Folk Concepts of Intentional Action in the Contexts of Amoral and Immoral Luck
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
This paper concerns a recently discovered, puzzling asymmetry in judgments of whether an action is intentional or not (Knobe, Philosophical Psychology 16:309–324, 2003a; Analysis 63:190–193, b). We report new data replicating the asymmetry in the context of scenarios wherein an agent achieves an amoral or immoral goal due to luck. Participants’ justifications of their judgments of the intentionality of the agent’s action indicate that two distinct folk concepts of intentional action played a role in their judgments. When viewed from this perspective, the puzzle disappears, although the asymmetry remains.
- Adams, F. 1986. Intention and intentional action: The simple view. Mind and Language 1: 281–301. CrossRef
- Adams, F., and A. Steadman. 2004. Intentional action in ordinary language: Core concept or pragmatic understanding? Analysis 64: 173–181. CrossRef
- Alicke, M. D. 2008. Blaming badly. Journal of Cognition and Culture 8(2): 179–186.
- Bratman, M. 1987. Intention, plans, and practical reason. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
- Carston, R. 2002. Thoughts and utterances: The pragmatics of explicit communication. Oxford: Blackwell. CrossRef
- Cushman, F., and A.R. Mele. 2008. Intentional action: Two-and-a-half folk concepts? In Experimental philosophy, ed. J. Knobe and S. Nichols. New York: Oxford University Press.
- Davidson, D. 1980. Essays on actions and events. Oxford: Clarendon.
- Feinberg, J. 1970. Doing and deserving. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Harman, G. 1976. Practical reasoning. Review of Metaphysics 79: 431–463.
- Knobe, J. 2003a. Intentional action in folk psychology: An experimental investigation. Philosophical Psychology 16: 309–324. CrossRef
- Knobe, J. 2003b. Intentional action and side-effects in ordinary language. Analysis 63: 190–193. CrossRef
- Knobe, J. 2006. The concept of intentional action: a case study in the uses of folk psychology. Philosophical Studies 130: 203–231. CrossRef
- Laurence, S., and E. Margolis. 1999. Concepts and cognitive science. In Concepts: Core readings, ed. E. Margolis and S. Laurence. Cambridge: The MIT Press.
- Leslie, A.M., J. Knobe, and A. Cohen. 2006. Acting intentionally and the side-effect effect: ‘Theory of mind’ and moral judgment. Psychological Science 17: 421–427. CrossRef
- Machery, E. 2008. The folk concept of intentional action: Philosophical and experimental issues. Mind and Language 23: 165–189. CrossRef
- Machery, E. 2009. Doing without concepts. New York: Oxford University Press. CrossRef
- Malle, B.F. 2006. Intentionality, morality, and their relationship in human judgment. Journal of Cognition and Culture 6: 61–86.
- Malle, B.F., and J. Knobe. 1997. The folk concept of intentionality. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 33: 101–121. Reprinted in W. Lesko (ed.) Readings in Social Psychology: General, Classic and Contemporary Selections. Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon. CrossRef
- Mallon, R. 2008. Knobe vs. Machery: Testing the trade-off hypothesis. Mind and Language 23: 247–255. CrossRef
- McCann, H.J. 2005. Intentional action and intending: Recent empirical studies. Philosophical Psychology 18: 737–748. CrossRef
- Mele, A. 1992. Springs of action. New York: Oxford University Press.
- Mele, A. 2001. Acting intentionally: Probing folk notions. In Intentions and intentionality: Foundations of social cognition, ed. B.F. Malle, L.J. Moses, and D.A. Baldwin. Cambridge: MIT Press.
- Mele, A., and F. Cushman. 2007. Intentional action, folk judgments, and stories: Sorting things out. Midwest Studies in Philosophy 31: 184–201. CrossRef
- Mele, A., and P. Moser. 1994. Intentional action. Nous 28: 39–68. CrossRef
- Nadelhoffer, T. 2005. Skill, luck, control, and intentional action. Philosophical Psychology 18: 341–352. CrossRef
- Nichols, S., and J. Ulatowski. 2007. Intuitions and individual differences: The Knobe effect revisited. Mind and Language 22(4): 346–365. CrossRef
- Rosch, E. 2010. Concepts. In The Cambridge encyclopedia of the language sciences, ed. P.C. Hogan. New York: Cambridge University Press.
- von Wright, G. H. 1971. Explanation and understanding. Cornell University Press.
- Zimmerman, M. 1984. An essay on human action. New York: Peter Lang Publishing, Inc.
- Folk Concepts of Intentional Action in the Contexts of Amoral and Immoral Luck
Review of Philosophy and Psychology
Volume 1, Issue 3 , pp 351-370
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links