Is Skepticism about Self-Knowledge Coherent?
- Gary Ebbs
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
In previous work I argued that skepticism about the compatibility ofanti-individualism with self-knowledge is incoherent. Anthony Brueckner isnot convinced by my argument, for reasons he has recently explained inprint. One premise in Brueckner's reasoning is that a person'sself-knowledge is confined to what she can derive solely from herfirst-person experiences of using her sentences. I argue that Brueckner'sacceptance of this premise undermines another part of his reasoning – hisattempt to justify his claims about what thoughts our sincere utterances ofcertain sentences would express in various possible worlds. I describe aweird possible world in which a person who uses Brueckner's reasoning endsup with false beliefs about what thoughts her sincere utterances of certainsentences would express in various possible worlds. I recommend that wereject Brueckner's problematic conception of self-knowledge, and adopt onethat better fits the way we actually ascribe self-knowledge.
- Brueckner, A. (1986) Brains in Vats. Journal of Philosophy 83: pp. 148-167
- Brueckner, A. (1997) Is Skepticism About Self-Knowledge Incoherent?. Analysis 57: pp. 287-290
- Burge, T. Individualism and the Mental. In: French, , Uehling, , Wettstein, eds. (1979) Midwest Studies in Philosophy. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis
- Ebbs, G. (1996) Can We Take Our Words at Face Value?. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 56: pp. 499-530
- Ebbs, G. (1997) Rule-Following and Realism. Harvard University Press, Cambridge,MA
- Putnam, H. The Meaning of “Meaning”. In: Putnam, H. eds. (1975) Mind, Language, and Reality. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
- Is Skepticism about Self-Knowledge Coherent?
Volume 105, Issue 1 , pp 43-58
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Additional Links
- Gary Ebbs (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Department of Philosophy, University of Illinois, Urbana, IL, 61801-3611, USA