Abstract
In Mind in a Physical World (1998), Jaegwon Kim has recently extended his ongoing critique of `non-reductive materialist' positions in philosophy of mind by arguing that Nagel's model of reduction is the wrong paradigm in terms of which to contest the issue of psychophysical reduction, and that an altogether different model of scientific reduction – a functional model of reduction – is needed. In this paper I argue, first, that Kim's conception of the Nagelian model is substantially impoverished and potentially misleading; second, that his own functional model is problematic in several respects; and, third, that the basic idea underlying his functional model can well be accommodated within a properly reinterpreted Nagelian model. I conclude with some reflections on the issue of psychophysical reduction.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Ager T. A. and Aronson, J. L.: 1974, 'Are Bridge Laws Really Necessary?', Noûs 8, 119-134.
Beckermann, Ansgar: 1992, 'Supervenience, Emergence, and Reduction', in A. Beckermann (ed.), Emergence or Reduction?, De Gruyter, Berlin and New York.
Bickle, John (undated), 'Concepts of Intertheoretic Reduction in Contemporary Philosophy of Mind', in M. Nani and M. Marraffa (eds.), A Field Guide to the Philosophy of Mind, published electronically (http://www.uniroma3it/Kant/field/cir.htm).
Block, Ned: 1990, 'Can The Mind Change the World?', in G. Boolos (ed.), Meaning and Method, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Brook, D. H. M.: 1994, 'How to Perform a Reduction', Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 4, 803-814.
Causey, R. L.: 1972, 'Attribute-Identities in Microreductions', Journal of Philosophy 69, 407-422.
Cummins, Robert: 1983, The Nature of Psychological Explanation,MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Davidson, Donald: 1987, 'Knowing One's Own Mind', Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association 61, 441-458.
Fodor, Jerry: 1974, 'Special Sciences, or the Disunity of Science as aWorking Hypothesis', reprinted in N. Block (ed.): 1980, Readings in Philosophy of Psychology, Vol. 1, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Horgan, Terence: 1996, 'Kim on the Mind-Body Problem', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 47, 579-607.
Hooker, C. A.: 1981, 'Towards a General Theory of Reduction', Dialogue 20, 38-60, 201-236, 496-629.
Kim, Jaegwon: 1984, 'Concepts of Supervenience', in Kim (1993a).
Kim, Jaegwon: 1989, 'The Myth of Nonreductive Materialism', in Kim (1993a).
Kim, Jaegwon: 1990, 'The Philosophical Concept of Supervenience', in Kim (1993a).
Kim, Jaegwon: 1992, 'Multiple Realization and the Metaphysics of Reduction', in Kim, J. (1993a).
Kim, Jaegwon: 1993a, Supervenience and Mind, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Kim, Jaegwon: 1993b, 'Can Supervenience and “Non-Strict Laws” Save Anomalous Monism', in Kim (1993a).
Kim, Jaegwon: 1998, Mind in a Physical World, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Lewis, David: 1972, 'Psychophysical and Theoretical Identifications', Australasia Journal of Philosoph 50, 249-258.
Lewis, David: 1980, 'Mad Pain and Martian Pain', in N. Block (ed.), Readings in Philosophy of Psychology, Vol. 1, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Lewis, David: 1994, 'Lewis, David: Reduction of Mind', in S. Guttenplan (ed.), A Companion to the Philosophy of Mind, Blackwell, Oxford and Cambridge, MA.
Marras, Ausonio: 1993, 'Psychophysical Supervenience and Nonreductive Materialism', Synthese 95, 275-304.
Marras, Ausonio: 2000, 'Critical Notice of Kim (1998)', Canadian Journal of Philosophy 20, 137-160.
Nagel, Ernest: 1961, The Structure of Science, Harcourt, Brace & World, New York.
Putnam, Hilary: 1970, 'On Properties', in Philosophical Papers, Vol. 1, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Richardson, Robert: 1979, 'Functionalism and Reductionism', Philosophy of Science 46, 533-558.
Richardson, Robert: 1982, 'How Not to Reduce a Functional Psychology', Philosophy of Science 49, 125-137.
Schaffner, K.: 1967, 'Approaches to Reduction', Philosophy of Science 34, 137-147
Sklar, Lawrence: 1967, 'Types of Inter-Theoretic Reduction', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 18, 109-124.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Marras, A. Kim On Reduction. Erkenntnis 57, 231–257 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020932406567
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020932406567