Abstract
Patent citations to the research literature offer a way for identifying and comparing contributions of scientific and technical knowledge to technological development. This case study applies this approach through a series of analyses of citations to Dutch research papers listed on Dutch-invented and foreign patents granted in the US during the years 1987–1996.
First, we examined the general validity and utility of these data as input for quantitative analyses of science-technology interactions. The findings provide new empirical evidence in support of the general view that these citations reflect genuine links between science and technology. The results of the various analyses reveal several important features of industrially relevant Dutch science: (1) the international scientific impact of research papers that are also highly cited by patents, (2) the marked rise in citations to Dutch papers on foreign-invented patents; (3) the large share of author-inventor self-citations in Dutch-invented patents; (4) the growing relevance of the life sciences, (5) an increase in the importance of scientific co-operation. We also find significant differences between industrial sectors as well as major contributions of large science-based multinational enterprises, such as Philips, in domestic science-technology linkages.
The paper concludes by discussing general benefits and limitations of this bibliometric approach for macro-level analysis of science bases in advanced industrialised countries like the Netherlands.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Kline, S. J., N. Rosenberg, An overview of innovation. In: R. Landau, N. Rosenberg (Eds) The positive sum game: harnessing technology for economic growth. Washington DC: National Academy Press, 1986.
Martin, B., A. Salter, D. Hicks, K. Pavitt, J. Senker, M. Scharp, N. Von Tunzelman, The relationship between publicly funded basic research and economic performance. Report for HM Treasury, Brighton: SPRU, 1996.
David, P. A., D. Mowery, E. Steinmuller, Analysing the economic payoffs from basic research, Economics of Innovation and New Technology, 2 (1993) 73-90.
Mansfield, E., Academic research and innovation, Research Policy, 20 (1991) 1-12.
Mansfield, E., Academic research underlying industrial innovations: sources, characteristics and financing, Review of Economic and Statistics, 77 (1995) 55-62.
Mansfield, E., Academic research and industrial innovation: an update of empirical findings, Research Policy, 26 (1998) 773-776.
Archibugi, D., Patenting as an indicator of technological innovation: a review, Science and Public Policy, 19 (1992) 357-368.
Coward, H. R., J. J. Franklin, Identifying the science-technology interface: matching patent data to a bibliometric model, Science, Technology & Human Values, 14 (1989) 50-77.
Noyons, E. C. M., A. F. J. Van Raan, H. Grupp, U. Schmoch, Exploring the science and technology interface: inventor-author relations in laser medicines research, Research Policy, 23 (1994) 443-457.
Carpenter, M. P., M. Cooper, F. Narin, Linkage between basic research and patents, Research Management, 23 (1980) 30-35.
Narin, F., E. Noma, Is technology becoming science?, Scientometrics, 7 (1985) 369-381.
Narin, F., D. Olivastro, Status report: linkage between technology and science, Research Policy, 21 (1992) 237-249.
Narin, F., K. S. Hamilton, D. Olivastro, Linkage between agency-supported research and patented industrial technology, Research Evaluation, 5 (1995) 183-187.
Narin, F., K. S. Hamilton, D. Olivastro, The increasing linkage between US technology and public science, Research Policy, 26 (1997) 317-330.
Narin, F., D. Olivastro, Linkage between patents and papers: an interim EPO/US comparison, Scientometrics, 41 (1998) 51-59.
Meyer, M., Does science push technology? Patents citing scientific literature (forthcoming in Research Policy).
Schmoch, U., Tracing the knowledge transfer from science to technology as reflected in patent indicators, Scientometrics, 26 (1993) 193-211.
Collins, P., S. Wyatt, Citations to patents in the basic research literature, Research Policy, 17 (1988) 65-74.
Narin, F., M. Rosen, D. Olivastro, Patent citation analysis: new validation studies and linkage statistics. In: Van Raan A. F. J. et al. (Eds), Science and technology indicators: their use in science policy and their role in science studies. Leiden: DSWO Press, 1989.
Grupp, H., U. Schmoch, Perceptions of scientification of innovation as measured by referring between patents and papers: dynamics in science-based fields of technology. In: Grupp, H. (Ed.), Dynamics of science-based innovation. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1992.
Hicks, D., P. Isard, B. Martin, A morphology of Japanese and European corporate research networks, Research Policy, 25 (1996) 359-378.
Godin, B., Research and the practice of publication in industries, Research Policy, 25 (1996) 587-606.
Tijssen, R. J. W., Th. N. Van Leeuwen, J. C. Korevaar, Scientific publication activity of industry in the Netherlands, Research Evaluation, 6 (1996) 1-15.
Tijssen, R. J. W., Th. N. Van Leeuwen, H. Hollanders, B. Verspagen, Netherlands Observatory of Science and Technology: Science and Technology Indicators 1998: English summary version, Leiden/Maastricht: CWTS/MERIT, 1998.
Grupp, H., U. Schmoch, Patent statistics in the age of globalisation: new legal procedures, new analytical methods, new economic interpretation, Research Policy, 28 (1999) 377-396.
Carpenter, M. P., F. Narin, Validation study: patent citations as indicators of science and foreign dependence, World Patent Information, 5 (1983) 180-185.
Meyer, M., Patents citing scientific literature: is the relationship causal or casual? The IPTS Report, No. 28 (1998) 11-18.
Griliches, Z., Patent statistics as economic indicators: a survey, Journal of Economic Literature, 28 (1990) 1661-1707.
National Science Foundation, Science & Engineering Indicators 1998, National Science Board, Arlington, 1998.
Narula R, J. Hagedoorn, Innovating through strategic alliances: moving towards ínternatíonal partnerships and contractual agreements, Technovation, 19 (1999) 283-294.
Anderson, J., N. Williams, D. Seemungal, F. Narin, D. Olivastro, Human genetic technology: exploring the links between science and technology. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 8 (1996) 135-156.
European Commission, Second European Report on S&T Indicators Report 1997, Brussels, 1997.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Tussen, R.J.W., Buter, R.K. & van Leeuwen, T.N. Technological Relevance of Science: An Assessment of Citation Linkages between Patents and Research Papers. Scientometrics 47, 389–412 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005603513439
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005603513439