Why the Infinite Decision Puzzle is Puzzling
- Cite this article as:
- Barrett, J.A. & Arntzenius, F. Theory and Decision (2002) 52: 139. doi:10.1023/A:1015564123344
Pulier (2000, Theory and Decision 49: 291) and Machina (2000, Theory and Decision 49: 293) seek to dissolve the Barrett–Arntzenius infinite decision puzzle (1999, Theory and Decision 46: 101). The proposed dissolutions, however, are based on misunderstandings concerning how the puzzle works and the nature of supertasks more generally. We will describe the puzzle in a simplified form, address the recent misunderstandings, and describe possible morals for decision theory.