton Law Review 32, 1763–1803.
Fost, Norman. (2000) Patient Access to Information on Clinicians Infected with Bloodborne Pathogens. Journal of the American Medical Association 284, 1975–1976.
Garner, Julia S. (1996) Hospital Infections Practices Advisory Committee. Guideline for Isolation Precautions in Hospitals. Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology 17, 53–80.
Gerberding, Julie. (1999) Provider-to-Patient HIV Transmission: How to Keep it Exceedingly Rare. Annals of Internal Medicine 130, 64–65.
Gerberding, Julie L. (1996) The Infected Health Care Provider. New England Journal of Medicine 334, 594–595.
Gostin, Lawrence O. (1991a) The HIV-infected Health Care Professional: Public Policy, Discrimination and Patient Safety. Archives of Internal Medicine 151, 663–665.
Gostin, Lawrence O. (1991b) CDC guidelines on HIV or HBV-positive Health Care Professionals Performing Exposure-prone Invasive Procedures. Law, Medicine and Health Care 19, 140–143.
Gostin, Lawrence O., Feldblum, Chai and Webber, David W. (1999) Disability Discrimination in America: HIV/AIDS and Other Health Conditions. Journal of the American Medical Association 281, 745–752.
Goujon, Christophe P. et al. (2000) Phylogenetic Analyses Indicate an Atypical Nurse-topatient Transmission of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1. Journal of Virology 74, 2525–2532.
Harpaz, Rafael et al. (1996) Transmission of Hepatitis B Virus to Multiple Patients from a Surgeon Without Evidence of Inadequate Infection Control. New England Journal of Medicine 334, 549–554.
Hepatitis B Outbreak Investigation Team, (2000) An Outbreak of Hepatitis B Associated with Reusable Subdermal Electroencephalogram Electrodes. Canadian Medical Association Journal 162, 1127–1131.
Hutin, Yvan J.F. et al. (1999) An Outbreak of Hospital-Acquired Hepatitis B Virus Infection Among Patients Receiving Chronic Hemodialysis. Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology 20, 731–735.
The Incident Investigation Team and Others (1997) Transmission of Hepatitis B to Patients from Four Infected Surgeons Without Hepatitis B Antigen. New England Journal of Medicine 336, 178–184.
Kohn, Linda T., Corrigan, Janet M. and Donaldson, Molla S. (Eds.) (1999) To Err is Human: Building a Safer Health System, Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
Law, Matthew G. et al. (2001) Modeling the Effect of Combination Antiretroviral Treatments on HIV Incidence. AIDS 15, 1287–1294.
Lo, Bernard and Steinbrook, Robert. (1992) Health Care Workers Infected with the Human Immunodeficiency Virus. Journal of the American Medical Association 267, 1100–1105.
Lot, Florence et al. (1999) Probable Transmission from an Orthopedic Surgeon to a Patient in France. Annals of Internal Medicine 130, 1–6.
Mangram, Alicia, et al. (1999) Guideline for Prevention of Surgical Site Infection, 1999. Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology 20, 247–278.
McIntosh, Phillip L. (1996) When the Surgeon has HIV: What to Tell Patients about the Risk of Exposure and the Risk of Transmission. University of Kansas Law Review 44, 315–364.
Ngui, Siew L., Watkins, Ruth P.F., Heptonstall, Julia and Teo, Chong G. (2000) Selective Transmission of Hepatitis B Virus after Percutaneous Exposure. Journal of Infectious Diseases 181, 838–843.
Noble, Alicia., Brennan, Troyen A. and Hyams, Andrew L. (1997) Snyder v. American Association of Blood Banks: A Re-examination of Liability for Medical Practice Guideline Promulgators. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 4, 49–62.
Panel for Clinical Practices for the Treatment of HIV, Guidelines for the Use of Antiretroviral Agents in HIV-Infected Adults and Adolescents, April 23, 2001 (viewed at http://www.hivatis.org/guidelines/adult/Apr23_01/text/index.html on August 8, 2001).
Parks v. Female Health Care Assoc., Ltd., No. 96 C 7133, 1997 WL 285870 (N.D. Ill. May 23, 1997).
Quinn, Thomas C. et al. (2000) Viral Load and Heterosexual Transmission of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1. New England Journal of Medicine 342, 921–929.
Rediger, Byron B. (2000) Living in a World with HIV: Balancing Privacy, Privilege, and the Right to Know Between Patients and Health Care Professionals. Hamline Journal of Public Law and Policy 21, 443–487.
Rhodes, Robert S., Telford, Gordon L., Hierholzer, Walter J. Jr. and Barnes, Mark (1995) Bloodborne Pathogen Transmission from Health-care Workers to Patients. Legal Issues and Provider Prospective. Surgical Clinics of North America 75, 1205–1217.
Robert, LaurieM. et al. (1995) Investigations of Patients of Health CareWorkers Infected with HIV. Annals of Internal Medicine 122, 653–657.
Robinson, Edward N. Jr. and de Bliek, Ruth (1996) The College Student, the Dentist, and the North Carolina Senator: Risk Analysis and Risk Management of HIV Transmission from Health Care Worker to Patient. Medical Decision Making 16, 86–91.
Rodgers, Audrey S. et al. (1993) Investigation of Potential HIV Transmission to Patient of an HIV-infected Surgeon. Journal of the American Medical Association 269, 1795–1801.
Rohlfsen, Ryan J. (1999) HIV-Infected Surgical Personnel Under the ADA: Do They Pose a Threat or are Reasonable Accommodations Possible. Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy 16, 127–144.
Roper, William L. Letter to State Health Departments, dated June 16, 1992.
Ross, Stefan R., Viazov, Sergei and Roggendorf, Michael (2000a) Risk of Hepatitis C Transmission from Infected Medical Staff to Patients: Model-based Calculations for Surgical Settings. Archives of Internal Medicine 160, 2312–2316.
Ross, Stefan R. et al. (2000b) Transmission of Hepatitis C Virus from a Patient to an Anesthesiology Assistant to Five Patients. New England Journal of Medicine 343, 1851–185.
Ross, Stefan R., Vlazov, Sergei and Roggendorf, Michael (1999) Provider-to-Patient Transmission of Hepatitis B Virus. Lancet 353, 324–325.
Saag, Michael S. et al. (1996) HIV Viral Load Markers in Clinical Practice. Nature Medicine 2, 625–629.
Schatz, Benjamin (1995) Supporting and Advocating for HIV-positive Health Care Workers. Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine 72, 263–272.
Summers, Todd (2001) Public Policy for Health Care Workers Infected with Human Immunodeficiency Virus. Journal of the American Medical Association 285, 882.
Tereskerz, Patti Miller, Pearson, Richard D. and Jagger, Janine (1999) Infected Physicians and Invasive Procedures: National Policy and Legal Reality. Milbank Quarterly 77, 511–529.
Van Detta, Jeffrey A. (1999) Typhoid Mary meets the ADA: A case study of the direct threat standard under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 22, 853–949.
Webber, David W. (Ed.) (1997) AIDS and the Law, New York: John Wiley and Sons Inc.