Abstract
With the advent of evolutionary developmental research, or EvoDevo, there is hope of discovering the roles that the genetic bases of development play in morphological evolution. Studies in EvoDevo span several levels of organismal organization. Low-level studies identify the ultimate genetic changes responsible for morphological variation and diversity. High-level studies of development focus on how genetic differences affect the dynamics of gene networks and epigenetic interactions to modify morphology. Whereas an increasing number of studies link independent acquisition of homoplastic or convergent morphologies to similar changes in the genomes, homoplasies are not always found to have identical low-level genetic underpinnings. This suggests that a combination of low- and high-level approaches may be useful in understanding the relationship between genetic and morphological variation. Therefore, as an empirical and conceptual framework, we propose the causality horizon to signify the lowest level that allows linking homoplastic morphologies to similar changes in the development. A change in a system below the causality horizon cannot be generalized. In more concrete terms, homoplastic morphologies cannot be reduced to the same change in gene regulation when that change occurs below the causality horizon; rather, a higher-level mechanism should be identified.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abouheif E, Wray GA (2002) Evolution of the gene network underlying wing polyphenism in ants. Science 297:249–252
Abzhanov A, Protas M, Grant BR, Grant PR, Tabin CJ (2004) Bmp4 and morphological variation of beaks in Darwin’s finches. Science 305:1462–1465
Abzhanov A, Kuo WP, Hartmann C, Grant BR, Grant PR, Tabin CJ (2006) The calmodulin pathway and evolution of elongated beak morphology in Darwin’s finches. Nature 442:563–567
Akam M (1998) Hox genes: from master genes to micromanagers. Curr Biol 8:R676–R678
Alberch P (1982) Developmental constraints in evolutionary processes. In: Bonner JT (ed) Evolution and development. Dahlem Konferenzen. Springer, Heidelberg, pp 313–332
Atchley WR (1987) Developmental quantitative genetics and the evolution of ontogenies. Evolution 41:316–330
Barton N, Partridge L (2000) Limits to natural selection. BioEssays 22:1075–1084
Beloussov LV (1998) The dynamic architecture of a developing organism: an interdisciplinary approach to the development of organisms. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Carroll SB, Grenier JK, Weatherbee SD (2001) From DNA to diversity: molecular genetics and the evolution of animal design. Blackwell, Malden
Charlesworth B, Lande R (1982) Morphological stasis and developmental constraint–no problem for Neo-Darwinism. Nature 296:610
Collier JR, Monk NA, Maini PK, Lewis JH (1996) Pattern formation by lateral inhibition with feedback: a mathematical model of delta-notch intercellular signalling. J Theor Biol 183:429–446
Coyne JA (2006) Comment on “Gene regulatory networks and the evolution of animal body plans.” Science 313:761
DeFaveri J, Shikano T, Shimada Y, Goto A, Merilä J (2011) Global analysis of genes involved in freshwater adaptation in threespine sticklebacks (Gasterosteus aculeatus). Evolution 65:1800–1807
Dworkin I, Gibson G (2006) Epidermal growth factor receptor and transforming growth factor-beta signaling contributes to variation for wing shape in Drosophila melanogaster. Genetics 173:1417–1431
Fisher RA (1930) The genetical theory of natural selection. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Frankel N, Erezyilmaz DF, McGregor AP, Wang S, Payre F, Stern DL (2011) Morphological evolution caused by many subtle-effect substitutions in regulatory DNA. Nature 474:598–603
Gehring WJ (1993) Exploring the homeobox. Gene 135:215–221
Gibson G, Hogness DS (1996) Effect of polymorphism in the Drosophila regulatory gene Ultrabithorax on homeotic stability. Science 271:200–203
Gilbert SF, Sarkar S (2000) Embracing complexity: organicism for the 21st century. Dev Dyn 219:1–9
Gong Z, Matzke NJ, Ermentrout B, Song D, Vendetti JE, Slatkin M, Oster G (2012) Evolution of patterns on Conus shells. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 109:E234–E241
Goodwin BC (1994) How the leopard changed its spots. Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London
Haldane JBS (1932) The causes of evolution. Longmans, London. Reprint: Princeton University Press, Princeton (1990)
Hallgrímsson B, Brown JJY, Hall BK (2005) The study of phenotypic variability: an emerging research agenda for understanding the developmental-genetic architecture underlying phenotypic variation. In: Hallgrímsson B, Hall BK (eds) Variation: a central concept in biology. Academic Press, New York, pp 525–551
Harjunmaa E, Kallonen A, Voutilainen M, Hämäläinen K, Mikkola ML, Jernvall J (2012) On the difficulty of increasing dental complexity. Nature 483:324–327
Harris MP, Williamson S, Fallon JF, Meinhardt H, Prum RO (2005) Molecular evidence for an activator-inhibitor mechanism in development of embryonic feather branching. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102:11734–11739
Janssens H, Hou S, Jaeger J, Kim AR, Myasnikova E, Sharp D, Reinitz J (2006) Quantitative and predictive model of transcriptional control of the Drosophila melanogaster even skipped gene. Nat Genet 38:1159–1165
Jeffery WR (2009) Regressive evolution in Astyanax cavefish. Annu Rev Genet 43:25–47
Knecht AK, Hosemann KE, Kingsley DM (2007) Constraints on utilization of the EDA-signaling pathway in threespine stickleback evolution. Evol Dev 9:141–154
Leinonen T, McCairns RJS, Herczeg G, Merilä J (2012) Multiple evolutionary pathways to decreased lateral plate coverage in freshwater threespine sticklebacks. Evolution 66:3866–3875
Marcellini S, Simpson P (2006) Two or four bristles: functional evolution of an enhancer of scute in Drosophilidae. PLoS Biol 4:2252–2261
Marcucio RS, Young NM, Hu D, Hallgrimsson B (2011) Mechanisms that underlie co-variation of the brain and face. Genesis 49:177–189
Meinhardt H (1982) Models of biological pattern formation. Academic Press, London
Mezey JG, Houle D, Nuzhdin SV (2005) Naturally segregating quantitative trait loci affecting wing shape of Drosophila melanogaster. Genetics 169:2101–2113
Moreira J, Deutsch A (2005) Pigment pattern formation in zebrafish during late larval stages: a model based on local interactions. Dev Dyn 232:33–42
Nakamasu A, Takahashi G, Kanbe A, Kondo S (2009) Interactions between zebrafish pigment cells responsible for the generation of Turing patterns. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106:8429–8434
Nebot A, Medina S, Cellier FE (1994) The causality horizon: limitations to predictability of behavior using fuzzy inductive reasoning. Proc Conf Model Simul 3:492–496
Newman SA, Comper WD (1990) “Generic” physical mechanisms of morphogenesis and pattern formation. Development 110:1–18
Newman SA, Müller GB (2005) Origination and innovation in the vertebrate limb skeleton: an epigenetic perspective. J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol 304:593–609
Nijhout HF (1990) Metaphors and the role of genes in development. BioEssays 12:441–446
Palsson A, Gibson G (2000) Quantitative developmental genetic analysis reveals that the ancestral dipteran wing vein prepattern is conserved in Drosophila melanogaster. Dev Genes Evol 210:617–622
Pennisi E (2002) Evolutionary biology: evo-devo enthusiasts get down to details. Science 298:953–955
Plikus MV, Zeichner-David M, Mayer JA, Reyna J, Bringas P, Thewissen JG, Snead ML, Chai Y, Chuong CM (2005) Morphoregulation of teeth: modulating the number, size, shape and differentiation by tuning Bmp activity. Evol Dev 7:440–457
Prum RO (2005) Evolution of the morphological innovations of feathers. J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol 304:570–579
Rebeiz M, Pool JE, Kassner VA, Aquadro CF, Carroll SB (2009) Stepwise modification of a modular enhancer underlies adaptation in a Drosophila population. Science 326:1663–1667
Salazar-Ciudad I (2006) Developmental constraints versus variational properties: how pattern formation can help to understand evolution and development. J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol 306:107–125
Salazar-Ciudad I (2008) Tooth morphogenesis in vivo, in vitro, and in silico. Curr Top Dev Biol 81:341–371
Salazar-Ciudad I (2009) Looking at the origin of phenotypic variation from pattern formation gene networks. J Biosci 34:573–587
Salazar-Ciudad I, Jernvall J (2002) A gene network model accounting for development and evolution of mammalian teeth. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99:8116–8120
Salazar-Ciudad I, Jernvall J (2010) A computational model of teeth and the developmental origins of morphological variation. Nature 464:583–586
Salazar-Ciudad I, Jernvall J, Newman SA (2003) Mechanisms of pattern formation in development and evolution. Development 130:2027–2037
Sheth R, Marcon L, Bastida MF, Junco M, Quintana L, Dahn R, Kmita M, Sharpe J, Ros MA (2012) Hox genes regulate digit patterning by controlling the wavelength of a turing-type mechanism. Science 338:1476–8140
Shvartsman SY, Muratov CB, Lauffenburger DA (2002) Modeling and computational analysis of EGF receptor-mediated cell communication in Drosophila oogenesis. Development 129:2577–2589
True JR, Haag ES (2001) Developmental system drift and flexibility in evolutionary trajectories. Evol Dev 3:109–119
von Dassow M, Davidson LA (2007) Variation and robustness of the mechanics of gastrulation: the role of tissue mechanical properties during morphogenesis. Birth Defects Res C Embryo Today 81:253–269
Weiss K, Fullerton SM (2000) Phenogenetic drift and the evolution of genotype–phenotype relationships. Theor Popul Biol 57:187–195
Wu P, Jiang TX, Shen JY, Widelitz RB, Chuong CM (2006) Morphoregulation of avian beaks: comparative mapping of growth zone activities and morphological evolution. Dev Dyn 235:1400–1412
Acknowledgments
We thank Jeffrey Schwartz for providing a forum to develop ideas presented in the article, and David Polly and Kate MacCord for critically reviewing the manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Salazar-Ciudad, I., Jernvall, J. The Causality Horizon and the Developmental Bases of Morphological Evolution. Biol Theory 8, 286–292 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13752-013-0121-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13752-013-0121-3