Abstract
Preservation of the biological diversity and ecosystems in protected areas can be achieved through projects linking conservation of the protected areas with improved standards of living for resident peoples within surrounding buffer zones. This is the hypothetical claim of the integrated conservation and development project (ICDP) approach to protected area management. This paper, based on several years of experience with the Ranomafana National Park Project in Madagascar, questions the major assumptions of this approach from ethical and practical perspectives. The four basic strategies available to ICDPs – protected areas, buffer zones, compensation, and economic development – are analyzed and shown to be deficient or untested in the case of Ranomafana. Recommendations are made to explore conservation models other than the western conception of the national park, to modify the notion of a buffer zone outside the protected area, to redistribute money or other resources directly to the poor people living in and around the protected areas, and to eliminate the middle men in the development business. An appeal is made to focus on local education, organization and discipline in order to promote self-determination and self-reliance among resident peoples of protected areas. The paper argues that a public works program, similar to the Roosevelt administration's Civilian Conservation Corps of the 1930s, funded through a hard-currency endowment or other innovative financing mechanism, should be tried as a replacement for the currently questionable ICDP approach at Ranomafana.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Armstrong, Susan J. and Richard G. Botzler (eds.), Environmental Ethics: Divergence and Convergence (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1993).
Ascher, William and Robert Healy, Natural Resource Policymaking in Developing Countries: Environment, Economic Growth, and Income Distribution (Duke University Press, Durham, NC, 1990).
Barclay, Tony, Terms of Reference: Reinventing USAID – A Look inside the Laboratory (Development Alternatives, Inc., Washington D.C., 1994).
Batisse, Michel, “The Biosphere Reserve: A Tool for Environmental Conservation and Management,” Environmental Conservation 9(2) (1982), 101–111.
Bawa Village Community, “Mozambique's Tchuma Tchato Initiative of Resource Management on the Zambezi: A Community Perspective,” Society and Natural Resources 10 (1997), 409–413.
Beede, Susan F., “Le Parc National des Cévennes,” in Patrick C. West and Steven R. Brechin (eds.) Resident Peoples and National Parks: Social Dilemmas and Strategies in International Conservation (University of Arizona Press, Tucson, 1991), pp. 100–106.
BRAC, The Net: Power Structure in Ten Villages (Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee, Dhaka, 1983).
Brandstetter, Robert, Hugh Popenoe, Alison Jolly and Donald Stone, Evaluation of the First Phase of the Ranomafana National Park Project (U.S. Agency for International Development/Madagascar, Antananarivo, 1993).
Brechin, Steven R. and Patrick C. West, “Protected Areas, Resident Peoples, and Sustainable Conservation: The Need to Link Top-Down with Bottom-up,” Society and Natural Resources 3 (1990), 77–79.
Chambers, Robert, Rural Development: Putting the Last First (Longman Scientific and Technical, Essex, 1983).
Colchester, Marcus, “Beyond ‘Participation’ Indigenous Peoples, Biological Diversity Conservation and Protected Area Management,” Unasylva 186(47) (1996), 33–39.
Comstock, Gary L., “Do Agriculturalists Need a New, an Ecocentric, Ethic? 1994 Presidential Address to the Agriculture, Food, and Human Values Society,” Agriculture and Human Values 12(1) (1995), 2–16.
Crossley, Rachel A, Tony Lent, Diana Propper de Callejon and Camilla Sethare, “Innovative Financinging for Sustainable Forestry,” Unasylva 188(48) (1997), 23–31.
del Castillo, Dennis, Final Report for the Agricultural Development Component of the Ranomafana National Park Project in Madagascar (North Carolina State University, Raleigh, 1993).
Duke, Ranomafana National Park: Integrating Rainforest Conservation with Sustainable Development in Madagascar: A grant proposal to USAID/Madagascar (Duke University, Durham, 1990).
Ferraro, Paul J., Natural Resource Use in the Southeastern Rain Forests of Madagascar and the Local Impacts of Establishing the Ranomanfana National Park. Unpublished Masters Thesis (Duke University, Durham, 1994).
Fiallo, Elba A., and Susan K. Jacobson, “Local Communities and Protected Areas: Attitudes of Rural Residents Towards Conservation and Machalilla National Park, Ecuador,” Environmental Conservation 22(3) (1995), 241–249.
Fimbel, Cherly and Robert Fimbel, “Conservation and Civil Strife: Two Perspectives from Central Africa (Rwanda: The Role of Local Participation)”, Conservation Biology 11(2) (1997), 308–314.
Gallegos, Carl M. “Madagascar: Unrealized Potential in Natural Resources,” Journal of Forestry 95(2) (1997), 10–15.
Glaeser, Bernhard, Environment, Development, Agriculture: Integrated Policy through Human Ecology (M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, 1995).
GMU, Guidelines and Administrative Requirements for Protected Area Development Grants (Grants Management Unit, Antananarivo, 1996).
Gow, David D., “Collaboration in Development Consulting: Stooges, Hired Guns, or Musketeers?,” Human Organization 50(1) (1991), 1–15.
Hancock, Graham, Lords of Poverty: The Power, Prestige, and Corruption of the International Aid Business (The Atlantic Monthly Press, New York, 1989).
Hardenbergh, Sabrina H.B., Food Distribution Among Malagasy Cultivators. Unpublished paper (University of Georgia, Athens, 1993a).
Hardenbergh, Sabrina H.B., Nutrition and the Forest. Paper presented at the Ranomafana National Park Project Phase II Planning Conference, August 29–September 5 (Fianarantsoa and Ranomafana, Madagascar, 1993).
Harmon, David, “National Park Residency in Developed Countries: The example of Great Britain,” in Patrick C. West and Steven R. Brechin (eds.) Resident Peoples and National Parks: Social Dilemmas and Strategies in International Conservation (University of Arizona Press, Tucson, 1991), pp. 33–34.
Harper, Janice, In Their Sights: The Role of the Independent Researcher Working near a Development Project. Paper presented at the Society for Applied Anthropology 1997 Annual Meeting, March 4–9, 1997.
Harrison, Paul, The Third Revolution: Environment, Population and a Sustainable World (I. B. Tauris & Co, Ltd., London, 1992).
Hart, Terese and John Hart, “Conservation and Civil Strife: Two Perspectives from Central Africa (Zaire: New Models for an Emerging State),” Conservation Biology 11(2) (1997), 308–314.
Hill, Edwin G., In the Shadow of the Mountain: The Spirit of the CCC (Washington State University Press, Pullman, 1990).
Ite, Uwem E., “Community Perceptions of the Cross River National Park, Nigeria,” Environmental Conservation 23(4) (1996), 351–357.
Johnson, Bruce, “Soil Survey”. Final Report for the Agricultural Development Component of the Ranomafana National Park Project in Madagascar (North Carolina State University, Raleigh, 1993).
Johnson, Bruce and Stan Buol, Trip Report: Man and the Biosphere Project (North Carolina State University, Raleigh, 1992).
Klitgaard, Robert E., Tropical Gangsters (Basic Books, New York, 1990).
Kothari, Ashish, Saloni Suri and Neena Singh, “People and Protected Areas: Rethinking Conservation in India”, The Ecologist 25(5) (1995), 188–194.
Kremen, Claire, Adina M. Merenlender and Dennis D. Murphy, “Ecological Monitoring: A Vital Need for Integrated Conservation and Development Programs in the Tropics,” Conservation Biology 8(2) (1994), 388–397.
Kull, Christian A., “The Evolution of Conservation Efforts in Madagascar,” International Environmental Affairs 8(1) (1996), 50–86.
Lee, Elizabeth, Spotlight: Madagascar. Population Today. May, 7, 1994.
Mackinnon, John R.,Kathleen Mackinnon, G. Child and Jim Thorsell, Managing Protected Areas in the Tropics (International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources, Gland, 1986).
MPAEF, “Decret No 91–250, portant création du Parc National No 4 de Ranomafana dans les Fivondronampokontany d'Ifanadiana, de Fianarantsoa II et d'Ambohimahasoa, Faritany de Fianarantsoa,” Ministère de la Production Animale (Elevage et Pêche) et des Eaux et Forêts, Repoblika Demokratika Malagasy, 1991).
Newton, Lisa J., and Catherine K. Dillingham, Watersheds: Classic Cases in Environmental Ethics (Wadsworth Publishing Company, Belmont, CA, 1994).
Oren, Carrie and Thomas T. Struhsaker, “Conservation and Civil Strife: Two Perspectives from Central Africa (Foreign Aid and Conservation of Tropic Forests: An Action Plan for Change),” Conservation Biology 11(2) (1997), 308–314.
Palmer, Paula, Environment, Development and Indigenous Knowledge Systems: A Participatory Action Research Approach Toward Natural Resource Management in Costa Rica's Cocles/Keoldi Indian Reserve. Unpublished M. A. Thesis (Michigan State University, East Lansing, 1989).
Peters, Dai, The Human Dimensions of Natural Resource Management: A Case Study of Ranomafana National Park, Madagascar. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation (North Carolina State University, Raleigh, 1995).
Peters, Joe, “Sharing National Park Entrance Fees: Forging New Partnerships in Madagascar,” Society and Natural Resources 11(4) (1998), 517–530.
Peters, Joe, “Local Participation in Conservation of the Ranomafana National Park, Madagascar,” Journal of World Forest Resource Management 8(2) (1997), 109–135.
Peters, Joe, “Ecotourism in Madagascar: Innovative Policies in Support of New Destinations,” Nature and Wildlife 11(1): (1995), 17–39.
Peters, Joe, Reconciling Conflicts Between People and Parks at Ranomafana, Madagascar: Management Interventions and Legislative Alternatives. Paper Presented at the National Symposium on Indigenous Knowledge and Contemporary Social Issues, March 3–5, 1994. University of South Florida, Tampa (1994a).
Peters, William J, Attempting to Integrate Conservation and Development Among Resident Peoples of the Ranomafana National Park, Madagascar. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation (North Carolina State University, Raleigh, 1994b).
Rahman, Anisur, People's Self-Development: Perspectives on Participatory Action Research (Zed Books, London, 1993).
Razafy, Aim, Sans Cible, Madagascar Tribune – No. 1022, 06 Mai 1992. Antananarivo (Madagascar, 1992).
Resor, James P. “Debt-For-Nature Swaps: A Decade of Experience and New Directions for the Future”, Unasylva 188(48) (1997), 15–22.
Schumacher, E.F., Small is Beautiful: Economics as if People Mattered (Harper & Row, New York, 1973).
Stone, Roger D., Wildlands and Human Needs: Reports from the Field (World Wildlife Fund, Washington, D.C., 1990).
Tisdell, Clement A, “Issues in Biodiversity Conservation Including the Role of Local Communities,” Environmental Conservation 22(3) (1995): 216–222 & 228.
USAID, Madagascar CPSP: Country Program Strategic Plan, FY 1993–98 (United States Agency for International Development/Madagascar, Antananarivo, 1992).
Vandergeest, Peter, “Property Rights in Protected Areas: Obstacles to Community Involvement as a Solution in Thailand,” Environmental Conservation 23(3) (1996): 259–268.
Weil, Andrew, The Natural Mind: A New Way of Looking at Drugs and the Higher Consciousness (Houghton Mifflin, Boston, 1972).
Wells, Michael P., “The Social Role of Protected Areas in the New South Africa”, Environmental Conservation 23(4) (1996), 322–331.
Wells, Michael and Katrina Brandon, People and Parks: Linking Protected Area Management with Local Communities (World Bank, World Wildlife Fund, and Agency for International Development, Washington, D.C., 1997).
West, Patrick C., “Introduction,” in Patrick C. West and Steven R. Brechin (eds.), Resident Peoples and National Parks: Social Dilemmas and Strategies in International Conservation (University of Arizona Press, Tucson, 1991), pp. xv–xxiv.
Westoby, Jack, The Purpose of Forests: Follies of Development (Basil Blackwell, New York, 1987).
Wright, R. Michael, Brian Houseal and Cebaldo De Leon, “Kuna Yala: Indigenous Biosphere Reserve in the Making,” Parks 10(3) (1985), 25–28.
Yaffee, Steven L., The Wisdom of the Spotted Owl: Policy Lessons for a New Century (Island Press, Washington, D.C., 1994).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Peters, J. Transforming the Integrated Conservation and Development Project (ICDP) Approach: Observations from the Ranomafana National Park Project, Madagascar. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 11, 17–47 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007796628731
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007796628731