Abstract
While various studies on river basin management (RBM) in industrialized and developing countries exist, limited attention has so far been paid to RBM in transition countries, i.e., countries that move from a centralized socialist system to democratic, decentralized and market-based structures. However, given that transition countries are characterized by fundamental changes in their political and economic setting, they amend themselves to the study of the role of both institutional design and contextual factors in the institutionalization of RBM. Against this background, this paper analyzes similarities and differences in the institutionalization of RBM in Mongolia and Ukraine and asks how they can be explained. The paper finds that while the two countries are converging in terms of the model of the river basin organization (RBO) adopted, they differ significantly in detailed institutional design and dynamics. The differences in institutional design are likely to influence the effectiveness of RBM in both countries. The differences in design and dynamics can be understood if contextual factors such as the severity of the water problem, economic conditions, the overriding governance context and the role of various actors are taken into account. The results show that not only is the detailed design of RBOs crucial for successful implementation of RBM, but also problem pressure as well as the broader governance and economic context.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Note that our definition of transition does not include autocracies under former Soviet influence.
It has to be noted that Ukraine was a Soviet Republic whereas Mongolia was independent, but adjusted its system to the Soviet model and was also highly influenced in its politics by the Soviet Union.
Countries under former Soviet influence vary with respect to their governance regimes (democracies versus autocracies) as well as with respect to their natural conditions and water problems (temperate versus arid climate). Hence, for a full-fledged representative analysis of water governance for this group of countries, all four factors would have to be varied.
Crimea is an exception because here the southern part is under sub-tropical climatic influence.
References
Abdullayev I (2009) Integrated water management in Central Asia: way of reform or way of getting more money for ailing sector? Paper presented at the Water Policy Dynamics in State-Centric Regimes Workshop, Bonn
AMCOW (2012) Status report on the application of integrated approaches to water resources management in Africa. African Ministers’ Council on Water, n.l
Bankwatch (2011) Spirited away: mongolia’s mining boom and the people that development left behind. CEE Bankwatch Network, urgewald, Bank Information Network, Oyu Tolgoi Watch, n.l
Barrow CJ (1998) River basin development planning and management: a critical review. World Dev 26(1):171–186
Basandorj D, Singh S (2008) Restoring the image of blue mongolia: rural water supply and sanitation. UNICEF/UNDP, Ulaanbaatar
Batima P, Natsagdorj L, Gombluudev P, Erdenetsetseg B (2005) Observed climate change in Mongolia. AIACC Working Papers, Ulaanbataar
Batsukh N, Dorjsuren D, Batsaikhan G (2008) The water resources, use and conservation in Mongolia. First national report. National Water Committee, Ulaanbaatar
Beveridge R, Monsees J (2012) Bridging parallel discourses of Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM): institutional and political challenges in developing and developed countries. Water Int 37(7):727–743. doi:10.1080/02508060.2012.742713
Blomquist W, Dinar A, Kemper KE (2005) Comparison of institutional arrangements for river basin management in eight basins. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper
Blomquist W, Dinar A, Kemper KE (2010) River basin management: conclusions and implications. In: Kemper K, Blomquist W, Dinar A (eds) Integrated river basin management through decentralization. Springer, Berlin, pp 229–238
Blumensaat F, Scheifhacken N, Ertel A-M, Helm B, Lupo A, Petzoldt T, Manturova O, Bodnarchuk T, Kovalchuk O, Berendonk TU, Krebs P (2011) Water quality in hydrological sensitive lowland rivers in the Western Ukraine: present deficits and future perspectives. Paper presented at the International Conference on Integrated Water Resources Management, Dresden
Bredies I (2009) Zur Verfassungsordnung ohne Verfassungs- und Rechtstaatlichkeit in der Ukraine und ihre Auswirkungen. Ukraine-Analysen
BTI (2014a) Mongolia country report. Bertelsmann transformation index
BTI (2014b) Ukraine country report. Bertelsmann transformation index
Burchi S (1985) Different types of river basin entities: a global outlook. In: Lundqvist J, Lohm U, Falkenmark M (eds) Strategies for River Basin Management. D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht, pp 293–298
Butterworth J, Warner JF, Moriarty P, Smits S, Batchelor C (2010) Finding practical approaches to integrated water resources management. Water Altern 3(1):68–81
Cap-Net, UNESCO-IHE (2008) Performance and capacity of river basin organizations. Cross-case comparison of four RBOs
Chalov S, Zavadsky A, Belozerova E, Bulacheva M, Jarsjö J, Thorslund J, Yamkhin J (2012) Suspended and dissolved matter fluxes in the upper Selenga river basin: synthesis. Geogr Environ Sustain 2(5):78–94
Chogdon O, Tsogtsaikhan U, Treydte K-P (2012) Zwischen »Boom und Frust«. Parlamentswahlen in der Mongolei im Juni 2012. Perspektive. Friedrich Ebert Stiftung (FES), Berlin
CIA (2014a) The World Factbook. Mongolia. https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/mg.html. Accessed 25 Feb 2014
CIA (2014b) The World Factbook. Ukraine. https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/up.html. Accessed 25 Feb 2014
Dinar A, Kemper KE, Blomquist W, Diez M, Sine G, Fru W (2005) Decentralization of river basin management: a global analysis. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper. World Bank, Washington, DC
Dixit A, Athukorala K, Mollinga P (eds) (2006) Integrated water resources management. global theory, emerging practice and local needs. SAGE Publications, New Delhi
Dolgorsuren G, Bron J, van der Linden W (2012) Integrated water management national assessment report, part II. Government of Mongolia/Kingdom of the Netherlands, Ulaanbaatar
Dombrowsky I (2005) Integriertes Wasserressourcen-Management als Koordinationsproblem. In: Neubert S, Scheumann W, Edig Av, Huppert W (eds) Integriertes Wasserressourcen-Management (IWRM). Ein Konzept in die Praxis überführen. Nomos, Baden-Baden, pp 61–82
Dombrowsky I (2008) Integration in the management of international waters: economic perspectives on a global policy discourse. Glob Gov 14(4):455–477
Dombrowsky I, Houdret A, Horlemann L (2014) Evolving river basin management in Mongolia? In: Huitema D, Meijerink S (eds) The politics of river basin organizations. Institutional design choices, coalitions and consequences. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham (in press)
Durth R (1996) Grenzüberschreitende Umweltprobleme und regionale Integration. Zur Politischen Ökonomie von Oberlauf-Unterlauf-Problemen an internationalen Flüssen. Nomos, Baden-Baden
Dutkiewicz P, Gorzelak G (2011) Central and eastern Europe: shapes of transformation, crisis, and the possible futures. In: Calhoun C, Derluguian G (eds) Aftermath. a new global economic order. New York University Press, New York, pp 181–208
EC (2006) Management of the Bug, Latoritza and Uzh river basins, Ukraine. Report on Project Component 3. Upper Tisza/Western Bug. Challenges and management requirements. European Commission
Ertel AM, Lupo A, Scheifhacken N, Bodnarchuk T, Manturova O, Berendonk TU, Petzoldt T (2012) Heavy load and high potential: anthropogenic pressures and their impacts on the water quality along a lowland river (Western Bug, Ukraine). Environ Earth Sci 65(5):1459–1473. doi:10.1007/s12665-011-1289-0
George AL, Bennett A (2005) Case studies and theory development in the social sciences. MIT Press, Cambridge
Hagemann N, Blumensaat F, Tavares Wahren F, Trümper J, Burmeister C, Moynihan R, Scheifhacken N (2014) The long road to improving the water quality of the Western Bug River (Ukraine): a multi-scale analysis. J Hydrol (Special issue: “water governance across competing scales”). doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2014.01.013
Hagemann N, Leidel M (2014) Introducing river basin management in a transitional context: a case study about Ukraine. In: Huitema D, Meijerink S (eds) The politics of river basin organizations. Institutional design choices, coalitions and consequences. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham (in press)
Hartje V (2002) International dimensions of integrated water management. In: Al Baz I, Hartje V, Scheumann W (eds) Co-operation on transboundary rivers. Nomos, Baden-Baden, pp 7–34
Herrfahrdt E, Kipping M, Pickardt T, Polak M, Rohrer C, Wolff CF (2006) Water governance in the Kyrgyz agricultural sector: on its way to integrated water resources management? Studies 14. Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE), Bonn
Herrfahrdt-Pähle E (2010) South African water governance between administrative and hydrological boundaries. Clim Develop 2(2):111–127. doi:10.3763/cdev.2010.0038
Herrfahrdt-Pähle E, Pahl-Wostl C (2012) Continuity and change in social-ecological systems: the role of institutional resilience. Ecol Soc 17(2). doi:10.5751/ES-04565-170208
Holtrup P (1999) Der Schutz grenzüberschreitender Flüsse in Europa-zur Effektivität internationaler Umweltregime. Forschungszentrum Jülich, Jülich
Hooper BP (2006) Key Performance indicators of river basin organizations. Visiting Scholar Program. Southern Illinois University, n.l
Horlemann L, Dombrowsky I (2012) Institutionalising IWRM in developing and transition countries: the case of Mongolia. Environ Earth Sci 65(5):1547–1559. doi:10.1007/s12665-011-1213-7
Houdret A, Dombrowsky I, Horlemann L (2013) The institutionalization of river basin management as politics of scale—insights from Mongolia. J Hydrol (Special issue: “water governance across competing scales”). doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2013.11.037
Howard MM (2003) The weakness of civil society in post-communist Europe. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Huitema D, Meijerink S (2014) The politics of river basin organizations. Coalitions, institutional design choices and consequences. In: Huitema D, Meijerink S (eds) The politics of river basin organizations. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
Kalbus E, Kalbacher T, Kolditz O, Krüger E, Seegert J, Röstel G, Teutsch G, Borchardt D, Krebs P (2012) Integrated water resources management under different hydrological, climatic and socio-economic conditions. Environ Earth Sci 65(5):1363–1366. doi:10.1007/s12665-011-1330-3
Karthe D, Chalov S, Malsy M, Menzel L, Theuring P, Hartwig M, Schweitzer C, Hofmann J, Priess J, Shinkareva G, Kasimov N (2014a) Integrating multi-scale data for the assessment of water availability and quality in the Kharaa–Orkhon–Selenga river system. Geogr Environ Sustain (in review)
Karthe D, Heldt S, Houdret A, Borchardt D (2014b) IWRM in a country under rapid transition: lessons learnt from the Kharaa river basin, Mongolia. Environ Earth Sci (accepted)
Kemper KE, Blomquist W, Dinar A (2010) Integrated river basin management through decentralization. Springer, Berlin
Kennedy K, Simonovic S, Tejada-Guibert A, de França Doria M, Luis Martin J (2009) IWRM implementation in basins, sub-basins and aquifers: state of the art review. The United Nations World Water Development Report, vol 3. The United Nations World Water Assessment Programme, Paris
Khmelko L (2012) Administrative decentralization in post communist countries: the case of water management in Ukraine. J Polit Sci Gov Polit 1(1):1–12
Kneese AV, Bower BT (1968) Managing water quality. economics, technology, institutions. The Johns Hopkins University Press and Resources for the Future, Washington, DC
Kovalchuk I, Quast J, Mykhnovych A, Steidl J, Ehlert V, Andreychuk Y (2008) Concepts of the sustainable water use and flood protection in the upper Dnister floodplain. In: Nobis R, Stetsiuk V, Kruhlov I (eds) Transformation processes in the Western Ukraine. Weißensee Verlag, Berlin, pp 431–440
Lankford BA, Hepworth N (2010) The Cathedral and the Bazaar: monocentric and polycentric river basin management. Water Altern 3(1):82–101
Leidel M, Niemann S, Hagemann N (2012) Capacity development as key factor for integrated water resource management (IWRM): improving water management in the Western Bug river basin, Ukraine. Environ Earth Sci 65(5):1415–1426
Livingstone A, Erdenechimeg C, Oyunsuvd A (2009) Needs assessment on institutional capacity for water governance in Mongolia. Ulaanbaatar
Lkhagvadorj A (2010) Fiscal federalism and decentralization in Mongolia. Universitätsverlag Potsdam, Potsdam
MacDonald M (2009) Water governance in the Western EECCA countries. Progr Rep 2. http://www.wgw.org.ua/publications/Prog%20Rep%202g.pdf
McCaffrey S (2003) The law of international watercourses. non-navigational uses. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Mearns R (2004) Pastoralism and sustainable livelihoods in Mongolia. Dev Change 35(1):105–106
Meijerink S, Huitema D (2010) Policy entrepreneurs and change strategies: lessons from sixteen case studies of water transitions around the globe. Ecol Soc 15(2):21
Menzel L et al. (2008) Hydrological impact of climate and land-use change: results from the MoMo project. Paper presented at the International Conference on Uncertainties in Water Resource Management: causes, technologies and consequences, Ulaanbaatar
MEP, GEF, UNDP (2007) National Environmental Policy of Ukraine: assessment and development strategy. Ministry of Environmental Protection of Ukraine, Global Environmental Facility, United Nations Development Programme, Kyiv
Merrey DJ (2008) Is normative integrated water resources management implementable? Charting a practical course with lessons from Southern Africa. Phys Chem Earth 33(8–13):899–905
Mitchell B (2005) Integrated water resource management, institutional arrangements, and land-use planning. Environ Plan 37:1335–1352
Molle F (2009) River-basin planning and management: the social life of a concept. Geoforum 40 (3):484–494. doi:10.1016/j.geoforum.2009.03.004
Moss T (2003) Solving problems of ‘fit’ at the expense of problems of ‘interplay’? the spatial reorganisation of water management following the EU water framework directive. In: Breit H, Engels A, Moss T, Troja M (eds) How institutions change: perspectives on social learning in global and local environmental contexts. Leske + Budrich, Opladen, pp 85–121
Moss T (2004) The governance of land use in river basins: prospects for overcoming problems of institutional interplay with the EU water framework directive. Land Use Policy 21:85–94. doi:10.1016/j.landusepol.2003.10.001
Mostert E (1998) River basin management in the European Union. How it is done and how it should be done. Eur Water Manag 1(3):26–35
Moynihan R (2013) IWAS Legal analysis: potential contribution of principles and approaches of international and European water law to Ukraine’s management of the Western Bug river (Internal IWAS report on file with author)
National Statistical Office of Mongolia (2014) Social and economic situation of Mongolia (As of the preliminary result of 2013) http://www.nso.mn/files/web201401en.pdf. Accessed 22 Jan 2014
Navruzov Y (2001) Local government in Ukraine. In: Munteanu I, Popa V (eds) New rules in the old environment. Local government and public service reform initiative, Budapest, pp 109–159
Newson M (1992) Land, water and development: river basin systems and their sustainable management. Routledge, London
Oates WE (1972) Fiscal federalism. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, New York
Oberkircher L, Tischbein B, Hornidge A-K, Schorcht G, Bhaduri A, Awan UK, Manschadi AM (2010) Rethinking Water Management in Khorezm, Uzbekistan. Working Paper Series 54. Bonn
OECD (2006) Financing water supply and sanitation in Eastern Europe, Caucasus and Central Asia. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris
OECD (2009) Dealing with post-decentralisation implications in the water sector: based on country experience cases. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris
Olson M (1969) The principle of “fiscal equivalence”: the division of responsibilities among different levels of government. Am Econ Rev 59:479–487
Opitz P (2010) Ineffizient und intransparent. Der ukrainische Energiesektor. Osteuropa 60(2–4):217–236
Ostrom E (2005) Understanding institutional diversity. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Pahl-Wostl C, Lebel L, Knieper C, Nikitina E (2012) From applying panaceas to mastering complexity: toward adaptive water governance in river basins. Environ Sci Policy 23:24–34. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2012.07.014
Pavlik D, Söhl D, Pluntke T, Bernhofer C (2014) Climate change in the Western Bug river basin and the impact on future hydro-climatic conditions. Environ Earth Sci. doi:10.1007/s12665-014-3068-1
Pavlov SS, Roerink GJ, Hellegers PJGJ, Popovych VF (2006) Irrigation performance assessment in crimea, Ukraine. Int J Water Resour Dev 22(1):61–78. doi:10.1080/07900620500405593
Priess JA, Schweitzer C, Wimmer F, Batkhishig O, Mimler M (2011) The consequences of land-use change and water demands in Central Mongolia. Land Use policy 28(1):4–10
Rogers P (1997) International river basins: pervasive unidirectional externalities. In: Dasgupta P, Mäler K-G, Vercelli A (eds) The economics of transnational commons. Carendon Press, Oxford, pp 35–76
Rudenko L (2010) In der Krise. Die ökologische Lage in der Ukraine. Osteuropa 60(2–4):301–307
Sadoff CW, Whittington D, Grey D (2002) Africa’s International Rivers. An Economic Perspective. The World Bank, Washington, DC
Schlager E, Blomquist W (2008) Embracing watershed politics. University Press of Colorado, Colorado
Sehring J (2009) The politics of water institutional reform in neopatrimonial states: a comparative analysis of Kyrgystan and Tajikistan. VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden
Shah T, Makin I, Sakthivadivel R (2001) Limits to Leapfrogging: Issues in Transponding Successful River Basin Management Institutions in the Developing World. In: Abernethy CL (ed) Intersectoral Management of River Basins. Deutsche Stiftung für internationale Entwicklung: Zentralstelle für Ernährung und Landwirtschaft (ZEL), Loskop Dam, South Africa, pp 89–114
Shields S (2012) The international political economy of transition. Neoliberal hegemony and Eastern Central Europe’s transformation. Routledge, London
State Statistics Service of Ukraine (2014) Population. http://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/. Accessed 25 Feb 2014
Teclaff LA (1996) Evolution of the river basin concept in national and international water law. Nat Resour J 36:359–392
Theesfeld I (2003) Constraints on collective action in a transitional economy: the case of Bulgaria’s irrigation sector. World Dev 32(2):251–271
Theesfeld I, Boevsky I (2005) Reviving pre-socialist cooperative traditions: the case of water syndicates in Bulgaria. Soc Rural 45(3):171–186
Thiel A (2014) Rescaling of resource governance as institutional change: explaining the transformation of water governance in Southern Spain. Environ Policy Gov. doi:10.1002/eet.1644
Thorslund J, Jarsjö J, Chalov S, Belozerova E (2012) Gold mining impact on riverine heavy metal transport in a sparsely monitored region: the upper Lake Baikal Basin case. J Environ Monit 14(10):2780–2792
Tortell P, Borjigdkhan A, Naidansuren E (2008) Institutional structures for environmental management in Mongolia. Ulaanbaatar and Wellington
UNCED (1992) United Nations Conference on Environment and Development, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Agenda 21. United Nations. http://www.sidsnet.org/docshare/other/Agenda21_UNCED.pdf. Accessed 23 August 2005
UNDP (2013) Human development report 2013. The rise of the south: human progress in a diverse world. UNDP, New York
UNEP (2012) The UN-water status report on the application of integrated approaches to water resources management. UNEP, UNDP, GWP, SIWI, UNEP, DHI-Center, Nairobi
Unnerstall H, Hagemann N (2011) Analysing the shortcomings of the Ukrainian urban waste water sector: institutional options for modernisation. In: Theesfeld I, Pirscher F (eds) Perspectives on institutional change: water management in Europe. Studies on agricultural and food sector in central and eastern Europe. IAMO studies series, 58 edn., Halle (Saale), pp 33–52
Warner J, Wester P, Bolding A (2008) Going with the flow: river basins as the natural units for water management? Water Policy 10(Supplement 2):121–138
Wilson A (2010) Schildkröten in der Dämmerzone. Die Politik in der Ukraine und der Wandel. Osteuropa 60(2–4):135–144
WorldBank (2006) Mongolia: a review of environmental and social impacts in the mining sector. Washington, DC
WorldBank (2013) World development Indicators. http://data.worldbank.org/data-catalog/world-development-indicators. Accessed 25 Feb 2014
Young OR (1999) Institutional dimensions of global environmental change. IHDP Report No. 9. IHDP, Bonn
Zakorchevna N (2011) Ukraine. Unpublished document
Acknowledgments
This study was written on the basis of research conducted in two projects: the International Water Research Alliance Saxony (IWAS, http://www.iwas-sachsen.ufz.de, Grant 02WM1165), and the Integrated Water Resources Management in Central Asia-Model Regional Mongolia project (MoMo, http://iwrm-momo.de/, Grant UFZ-033L003A), both funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF). We thank the BMBF for its financial support and Zak Seridarian for the English proof reading. The paper has also greatly benefited from the constructive comments of two anonymous reviewers.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dombrowsky, I., Hagemann, N. & Houdret, A. The river basin as a new scale for water governance in transition countries? A comparative study of Mongolia and Ukraine. Environ Earth Sci 72, 4705–4726 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-014-3308-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-014-3308-4