Electron Detachment Dissociation of Underivatized Chloride-Adducted Oligosaccharides
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Kornacki, J.R., Adamson, J.T. & Håkansson, K. J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom. (2012) 23: 2031. doi:10.1007/s13361-012-0459-y
- 689 Downloads
Chloride anion attachment has previously been shown to aid determination of saccharide anomeric configuration and generation of linkage information in negative ion post-source decay MALDI tandem mass spectrometry. Here, we employ electron detachment dissociation (EDD) and collision activated dissociation (CAD) for the structural characterization of underivatized oligosaccharides bearing a chloride ion adduct. Both neutral and sialylated oligosaccharides are examined, including maltoheptaose, an asialo biantennary glycan (NA2), disialylacto-N-tetraose (DSLNT), and two LS tetrasaccharides (LSTa and LSTb). Gas-phase chloride-adducted species are generated by negative ion mode electrospray ionization. EDD and CAD spectra of chloride-adducted oligosaccharides are compared to the corresponding spectra for doubly deprotonated species not containing a chloride anion to assess the role of chloride adduction in the stimulation of alternative fragmentation pathways and altered charge locations allowing detection of additional product ions. In all cases, EDD of singly chloridated and singly deprotonated species resulted in an increase in observed cross-ring cleavages, which are essential to providing saccharide linkage information. Glycosidic cleavages also increased in EDD of chloride-adducted oligosaccharides to reveal complementary structural information compared to traditional (non-chloride-assisted) EDD and CAD. Results indicate that chloride adduction is of interest in alternative anion activation methods such as EDD for oligosaccharide structural characterization.
Key wordsMS/MS Tandem mass spectrometry CAD collision activated dissociation EDD electron detachment dissociation FT-ICR Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance Carbohydrate Structural characterization Oligosaccharide Chloride adduct
Interest in glycomics, the study of biological carbohydrates (or saccharides), continues to grow as the importance of glycoconjugates is realized. Glycoconjugates are oligosaccharide (or glycan)-containing biomolecules whose activity has been linked to a variety of important biological functions [1, 2], such as protein folding  and immune system response . The role of glycoconjugates as crucial cellular mediators is increasingly apparent as glycosylation is one of the most prevalent post-translational modifications. Variety among oligosaccharide structures and isomeric forms may play a significant role for the biological function of glycoconjugates, and an understanding of the structural complexities of these compounds is a necessary first step in fully realizing their function. Oligosaccharides contain many diverse features and complete structural characterization requires information regarding linkage, sequence, branching, and anomeric configuration (a term defining the stereochemistry of the glycosidic bond).
Mass spectrometry is widely employed for the structural characterization of oligosaccharides due to its high sensitivity, minimal sample consumption, and relatively short acquisition times. Instruments that allow for tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS or MSn) have emerged as indispensable tools for oligosaccharide structural analysis [5, 6, 7], particularly when allowing for multiple stages of MS/MS. Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS) offers the advantage of several MS/MS techniques combined with high mass accuracy and resolution. Tandem MS of oligosaccharides generally produces glycosidic and cross-ring product ions, both of which reveal important information regarding structure. Glycosidic cleavages occur between monosaccharide units and indicate saccharide sequence and branching while cross-ring cleavages provide information regarding saccharide linkage and are particularly useful when occurring at branching residues. Several factors affect the extent of fragmentation and the types of product ions detected, including the ionization technique, the lifetime of the ion before detection, and the amount of energy deposited into the ion. The presence of functional groups also affects fragmentation, and Zaia and coworkers have shown that sialylated oligosaccharides (those containing a sialic acid residue) require more energy to induce fragmentation than their asialo or nitrate-adducted counterparts in collision activated dissociation (CAD) .
Most modern mass analyzers rely upon low energy CAD for MS/MS experiments. Low energy activation methods typically generate glycosidic bond cleavages when applied to oligosaccharide analysis. However, it has been shown that oligosaccharides adducted with alkali, alkaline earth, and transition metals often yield more cross-ring product ions than the corresponding protonated species following vibrational excitation methods such as CAD and infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) [9, 10, 11, 12, 13]. More recently, vibrational activation has been used in conjunction with electron capture dissociation (ECD) [14, 15] for positive ion mode oligosaccharide analysis [13, 16]. ECD occurs via radical-driven fragmentation pathways when polycationic molecules are irradiated with low-energy electrons (~1 eV) and generates charge-reduced radical species and product ions. ECD has been widely used for peptide and protein cation characterization  because it regularly leaves labile modifications intact while provoking extensive backbone fragmentation [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23]. Previous work from our lab demonstrated that oligosaccharides adducted with divalent metal cations exhibit highly complementary fragmentation in ECD compared to IRMPD . Han and Costello have recently shown that electron transfer dissociation (ETD) in combination with CAD is also valuable for characterization of permethylated oligosaccharides . However, permethylation does involve additional wet chemistry, can be challenging for small sample amounts, and is not compatible with, e.g., sulfonated glycans such as glycosaminoglycans [GAGs].
Fewer studies regarding the analysis of oligosaccharides in negative ion mode mass spectrometry are available, but it is known that differences in fragmentation are observed between oligosaccharide anions and cations [25, 26, 27, 28]. Following CAD, anionic oligosaccharides tend to produce mostly C-type glycosidic and A-type cross-ring product ions while cationic species produce mostly B and Y-type glycosidic product ions (Domon and Costello nomenclature) . Electron detachment dissociation (EDD) is a negative ion mode ion-electron reaction MS/MS technique typically showing lower fragmentation efficiency than ECD/ETD and requiring longer ion-electron interaction times (~1 s). Nevertheless, rich fragmentation chemistry occurs in EDD, frequently providing unique structural information for oligosaccharides, including GAGs [30, 31, 32, 33]. Unlike ECD, EDD is used for the fragmentation of polyanions in negative ion mode . Introduced in 2001, EDD relies upon radical formation from electron detachment and subsequent fragmentation of an originally polyanionic species when irradiated with medium-energy electrons (>10 eV). In addition to oligosaccharides, EDD has been applied to peptides [34, 35, 36, 37], oligonucleotides [38, 39], and gangliosides . Negative ion mode analysis is particularly amenable to acidic oligosaccharides as such compounds readily deprotonate. In addition, the tendency of sialylated oligosaccharides to lose sialic acid residues is not as apparent in negative compared to positive ion mode . Furthermore, solvent background is typically lower in negative ion mode. We have previously shown a significant increase in A- and X-type cross-ring fragments following EDD of neutral and sialylated oligosaccharides that are not observed by vibrational excitation techniques .
Chloride anion attachment to analyze carbohydrates was first demonstrated by Harvey for N-linked glycans  and later used by Cole and co-workers to examine post-source decay of neutral and acidic oligosaccharides for determination of anomeric configurations . Noting the ease at which neutral oligosaccharides form [M + anion]– adducts, anion attachment was implemented to simultaneously analyze neutral and acidic carbohydrates without switching the instrument polarity. Here, we examine EDD of underivatized chloride-adducted oligosaccharides. The current study focuses on the fragmentation patterns of neutral and sialylated oligosaccharides and compares these fragmentation patterns to those obtained following EDD of doubly deprotonated species and CAD of chloride-adducted species.
2.1 Sample Preparation
Maltoheptaose (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA), LS-tetrasaccharides (LSTa and LSTb), and an asialo biantennary glycan (NA2; V-Labs, Covington, LA, USA) were prepared in a solution of 50 % methanol (Fisher, Fair Lawn, NJ, USA) and 0.1 % ammonium hydroxide (Sigma) to a final concentration of 3 μM. Chloride-adducted samples were prepared in a solution of 50 % methanol with ammonium chloride (Sigma-Aldrich) added to a final concentration of 21 μM. Samples were refrigerated and undisturbed for at least 1 week.
2.2 Mass Spectrometry
All experiments were performed with a 7-T FT-ICR mass spectrometer with a quadrupole front end (APEX-Q, Bruker Daltonics, Billerica, MA, USA) . Oligosaccharide solutions were infused via an external Apollo II electrospray ion source at a flow rate of 60 μL/h with the assistance of N2 nebulizing gas. The off-axis sprayer was grounded and the inlet capillary was set to approximately 2.5–3.1 kV for generation of oligosaccharide anions. N2 drying gas, 175 °C, was applied to assist desolvation of the ESI droplets. Following ion accumulation in the first hexapole for 50 ms, ions were mass selectively accumulated in the second hexapole for 2–6 s. Ions were then transferred through high-voltage ion optics and captured with dynamic trapping in an Infinity ICR cell . The experimental sequence leading to the ICR cell fill was looped 4–8 times to achieve maximum precursor ion signal for EDD. Precursor ions were further isolated in the ICR cell using correlated harmonic excitation fields (CHEF) . An indirectly heated hollow dispenser cathode  was used to perform EDD with a constant heating current of 2.0 A and a pulsed cathode bias voltage that varied between –20 and –35 V for 1–2 s. A 6 mm diameter lens electrode located immediately in front of the cathode was held 0.4–1.0 V higher than the bias voltage to regulate the number of electrons entering the ICR cell . External CAD was performed in a hexapole following mass selective ion accumulation with argon as collision gas.
2.3 Data Analysis
All spectra were acquired with XMASS software (Bruker Daltonics) in broadband mode from m/z 200–2,000 using 256 k data points and summed over 20 or 50 scans for CAD or EDD experiments, respectively. Data processing was performed with MIDAS software . A Hanning window function was applied, and the time-domain data were zero filled once prior to fast Fourier transformation followed by magnitude calculation. A peak list was generated and exported to Microsoft Excel for internal frequency-to-mass calibration with a two-term calibration equation. The calculated masses of the precursor ion and an abundant product ion were used for calibration. A second set of abundant ions at different ends of the spectrum were often used for confirmation of the calibration. Only assignments better than 20 ppm were included. This relatively high tolerance was needed due to the deterioration of mass accuracy as a result of the high space charge conditions during EDD causing increased ion magnetron motion. Product ion spectra were interpreted with the aid of the web application GlycoFragment (http://www.glycosciences.de/tools/GlycoFragments/) .
3 Results and Discussion
All product ions are labeled according to the Domon and Costello nomenclature , where A-, B-, and C-type fragments contain the non-reducing end of the molecule, and X-, Y-, and Z-type fragments contain the reducing end. B-, C-, Y-, and Z-type ions arise from cleavage of glycosidic bonds, whereas A- and X-type ions result from cross-ring cleavages. When more than one product ion assignment is possible, alternative assignments are indicated in parentheses (e.g., C4(Y4)). Product ions arising from multiple cleavage sites are designated with a slash between the sites of cleavage (e.g., C2/Z3β – 2H). Letters α and β are used to identify branched oligosaccharides where α indicates the heavier branch. Product ions bearing a chloride anion as a charge carrier are denoted with a superscript Cl (e.g., C4Cl).
Two chloride-adducted neutral oligosaccharides were subjected to MS/MS by EDD and CAD to examine the fragmentation behavior of oligosaccharides lacking an acidic moiety. These two oligosaccharides included maltoheptaose, a linear oligosaccharide containing seven, α1 → 4 linked glucose units, and NA2, an asialo, biantennary glycan with the following composition: Galβ4GlcNAcβ2Manα6(Galβ4GlcNAcβ2Manα3)Manβ4GlcNAcβ4GlcNAc (α or β indicates stereochemistry and the numbers indicate anomeric linkage to that particular carbon in the adjacent ring). EDD and CAD spectra from these singly chloridated oligosaccharides were compared to previously obtained spectra of doubly deprotonated samples .
3.1 CAD and EDD of Chloridated Maltoheptaose
Although most product ions are even-electron species, some odd-electron products are observed following EDD through neutral hydrogen loss from the even-electron product. Ions exhibiting hydrogen loss typically form via a minor fragmentation pathway and are therefore of lower abundance than their even-electron counterparts. One exception is the ion at m/z 646.2, denoted B4(Z4) – H, where the radical species is more abundant than the corresponding even-electron species. Identical behavior was seen in our previous work on EDD of doubly deprotonated maltoheptaose  and loss of neutral hydrogen from B-type ions has been reported by Amster and coworkers in EDD of GAGs . Here, the addition of chloride to the precursor ion does not appear to alter the reproducibility of this fragment, indicating that electron detachment occurs from the deprotonated site rather than from the chloride adduct. This preference in electron detachment site may be rationalized based on the much higher electron affinity of a chlorine atom radical (3.61 eV ) compared with an alkoxide radical (e.g., 1.7 eV for cyclobutoxide ) although these numbers are distant approximations in the molecular context of the oligosaccharide. The negative charge on this fragment may be due to neutral HCl loss from excess vibrational energy in EDD.
Further hydrogen loss is observed for two other product ions, occurring at m/z 537.1 and 861.2 and denoted by C3(Y3)Cl – 2H and C5(Y5)Cl – 2H, respectively where the loss of two neutral hydrogen atoms is the dominant pathway. (C – 2H)-type product ions have been observed by several investigators following high-energy CAD (heCAD) [52, 53, 54, 55, 56], by us in EDD of sialylated oligosaccharides , and by Amster and co-workers in EDD of GAGs [31, 32, 33]. However, these product ions were not observed following EDD of doubly deprotonated maltoheptaose . In the current experiments, both these singly charged product ions bear a chloride anion, which likely explains their absence from EDD of doubly deprotonated maltoheptaose.
Two chloride-adducted product ions, denoted Z5Cl + 2H (m/z = 847.2) and Z4Cl + 2H (m/z = 685.2), which could alternatively correspond to Y5Cl – 16 Da and Y4Cl – 16 Da, were observed following EDD of chloride-adducted maltoheptaose. Previous work suggests that these products correspond to Z + 2H rather than the Y – 16 Da fragments reported by Kováčik et al.  and by Harvey et al.  from positive-ion mode heCAD. Hydrogen addition and abstraction has been observed following ECD of peptides [58, 59] and further documented for EDD of peptides . Further support for the formation of (Z + 2H)-type ions, rather than (Y – 16)-type products, is shown in Figure 1a by the presence of complementary C – 2H species. For example, the products Z4Cl + 2H and C3Cl – 2H are complementary and together account for the intact mass of maltoheptaose. Chloride adduction appears to increase the likelihood of detecting complementary product ions. Such complementary product ion pairs are highly valuable in structural characterization studies.
Several unique cross-ring cleavages (not observed following CAD or IRMPD) were reported from EDD of doubly deprotonated maltoheptaose . EDD of chloridated and singly deprotonated maltoheptaose, [M – H + Cl]2–, shows several additional glycosidic and cross-ring fragments not observed by CAD or IRMPD, including B2(Z2), B3(Z3), 3,5X1Cl, 1,5X3Cl, and 1,5X5Cl. X-type fragments are of particular interest since they are rarely observed following low energy CAD, IRMPD, or ECD of underivatized glycans although 1,5X ions do not provide linkage information. Here, the chloride anion is the major charge carrier for all X-type fragments. However, chloride adduction is not prerequisite to the detection of unique cross-ring fragments; for example, the singly charged 1,5X5 product ion exists in deprotonated (m/z 855.3) as well as chloride-adducted states (m/z 891.2). Again, the deprotonated fragment may be explained via neutral HCl loss.
3.2 EDD and CAD of a Chloride-Adducted Asialo Biantennary Glycan (NA2)
EDD and CAD spectra were collected for an asialo biantennary glycan (NA2) bearing either one or two chloride anions to form the doubly charged precursor ion. Unlike maltoheptaose, [M + 2Cl]2– was significantly more abundant following ESI than the [M – H + Cl]2– species, which may be due to NA2’s increased size. For the sake of consistency, only the [M – H + Cl]2– precursor is further discussed.
EDD of singly deprotonated NA2 bearing a chloride adduct resulted in a combination of singly and doubly charged product ions (denoted with an asterisk; Figure 2a), matching observations from EDD of the doubly deprotonated precursor . Many of the doubly charged products could not be identified and likely arise from direct decomposition of the activated precursor ion rather than resulting from radical formation and subsequent fragmentation. All product ions appear to be even-electron species since neutral loss of a hydrogen atom was not observed as a dominant fragmentation pathway. However, the observation of C4Cl – 2H and C5Cl – 2H products, at m/z = 1267.4 and 1470.5, respectively, lends further evidence to the chloride anion’s role in the detection of unique fragments, not observed following EDD of doubly deprotonated NA2 . Also observed are products resulting from multiple cleavage sites, such as 2,4A6/Y4, but such products are not exclusively observed for the chloride-adducted precursor. Neither is one of the most abundant product ions, which corresponds to the loss of the 3-linked antenna and two reducing GlcNAc residues (labeled GlcNAcMan3 – H2O at m/z = 688.2). Yet, the reproducibility of this product ion is important as its location at the oligosaccharide’s branch point allows for determination of the monosaccharide composition for the 6-linked and the 3-linked antennae.
Several unique cross-ring cleavages and a previously unobserved B1 ion were noted following EDD of the chloride-adducted oligosaccharide, including 0,2A2, 1,3A3, 0,2A4, 2,4A6Cl, 1,5X4Cl, and 1,5X5Cl. The mechanism yielding 0,2A-type ions from CAD is generally accepted to involve anomeric ring opening followed by retro-aldol rearrangement by the hydroxyl group in the 3-position [62, 63, 64, 65]. Because a free OH group in the 3 position is required for such rearrangement, the absence of 0,2A-type ions for 3-linked residues has been used to justify this mechanism. Here, we observe a 0,2A-type ion (0,2A4) at the 3-linked mannose residue, suggesting that formation of this ion in EDD results from secondary decomposition of a Y3 ion, or by a radical-driven mechanism that is not yet understood. Finally, the presence of a chloride anion on various products can indicate the location(s) of anion interaction. X-type product ions, hydrogen abstracted C-type ions, and the 2,5A6Cl ion all include chloride as charge carrier, suggesting that the anion interacts near the middle of the gas phase NA2 molecule, or that a mixture of charge isomers exists in the gas phase.
CAD of chloridated NA2 showed similar results to maltoheptaose with dissociation yielding only doubly charged C- and A-type fragments (Figure 2b). Although fragmentation was minimal following relatively low energy collisions, a high abundance 0,2A6Cl ion was observed, corresponding to the only unique product detected for the chloridated oligosaccharide. Like maltoheptaose, the chloride-NA2 interaction appears to be weak as small increases in collision energy drastically reduced the abundance of the [M – H + Cl]2– precursor ion.
3.3 MS/MS of Chloridated Sialylated Oligosaccharides
EDD fragmentation patterns were examined for three chloride-adducted oligosaccharides containing one or two sialic acids. First studied was linear LS-tetrasaccharide, LSTa, with the following composition: Neu5Acα3Galβ3GlcNAcβ3Galβ4GlcNAc. Next examined was LSTb, a similar LS-tetrasaccharide, exhibiting a branched structure due to the α2 → 6 linkage to galactose (Gal). A disialylacto-N-tetraose oligosaccharide (DSLNT) was also examined. With a structure similar to LSTa, DSLNT contains an additional sialic acid reside that is α2 → 6 linked to GlcNAc.
CAD of all chloride-adducted sialylated oligosaccharides yielded little information, consistent with previous reports by Zaia et al. that sialylated carbohydrates require significantly more energy than neutral oligosaccharides for efficient fragmentation . Energies sufficient to induce fragmentation of chloride-adducted sialylated oligosaccharides far exceeded the energy needed to dissociate the chloride-carbohydrate interaction, and the potential benefit of using this anion to stimulate alternative fragmentation pathways was thus lost. This shortcoming extols the benefit of alternative activation methods such as EDD for fragmentation of anion-adducted oligosaccharides.
For LSTa, a relatively abundant [M – H + Cl]2– precursor ion was observed from standard negative ion mode electrospray ionization conditions. Following EDD of this precursor ion (Figure 3a), all resultant product ions were singly charged either by deprotonation or chloride adduction, with the exception of the peak at m/z = 498.7. A Y3 fragment at m/z = 543.2 showed neutral hydrogen loss as the predominant species. Two C – 2H product ions, C3 – 2H and C4 – 2H, were observed, but unlike the neutral oligosaccharides discussed above, these products do not bear a chloride anion as the charge carrier and were also observed following EDD of doubly deprotonated LSTa . As stated previously, hydrogen abstraction products have been observed following heCAD in positive ion mode, but the precise mechanism generating such ions has not been elucidated . Wolff et al. attempted to clarify this behavior in EDD of GAGs and proposed that electron detachment occurs at the carboxylate group of hexuronic acid, followed by hydrogen transfer to create an oxy radical at C2 or C3 and subsequently leading to the formation of a C – 2H product by α-cleavage . However, because we observe C - 2H species near the reducing end of the molecule (at C3 and C4) it is unlikely that electron detachment at the carboxylate group of sialic acid is responsible for these products. This seemingly unique behavior for the chloride-adducted precursor ion may be explained by the chloride adduct sharing a hydrogen with the sialic acid carboxylate group rather than with an oligosaccharide hydroxyl group (such carboxylic acid binding is not possible for maltoheptaose and NA2 as they lack sialic acid). This mode of binding, which prevents carboxylic acid deprotonation, was recently proposed by Cole and co-workers for chloride-peptide anionic complexes .
The chloride adduct of deprotonated disialylacto-N-tetraose oligosaccharide (DSLNT) was always of low abundance with respect to the doubly deprotonated ion following negative mode electrospray ionization. Two sialic acid residues makes DSLNT particularly amenable to EDD under standard conditions but makes isolation of the chloridated precursor ion particularly difficult due to ion suppression by the highly abundant doubly deprotonated species. The difficulty in precursor ion isolation could also be due to a higher lability of the chloride adduct due to the presence of one protonated sialic acid that can facilitate HCl loss. Attempts to isolate the chloridated precursor by quadrupole and in-cell isolation by CHEF  could not completely segregate the ion of interest from the doubly deprotonated species, and the [M – 2H]2– ion remained at 75 % relative abundance under the best isolation conditions.
Our results demonstrate that EDD of underivatized chloride-adducted oligosaccharides provides structural information complementary to that from EDD of the corresponding doubly deprotonated species. EDD of chloridated oligosaccharides led to an increase in the types of cross-ring cleavages observed in all examples investigated, and generally showed an increase in the types of glycosidic fragments observed as well. Chloride adduction did not present a challenge for the formation of doubly charged anions for neutral oligosaccharides, but it remains a potential issue for acidic species. For neutral oligosaccharides, ion abundance of the [M – H + Cl]2– precursor and doubly deprotonated anion were generally comparable and always considerably greater than the singly deprotonated species following electrospray ionization. The singly chloridated species was not observed with high abundance. Isolation of the chloride-adducted species for acidic oligosaccharides was challenging and generally required two stages of isolation (quadrupole and in-cell) due to the high abundance of the doubly deprotonated anion within close m/z proximity to the chloridated precursor. Complete isolation of the doubly sialylated oligosaccharide (DSLNT) was not achieved and may be responsible for the lack of unique fragment ions observed in that case. Therefore, chloride adduction may not be appropriate for oligosaccharides bearing two or more acidic protons.
CAD experiments revealed a weak interaction between the carbohydrate and the chloride anion, which was easily displaced at low collision energies. However, CAD of neutral chloride-adducted oligosaccharides did produce unique cross-ring product ions not observed following EDD or CAD of doubly deprotonated samples, but cross-ring fragmentation was more extensive following EDD. Several unusual product ions resulting from abstraction of neutral hydrogen were observed in EDD of chloridated oligosaccharides, including C – H, C – 2H, and Y – 2H, which have also been seen in EDD of doubly deprotonated species. The presence of a complementary product ion pair (C3Cl – 2H and Z4Cl + 2H) in EDD of chloridated maltoheptaose further suggests that the previously noted Y – 16 Da ions are actually Z + 2H ions. Due to the increase in glycosidic and cross-ring product ion formation, chloride adduction appears to be promising when used in conjunction with EDD for structural characterization of oligosaccharides. Future work includes improvement of sensitivity and throughput via (e.g., a more sensitive FT-ICR mass spectrometer [SolariX; Bruker Daltonics]) and use of nanoelectrospray ionization. Chloride adduction should also be of interest in other alternative anion activation strategies for oligosaccharide structural characterization, including negative electron transfer dissociation  and 193 nm photodissociation .
The authors acknowledge support for this work by an NSF Career Award, CHE 0547699 (to K.H.), a Smeaton Award for Undergraduate Summer Research (to J.R.K), and support by the University of Michigan.