Abstract
This article isolates ten prepositions, which constitute the undercurrent paradigm of contemporary discourse of health disease and medicine. Discussion of the interrelationship between those prepositions leads to a systematic refutation of this paradigm. An alternative set is being forwarded. The key notions of the existing paradigm are that health is the natural condition of humankind and that disease is a deviance from that nature. Natural things are harmonious and healthy while human made artifacts are coercive interference with natural balance. It is suggested that the current paradigm is influenced by the world of finances and by instrumental reason. The alternative model suggests that human nature cannot be delineated. Humans fashion their own selves and nature by artificial means, medicine among them. The article discusses the implications of the paradigm adapted in various scholarly and popular debates such as the use of sex hormones for contraception, the care of the elderly, holistic medicine and distributive justice in health care. Medicine is not an isolated or a privileged realm. There is no unique entitlement to health care. It is always part of a broader agenda of social values and institutions. A open view of human societies, values and practices as they are situated within concrete material conditions is the platform required for an integrative and creative discourse of health care.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen, G.E.: 1997, 'The Double-Edged Sword of Genetic Determinism: Social and Political Agendas in Genetic Studies of Homosexuality, 1940-1994', in: V.A. Rosario (ed.), The Science of Homosexuality. New York: Routledge, pp. 242–255
Alter, J.S.: 1999, 'Heaps of Health, Metaphysical Fitness', Current Anthropology 40, S43–S66.
Antonovsky, A.: 1979, Health, Stress and Coping. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.
Antonovsky, A.: 1987, Unraveling The Mystery of Health. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.
Antonovsky, A.: 1994, 'A Sociological Critique of the “Wellbeing” Movement', Advances: The Journal of Mind-Body Health 10 (3), 6–11.
Ardrey, R.: 1976, The Hunting Hypothesis: A Personal Conclusion Concerning the Evolutionary Nature of Man. NewYork: Athenaeum.
Bayer, R.: 1981, Homosexuality and American Psychology: The Politics of Diagnosis. New York: Basic Books.
Beauchamp, T.L. and J.F. Childress: 1994, Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 4th edn. New York: Oxford University Press.
Benn, S.I. and R.S. Peters: 1965, The Principles of Political Thought: Social Foundations of The Democratic State. New York: Free Press.
Bloch, M.: 1992, 'Language, Anthropology and Cognitive Science', Man 26, 183–198.
Bloom, A.: 1994, 'The Body Lies', The New Yorker, July 18th.
Boorse, C.: 1977, 'Health as a Theoretical Concept', Philosophy of Science 44, 542–573.
Boorse, C.: 1975, 'On the Distinction Between Disease and Illness', Philosophy and Public Affairs 5, 49–68.
Brody, H.: 1987, Stories of Sickness. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Bronowsky, J.: 1966, 'The Logic of the Mind', Nature 209, 1171–1173.
Bunzl, M.: 1980, 'Comment on Health as a Theoretical Concept', Philosophy of Science 47, 116–118.
Canguilhem, G.: 1991, The Normal and the Pathological. New York: Zone.
Caplan, A.L., H.T. Engelhardt and J.J. McCartney (eds.): 1981, Concepts of Health and Disease. Reading (MA): Addison Wesley.
Caplan, A.L.: 1993, 'The Concepts of Health, Illness, and Disease', in: W.F. Bynum and R. Porter (eds.), Companion Encyclopedia of the History of Medicine. New York: Routledge, pp. 233–248.
Cassell, E.J.: 1976, 'Illness and Disease', Hastings Center Report 6 (April), 27–37.
Cassell, E.J.: 1991, The Nature of Suffering and the Goals of Medicine. New York: Oxford University Press.
Cassidy, C.M.: 1994, 'Unraveling the Ball of String: Reality, Paradigms, and the Study of Alternative Medicine', Advances: The Journal of Mind Body Health 10 (1), 15–31.
Choron, J.: 1963,Death and Western Thought. New York: Macmillan.
Clark D.: 1999, '“Total Pain”, Disciplinary Power and the Body in the Work of Cicely Saunders, 1958-1967', Social Science and Medicine 49, 727–736.
Clements, F.E.: 1932, Primitive Concepts of Disease. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Clouser, K.D., C.M. Culver and B. Gert: 1981, 'Malady: A New Treatment of Disease', The Hastings Center Report 11(3), 29–37.
Coleman, W.: 1982, Death is a Social Disease: Public Health and Political Economy in Early Industrial France. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Couliano, I.P.: 1987, Eros and Magic in the Renaissance.Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Collingwood, R.G.: 1945, The Idea of Nature. London: Clarendon Press.
Conrad, L.I., M. Neve, R. Porter and N. Nutton: 1995, The Western Medical Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
D'Andrade, R.: 1995, The Development of Cognitive Anthropology.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dawkins, R.: 1989, The Selfish Gene, 2nd edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Desjarlais, R.R.: 1992, Body and Emotion: the Aesthetics of Illness and Healing in the Nepal Himalayas. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Douglas, M. and A. Wildavsky: 1982, Risk and Culture. An Essay on The Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Dubos, R. and J. Dubos: 1952, The White Plague: Tuberculosis, Man and Society. Boston: Little Brown.
Dubos, R.: 1968, Medicine, Man and Environment. New York: Praeger.
Duplessis, R.S.: 1997, Transition to Capitalism in Early Modern Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Edgerton, R.: 1992, Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony. New York: Free Press.
Eliade, M.: 1963, Myth and Reality. New York: Harper and Row.
Eliade, M.: 1978, The Forge and the Crucible: The Origins and Structures of Alchemy, 2nd edn. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Eliade, M.: 1954, The Myth of Eternal Return. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Elkins, J.: 1999, Pictures of the Body, Pain and Metamorphosis.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Ellul, J.: 1971, The Technological Society. New York: Random House.
Engel, G.L.: 1977, 'The Need for a New Medical Model: A Challenge for Biomedicine', Science 196, 129–136.
Engelhardt, H.T.: 1976, 'Ideology and Etiology', Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1, 256–268.
Fabrega, H. and L. Van Tegeren: 1976, 'A Behavioral Framework for the Study of Human Disease', Annals of Internal Medicine 84, 200–208.
Fabrega, H.: 1975, 'The Need for an Ethnomedical Science', Science 189, 969–975.
Fabrega, H.: 1997, Evolution of Sickness and Healing.Berkeley: University of California Press.
Farmer, P.: 1999, Infections and Inequalities: The Modern Plagues. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Fletcher, J.F.: 1974, 'Four Indicator of Humanhood', Hastings Center Report 4 (6), 4–7.
Foucault, M.: 1988, The Care of the Self: History of Sexuality, volume III. New York: Vintage.
Fox, R.: 1989, The Search for Society: Quest for a Biological Science and Morality. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Frake, C.O.: 1961, 'The Diagnosis of Disease Among the Subanum of Mindanau',American Anthropologist 63, 113–132.
Frank, A.W.: 1995, The Wounded Storyteller: Body, Illness and Ethics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Frayser, S.G.: 1985, Varieties of Sexual Experience: An Anthropological Perspective on Human Sexuality. New Haven: HARF Press.
Geertz, C.: 1973, The Interpretation of Cultures. New York: Basic Books.
Gilman, S.L.: 1988, Disease and Representation. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Gilman, S.L.: 1993, The Case of Sigmound Freud. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Glacken, C.L.: 1967, Traces on the Rhodian Shore: Nature and Culture in Western Thought from Ancient Times to the End of the Twentieth Century. Berkeley: University of California Press, ch. 10.
Gladstone, I.: 1981, Social and Historical Foundations of Modern Medicine. New York: Brunner/Mazel.
Glymour, C. and D. Stalker: 1983, 'Engineers, Canks, Physicians, Magicians', New England Journal of Medicine 308, 960–964.
Good, B. and M.J. DelVecchio-Good: 1992, 'The Comparative Study of Greco-IslamicMedicine: The Integration ofMedical Knowledge into Local Symbolic Contexts', in: C. Leslie and A. Young (eds.), Paths to Asian Medical Knowledge.Berkeley: University of California Press.
Good, B.J.: 1994, Medicine, Rationality and Experience: An Anthropological Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Good, B.J.: 1977, 'The Heart of What's the Matter: The Semantics of Illness in Iran', Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 1, 25–58.
Goody, J.: 1977, The Domestication of the Savage Mind.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Goosens, W.K.: 1980, 'Values, Health and Medicine', Philosophy of Science 47, 100–115.
Grmek, M.: 1989, Disease in the Ancient Greek World.Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Grmek, M.D.: 1998, 'The Concept of Disease', in: M.D. Grmek (eds.), Western Medical Thought from Antiquity to the Middle Ages. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press, pp. 241–258.
Grossinger, R.: 1980, Planet Medicine. New York: Doubleday.
Hahn, R.A.: 1995, Sickness and Healing: An Anthropological Perspective. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Handlin, O.: 1965, 'Science and Technology in Popular Culture', Daedalus (Winter), 156–170.
Harris, G.G.: 1989, 'Concepts of Individual, Self and Person in Description Analysis', American Anthropologist 91, 599–612.
Harvis, R.: 1987, Games Against Nature: An Eco-Cultural History of the Nunu of Equatorial Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hesiod: 1914, Works and Days. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hinde, R.A.: 1987, Individuals, Relationship and Culture: Links between Ethology and the Social Sciences. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hohenberg, P.M. and L.H. Lees: 1995, The Making of Urban Europe 1000-1994, 2nd edn. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.
Horton, R.: 1995, 'Is Homosexuality Inherited?', New York Review of Books, July 13th.
Hudson, R.P.: 1992, 'Concepts of Disease in the West', in: K.F. Kiple (ed.), Cambridge World History of Human Disease.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Imhof, A.E.: 1996, Lost Worlds: How our European Ancestors Coped with Everyday Life and Why Life is So Hard Today.Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.
James, W.: 1902, The Varieties of Religious Experience. New York: Modern Library.
Jouanna, J.: 1998, 'The Birth ofWestern Medical Art', in: M.D. Grmek (ed.), Western Medical Thought from Antiquity to The Middle Ages. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press, pp. 22–71.
Kass, L.: 1975, 'Regarding the End of Medicine and the Pursuit of Health', The Public Interest (Summer) 40, 11–42.
Kessler, D.A.: 2000, 'Cancer and Herbs', New England Journal of Medicine 342, 1742–1743.
King, L.: 1954, 'What is Disease?', Philosophy of Science 21, 193–203.
Kleinman, A., L. Eisenberg and B. Good: 1978, 'Culture Illness and Care: Clinical Lessons from Anthropology and Cross-Cultural Research', Annals of Internal Medicine 88, 251–258.
Kleinman, A.: 1974, 'Cognitive Structures of Traditional Medical Systems', Ethnomedicine 3, 27–49.
Kopelman, L. and Moskop, J.: 1981, 'The Holistic Health Movement: A Survey and Critique', Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 6, 209–235.
Kopelman, L.M.: 1995, 'Conceptual and Moral Disputes About Futile and Useful Treatment', Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 20, 109–121.
Kramer, P.D.: 1994, Listening to Prozac. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Kraupl, Taylor F.: 1979, The Concept of Illness, Disease and Morbus. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kristeller, P.A.: 1964, Eight Philosophers of the Renaissance.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
von Kundratowitz, H.J.: 1991, 'The Medicalization of Old Age', in: M. Pelling and R.M. Smith (eds.), Life, Death and The Elderly: A Historical Perspective. New York: Routledge, pp. 134–164.
Kuriyama, S.: 1999, The Expressiveness of the Body and the Divergence of Greek and Chinese Medicine. New York: Zone Books.
Lakoff, G. and M. Johnson: 1999, Philosophy in The Flesh: The Embodied Mind and Its Challenge to Western Thought. New York: Basic Books.
Lazonick, W.: 1979, 'Industrial Relations and Technical Change: The Case of the Self Acting Mule', Cambridge Journal of Economics 3, 231–262.
Lee, R.B.: 1972, 'Kung Spatial Organization', Human Ecology 1, 125–147.
Levi-Strauss, C.: 1969, The Raw and The Cooked: Introduction to The Science of Mythology, volume I. New York: Harper & Row.
Levi-Strauss, C.: 1972, The Savage Mind. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Lewis, M.A.: 1998, 'The Epidemiology of Oral Contraceptive Use: A Critical Review of Studies on Oral Contraceptives and the Health of YoungWomen',American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 179, 1086–1097.
Lippmann, W.: 1929, A Preface to Morals. New York: McMillan.
Loux, F.: 1993, 'Folk Medicine', in: W.F. Bynum and R. Porter (eds.), Companion Encyclopedia of The History of Medicine.New York: Routledge, pp. 661–675.
Love, S. Dr.: 1998, Susan Love's Hormone Book: Making Informed Choices about Menopause. New York: Random House.
Lovejoy, A.O.: 1936, The Great Chain of Being. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.
Macpherson, C.B.: 1962, The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism. Toronto: Toronto University Press.
Margolis, J.: 1976, 'The Concept of Disease', Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1, 238–254.
McKnight, J.: 1995, The Careless Society: Community and Its Counterfeits. New York, Basic Books.
McKeown, T.: 1988, The Origins of Human Disease. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Mokyr, J.: 1990, The Levers of Riches: Technological Creativity and Economic Progress. New York: Oxford University Press.
Moore, R.I.: 1977, The Origins of European Dissent. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Morris, D.B.: 1998, Illness and Culture in the Postmodern Age.Berkeley: University of California Press.
Nordenfelt, L.: 1993, 'On the Relevance and Importance of the Notion of Disease', Theoretical Medicine 14, 15–26.
Nordenfelt, L.: 1996, On The Nature of Health: An Action Oriented Approach. Dordrecht, Kluwer.
Nordenfelt, L.: 1999, 'On Disability and Illness, a Reply to Edwards', Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 20, 181–189.
Nutton, V.: 1993, 'Humoralism. In the Concepts of Health, Illness, and Disease', in: W.F. Bynum and R. Porter (eds.), Companion Encyclopedia of The History of Medicine. New York: Routledge. pp. 281–291.
Odenwald, W.F., F.R. Aqueno, J.N. Katz, R. Strahman and R.C. Lewontin: 1995, 'Genes and Sexuality - An Exchange', New York Review of Books, 2nd November.
Owen, D.: 1984, 'Medicine, Morality and the Market', Lancet 2, 30–31.
Patel, M.: 1987, 'Problems in the Evaluation of Alternative Medicine', Social Science and Medicine 103, 674–678.
Parsons, T.: 1951, The Social System. New York: Free Press.
Pellegrino, E.D. and D.C. Thomasma: 1981, A Philosophical Basis of Medical Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Polunin, I.V.: 1967, 'Health and Disease in Contemporary Primitive Societies', in: D. Brothwell and A.T. Sandison (eds.), Disease in Antiquity: A survey of The Diseases, Injuries, and Surgeries of Early Populations. Springfield (IL): Charles C. Thomas, pp. 77–78.
Radin, P.: 1957, Primitive Man as a Philosopher, 2nd edn. New York: Dover.
Rawls, J.: 1971, A Theory of Justice. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.
Rawls, J.: 1980, 'Kantian Constructivism in Moral Theory', Journal of Philosophy 77, 519.
Resnick, N.M.: 1997, 'Geriatric Medicine', in: A.S. Fauci et al. (eds.), Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine, 14th edn.New York: McGrow Hill.
Richards, J.: 1991, Sex, Dissidence and Damnation - Minority Groups in the Middle Ages. London: Routledge.
Ridley, M.: 1996, The Origins of Virtue: Human Instincts and the Evolution of Cooperation. New York: Viking.
Risse, G.B.: 1999, Mending Bodies, Saving Souls: A History of Hospitals. New York: Oxford University Press.
Rollin, B.E.: 1979, 'On the Nature of Illness', Man and Medicine 4, 157–162.
Rossdale, M.: 1965, 'Health in a Sick Society', New Left Review 34, 82–91.
Sahlins, M.: 1978, 'Cultures as Protein and Profit', The New York Review of Books, November 23rd.
Sale, K.: 1995, Rebels Against the Future: The Luddites and Their War on the Industrial Revolution. New York: Addison Wesley.
Schama, S.: 1995, Landscape and Memory. New York: Knopf.
Scheper-Hughs, N. and M.M. Lock: 1987, 'The Mindful Body: A Prolegomena to Future Work in Medical Anthropology', Medical Anthropology Quarterly 1, 6–41.
Scheper-Hughs, N.: 1992, Death Without Weeping: The Violence of Everyday Life in Brazil. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Singer, M.: 1990, 'Reinventing Medical Anthropology', Social Science and Medicine 30, 179–187.
Snell, B.: 1953, The Discovery of the Mind: Greek Origins of European Thought. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.
Sontag, S.: 1989, Illness as Metaphor and AIDS and Its Metaphors. New York: Doubleday.
Spiro, H.M.: 1986, Doctors, Patients and Placebos. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Stivers, R.: 1999, Technology as Magic: The Triumph of the Irrational. New York: Continuum.
Taljedal, I.B.: 1997, 'Weak and Strong Holism', Scandinavian Journal of Social Medicine 27, 67–69.
Tambiah, S.J.: 1970, 'The Cosmological and Performative Significance of a Thai Cult of Healing through Meditation', Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 1, 97–132.
Tambiah, S.J.: 1990, Magic, Science, Religion and The Scope of Rationality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Taussig, M.: 1987, Shamanism, Colonialism and the Wild Man: A Study in Terror and Healing. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Tedlock, B.: 1987, 'An Interpretive Solution to the Problem of Humoral Medicine in Latin America', Social Science and Medicine 24, 1069–1083.
Thomas, K.: 1983, Man and the Natural World: A History of the Modern Sensibility. New York: Pantheon.
Walzer, M.: 1983, Spheres of Justice: A Defense of Pluralism and Equality. New York: Basic Books.
White, L.: 1967, 'The Historical Roots of our Ecologic Crisis', Science 155, 1203–1207.
Yates, F.: 1964, Giordano Bruno and the Hermetic Tradition.Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Young, A.: 1980, 'An Anthropological Perspective on Medical Knowledge', Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 5, 102–116.
Young, A.: 1982, 'The Anthropologies of Illness and Sickness', Annual Review of Anthropology 11, 257–285.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Barilan, Y.M., Weintraub, M. The naturalness of the artificial and our concepts of health, disease and medicine. Med Health Care Philos 4, 311–325 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1012034826744
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1012034826744