Abstract
Many physicians assert that new cost-control mechanisms inappropriately interfere with clinical decision-making. They claim that high costs arise from poorly practiced medicine, and argue that effective utilization of resources is best promoted by advancing the scientific and ethical ideals of medicine. However, the claim is not warranted by empirical evidence. In this essay, I show how it rests upon aesthetic considerations associated with diagnostic elegance. I first consider scientific rationality generally. After a review of analytical empiricist and socio-historical approaches in the philosophy of science, a form of Kant's aesthetic is used to explain how scientific discovery and justification are linked, and to show how meta-theoretical considerations associated with the goals and method of science work together with exemplars of practice. This analysis enables us to understand how the ideals of medicine as a science guide the initial patient history and physical exam in such a way that a parsimonious use of tests is indicated. Aesthetic considerations unite the basic scientific and ethical commitments of the modern medical paradigm and are central for rightly understanding clinical judgment.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Angell, M.: 1987, ‘Medicine: The endangered patient-centered ethic’, Hastings Center Report 17, pp. 12–13.
Baird, D.: 1995, ‘Meaning in a material medium’, PSA 1994 2, pp. 441–451.
Baird, D. and A. Nordmann: 1994, ‘Facts-well-put’, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 45, pp. 37–77.
Bole, T.: 1995, ‘The neologism ONTOI in Broussais's condemnation of medical ontology’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 20(5), pp. 543–549.
Buchanan, A.: 1996, ‘Is there a medical profession in the house?’, In: R. Spece, D. Shimm and A. Buchanan (eds.), Conflicts of Interest in Clinical Practice. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 105–136.
Cassell, E.: 1976, The Healer's Art. Cambridge, MS: MIT Press.
Canguilhem, G.: 1991, The Normal and the Pathological. New York: Zone Books.
Eddy, D.: 1996, Clinical Decision Making: From Theory to Practice. Sudbury, MS: Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
Engel, G.: 1977, ‘The care of the patient: Art or science?’, The Johns Hopkins Medical Journal 140, pp. 222–232.
Engel, G.: 1978, ‘Biomedicine's failure to achieve Flexnerian standards of education’, Journal of Medical Education 53, pp. 387–392.
Engel, G.: 1980, ‘The clinical application of the biopsychosocial model’, The American Journal of Psychiatry 137(5), pp. 535–544.
Engel, G.: 1988, ‘How much longer must medicine's science be bound by a seventeenth century world view?’, In: K.L. White (ed.), The Task of Medicine: Dialogue at Wickenburg. Menlo Park, California: The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, pp. 113–136.
Engelhardt, H.T.: 1996, Foundations of Bioethics, Second Edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fleck, L.: 1979 [1935], Genesis and Development of a Scientific Fact. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Flexner, A.: 1910, Medical Education in the United States and Canada: A Report to the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching. New York: The Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.
Gadamer, H.G.: 1992, Truth and Method, J. Weinsheimer and D. Marshall (trs.). New York: Crossroad.
Goodman, J. and G. Musgrave: 1992, Patient Power: Solving America's Health Care Crisis. Washington, D.C.: Cato Institute.
Halberstam, M.: 1999, Totalitarianism and the Modern Conception of Politics. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Hempel, C.: 1965, Aspects of Scientific Explanation. NewYork: Free Press.
Hempel, C.: 1988, ‘Scientific rationality: Analytic vs. pragmatic perspectives’, In E.D. Klemke, R. Hollinger and A.D. Kline (eds.), Introductory Readings in the Philosophy of Science. Buffalo, New York: Prometheus Books, pp. 292–304.
Kant, I.: 1965 [1781], Critique of Pure Reason, N.K. Smith (tr.). New York: St. Martin's Press.
Kant, I.:1987 [1790], Critique of Judgment, W.S. Pluhar (tr.). Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company.
Kassirer, J.P.: 1998, ‘Managed care - should we adopt a new ethic?’, New England Journal of Medicine 339(6), pp. 397–398.
Khushf, G.: 1992, ‘Post-modern reflections on the ethics of naming’, In J.L. Peset and D. Gracia (eds.), The Ethics of Diagnosis. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 275–300.
Khushf, G.: 1997, ‘Why bioethics needs the philosophy of medicine: Some implications of reflection on concepts of health and disease’, Theoretical Medicine 18, pp. 145–163.
Khushf, G.: 1998, ‘A radical rupture in the paradigm of modern medicine: Conflicts of interest, fiduciary obligations, and the scientific ideal’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 23(1), pp. 98–122.
Khushf, G. and R. Gifford: 1998, ‘Understanding, assessing, and managing conflicts of interest’, In: L. McCullough, J. Jones and B. Brody (eds.), Surgical Ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 342–366.
Kuhn, T.: 1996, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Third Ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Lauden, L.: 1977, Progress and its Problems: Toward a Theory of Scientific Growth. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Makkreel, R.A.: 1990, Imagination and Interpretation in Kant: The Hermeneutical Import of the Critique of Judgment. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.
McAllister, J.W.: 1996, Beauty and Revolution in Science. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Miles, S.H. and R. Koepp: 1995, ‘Comments on the AMA Report “Ethical Issues in Managed Care”’, Journal of Clinical Ethics 6, pp. 306–311.
Mitchell, J.: 1996, ‘Physician joint ventures and self-referral: An empirical perspective’, In: R. Spece, D. Shimm and A. Buchanan (eds.), Conflicts of Interest in Clinical Practice. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 300–317.
Morreim, E.H.: 1995, Balancing Act: The New Medical Ethics of Medicine's New Economics. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press.
Pellegrino, E.: 1978, ‘Medical economics and morality: The conflict of canons’, Hospital Progress (August), pp. 50–55.
Pellegrino, E.:1980, ‘Medical economics and medical ethics: Points of conflict and reconciliation’, Journal of MAG 69 (March), pp. 175–183.
Pellegrino, E. And Thomasma, D.: 1981, A Philosophical Basis of Medical Practice: Toward a Philosophy and Ethic of the Healing Professions. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pellegrino, E.: 1994, ‘Words can hurt you: Some reflections on the metaphors of managed care’, JABFP 7(6), pp. 505–510.
Pellegrino, E.: 1996, ‘The autopsy: Some ethical reflections on the obligations of pathologists, hospitals, families, and society’, Arch Pathol Lab Med 120, pp. 739–742.
Pellegrino, E.: 1998, ‘Managed care: An ethical reflection’, Christian Century 115(22), pp. 748–751.
Popper, K.: 1959, The Logic of Scientific Discovery. New York: Free Press.
Reiser, S.J.: 1978, Medicine and the Reign of Technology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Relman, A.: 1980, ‘The new medical-industrial complex’, The New England Journal of Medicine 303, pp. 963–970.
Relman, A.: 1985, ‘Dealing with conflicts of interest’, The New England Journal of Medicine 313, pp. 749–751.
Rodwin, M.A.: 1993, Medicine, Money and Morals: Physician's Conflicts of Interest. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Sanchez-Gonzalez, M.: 1990, ‘Medicine in John Locke's philosophy’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 15, pp. 675–695.
Schaffner, K.: 1993, Discovery and Explanation in Biology and Medicine. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Shortell, S.M. et al.: 1998, ‘Physicians as double agents: Maintaining trust in an era of multiple accountabilities’, Journal of the American Medical Association 280(12), pp. 1102–1108.
Toombs, S.K.: 1992, The Meaning of Illness: A Phenomenological Account of the Different Perspectives of Physician and Patient. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Wulff, H., S.A. Pedersen and A. Storr: 1990, Philosophy of Medicine: An Introduction, Second Edition. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Khushf, G. The Aesthetics of Clinical Judgment: Exploring the Link between Diagnostic Elegance and Effective Resource Utilization. Med Health Care Philos 2, 141–159 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009941101276
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009941101276