Abstract
To potentially improve second-year medical students’ peer engagement and learning outcomes, we modified 2 weeks of an 8-week hybrid problem-based learning (PBL) curriculum to include team-based learning (TBL) strategies and a greater emphasis on discussion during PBL activities. Evaluation of this combined PBL–TBL 2-week curriculum (Study 1) included anonymous student and faculty ratings of their curricular experiences before, during, and after the new 2-week PBL–TBL activities and comparison of students’ end of block examination scores with a control group of students who did not have the PBL–TBL activities. Results were that students and faculty rated the 2 weeks in which the combined PBL–TBL was introduced as more positive on several items related to engagement, productivity, and skills development compared to the PBL-only weeks. Students’ scores on in-common multiple choice and clinical case essay examination questions were significantly higher than control cohorts’ scores regardless of academic class rank. In the following academic year (2011), we incorporated PBL–TBL into a full 8-week block. Anonymous student and faculty surveys at end of block were consistent with ratings in 2010. Analyses of students’ end of block examination scores compared to a 2009 control cohort found no overall significant differences for in-common questions; however, students in the lower third of class ranks in 2011 had significantly improved multiple choice examination scores compared to those from 2009. We conclude that incorporating TBL activities into PBL curricula that include student discussion is an effective strategy for improving second-year medical students’ engagement, self-perceived skill development and productivity, and performance outcomes for students with lower academic ranks.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Khoo H (2003) Implementation of problem‐based learning in Asian medical schools and students' perceptions of their experience. Med Educ 37:401–409
Kinkade S (2005) A Snapshot of the status of problem-based learning in U.S. medical schools, 2003–04. Acad Med 80(3):300–301
Barrows HS (1996) Problem-based learning in medicine and beyond: a brief overview. In: Wilkerson L, Gilselaers H (eds) Bringing problem-based learning to higher education: theory and practice. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco
Schmidt HG, Rotgans JI, Yew EHJ (2011) The process of problem-based learning: what works and why. Med Educ 45:792–806
Sanson-Fisher R, Lynagh MC (2005) Problem-based learning: a dissemination success story? MJA 183(5):258–260
Koh GC-H, Khoo HE, Wong ML, Koh D (2008) The effects of problem-based learning during medical school on physician competency: a systematic review. CMAJ 178(1):34–41
Karimi R (2011) Interface between problem-based learning and a learner-centered paradigm. Adv Med Educ Pract 2:117–125
Distlehorst LH, Dawson E, Robbs R, Barrows HS (2005) Problem-based learning outcomes: the glass half-full. Acad Med 80(3):294–299
Khan H, Taqui AM, Khawaja MR, Fatmi Z (2007) Problem-based versus conventional curricula: influence on knowledge and attitudes of medical students towards health research. PLoS ONE 7:e632
Lim WK (2012) Dysfunctional problem-based learning curricula: resolving the problem. BMC Med Educ 12:89
Delva RA, Woodhouse S, Hains S, Birthwhistle RV, Knapper C, Kirby JR (2000) Does PBL matter? Relations between instructional context, learning strategies, and learning outcomes. Adv Health Sci Educ 5:167–177
Wu L-T, Hsu L-C, Sun S-S, Wu H-C, Tu M-G, Kwan C-Y (2012) The change of student perception toward PBL in a medical school with a hybrid-PBL preclinical curriculum in Taiwan. J Med Educ 16(3):97–113
Christianson CE, McBride RB, Vari RC, Olson L, Wilson HD (2007) From traditional to patient-centered learning: curriculum change as an intervention for changing institutional culture and promoting professionalism in undergraduate medical education. Acad Med 82(11):1079–1088
Tosteson DC (1991) New pathways for medical education. JAMA 265(8):1022–1023
Hoffman K, Hosokawa M, Blake R, Headrick L, Johnson G (2006) Problem-based learning outcomes: ten years of experience at the University of Missouri–Columbia School of Medicine. Acad Med 81:617–625
Tan NC, Kandiah N, Chan YH, Umapathi T, Lee SH, Tan K (2011) A controlled study of team-based learning for undergraduate clinical neurology education. BMC Med Educ 11:91
Koles GP, Stolfi A, Borges NJ, Nelson S, Parmelee DX (2010) The impact of team-based learning on medical students’ academic performance. Acad Med 85:1739–1745
Haidet P, Schneider V, Onady G (2008) Research and scholarship: team-based learning in health professions education. In: Michaelsen L, Parmelee D, McMahon K, Levine R (eds) Team-based learning for health professions education: a guide to using small groups for improving learning. Stylus Publishing, Sterling, pp 117–130
McInerney MJ, Fink LD (2003) Team-based learning enhances long-term retention and critical thinking in an undergraduate microbial physiology course. Microbiol Educ 4:3–12
Zgheib NK, Simaan JA, Sabra R (2010) Using team-based learning to teach pharmacology to second year medical students improves student performance. Med Teach 32(2):130–135
Michaelsen LK, Knight AB, Fink LD (eds) (2002) Team-based learning: a transformative use of small groups. Praeger, Westport, pp 27–52
Okubo Y, Ishiguro N, Suganuma T et al (2012) Team-based learning, a learning strategy for clinical reasoning, in students with problem-based learning tutorial experiences. Tohoku J Exp Med 227:23–29
Abdelkhalek N, Hussein A, Gibbs T, Hamdy H (2010) Using team-based learning to prepare medical students for future problem-based learning. Med Teach 32:123–129
Kirschner PA, Sweller J, Clark RE (2006) Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: An analysis of the failure of constructivist, discovery, problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching. Educ Psychol 41:75–86
Haidet P, Levine RE, Parmelee DX, Crow S, Kennedy F, Kelly PA et al (2012) Guidelines for reporting team-based learning activities in the medical and health sciences education literature. Acad Med 87(3):292–299
Kennedy RR (2009) The power of in-class debates. Act Learn High Educ 10(3):225–236
Butler AC (2010) Repeated testing produces superior transfer of learning relative to repeated studying. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 36(5):1118–1133
Trappler B (2006) Integrated problem-based learning in the neuroscience curriculum—the SUNY downstate experience. BMC Med Educ 6:47
Halaas GW, Hill T, Christianson C (2010) University of North Dakota School of Medicine and Health Sciences. Acad Med 85(9):S434–S438
Vasan NS, DeFouw DO, Compton S (2009) A survey of student perceptions of TBL in anatomy curriculum: favorable views unrelated to grades. Anat Sci Educ 2:150–155
Koles P, Nelson S, Stolfi A, Parmelee D, DeStephen D (2005) Active learning in a Year 2 pathology curriculum. Med Educ 39:1045–1055
Holen A (2000) The PBL, group: self-reflections and feedback for improved learning and growth. Med Teach 22:485–488
Pant D (2010) Student self‐reflection and peer feedback in small group process: In search of a “yardstick” in a hybrid PBL medical curriculum. Dissertation Abstracts International 72(4):1164A (UMI 3445659)
Srinivasan M, Li S-TT, Meyers FJ, Pratt DD et al (2011) Teaching as a competency: competencies for medical educators. Acad Med 86(10):1211–1220
Team-based Learning Collaborative Website (2013) Accessed at http://www.teambasedlearning.org/
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Vogeltanz-Holm, N., Olson, L.M., Borg, K.E. et al. Implementation and Evaluation of a Team-Based Learning Approach Within a Hybrid Problem-Based Learning Medical Education Curriculum. Med.Sci.Educ. 24, 125–133 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40670-014-0008-3
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40670-014-0008-3