Instability Of Ex Post Aggregation In The Bolker–Jeffrey Framework And Related Instability Phenomena
- Mathias Risse
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Suppose n Bayesian agents need to make a decision as a group. The groupas a whole is also supposed to be a Bayesian agent whose probabilities andutilities are derived or aggregated in reasonable ways from the probabilitiesand utilities of the group members. The aggregation could beex ante, i.e., interms of expected utilities, or it could be ex post, i.e., in terms of utilitiesonly, or in terms of utilities and probabilities separately. This study exploresthe ex post approach. Using the Bolker/Jeffrey framework, we show thatex post aggregation is subject to an instability phenomenon. That is, it mayhappen that the group preference between actions ``flips back and forth'' dependingon the level of detail in which the decision problem is described. Structurally verysimilar phenomena also occur elsewhere in social choice theory, in statistics (Simpson'sParadox), and in voting theory (Ostrogorski's Paradox).
- Anscombe, G.: 1976, ‘On Frustration of the Majority by Fulfillment of theMajority'sWill’, Analysis 36, 161–168.
- Arrow, K.: 1964, ‘The Role of Securities in theOptimal Allocation of Risk-Bearing’, Review of Economic Studies 31.
- Bickel, P., E. Hammel, and J. O'Connell, ‘Sex Bias in Graduate Admissions: Data from Berkeley’, in W. Fairley and F. Mosteller, Statistics and Public Policy, Addison-Wesley, Reading.
- Blyth, C.: 1972, ‘On Simpson's Paradoxand the Sure-Thing-Principle’, Journal of the American Statistical Association 67, 364–366.
- Bradley, R.: 1998, ‘A Representation Theorem for a Decision Theory with Conditionals’, Synthese 116, 187–229.
- Broome, J.: 1990, ‘Bolker Jeffrey Expected Utility Theory and AxiomaticUtilitarianism’, Review of Economic Studies, 477–502.
- Cartwright, N.: 1979, ‘Causal Laws andEffective Strategies’, Nous 13, 419–436.
- DeGroot M.: 1989, Probability and Statistics,Addison-Wesley, Reading.
- Hammond, P.: 1982, ‘Ex-ante and Ex-post Welfare Optimality underUncertainty’, Economica 48, 231–250.
- Hammond, P.: 1983, ‘Ex-post Optimality as aDynamically Consistent Objective for Collective Choice under Uncertainty’, in: P. Pattanaik an M. Salles (eds), Social Choice and Welfare, North Holland, Amsterdam.
- Hild, M.: forthcoming, ‘The Instability ofEx Post Aggregation’.
- Hild, M., R. Jeffrey, and M. Risse: forthcoming, ‘Preference AggregationAfter Harsanyi’, forthcoming in M. Salles and J. Weymark, Justice, Political Liberalism, and Utilitarianism: Proceedings of the Caen Conference in Honor of John Harsanyi and John Rawls, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
- Hylland, A. and R. Zeckhauser: 1979, ‘The Impossibility of Bayesian GroupDecision Making with Separate Aggregation of Beliefs and Values’, Econometrica 47, 1321–1336.
- Jeffrey, R.: 1983, The Logic of Decision, 2nd edition, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
- Joyce, J.: 1999, Foundations of Causal Decision Theory, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
- Levi, I.: 1990, ‘Pareto Unanimity and Consensus’, Journal of Philosophy 87.
- Malinas, G.:1997, ‘Simpson's Paradox and the Wayward Researcher’, Australasian Journal of Philosophy 75, 343–359.
- Mittal, Y.: 1991, ‘Homogeneity of Subpopulations and Simpson's Paradox’, Journal ofthe American Statistical Association 86, 167–172.
- Mongin, P.: 1995, ‘Consistent BayesianAggregation’, Journal of Economic Theory 33, 313–351.
- Nermuth, M.: 1991, ‘Two-StageDiscrete Aggregation: the Ostrogorski Paradox and Related Phenomena’, Social Choice and Welfare 9, 99–116.
- Ordeshook, P.: 1986, Game Theory and Political Theory, Cambridge UniversityPress, Chicago.
- Saari, D.: 1987, ‘The Source of Some Paradoxes from Social Choice and Probability’,Journal of Economic Studies 41, 1–22.
- Savage, L.: 1954, The Foundations of Statistics,Wiley, New York.
- Tanguiane, A.: 1994, ‘Arrow's Paradox and Mathematical Theory ofDemocracy’, Social Choice and Welfare 11, 1–82.
- van Fraassen, B.: 1989, Laws andSymmetry, Clarendon, Oxford.
- Vaupel, J. and A. Yashin: 1985, ‘Heterogeneity's Ruses: SomeSurprising Effects of Selection on Population Dynamics’, The American Statistician 39, 176–185.
- Wagner, C.: 1982, ‘Simpson's Paradox in Real Life’, The American Statistical Association 36,46–48.
- Wagner, C.: 1983, ‘Anscombe's Paradox and the Rule of Three-Fourths’, Theory andDecision 15, 303–308.
- Warner, F.: 1970, Foundations of Differentiable Manifolds and LieGroups, Scott, Foresman, Glenview.
- Young, P. and M. Balinski: 1994, Fair Representation,Yale University Press, New Haven.
- Instability Of Ex Post Aggregation In The Bolker–Jeffrey Framework And Related Instability Phenomena
Volume 55, Issue 2 , pp 239-270
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Additional Links
- Mathias Risse (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Department of Philosophy, Yale University, New Haven, CT, 06520, U.S.A.