An investigation of the potential existence of ``food deserts'' in rural and urban areas of Northern Ireland
Cite this article as: Furey, S., Strugnell, C. & McIlveen, M.H. Agriculture and Human Values (2001) 18: 447. doi:10.1023/A:1015218502547 Abstract
Food Deserts have recently beenidentified in the United Kingdom. They havebeen defined by Tessa Jowell, UK GovernmentHealth Minister, as an area ``where people donot have easy access to healthy, fresh foods,particularly if they are poor and have limitedmobility.'' The above definition is particularlyrelevant in Northern Ireland, where it isestimated that 32% of households do not haveeasy access to a car and it is recognized thatcertain groups in Northern Ireland are amongstthe poorest consumers in the United Kingdom.The phenomenon has been further exacerbated bythe effect of large grocery retailers locatingon the periphery of towns and the subsequentdisplacement effect of independent retailers inthe town center. The resultant effect is suchthat disadvantaged consumers cannot accessfresh, quality, nutritious foods at anaffordable price. Preliminary researchindicates that certain consumer groups areexcluded from equitable shopping provision –possibly to the detriment of their healthstatus. Research methodology includes aconsumer questionnaire, consumer focus groups,interviews, and comparative shopping exercisesthat confirm an inability among vulnerableconsumer groups to achieve an affordable,healthy diet. This was further complicated bynon-car owners' and lower-income family unitsneeding to shop locally and more frequentlythan their higher-income, car-ownercounterparts. This was demonstrated with theuse of shopping diaries. Future research to beconducted includes a large-scale survey acrossNorthern Ireland to ascertain accessibility,availability, and affordability of qualityfresh foods and to distinguish the consumergroups who are most vulnerable.
Accessibility Affordability Availability Food Deserts Out-of-town References
Anon. (1997). “Tony Blair's big idea.” In
The Economist, December 6, p. 59.
BBC News On-Line (1998).
Northern Ireland: Facts and Figures http://bbcnews.org/low/english/events/northern-ireland/ facts.
Caraher, M., P. Dixon, T. Lang, and R. Car-Hill (1998). “Access to healthy foods: Part I. Barriers to accessing healthy foods: Differentiations by gender, social class, income and mode of transport.”
Health Education Journal
Cecora, J. (1993). “Spatial behaviour of rural consumer households in highly developed economies-survey results for Western Germany.”
Journal of Consumer Studies and Home Economics
Cull, C. (1997). “Nice little earners.”
Grocer, July 26, pp. 28–36.
Cummins, S. and S. Macintyre (1999). “The location of food stores in Urban Areas: A case study in Glasgow.”
British Food Journal
Department of Health (1999).
Saving Lives-Our Healthier Nation
. London: Stationery Office.
Donkin, A. J. M. et al. (2000). “Mapping access to food in a deprived area: The development of price and availability indices.”
Public Health Nutrition
Dowler, E. A. (2000).
Report on Literature Regarding Access to (Food) Shops. University of London.
Dowler, E. A. and M. Raats (2000).
Report on Literature Regarding Access to (Food) Shops
. London: University of London.
Elliott, V. (1997). “Food deserts threaten health of poor and old.”
The Times, 05.11.97, p. 5.
Field, D. (1999).
What Would it Take for Everyone in Ontatio to Have Adequate Access to Affordable Nutritious Food?
General Consumer Council for Northern Ireland (2000a).
Rail and Bus Services a Mess
. Belfast: GCC for NI.
General Consumer Council for Northern Ireland (2000b). Personal communication.
General Consumer Council for Northern Ireland (1998).
Food Retailing in Northern Ireland
. Belfast: General Consumer Council for Northern Ireland.
Hamilton, W. L., J. T. Cook, W. W. Thompson, L. F. Buran, E. A. Frongillo Jr., C. M. Olson, and C. A. Wehler (1997).
Household Food Security in the United States in 1995: Summary Report of the Food Security Measurement Project
. USDA, Virginia, p. vi.
Jenner, G. (1998). “Sainsbury's share soars in Northern Ireland.”
Supermarketing. 18.09.98, p. 8.
Kempson, E. (1996).
Life on a Low Income
(pp. 23–24). York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
Lang, T. (1997).
Food Policy for the 21st Century: Can It Be Both Radical and Reasonable
? (pp. 1–30). London: Thames Valley University.
Lang, T. and M. Caraher (1998). “Access to healthy foods: Part II. Food poverty and shopping deserts: What are the implications for Health promotion policy and practice?”
Health Education Journal
Laurence, J. (1997). “The poor of Britain are going hungry.”
The Independent, 15.10.97 (London), p. 7.
Leather, S. (1992). “Less money, less choice: poverty and diet in the UK today.” In National Consumer Council (1992)
Your Food, Whose Choice?
(pp. 72–94). London: HMSO.
Leather, S. (1997). “Food poverty: The making of modern malnutrition.”
70(1): 21, 23.
Low Income Project Team (1996).
Low Income, Food, Nutrition and Health: Strategies for Improvement
. London: LIPT.
Northern Ireland Economic Council (1990).
Retailing in Northern Ireland
(pp. 1–69). Belfast: NIEC.
Piachaud, D. and J. Webb (1996).
The Price of Food: Missing Out on Mass Consumption (pp. 14, 30, 32). London School of Economics and Political Science.
Policy Action Team 13 (1999).
National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal: Improving Shopping Access for People Living in Deprived Neighbourhoods
(pp. 1–2). London: Department of Health.
Power, A. (2000). “Social exclusion.”
Sheehy, C. (1998). “Do we want to shop and change?”
Evening Herald, 08.10.98 (Dublin), pp. 10–12.
Social Exclusion Unit (1998).
Bringing Britain Together: A National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal. SEU.
Strugnell, C. J. (1998). “Food deserts-fact or fiction.”
Nutrition and Food Science (6): 349–350.
Vaines, E. (1999). “The sacred nature of food: A family perspective.” In C. J. Strugnell and G. A. Armstrong (eds.),
Consumer Education: An International Dimension. Conference Proceedings for the XIXth International Consumer Studies and Home Economics Research Conference
. Belfast: University of Ulster.
Webster, J. and V. Johnson (2000).
Reaching the Parts... Community Mapping: Working Together to Tackle Social Exclusion and Food Poverty
. London: Sustain.
Williams, C. and E. A. Dowler (1994).
Framework of the Determinants of Food and Nutrition Security in the UK
. London: University of London.
Google Scholar Further Reading
Furey, S., H. McIlveen, and C. J. Strugnell (1999). “Food deserts-an issue of social justice.”
Journal of Media and Culture 2(7) (http://www.uq.edu.au/mc/).
Furey, S., H. McIlveen, and C. J. Strugnell (2000). “An investigation to identify the characteristics, extent and location of 'food deserts' in both rural and urban areas of Northern Ireland.”
(October) 35(2): 198.
Google Scholar Copyright information
© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001