Abstract
A significant proportion of conservationists' work is directed towards efforts to save disappearing species. This relies upon the belief that species extinction is undesirable. When justifications are offered for this belief, they very often rest upon the assumption that extinction brought about by humans is different in kind from other forms of extinction. This paper examines this assumption and reveals that there is indeed good reason to suppose current anthropogenic extinctions to be different in kind from extinctions brought about at other times or by other factors. Having considered – and rejected – quantity and rate of extinction as useful distinguishing factors, four alternative arguments are offered, each identifying a way in which anthropogenic extinction is significantly different from other forms of extinction, even mass extinction: (1) Humans are a different kind of natural cause from other causes of extinction; (2) Extinctions brought about by humans are uniquely persistent; (3) Anthropogenic extinctions are effectively random whereas past mass extinctions are rule-bound; (4) The impact of the current anthropogenic extinction event differs from the impact of other extinction events of the past, such that future recovery may not follow past patterns. Together, these four arguments suggest that the present-day extinction event brought about by humans may be unprecedented and that we cannot clearly extrapolate from past to present recovery from extinctions. Although insufficient as justification for the claim that present-day extinctions are undesirable, the arguments provide some ammunition for conservationists' conviction that species extinction – in which humans play an accelerating role – ought to be prevented.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anon: 1995, 'In Brief', New Scientist 148, No.2004, p. 13.
Begon et al.: 1990, Ecology, Individuals, Populations and Communities, Blackwell Scientific Publications, Cambridge, Mass, p. 842.
Bowler, P.J.: 1992, The Fontana History of the Environmental Sciences, Fontana Press, London, p. 426.
Callicott, J.B.: 1995, 'The Value of Ecosystem Health', Environmental Values 4, 345–361.
Campbell, N.A.: 1987, Biology (second edition), Benjamin/Cummings, California, pp. 500–501.
Dawkins, R.: 1986, The Blind Watchmaker, Penguin, London.
Diamond, J.: 1984, 'Historical Extinction: A Rosetta Stone for Understanding Prehistoric Extinctions', in P.S. Martin and R.G. Klein (eds.), Quaternary Extinctions: A prehistoric revolution, University of Arizona Press, Tuscon, Arizona, p. 838.
Ehrlich, P. and Ehrlich, A.: 1981, Extinction, Random House, New York, pp. 7–10; 28.
Elliot, R.: 1994, 'Extinction, Restoration, Naturalness', Environmental Ethics 16, 135–143.
Evernden, N: 1985, The Natural Alien; humankind and environment, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.
Gould, S.J.: 1977, Ever Since Darwin, Penguin, London, p. 42.
Gould, S.J.: 1989, Wonderful Life, Penguin, London, pp. 305–307.
Groombridge, B. (ed.): 1992, Global Biodiversity: Status of the Earth's Living Resources (A Report compiled by the World Conservation Monitoring Centre), Chapman and Hall, London, p. 203.
HMSO: 1994, Biodiversity: the UK action plan, HMSO, London, p. 18.
International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources: 1988, 1988 IUCN Red List Of Threatened Animals, IUCN, Cambridge, UK, p. iii.
Norton, B.: 1986, 'On the inherent Danger of Undervaluing Species' and 'Epilogue', in B. Norton, The Preservation of Species; the value of biological diversity, Princeton University Press, New Jersey, pp. 113; 270.
Ollason, J.G.: 1991, 'What Is This Stuff Called Fitness?', Biology and Philosophy 6, 81–92.
Ponting, C.: 1992, A Green History of the World, Penguin, London, p. 193.
Porritt J.: 1996, 'Jonathon Porritt', BBC Wildlife 14(1), 61.
Price, E.O.: 1984, 'Behavioural Aspects of Animal Domestication', The Quarterly Review of Biology 59(1), 1–32.
Primack, R.: 1993, Essentials of Conservation Biology, Sinaur Associates Inc., Sunderland, Mass., pp. 30; 75–88.
Ruse, M.: 1982, Darwinism Defended: A Guide to the Evolution Controversies, Addison-Wesley, London.
Shimony, A.: 1989, 'The Non-Existence Of The Principle Of Natural Selection', Biology and Philosophy 4.
Shrader-Frechette K.S. and McCoy, E.D.: 1994, 'Biodiversity, Biological Uncertainty, and Setting Conservation Priorities', Biology and Philosophy 9, 180–182.
Sober, E.: 1984, The Nature of Selection: Evolutionary Theory in Philosophy, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Tudge, C.: 1991, Last Animals at the Zoo; how mass extinction can be stopped, Hutchison Radius, London, p. 40.
Vermeij, G.J.: 1986, 'The Biology of Human-Caused Extinction', in B. Norton (ed.), The Preservation of Species; The value of biological diversity, Princeton University Press, New Jersey, pp. 30; 42–44.
Waters, C.K.: 1986, 'Natural Selection Without Survival Of The Fittest', Biology and Philosophy 1, 207–225.
Wilcox, B.: 1988, 'Tropical Deforestation and Extinction', in International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources, IUCN Red List of Threatened Animals, IUCN, Cambridge, p. ix.
Wilson, E.O.: 1992, The Diversity of Life, Penguin, London, pp. 67–68.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Aitken, G. Extinction. Biology & Philosophy 13, 393–411 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006567916998
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006567916998